New Leaving Cert science redevelopment project fails to address ‘crisis' in staff shortages
The ASTI is Ireland's main second level teachers union and represents 20,200 teachers across community schools, community colleges, comprehensive schools and voluntary secondary schools.
From September 2025 to 2029 new and revised Leaving cert subject specifications are set to be introduced on a phased basis across the entire Senior Cycle curriculum as part of the Senior Cycle Redevelopment Programme.
In response to the revised science subject specifications, half of all principals and deputy principals have said their schools do not have enough science laboratories to meet the number of students in their schools.
Additionally, 47% said they have teacher supply problems for science subjects and 44% believe their science labs are not well equipped.
Aaron Wolfe is the principal at Coláiste Éamann Rís secondary school in Cork City. He told the Irish Independent that despite progress in funding for science lab equipment and curricular reform, many schools, including his, do not have the space needed to benefit from them.
Mr. Wolfe's school is due to have an extension built to add two new science labs to the school which will bring them up to four labs, however, he said they are still at stage one of the process and do not have planning permission presently.
He said: 'We have a school of nearly 800 students and using two labs makes it difficult for timetabling, you're reduced in the amount of time you can do the practical elements of the course, it makes it challenging and we wouldn't be the only school in the country who are facing these kinds of challenges with regards to science.'
Speaking about the availability of equipment Mr. Wolfe said: 'The government did launch funding to buy science lab equipment the problem is if you don't actually have the room or the storage facilities for that equipment, we have very small storerooms in the school, two storerooms with the two science labs.
'Science for us is not underfunded in terms of equipment, it's getting the access to the equipment, it's more rooms we need.'
He continued: "Education in this country is not properly funded then you have the teacher shortage, it's trying to even get the science teachers to be able to actually teach the subjects and these are all added burdens to the management of schools.'
ADVERTISEMENT
According to the ASTI/RedC survey, almost three-quarters of second level school principals work more than 50 hours per week and over a third work for 56 or more hours.
The survey revealed that unsustainable workloads and a 'relentless' stream of new initiatives and policies is preventing schools leaders from focusing on key leadership duties, particularly in terms of leading teaching and learning in their schools.
Mr. Wolfe said: 'There's a crisis there in education because no one wants to actually become a principal anymore because they just see the burden on principals to meet all the legislative demands that are being put in place.
"Any new initiative that is being rolled out by the Department of Education is being put on 'well the principal can do this' and you have a constant stream of circulars arriving into schools of extra work that the principal is required to do and very little of those circulars have to do with teaching and learning.'
He added: "On top of all this you have this curriculum reform, it seems to be that they're pushing on with reform whether it's needed or whether it's wanted or not but the fact is we don't actually have teachers to go into the classrooms and teach this new curriculum in the first place.
"It makes it challenging for the teachers but teachers will make do but I suppose we're reaching a stage where we shouldn't have to make do, that we have this new course and any sort of change to the curriculum should be properly funded.'
"It shouldn't be up to schools to find work arounds, we should just have the facilities that we need deliver a top class education.'
Mr. Wolfe said he believes there is a crisis in Ireland in that there are not enough young people going into the teaching profession which he says is evident in the job advertisements being put online as the number of applicants have fallen or there are not applicants at all.
He shared that staff shortages in schools are compounding the issue and that aside from science teacher shortages, guidance councillors are also in short supply.
He said: "For guidance councillor positions, I've had no applications, I'm going to have to re-advertise for it. We're a city centre school, we have a fantastic WSC, great place to work, but we have no applicants because guidance councillors don't exist out there and now there's a mental health crisis in this country but we don't have guidance councillors, we don't have enough guidance councillors to go into the schools to fill these positions, that's a problem.'
Applications for a guidance councillor position had closed on Friday, April 11, 2025 with no applicants, Mr Wolfe said he has had to re-advertise for it and that the same position was left vacant last year as they were unable to fill it.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
3 days ago
- Irish Independent
Letters: President Higgins was right to call out Netanyahu and his slander of Ireland
Netanyahu's tactics against those who criticise his government's attempt to deflect attention from what the majority see as a calculated and continuing campaign of genocide. History has shown that aggressors often distort narratives to cast themselves as the aggrieved – a strategy that does not fool the people of Ireland or its political representatives. President Higgins has devoted his life to standing against injustice, consistently speaking out with moral courage when others remain silent. His intellect, integrity and advocacy for the oppressed are needed now more than ever. Please continue, Mr Higgins. Your voice matters. Enda Kilgallen, Dublin 18 Jewish people who want peace are the very ones who were massacred Bishop Kevin Doran claims that those Jewish people who seek a peaceful homeland for everyone in Israel and Palestine deserve our support and respect ('I understand why some are so hesitant to criticise Israel – but this needs to change', Irish Independent, May 28). However, he overlooks the fact it was precisely those Jews who were targeted by Hamas and its allies when they attacked Israel on October 7, 2023, and carried out a pogrom involving rape, mutilation and murder. Jews like Vivian Silver (74), a life-long peace activist who drove sick Gazans to hospitals in Israel every week for treatment. She was shot dead in her home in Kibbutz Be'eri on October 7 and her house was burnt down. Or Jews like Shiri Bibas who, along with her sons Kfir (nine months) and four-year-old Ariel, was kidnapped and then beaten and strangled in Gaza. Karl Martin, Dublin 13 Time for France, UK and Canada to follow through on their 'concrete actions' I listened yesterday to Tom Fletcher, UN under-secretary general for humanitarian affairs, as he described the continuing failure of food and medical aid to be delivered to Gaza. Eleven days ago, the leaders of Canada, France and the UK spoke in the strongest terms yet about Israel's egregious acts and indicated they will take 'concrete actions' unless the Netanyahu government changes course. Since then, the world has seen a trickle of aid getting into Gaza – nowhere near the 600 trucks a day that aid agencies deem necessary. Surely it is clear to those three leaders, and to the 23 foreign ministers who issued a statement at the same time demanding the provision of aid, that Israel is providing optics with the paltry aid getting into Gaza. The rhetoric from various Israeli government ministers clearly shows there is no sense of a commitment to allowing the necessary levels of aid to enter Gaza. These world leaders must have had in mind what their 'concrete actions' were going to be when they threatened them. Now is the time to stop talking and take action; they need to unleash their proposed actions. The Netanyahu government has ridden roughshod over every red line put before it over the last 20 months with impunity. The world must now take firm, punitive action against Israel. Philip Brady, Donnycarney, Dublin Trump's political menu lacks sustenance and leaves bad taste behind I've just learned that Taco stands for Trump Always Chickens Out, and now I can't stop seeing fast food through a political lens ('Trump's woes may turn into Europe's golden opportunity', editorial, May 30). Take Pizza: Pitches Inflammatory Zealotry, Zero Accountability. Every slice is loaded with something divisive – extra cheese, hold the facts. Or the Donut: Denies Often, Never Understands Truth – round and repetitive, with a hollow centre. Then there's the Hot Dog: Habitually Over-Talks, Doesn't Offer Governance. All bun, no leadership. And who could forget the Burger: Blusters Unceasingly, Rarely Gets Effective Results. It may look substantial, but you'll regret biting into it. Perhaps it's time the political menu offered something a little more nourishing – or at least less processed. Enda Cullen, Tullysaran Road, Armagh Let's hope penny will drop for unwitting vandals damaging the Causeway Tourists are placing coins in the cracks between the basalt rocks at the Giant's Causeway. When they realise the damage this is causing, I'm sure the penny will drop. Noel Kelly, Doonbeg, Co Clare Leaving Cert diarist a joy to read – I look forward to following her journey The young people of today never fail to amaze me. They are so full of empathy and bursting with confidence. No more so than Michaela Gillooly, this year's Leaving Cert Diary reporter, who will be writing about her experiences over the course of the exams. After reading her first article ('I'm aiming for over 500 points – I'd be lying if I said I wasn't nervous', May 29), written even before this anxious time begins, let me assure your readers we have much to look forward to. Brian McDevitt, Glenties, Co Donegal US court will not hold the president back for long, so EU must strike a deal now While it is reassuring to see push-back by a US federal court on Donald Trump's unilateral decision to impose tariffs on imports, we should all know that Trump is not an enthusiastic fan of courts opposing his will. I sincerely hope the EU doesn't take too much solace and uses the decision as an incentive now to strike a deal while the iron is hot. Aidan Roddy, Cabinteely, Dublin 18 Clarification In an editorial published on May 21, the UN was quoted alleging that 14,000 babies would die in Gaza within 48 hours unless they were given food and medical aid. We wish to point out that the UN later issued a correction, clarifying that the figure of 14,000 babies actually represents potential deaths from malnutrition over the course of a full year. It highlighted a report from the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification, which stated 14,100 severe cases of acute malnutrition were expected to occur between April 2025 and March 2026.
Irish Independent
3 days ago
- Irish Independent
TUI members vote to accept senior cycle redevelopment measures
The union's executive committee had recommended acceptance as it believed the measures were the best that could be achieved through negotiations. The TUI said in a statement that it made it clear 'at all times' that the ballot was on the implementation measures and not the curriculum itself, which the Education Minister has the power to prescribe under the Education Act 'and which other stakeholders have no veto over'. TUI president David Waters said it is clear that members 'still have a range of concerns around various issues related to the redevelopment process, and we will be insisting that the Department honours the commitments set out in the negotiated document'. "We have specific concerns about the system capacity for the roll-out of the science subjects in schools that have been chronically under-resourced, the potential risks to assessment posed by AI and the additional resourcing required to ensure that no students, particularly those in DEIS settings, are put at a disadvantage by any of the changes. It is now imperative that these and any other arising issues are urgently addressed.' The union had called for a delay in the implementation of the revised Trance 2 subjects of English and accounting ahead of recent negotiations that led to the publication of the Senior Cycle Implementation Measures document. It stated that the Department will 'continue to engage regularly with the NCCA on the delivery timelines' of Tranche 2-5 subjects and 'where considered appropriate and necessary for development and/or implementation reasons, the implementation of individual subjects may be delayed from the current published schedule.' The union added that it 'once again drew attention to Ireland's shamefully low level of investment in education, which sees us spend a lower percentage of national wealth on education than any other listed OECD country'. "The education budget for 2026 will need to increase significantly to properly facilitate such significant change.'
Irish Times
3 days ago
- Irish Times
Teaching union votes to accept controversial Leaving Cert reforms
Members of the Teachers' Union of Ireland (TUI) have voted by a margin of 73 per cent to 27 per cent to accept a package of supports aimed at easing the roll-out of controversial Leaving Certificate reforms. The outcome of the Association of Secondary Teachers Ireland (ASTI) ballot on the same issue is due next Friday. The strength of the TUI vote, however, looks likely to avert the threat of industrial action across second level schools in the autumn. It also paves the way for curriculum changes which seek to broaden assessment and ease pressure facing Leaving Cert students. READ MORE The reforms will see students awarded a minimum of 40 per cent for project work or practicals across all subjects. Minister for Education Helen McEntee , who has pushed ahead with the reforms despite calls for a pause from teaching unions, welcomed the outcome of the TUI vote. She thanked the union for its 'positive engagement' during recent negotiations and for its 'commitment to finding a shared path forward to the continued implementation of senior cycle redevelopment for the benefit of all students'. Teaching unions' annual conferences at Easter heard concerns that laboratories were ill-equipped for the volume of new research projects for physics, chemistry and biology. It was also stated that the changes would benefit affluent schools with access to more resources. During subsequent negotiations with teaching unions, the Department of Education announced a support package aimed at easing the roll-out of the reforms, which begin for fifth year students in September next. The package clarified that pay increases of up to 5 per cent, due under the public sector pay deal, were contingent on co-operating with senior cycle reforms. It also offered pledges of flexibility in relation to so-called Croke Park hours and a shorter qualifying period for teachers to attain job permanency by way of a contract of indefinite duration. In addition, the support package pledged to address teachers' concerns over workload and authenticating students' work against a backdrop of rapid developments in artificial intelligence (AI), among other issues. The TUI's executive committee had recommended acceptance, stating that it believed the measures were the 'best that could be achieved through negotiation'. The ASTI, on the other hand, did not issue any recommendation to members. In a statement on Friday evening, the TUI said it made clear at all times that the ballot was on the 'acceptability of the implementation measures and not the actual curriculum', which the Minister has the power to prescribe under the Education Act and 'which other stakeholders have no veto over'. TUI president David Waters said its members had assessed the support package for senior cycle implementation and voted to accept it. 'However, it is clear that they still have a range of concerns around various issues related to the redevelopment process, and we will be insisting that the department honours the commitments set out in the negotiated document,' Mr Waters said. He said members still had concerns about the system capacity for the roll-out of the science subjects in schools that have been 'chronically under-resourced', the potential risks to assessment posed by AI and the additional resourcing required to ensure that 'no students, particularly those in Deis settings, are put at a disadvantage by any of the changes'. 'It is now imperative that these and any other arising issues are urgently addressed,' Mr Waters said. Earlier this week, the TUI welcomed a report in The Irish Times of a delay in the implementation of changes in English and accounting until September 2027. The reforms – including oral exams for English – were due to roll out in September 2026.
