Lyoya family hurt, Schurr relieved by prosecutor's decision not to retry, advocates say
'(The Lyoya family is) very hurt, still trying to understand the American justice system. They don't see any excuse for this verdict or for the person who shot their son in the back of the head to be free,' Commissioner Robert Womack said. 'We're going to continue to work them on the healing process.'
Kent County Prosecutor Chris Becker announced Thursday that he would not retry Christopher Schurr, whom he had charged with second-degree murder in the April 2022 death of Lyoya, a 26-year-old refugee from the Democratic Republic of Congo. After years of appeals, the case went to trial in late April. On May 8, the jury deadlocked.
Prosecutor will not retry Christopher Schurr in Patrick Lyoya's death
Schurr's attorneys, Matthew Borgula and Mark Dodge, said their client feels relieved and vindicated by Becker's decision.
'But certainly not celebration,' Dodge said. 'As far as the last three years, it's never been anything to celebrate for Mr. Schurr and his family.'
'The prosecutor got this right here, that a retrial wouldn't be good for anybody because at best it would've ended up in another hung jury,' Borgula said.
In a Facebook post, the Fraternal Order of Police State Lodge of Michigan commended Becker's choice not to pursue a retrial.
'This decision reflects a recognition of the complex and split-second circumstances law enforcement officers face in the line of duty,' the post read.
Schurr juror: One hold-out kept former officer from being acquitted
The attorney representing Lyoya's family in a civil wrongful death suit against Schurr said in a statement that the decision not to retry meant the family would never see justice in a criminal court.
'The Lyoya family has not only lost Patrick, but now the hope that former officer Christopher Schurr will ever be held criminally accountable for taking Patrick's life. With today's decision, what was once a pause in justice has now become a permanent reality. This is not a verdict nor the outcome the Lyoya family sought,' attorney Ven Johnson stated. 'We will continue to stand with the Lyoya family in their pursuit of truth, accountability and justice for Patrick, and are awaiting our day in civil court.'
Womack praised Becker's work on the case and takes the prosecutor at his word that a guilty verdict would be difficult to achieve.
'I think the jury is reflective of the community, that we are split in half when it comes to this situation here in Grand Rapids,' Womack said.
Womack added that he remains disappointed the case wasn't retried and wants to continue to fight for police reform in the city of Grand Rapids.
Greater Grand Rapids NAACP President Cle Jackson and Urban League of West Michigan President Eric Brown feel differently.
'My initial reaction was anger. I'll be candid. It was anger then it moved to disappointment and devastation. I could not believe this was the decision he came to,' Brown said.
They say Lyoya's family and the community deserved another chance.
'It's devastating. It's devastating. We had an opportunity to again to go back, retry and try to get it right. Patrick deserves that,' Jackson said. 'The Lyoya family deserves that opportunity to retry. Just like the ex-officer Schurr had an opportunity to due process.'
'We had the opportunity to get it right, didn't make it, but we had another opportunity to do even better, to try even harder. I think that was justice disserved,' Brown agreed.
They argued the leader of Michigan State Police, the Grand Rapids police chief and the Grand Rapids city manager all should have been called to testify as expert witnesses, and questioned why a woman whose husband is a police officer was allowed to remain on the jury.
Jackson and Brown say they have reached out to Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel, urging her to take up the case.
Grand Rapids leaders promise 'commitment to police reforms' despite no Schurr retrial
Womack said his goal now is to continue to fight for reforms to policing in West Michigan.
'This just gives us more motivation to fight for better police and community relations. That's only going to change with policies, training and laws being changed that will protect our community from incidents like this,' he said.
Jackson, the NAACP president, noted the Grand Rapids Police Department did make some changes to policy after Lyoya's death, but said those changes don't have any teeth.
'There's no level of enforcement and oversight embedded in policy,' he said.
In statements Thursday, Grand Rapids city leaders said they are committed to ongoing dialogue and reforms.
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NBC News
11 minutes ago
- NBC News
Anna Sorokin says she received hundreds of death threats over bunnies abandoned in Brooklyn park
Anna "Delvey" Sorokin says she's received hundreds of death threats in the days since was was accused of dumping pet rabbits she posed with for a photoshoot in a Brooklyn park. The fake German heiress who stole tens of thousands of dollars from banks posed alongside three bunnies on the streets of Manhattan's posh Tribeca neighborhood last week. The bunnies were recognized and discovered in Brooklyn's Prospect Park days later, prompting fierce online backlash. But the headline-making New York City socialite — who vehemently denied responsibility for the discarded bunnies — said in an interview with NBC News that she's particularly shocked by the strong reaction over the incident. 'It just seems to me like everything I do is just wrong," Sorokin, 34, said in a phone call with NBC News. "I can never do right by these people.' Sorokin shared screenshots of dozens of hateful messages she's received within the last few days to her Instagram — which she called "unusable" — with NBC News. Some of them suggest that she she should be killed or take her own life, including one that advises Sorokin to get someone to "make a carpet out of your skin." 'It seems like a lot of these people, just because they're engaged in animal rescue, they feel like they're entitled to insult you or talk to you or say anything because they're hiding behind this thing that they're doing,' she said. The 34-year-old, whose life was depicted in Netflix's hit 2022 series "Inventing Anna," took the photoshoot with the bunnies on August 3 to create content for her Instagram account, which has more than 1.1 million followers. Shortly before the shoot, she posted on Instagram story asking if any of her followers in the New York City metropolitan area had a pet rabbit she could borrow for the shoot, Sorokin said. Christian Batty, a 19-year-old hair stylist Sorokin met briefly last year, reached out to her and offered what he described as a friend's rabbits, she said. Sorokin added that she paid Batty to provide the rabbits and for his Uber to return the rabbits to their owner in Yonkers — or so she thought. A screenshot of the Uber receipt Sorokin shared with NBC News show the ride's drop off location was just south of Prospect Park, where the rabbits were later spotted. Days later, she said she started receiving messages on social media about the rabbits being spotted in Prospect Park. A Facebook user posted images of the domesticated bunnies in the park to a public Facebook group dedicated to rabbits, House Rabbit Society, and other users connected them to Sorokin's photos. Sorokin initially thought the posts were fake, but the flood of messages did not stop. At first, Batty denied dumping the rabbits in the park, according to screenshots of text messages between Sorokin, Batty and photographer Jasper Soloff that Sorokin posted on her Instagram story and shared with NBC News. "Jasper had no knowledge or input as to how the bunnies were obtained or what happened to them after the photo shoot," Soloff's attorney, Gary Adelman, said in a statement. Batty did not immediately return a request for comment. Hours later, Batty confessed that he did dump the rabbits and absolved Sorokin of any involvement, according to a statement he posted to his Instagram account, which has since been taken down. "When I realized the rabbits were being surrendered to me, I panicked," Batty said in the statement, screenshots of which were provided by Sorokin. "At 19, with no experience caring for animals, no pet-friendly housing, and no knowledge of available resources, I felt overwhelmed and made the worst possible choice." "Believing, mistakenly, that there were existing rabbits in that area, I released them there, thinking that was my best option," he added. Sorokin pushed back on the notion that Batty's age was an issue. "He's old enough to move to New York and live on his own, he should have enough common sense to handle rabbits," Sorokin said. "We're not like asking him to do anything that requires high IQ from him. I just don't know what to say." Sorokin said that she was concerned about how the incident might affect her pending immigration case. Sorokin was convicted by a Manhattan jury in April 2019 on four counts of theft services, three counts of grand larceny and one count of attempted grand larceny after being accused of defrauding banks and friends of tens of thousands of dollars. Prosecutors said that Sorokin convinced friends and businesses to loan her money to afford a lavish lifestyle under the guise that she was the daughter of a oil baron or diplomat, worth tens of millions of dollars. In 2021, Sorokin was released on parole while she fights deportation. She has been forced to wear an electronic ankle monitor and cannot leave a 75-mile house arrest radius based in New York. "This time, I've done nothing wrong," she said. "And I had the best intentions and it's really frustrating." The New York Times reported that the rabbits were rescued by blogger Terry Chao, who spotted the rabbits in the park. Chao could not immediately be reached for comment. Sorokin said she donated $1,000 to the group All About Rabbits Rescue in the aftermath of the scandal. She also denied harming the rabbits by putting them in leashes, as some have suggested online. "I don't know, I'm not a bunny professional. I didn't know the leashes were such a big deal," she said. "We would put them down for, I don't know, a minute or two, take a picture and pick them up. We were not walking them by any means. And they seemed to be happy."
New York Post
11 minutes ago
- New York Post
Uncle of victim in deadly NJ car crash slams mom who allegedly helped driver son flee charges: ‘She shouldn't be walking free'
The family of the teenager killed in a horrific New Jersey crash slammed the accused driver for leaving his pal to die – and the motorist's mother for allegedly trying to help him dodge criminal charges. Parim Murati, the distraught uncle of 'one of a kind' 19-year-old Albion Hysenaj, railed Tuesday over the social media support for Vilma Vneshta, the mom accused of fleeing with her son Alvi Limani, 20, to Florida following the fatal smash-up that killed Hysenaj. 4 Ablion Hysena was remembered as one of a kind. Courtesy Hysenaj Family Advertisement 'People put posts saying 'It's a mother's love,' but how does my sister feel now?' Murati, 41, said of Hysenaj's mother, who is a single parent. 'People want to compare and say a mother would do that for their child, but nobody is putting themselves in my sister's shoes who actually lost a child.' Vneshta, 42, and Limani, 20, allegedly absconded to Florida with an eye on leaving the country following the horrific June 29 Garden State Parkway crash that stemmed from a street race turned tragic, according to authorities. Advertisement Vneshta and Limani were caught in Miami on July 17 and shipped back to the tristate area last week, the New Jersey State Police said. Vneshta is facing a count of hindering apprehension. 'I believe she deserves time, she deserves to go to jail as well,' Murati said. 'She shouldn't be walking free. Being a mother, she should've thought about what happened to my sister … What if they would've gotten him out of the county? We wouldn't have gotten any justice.' Advertisement A message left for Vnestha's lawyer was not returned Tuesday. 4 Vilma Vneshta, 42, is accused of fleeing with her son Alvi Limani, 20, to Florida following the fatal smash-up that killed Hysenaj. Facebook/Vilma Vneshta Murati is also disgusted at Limani, who is facing a slew of charges including aggravated manslaughter. He allegedly slammed into two cars on the parkway and rolled his BMW over, ejecting Hysenaj and one other passenger, who survived, from the car. 'How do you leave your friend? What if he could've saved him?' the uncle said. 'What if that little bit of help, put your hand on a wound there, what if he could've helped him? … he could've called 911, he could've done anything.' Advertisement 4 Limani was brought back to NJ last week. Tiktok/jhongb85 Hysenaj, a recent high school graduate and lifelong Staten Islander, loved video games and had dreams of becoming an entrepreneur. He helped his mother as much as possible at her job and could easily take apart a PC and put it back together without any training, his uncle said. 'My nephew was most definitely one of a kind, a loving, sweet little boy,' Murati said. 4 Vneshta was also arrested. Tiktok/jhongb85 'He basically lit up the room when he walked in the room. Always caring, always there for anyone. He was the type of person you could ask him something and he was gonna do it with a smile on his fase.' Staten Island resident Emily Harrington, 19, is also facing charges tied to the crash after she allegedly left the crash scene with Limani. The other driver involved in the fatal car racing, Jeter Ogando, 23, of Perth Amboy, NJ, is facing vehicular homicide and related charges.
Yahoo
13 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Trump Burger Owner to Be Deported for Being Sham Marriage ‘Illegal Alien'
The co-owner of a Donald Trump-themed burger chain in Texas was arrested and is facing deportation after allegedly overstaying his visa and orchestrating a 'sham' marriage. Roland Beainy, 28, is one of the masterminds behind Trump Burger, a viral MAGA eatery whose locations feature American flags, buns stamped 'TRUMP,' and even an impersonator of the president—who went round asking Latino customers if they had green cards. The business was founded in 2020 and now has four locations around the Houston area. However, Beainy, who is a Lebanese national, has been swept up in his idol's sweeping immigration crackdown. After being arrested by Immigration and Customs Enforcement in May, he is now facing the prospect of deportation. 'Despite false claims to the contrary, Roland Mehrez Beainy does not have any immigration benefits that prevented his arrest or removal from the United States,' an ICE spokesperson told the Daily Beast in a statement. Describing the Trump diehard as an 'illegal alien,' the spokesperson said that Beainy came to the U.S. from Lebanon in 2019 as a 'non-immigrant visitor' but failed to leave as required by Feb. 12, 2024. He was arrested on May 16 of this year and is now undergoing court proceedings, although he has been granted bond. 'Under the current administration, ICE is committed to restore integrity to our nation's immigration system by holding all individuals accountable who illegally enter the country or overstay the terms of their admission,' the spokesperson said. 'This is true regardless of what restaurant you own or political beliefs you might have.' A spokesperson for the Department of Homeland Security claimed further that Beainy had staged a 'sham' marriage in an effort to obtain a green card. Newsweek reported that a woman claiming to be Beainy's wife had filed a petition for legal status on his behalf. But the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services found no evidence to demonstrate that they were actually married. 'USCIS revoked the petition after evidence, including admissions from the petitioner's own family, exposed his marriage as a sham designed to game the system,' the DHS spokesperson said. 'This person has no green card, a history of illegal marriages, and an assault charge. DHS is actively pursuing all legal avenues to address this flagrant abuse of our immigration laws.' Responding to the situation, Beainy told Houston news site Chron, '90 percent of the s--t they're saying is not true.' He didn't offer any other comment, citing the advice of his attorney. The Daily Beast has reached out to Trump Burger and Beainy for comment. Beainy is currently embroiled in multiple legal battles related to Trump Burger, according to The Fayette County Record. In one ongoing lawsuit, Beainy is fighting to prove that he bought his 50 percent in the business for $65,000 from Iyad Abuelhawa, who goes by Eddie Hawa. Hawa argues that there was no written agreement and is demanding $1 million in damages. Beainy is also suing the landlord for a Trump Burger location in Kemah Texas that has since rebranded itself as 'MAGA Burger.' Beainy claims that Archie Patterson 'commandeered' the business from him after a dispute over a liquor license. While Trump is famously a lover of hamburgers—particularly McDonald's, where on the campaign trail he once worked a shift—he hasn't seemed to be a fan of Trump Burger. The Fayette County Record reported that Trump's company, The Trump Organization, sent the eatery a cease-and-desist letter in February for 'flagrantly infringing upon the Trump Organization's valuable and well-established intellectual property right' by using Trump's name and brand. The Trump Organization did not immediately return the Daily Beast's request for comment. The White House declined to comment on Beainy's arrest. In a scathing review of Trump Burger, the culinary site Eater reported earlier this year that the chain features a joke menu item called 'the Biden Burger,' which has a 1 oz patty with 'old tomato' and 'the oldest buns available due to cheating and inflation.' 'Images of Trump dominate the space, with life-size posters alongside flags, slogans, and merchandise that blur the line between restaurant decor and propaganda,' Eater reported. The outlet described the burgers as 'thick but bland' and topped with a 'waxy cheese,' but observed that the fries were 'crisp.' Solve the daily Crossword
