The All Blacks hopefuls facing nervous wait during playoffs: Elliott Smith's Tight Five
An explanation
There might not be enough of a window for players to come from nowhere to make the cut, but the playoffs will crystallise the selections for Scott Robertson and co as they nail down the 35-man squad to face France.
It's such an advantage the deeper your side goes in the playoffs, with a chance to show how you play in a pressure game and whether your skillset can remain whole or even expand as the big moments happen. Of course, the opposite can happen – and you can play your way out of the mix.
A prediction
That's why Fabian Holland and Timoci Tavatavanawai, two players in the All Blacks mix, face a nervous wait as the finals play out. Neither is a certainty to make the squad and there's little they can do over the next three weeks as Josh Lord gets his chance to impress for the Chiefs, while Braydon Ennor and Quinn Tupaea (assuming he can return from an eye injury) – feasibly in a shootout with Tavatavanawai – will be front and centre.
A try here, a line-break there, a try-saving tackle, whatever it might be, special plays in the finals mean more to All Blacks selectors.
A suggestion
There's recent precedent for the playoffs helping to clear up tight selections for the All Blacks coaches, with Wallace Sititi's wrecking-ball performance against the Hurricanes in last year's semifinal for the Chiefs helping to earn him a spot.
Akira Ioane and Hoskins Sotutu had a line drawn through their names as the Blues pack was torn to shreds by the Crusaders the previous season, with then All Blacks coach Ian Foster admitting their performances that night had made up the selectors' minds.
Wallace Sititi caught the eye of selectors in last season's semifinal against the Hurricanes. Photo / Photosport
A question
Who can rule the big moments?
Even indirectly, there can be comparisons drawn between the players in the mix as to the influence they wield in the last three weeks. Du'Plessis Kirifi may not get a chance to go head to head with Dalton Papali'i in the playoffs, but the chance to show that the former can handle it when the heat is turned up and keep his discipline – a major improvement in his game this year – could prove vital come June 23. Papali'i has an All Blacks jersey to protect after missing last year's end-of-year tour through injury and was seemingly on the outer before then anyway.
The All Blacks were found lacking last year in closing out big fixtures, twice in South Africa and against France in Paris – three games they could have won. The Super Rugby playoffs are not test rugby, but they have a big say in who gets there.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
3 hours ago
- RNZ News
Brumbies v Hurricanes: what you need to know
Photo: LIAM SWIGGS Brumbies v Hurricanes Kick-off: 9:35pm Saturday 7 June GIO Stadium, Canberra Live blog updates on RNZ Sport The big chat about this game this week is whether it actually means anything, given that if the Chiefs and Crusaders win their games, both of these teams go through next week regardless of the result. So really, the Brumbies and Canes are fighting over a trip to Hamilton or Christchurch. Much has also been made of the Hurricanes' form lately, they come in having won five in a row and a massive victory last weekend over Moana Pasifika. The Brumbies had a controversial loss to the Crusaders last weekend, however, hold a significant home ground advantage in Canberra. Brumbies: 1. James Slipper, 2. Billy Pollard, 3. Allan Alaalatoa, 4. Nick Frost, 5. Tom Hooper, 6. Rob Valetini, 7. Rory Scott, 8. Tuaina Taii Tualima, 9. Ryan Lonergan, 10. Noah Lolesio, 11. Corey Toole, 12. David Feliuai, 13. Len Ikitau, 14. Andy Muirhead, 15. Tom Wright Bench: 16. Lachlan Lonergan, 17. Lington Ieli, 18. Feao Fotuaika, 19. Lachlan Shaw, 20. Luke Reimer, 21. Harrison Goddard, 22. Declan Meredith, 23. Ollie Sapsford Hurricanes: 1. Xavier Numia, 2. Jacob Devery, 3. Tyrel Lomax, 4. Zach Gallagher, 5. Caleb Delany, 6. Devan Flanders, 7. Du'Plessis Kirifi, 8. Peter Lakai, 9. Cam Roigard, 10. Brett Cameron, 11. Fatafehi Fineanganofo, 12. Peter Umaga-Jensen, 13. Billy Proctor, 14. Bailyn Sullivan, 15. Ruben Love, 16. Raymond Tuputupu, 17. Tevita Mafileo, 18. Pasilio Tosi, 19. Hugo Plummer, 20. Brad Shields, 21. Ereatara Enari, 22. Ngatungane Punivai, 23. Callum Harkin Only the one change for the Brumbies but it's a pretty big addition to the front row, with Allan Alaalatoa coming back in and bringing his vast experience as well. Jacob Devery of the Hurricanes scores. Photo: Elias Rodriguez / Asafo Aumua is out and replaced by Jacob Devery, a situation that ended up being far more complicated than it should have after the All Black hooker was injured at training this week. Aumua was named in the team despite it being common knowledge that he had to be carted off the field, while the only other change is Caleb Delany starting at lock in place of Hugo Plummer. Cam Roigard of the Hurricanes celebrates a try. Photo: Masanori Udagawa / PHOTOSPORT The Hurricanes are undefeated in their last six games, despite trailing at half-time in three of those games - after winning only three of their previous nine games in the competition. The Brumbies have lost three of their last seven Super Rugby Pacific games at GIO Stadium after winning 10 in a row prior to that. Cam Roigard is on a three-game try scoring streak in Super Rugby Pacific. Hurricanes 35 - 29 Brumbies The Canes held on in a tight game just four weeks ago in Canberra, however, the scoreline doesn't reflect the clinical way they closed out the game against a fast-finishing Brumbies side. Despite holding a six-point lead, the Canes kept the ball in the right part of the field and simply tackled their way to a very important win. The feeling among long suffering Canes supporters is that the team has officially entered title contender status, which is a long way from where things were halfway through the season. They take a lot of belief and momentum into this one, so expect the ball to be given a lot of air because the Canes have got to this point by freeing the shackles. Expect the Brumbies to do the same, however they will revert to their power game if required.
RNZ News
5 hours ago
- RNZ News
Moana Pasifika season review: A force now to be feared
Captain Ardie Savea celebrates a win over the Blues. Photo: Brett Phibbs / In 2025, Moana Pasifika made believers of many. They came within one win of beating every New Zealand franchise, brought life to a dormant stadium and silenced plenty of critics. More importantly, they proved the project is working, giving Pacific players a platform, fans an identity and YouTube plenty of highlights. Moana Pasifika ultimately fell short of their ambition of playoff footy and, after conceding 149 points in their last two games, the gloss was somewhat taken off a very bright season. Jonty Dine looks back at the historic year that was. Beating big brothers The rivalry between the two Auckland-based franchises only grew in 2025 and, of all their Kiwi scalps, none was more satisfying than the 27-21 defeat of the Blues in front of the Albany faithful. Captain Ardie Savea produced what was described as the greatest individual performance in the competition's history. Conquering Crusaders An upset for the ages, Moana's jaw-dropping 45-29 victory in "the toughest place to play in Super" suddenly gave rivals no choice but to put some respect on their name. Miracle scores thrice The encapsulation of what Moana was about - providing a platform for a Pacific player struggling to break into the top leagues - Miracle Faiʻilagi repaid the faith shown in him with this spectacular trio of tries against the Hurricanes, as they scored another upset over a New Zealand franchise, holding off the Hurricanes 40-31. New Moana Pasifika Tana Umaga helped change the franchise culture. Photo: Brett Phibbs / Ending Highlander hopes In a thriller under the Dunedin roof, Moana halfback Melani Matavao had his own 'hand of God' moment , as he charged down a Taine Robinson clearance, regathered and scored the matchwinner to eliminate the Highlanders from playoff contention with an enthralling 34-29 victory. Back to back After their monumental win in Christchurch, the question was could Moana back it up against the Waratahs the next week? Answering in emphatic fashion, a treble for prop Feleti Sae-Ta'ufo'ou drove the 45-28 win. Ominous start Moana Pasifika were left to lament a three-loss run to start their campaign, a stretch of games that could have easily ended very differently. In their opening clash with Western Force in Perth, a 12-try epic concluded in heartbreaking fashion for the visitors. Down by 13 points with five minutes to play, the Force brought it back within six, before first-five Ben Donaldson inexplicably went 80 metres to score under the sticks and steal it. Similarly, Moana's round three match with the Highlanders - their first at home - saw them fall just two points short, after mounting a stunning comeback. Blanked by Brumbies An Ardie Savea-less Moana Pasifika failed to fire a shot on a damp day in Pukekohe, beaten 24-0 and sparking [ criticisms for the side's insistence on turning down kickable penalties. Ardie Savea leads the Moana Pasifika challenge. Photo: Photosport Hamilton humiliation While the Brumbies defeat stung, the hiding dished out by the Chiefs was effectively the blow that ended Moana Pasifika's playoff hopes, humbled in Hamilton 85-7 at the hands of a ruthless Chiefs side . Wheels come off in Welly While the fans embraced the return of one of Wellington's favourite sons - Savea - to the city, the Hurricanes were far less welcoming, handing Moana Pasifika a 64-12 hiding at the 'Cake Tin' to officially kill their campaign. Disrespectfully labelled a band of battlers in some corners, the Moana Pasifika squad proved they were anything but, with several players stamping their mark in Super Rugby 2025. Patrick Pellegrini While the pre-season talk centred around Jackson Garden-Bachop taking the reins, the unheralded Pellegrini made the biggest moves. His powerful punt, astute game management and deceptive speed saw him touted as one of the premier first-fives in the competition. Semisi Tupou Ta'eiloa A schoolboy star after making the bold move from Auckland to Invercargill, the blockbusting No.8 thrived alongside Savea and even thrust his name into All Blacks bolter conversations. Feleti Sae-Taʻufoʻou Another big mover was hulking prop Sae-Taʻufoʻou, announcing himself with a hattrick against the Waratahs, the Turbo was brutal with ball in hand. Moana Pasifika first-five Patrick Pellegreni Photo: Martin Hunter/ActionPress The primary focus upon Moana's inception was to provide a professional platform for Pasifika players who may be overlooked elsewhere. Several players epitomised this by playing their career best rugby after moving there in 2025. Lalomilo Lalomilo After making just two appearances for the Chiefs in 2023, Lalomilo had bided his time since earning national U20 selection. He returned north and appeared to find a permanent home in the Moana Pasifika midfield. A powerful runner, the Samoan is far from one-dimensional, showcasing some classy touches Jonathan Taumateine Halfback Taumatene found himself lost in the shuffle at both the Chiefs and Hurricanes, before signing with Moana Pasifika in their inaugural season. He was often stuck behind Ere Enari in the pecking order for his first three years with the side, but Umaga showed plenty of faith in Taumateine, who delivered some quality performances Millennium Sanerivi Another who produced a season as epic as his name and another Chiefs development player unable to crack the main squad, the former King's College First XV captain made his debut at hooker in round one against the Force and locked down the No.2 jersey, playing 13 of 15 games. This phenomenon was evident from the very first media session of the year, when a horde of journalists huddled around Moana Pasifika's superstar signing - the biggest coup in Super Rugby history. Ardie Savea made a mockery of claims his game would suffer at Moana Pasifika. Photo: © Photosport Ltd 2025 Making a mockery of predictions his game would suffer at the franchise, Savea was simply sensational for his adopted franchise, taking his game to levels rivalling the greatest players in the game's history. Influence is an understatement - Savea's men would follow him into war. A generational figure, who has become only more mythical at Moana Pasifika. Without a home in 2024, Moana struggled to find a sense of belonging, as they bounced between venues, sharing Go Media Stadium with the Warriors and unable to forge a genuine connection with their fanbase. Enter Albany. Moana Pasifika brought a serious injection of life to a ground in dire need of a rebirth. The atmosphere at QBE Stadium was electric and the roar when Savea snatched the matchwinning pilfer against the Blues absolutely deafening. They may have only numbered about 10,000, but the fans brought the energy and passion of a million. Tonga turmoil In a significant blow to Pacific rugby, Moana Pasifika were forced to relocate a home game against the Chiefs from Tonga to Pukekohe, due to logistical barriers on the island. Assurances have been made for efforts to make the fixture a reality in 2026, but Tongans will no doubt be sceptical. Miracle Faiʻilagi's hattrick of tries were a season highlight. Photo: Michael Thomas/ActionPress Sharks circle Fears the side would simply become a poaching ground for bigger franchises were proven justified, when Moana's top two 2023 performers - Timoci Tavatavanawai and Levi Aumua - were snapped up by the Highlanders and Crusaders respectively. Unfortunately, the trend appears to be continuing with dynamic young winger Kyren Taumoefolau likely lured away by the Chiefs for next year. While the NPC's 'Battle of the Bridge' has fizzled, a new Auckland grudge match has been born. What began as a cordial co-existence has become an increasingly heated feud between Moana Pasifika and the Blues. While the Blues say the right things on camera about the respect they have for Moana, the players and coaches across the bridge have spoken about the negative narratives coming from their so-called 'big brothers'. After Moana's official elimination from playoff contention, the Blues celebrated their finals berth with a post on Instagram saying "Keep doubtin us, we just picking the right time, don't care who side u on, there's only one of us in the finals". Moana Pasifika skipper Savea clapped back with "Lions don't care about the opinions of sheep". Shots fired. The scoreline was one apiece in 2025 and next year's clashes are bound to be barnburners. Rating B- 7/10 3.5 stars Moana Pasifika didn't reach the promised land in 2025, but they found their compass. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
NZ Herald
9 hours ago
- NZ Herald
All Blacks 2025: NZ rugby coach Scott Robertson's revolution enters decisive stage
The All Blacks' story has certainly followed a revolutionary path in that there was a seismic cleanout of personnel after the 2023 World Cup – a grand toppling of the previous regime that felt brutal and public in the way so many lost their jobs, and lost them while they were still in them. And then came the period of unrest, the uncertainty in the aftermath of the blood-letting that saw Robertson suffer upheaval in his own coaching team after assistant Leon MacDonald quit after five tests. It saw Robertson pick an unwinnable fight with his employer by regularly protesting existing All Blacks' eligibility policies and advocating for change. Then in the final test of the year there was TJ Perenara's politicised haka, which caused significant angst and upset among the senior playing group. There was also an at-times bitter and toxic battle between warring factions trying to amend New Zealand Rugby's constitution to change the way directors were appointed. Damian McKenzie was given sporadic opportunities at first five-eighths last year. Photo / Photosport Last year was turbulent, and there was an air of volatility about the All Blacks in their chop-and-change selections (Robertson was unable to commit to Damian McKenzie as chief playmaker), their up-and-down performances, and their failure to deliver a transformational brand of rugby that was cohesive and enlightened. If there was a revolutionary tactical blueprint, a bright new vision for how players are presented to the public, and an intent to unearth a cohort of emerging superstars, it never materialised amid the constant upheaval. But 2025 should be the year that stage two of the revolution begins. Robertson now has his coaching team set up how he wants, and with MacDonald gone there is no longer ambiguity about the axis of power and who is playing Trotsky to his Lenin. Scott Robertson and Vladimir Ilyich Ulyanov. Photos / Getty Images; Supplied Graphic / Herald This is the Robertson-Scott Hansen regime and, despite the clamouring for the captaincy to be shifted to Ardie Savea, Scott Barrett is the third member of the inner sanctum. The power base has been established inside the team, and so too has it been fortified within NZR. In February, a significantly more competent and focused board of directors, led by former All Blacks captain David Kirk, took their seats. They made their presence immediately felt by getting chief executive Mark Robinson to publicly align Robertson with the eligibility policy. This effectively ended what was increasingly being seen as less of a broadly principled quest to update a no longer fit-for-purpose law regime, and more a thinly disguised attempt to bend the rules to select the Japan-based Richie Mo'unga. The greater stability in the wider rugby landscape and the confidence that may have grown within Robertson and his coaching team because of that greater stability could potentially see stage two of the revolution begin with a more radical lens applied to selection this year. Super Rugby has shifted into the playoffs to provide a more intense environment. Perhaps Robertson will be using these next few weeks to decide whether there is room in his 35-man squad for new players, and indeed whether there are some potential unexpected twists in the way some already identified talents could be utilised. Top of the list as a possible new cap will be Chiefs loose forward Simon Parker, whose work this season has been unmissable. He may well be the thundering big lump the All Blacks are constantly hunting for. At 1.97m and 117kg, he's a unique beast in New Zealand. Athletes of these dimensions roam all over Europe, but in New Zealand it is rare to find someone of this size capable of playing in the back-row and able to live with the high-paced, aerobic demands of Super Rugby. Parker may be the player the All Blacks can develop into becoming their version of South Africa's Pieter-Steph du Toit – a feat which would effectively be revolutionary in itself. As a positional twist, perhaps these next few weeks could provide reason for Robertson to double down on using Ruben Love as a wing in the test arena. The 24-year-old won his solitary cap playing on the right wing last year (after running at fullback for the Hurricanes) and has this season shown himself to be a more than capable first five-eighths. Is Love the sort of multi-skilled all-rounder the All Blacks could park in the No 14 jersey to replace the departing Mark Tele'a and give themselves three play-makers on the field at any one time? As revolutionary concepts go, having two natural No 10s in the back three is as radical as they come and would align strongly with Robertson's desire to have his All Blacks play a sweeping style of rugby based on the accuracy of their pass and catch. The revolution did begin last year, just not in the way everyone expected or wanted. But this year, the people need to see what they thought they were going to get in 2024 – a new-look All Blacks team that justified the decision to topple the previous regime. Gregor Paul is one of New Zealand's most respected rugby writers and columnists. He has won multiple awards for journalism and has written several books about sport.
