Opening statements start in ‘rape' retrial of Harvey Weinstein
The case is being retried because an appeals court threw out the landmark 2020 conviction.
Advertisement
The retrial is happening at the same Manhattan courthouse as the first trial, and two accusers who gave evidence then are expected to return.
Weinstein's retrial is playing out at a different cultural moment than the first, which happened during the height of the #MeToo movement.
Along with the charges being retried, he faces an additional allegation from a woman who wasn't involved in the first case.
The jury counts seven women and five men, unlike the seven-man, five-woman panel that convicted him in 2020, and there's a different judge.
Advertisement
The #MeToo movement, which exploded in 2017 with allegations against Weinstein, has also evolved and ebbed.
At the start of Weinstein's first trial, chants of 'rapist' could be heard from protesters outside.
TV lorries lined the street, and reporters queued for hours to get a seat in the packed courtroom.
His lawyers decried the 'carnival-like atmosphere' and fought unsuccessfully to get the trial moved from Manhattan.
Advertisement
This time, over five days of jury selection, there was none of that.
Those realities, coupled with the New York Court of Appeals' ruling last year vacating his 2020 conviction and 23-year prison sentence, because the judge allowed evidence about allegations Weinstein was not charged with, are shaping everything from retrial legal strategy to the atmosphere in court.
Weinstein, 73, is being retried on a criminal sex act charge for allegedly forcibly performing oral sex on a movie and TV production assistant, Miriam Haley, in 2006 and a third-degree rape charge for allegedly assaulting an aspiring actor, Jessica Mann, in a Manhattan hotel room in 2013.
Weinstein also faces a criminal sex act charge for allegedly forcing oral sex on a different woman at a Manhattan hotel in 2006.
Advertisement
Prosecutors said that the woman, who has not been named publicly, came forward days before his first trial but wasn't part of that case.
They said they revisited her allegations when his conviction was thrown out.
The Associated Press does not generally identify people alleging sexual assault unless they consent to be named, as Ms Haley and Ms Mann have done.
Weinstein has pleaded not guilty and denies raping or sexually assaulting anyone.
Advertisement
His acquittals on the two most serious charges at his 2020 trial, predatory sexual assault and first-degree rape, still stand.
Lindsay Goldbrum, a lawyer for the unnamed accuser, said Weinstein's retrial marks a 'pivotal moment in the fight for accountability in sex abuse cases' and a 'signal to other survivors that the system is catching up — and that it's worth speaking out even when the odds seem insurmountable'.
This time around, the Manhattan district attorney's office is prosecuting Weinstein through its Special Victims Division, which specialises in such cases, after homicide veterans helmed the 2020 version.
At the same time, Weinstein has added several lawyers to his defense team — including Jennifer Bonjean, who is involved in appealing his 2022 rape conviction in Los Angeles.
She helped Bill Cosby get his conviction overturned and defended R Kelly in his sex crimes case.
'This trial is not going to be all about #MeToo.
'It's going to be about the facts of what took place,' Weinstein's lead lawyer, Arthur Aidala, said recently.
'And that's a big deal.
'And that's the way it's supposed to be.'
But there has already been some talk of #MeToo.
A prosecutor asked prospective jurors whether they had heard of the movement.
Most said they had, but that it would not affect them either way.
Others went further.
A woman opined that 'not enough has been done' as a result of #MeToo.
A man explained that he had negative feelings about it because his high school classmates had been falsely accused of sexual assault.
Another man said he viewed #MeToo like other social movements: 'It's a pendulum.
'It swings way one way, then way the other way, and then it settles.'
None of them is on the jury.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
2 days ago
- BBC News
Guernsey charity responds to rise in sex offence reports
An increase in the reporting of sexual offences has shown positive steps have been taken by police and charities to encourage people to come forward, the founder of a charity has in August, figures showed reporting of sexual offences in Guernsey increased by 46% in of the figures said the rise could be attributed to several factors but increased awareness about sexual misconduct - through movements like #MeToo, campaigns by local charities, and a reduced stigma in reporting such crimes - had all played a Murray, of SafetyNet, said she was "really encouraged" by the rise as it was an "incredibly good reflection" of efforts made by police and charities. 'Your decision' She said: "We've said from the start that what really needs to happen is reporting has to increase because if reporting doesn't increase, convictions won't increase."Although it sounds strange to say, I was actually really pleased to see that increase and really encouraged to see it."She said the increase in people reporting was "an incredibly good reflection of the efforts that have been made by the police, of the efforts as well of the charitable sector"."If you've been the victim of a sexual assault you really do feel that you completely have lost control that's why it's incredibly important that what happens next is your decision."She added it was "almost indescribable" how difficult it was for victims to deal with what they have been through "let alone then decide 'what do I want to do about this?'". Acting Det Ch Insp Tanner, from Guernsey Police, said: "We obviously have the establishment of the sexual assault referral centre... and that is a great place for people to go if they're unsure if they want to make a report."They're able to go there, they can still capture the evidence so then if they then feel the confidence of going forward they can then come to the police and that evidence isn't lost, they're supported there by specially trained people who can talk them through the process." He said: "Obviously we want to hear about it so we can report it but we understand it's the victim's choice."He added the main message was "we will investigate it properly, we will follow all the leads and we will work with you".
The Independent
2 days ago
- The Independent
Ethiopian migrants face kidnappings and death, leaving behind heartbroken families
When 19-year-old Nigus Yosef told his parents he was going to leave home in Ethiopia's Tigray region and try to get to Saudi Arabia, they begged him not to go. Two of their children had already made the crossing, via the Gulf of Aden and then war-torn Yemen. Yosef's brother is now in jail in Yemen for entering that country illegally. His sister made it to Saudi Arabia, also illegally, which means it will be difficult for her to leave. On August 3, 2025, Yosef and five friends from his town of Adi Qeyih boarded a boat bound for Yemen. That night, it capsized. Only 56 people of the nearly 200 people on board survived. Yosef was not one of them. 'His parents are in deep shock and grief,' his uncle, Redae Barhe, said in a telephone interview. 'They can't even voice their sorrow.' Nigus Yosef is one of 132 missing from the boat that capsized this month; one of countless people from African countries gone missing on a journey in search of a new life. Journeys fraught with danger The families they leave behind know that there are high odds of misfortune. Boats are often overcrowded, unable to withstand rough seas. Once on dry land, there are other dangers. Migrants are vulnerable, with few resources or protection, making them easy prey for human traffickers and kidnappers. Senait Tadesse says that her 27-year-old daughter made it to Yemen, only to be held captive by kidnappers who communicated with Tadesse through Facebook, demanding a US$ 6,000 ransom to release her only child. Tadesse said in an interview with The Associated Press in the capital, Addis Ababa, that she sold her car and all her jewelry to raise the cash and deposited the money in an Ethiopian bank account. But the kidnappers demanded more. She sold all her belongings; they still wanted more. Not knowing what else to do, she went to the police, armed with the local bank account number that the kidnappers had been using. Meanwhile, she was on Facebook, trying to get news of her daughter. Eventually, a post from a survivor confirmed that Tadesse's daughter had been killed. To date, no arrests have been made. Driven by desperation Although Ethiopia has been relatively stable since the war in the country's Tigray region ended in 2022, youth unemployment is high and there are still pockets of unrest. 'Many young people no longer see a future for themselves within a nation that does not prioritize their needs,' explained Yared Hailemariam, an Ethiopian human rights advocate based in Addis Ababa. 'The cause of this migration is lack of economic opportunities and growing conflicts. Young people are faced with a choice of either taking up arms to fight in endless conflicts, or providing for their families.' The war in Tigray was the reason why Nigus Yosef never finished school. When the conflict started in 2020, he was in 7th Grade, and he dropped out to join the Tigray armed forces. When the ceasefire was signed in 2022, he came back home, but couldn't find a job. After three years, he was desperate. Residents in the region say that traffickers seize on that desperation, and that their networks extend even into remote areas and rural villages. Eden Shumiye was just 13 when she left Adi Qeyih with Yosef and his friends. Her parents say that she was preyed on by people smugglers during the town's public market day, and that they convinced her to leave with the group. Her parents heard nothing from her until one of the other migrants called them when they reached Wuha Limat, near the Ethiopia-Djibouti border. The news left them sick with worry. After the boat capsized, a relative of one of the survivors managed to send a voice message to them from Saudi Arabia via the messaging app Imo, confirming that Eden's dead body had been recovered. Of the six young people who left Adi Qeyih, only two survived. 'Her mother is heartbroken,' Eden's father, Shumiye Hadush, told The Associated Press. 'The pain is truly overwhelming.' Ethiopia issues a warning In response to the recent tragedy, the Ethiopian government issued a statement warning citizens 'not to take the illegal route,' and to 'avoid the services of traffickers at all cost,' while urging people to 'pursue legal avenues for securing opportunities.' But Girmachew Adugna, a migration scholar specializing in Ethiopia and the Horn of Africa, points out that legal migration channels are slow and time-consuming. 'Passports are hard to obtain due to rising costs,' he says. 'Young people often have little or no access to legal migration pathways, which leads them to migrate through irregular means.' More than 1.1 million Ethiopians were classified as migrants who left their home country and were living abroad in 2024, up from about 200,000 recorded in 2010, according to United Nations figures. In spite of Yemen's civil war, the number of migrants arriving there has tripled from 27,000 in 2021 to 90,000 last year, the U.N. International Organization for Migration, or IOM, said last month. To reach Yemen, migrants are taken by smugglers on often dangerous, overcrowded boats across the Red Sea or Gulf of Aden. The IOM said at least 1,860 people have died or disappeared along the route, including 480 who drowned. 'Our youth are dying because of this dangerous migration,' says Eden Shumiye's father Hadush. 'They fall victim to the cruelty of traffickers. When will this tragedy come to an end?' ___ Associated Press writer Khaled Kazziha in Nairobi, Kenya contributed to this report. ___ For more on Africa and development: The Associated Press receives financial support for global health and development coverage in Africa from the Gates Foundation. The AP is solely responsible for all content. Find AP's standards for working with philanthropies, a list of supporters and funded coverage areas at
STV News
6 days ago
- STV News
Weinstein could face trial for a third time on rape charge
Harvey Weinstein is set to face his third trial in New York City in a sexual assault case, after the jury failed to reach a verdict on a rape charge. Weinstein, 73, was convicted in June of forcing oral sex on TV and movie production assistant and producer Miriam Haley in 2006. At the same time, the jury acquitted him of forcing oral sex on another woman, one-time model Kaja Sokola, but couldn't decide on a charge that he raped hairstylist and actor Jessica Mann in 2013. He is due to be sentenced on September 30 for the Haley conviction, but only if the new trial relating to the Mann charges does not go ahead. If there is a retrial, the judge wants it to happen in the next few months. Prosecutors and Weinstein's lawyers vowed on Wednesday that they were willing to square off at yet another trial, which would be his third in New York and fourth overall. But Weinstein's lawyers aren't ruling out the possibility of reaching a deal to resolve the case, though they also emphasise he's not willing to plead guilty to raping Mann, and they are pressing prosecutors simply to abandon that charge. Harvey Weinstein's lawyers have said they are ready to fight the trial. / Credit: AP For the charge relating to Mann, any conviction is punishable by up to four years in prison, less than Weinstein has already served, and far less than the potential 25 years he faces for his conviction related to Haley. At Weinstein's first trial in 2020, jurors convicted him of raping Mann and forcing oral sex on Haley. Then an appeals court overturned those convictions in 2024 and sent the case back for retrial because of legal issues involving other women's testimony. This spring, a new jury convicted him again of sexually assaulting Haley and acquitted him of doing the same to another woman who wasn't part of the first trial. But amid fractious deliberations, the majority-female jury found themselves stuck on the charge related to Mann. Mann has testified that she also had a consensual, on-and-off relationship with the then-married Weinstein, but that she told him 'I don't want to do this' as he cornered her in the hotel room. She said he persevered with advances and demands until she 'just gave up'. If an autumn trial happens, it would likely put Weinstein's high-profile #MeToo case back in court as Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg is in the final stage of his reelection bid. Bragg, a first-term Democrat who made prosecuting sex crimes cases a priority, has expressed satisfaction with Weinstein's conviction on a criminal sex act charge related to Haley. Bragg has said Mann deserves a verdict on her part of the case. Weinstein lawyer Arthur Aidala told reporters outside court that, in his view, it's up to prosecutors to resolve the rape charge, either by dropping it and clearing the way for sentencing, or by promptly taking it to trial again. Weinstein sat in court in a wheelchair while wearing a blue suit and black-rimmed glasses. The Pulp Fiction and Shakespeare in Love producer is committed to fighting the rape charge at another trial, Aidala said, though the lawyer added: 'I've been doing this long enough to say never say never.' Weinstein has also been convicted of sex crimes in California; he's appealing that verdict. He denies all of the allegations against him. Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
