logo
Opinion: Political water cooler talk

Opinion: Political water cooler talk

Yahoo05-02-2025
In addition to the Super Bowl lineup, 'water cooler' conversations last week were dominated by political topics. We try to quench the readers' thirst with our perspectives.
The Legislature came out swinging against public employee unions this session. The bill passed the full House and a Senate committee before being slowed down. Why are these workers targeted and what is the likely outcome?
COWLEY: The divisive relationship between the UEA and Republican-led Legislature has added fuel to this fire. Unions are inherently political in nature, and that political power has disproportionately been deployed to benefit Democrats, but union members aren't necessarily the stalwarts of liberal values they once were. Many union workers voted for Trump. Unions are made up of blue-collar workers who are feeling the sting of inflation at the grocery store and gas pump. Many are gun owners. That all sounds pretty Republican to me, so why are some unions, particularly the UEA, still carrying the banner of Democrat causes? The Legislature doesn't want liberal union leadership speaking for all public employees. My suggestion: Address the problem, but leave the police and firefighters out of it.
The Legislature introduced a substitute bill that would require a recertification vote every five years granting the union collective bargaining authority on behalf of all employees, union and non-union. The bill does not impact the right to join a union.
PIGNANELLI: 'I learned from my father to respect the dignity of work and the dignity of working people.' — Donald Trump
When in private legal practice, I was honored to represent many Utahns — hired by a public agency — in various employment disputes and wage negotiations. These included school employees (i.e. custodians, school bus drivers, secretaries, etc.), police officers and firefighters.
I advocated for them in multiple settings with elected or prominent appointed officials. The associations to which they belonged retained me or provided support otherwise. Almost always, the agency on the other side enjoyed professional assistance. Thus, such trade organizations help level the playing field for these good people.
Public employees have statutory protections, but navigating sometimes turbulent waters requires external help. Fellow citizens who protect our children and keep us all safe have the right to associate with their colleagues to also help them. The freedom of association provided in our federal and state constitutions recognizes these fundamental considerations.
True to his campaign promises, Trump froze billions of dollars of federal funding about to go out the door. A federal court has halted the action for now, but if Trump prevails, how will this impact Utah?
COWLEY: Promises made, promises kept. Trump said for years on the campaign trail that he would drastically cut government spending. Why is anyone surprised that he is actually doing it? Perhaps because we have heard this perennial promise from just about every presidential candidate, but none have followed through.
Cutting spending is a great rallying cry for those worried about our ballooning national debt, but when it comes down to the brass tacks, there is a real price to be paid for all these cost-cutting measures. Each federal program, no matter how obscure, has a constituency that deeply cares about it. Many are happy to see pork cut until it is their golden goose headed to slaughter.
Trump's goals to address the national debt, reestablish domestic manufacturing dominance and restore border security aren't achievable without some sacrifices — withholding federal funds and implementing tariffs. Time will tell how much fiscal pain voters are willing to endure to see these principles come to fruition.
In a tight budget year, this freeze would make the Legislature's constitutional obligation to balance the budget even harder.
PIGNANELLI: About a quarter of our state budget is from federal sources, and much more is spent in Utah through other activities. Such reliance on Washington, D.C., is replicated in the other states, thus explaining consternation with Trump's freeze on grants.
Interest payments on the national debt are now the highest spending category in the federal budget. Although the philosophical underpinnings of Trump's actions are rational, he once again selected a sledgehammer over a more productive scalpel. This was disturbing to members of both parties. Yet, Trump is signaling that much more discomfort is in the future if the usual talk of reducing the deficit translates into action.
Trump's cabinet is almost complete, having endured Senate interrogations, but three nominees still remain. Will RFK Jr., Tulsi Gabbard and Kash Patel get the green light, and what is Utah's delegation saying about them?
COWLEY: Moderate Republicans feel pressure to not rubber stamp every single Trump cabinet appointee and policies. They may use these last few appointees to make a stand. Utah's Sen. Curtis expressed his concern with Tulsi, RFK has drawn criticism from both the left and right for his stance on vaccines, and Patel faced one of the most contentious Senate inquisitions yet. Protestations and feigning apprehension, then voting for these cabinet members, may be enough for moderates to demonstrate their independence from Team Trump without incurring its ire.
PIGNANELLI: Curtis' mild hesitancy on Gabbard has prompted a flurry of activity. But her approval by the Senate Intelligence Committee will likely secure her Senate confirmation. This will make it easier for Kennedy and Patel.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Six months after L.A. fires, Newsom calls for federal aid while criticizing Trump's ‘polluted heart'
Six months after L.A. fires, Newsom calls for federal aid while criticizing Trump's ‘polluted heart'

Los Angeles Times

time25 minutes ago

  • Los Angeles Times

Six months after L.A. fires, Newsom calls for federal aid while criticizing Trump's ‘polluted heart'

Gov. Gavin Newsom on Monday marked the six-month anniversary of the Eaton and Palisades fires with a call for billions in federal funding to support the state's wildfire recovery, and offered a blistering critique of the Trump administration's most recent immigration raids in MacArthur Park. Newsom said the immigration raids were proof of President Trump's 'polluted heart,' a shift from the weeks after the fires when he tried to strike a more conciliatory tone as he pushed for more federal aid from Congress and the White House. The comments, made after a news conference to mark the six-month anniversary of the fires, left Newsom once again in the conflicting position of criticizing Republicans while asking them for disaster aid. So far, the GOP-led U.S. House of Representatives has made no progress on a request from Newsom, made in late February, for $40 billion in additional wildfire funding that would go toward rebuilding schools, churches, homes and hospitals. Newsom said Monday that fire funding is a nonpartisan issue, and that all U.S. states are 'in this together.' He said that other states have outstanding requests for federal aid after their own natural disasters, and that the Republican-controlled House will 'absolutely' come through. He urged federal lawmakers to do the same for Texas after last week's deadly floods. 'South Carolina, I think they should get every penny that they need,' Newsom said. 'North Carolina, they should get every penny that they need. ... I expect that we will figure out a path, a bipartisan path, to support the people of the United States of America, and those include the 40 million Americans residing in California.' Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass had been scheduled to appear at the event, held at Pasadena City College, but did not attend after heavily armed federal immigration agents on horseback descended on MacArthur Park. The federal government's work in Los Angeles County has included a record-breaking debris removal program run by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers. Newsom said Monday that 9,195 of the 9,873 properties enrolled in the federal government's debris removal program have been cleared. That figure doesn't include commercial buildings, which were not included in the Army Corps program, or the nearly 2,000 property owners who chose to hire their own private contractors for debris removal. Newsom said the clearance was the fastest in California history, surpassing the cleanups that followed the 2018 Camp and Woolsey fires. The federal government has reimbursed the state and local governments for direct response costs and paid for their own debris cleanup, said Brian Ferguson, a spokesperson for the governor. The federal government has also provided more than $3 billion in individual assistance to homeowners and small-business loans, he said. Long-term recovery funding, which the federal government typically provides states after disasters, is expected to be determined by Congress after lawmakers return to work in September, Ferguson said. Reps. Judy Chu (D-Monterey Park) and Brad Sherman (D-Sherman Oaks), who represent Altadena and Pacific Palisades in Congress, said they were continuing to push for the supplemental aid package in Congress with 'no strings.' Some Republicans have suggested linking aid to policy decisions in California, including changes to water policy or voter identification laws. Sherman said California's $40-billion request could get through the House 'as a supplemental that also includes the Texas disaster and other disasters.' Newsom and Trump appeared to put aside their political differences in January when the commander in chief traveled to Los Angeles to survey wildfire damage. After embracing on the tarmac at Los Angeles International Airport, the two sparring partners pledged to work together to rebuild the fire-ravaged communities. Hours before the in-person meeting, the president had threatened to condition any wildfire funding on California agreeing to adopt more stringent voter identification laws. Trump has continued to point the finger at Newsom since the meeting, calling the governor and local officials 'incompetent.' In his final days in the White House, President Biden pledged that the federal government would cover 100% of disaster assistance costs to California for 180 days, and the Trump administration has 'honored that commitment,' Newsom said Monday. But Newsom hasn't held back sharp critiques of the president's leadership on other major topics, including immigration, tariffs, and healthcare funding. After discussing the state's response to the wildfires, Newsom condemned the federal immigration raids on Monday in MacArthur Park in Los Angeles as 'a disgrace.' The timing isn't a coincidence, Newsom said. He said that an estimated 41% of the state's construction workforce is working without legal status, and that immigration raids could shake a sector that is 'foundational' to the state's recovery. 'They know what they're doing,' he said. 'And then again, they have no idea what they're doing. Their ignorance is legendary. And the impacts of this will be felt in the recovery — and that's on them. Donald Trump owns that. He owns the cruelty, he owns the arrogance.'

Zohran Mamdani's opposition struggles to unite in New York City mayoral race
Zohran Mamdani's opposition struggles to unite in New York City mayoral race

CNN

time26 minutes ago

  • CNN

Zohran Mamdani's opposition struggles to unite in New York City mayoral race

Fresh off losing New York's Democratic primary for mayor to Zohran Mamdani, former Gov. Andrew Cuomo on Monday ramped up his efforts to push the incumbent mayor, Eric Adams, out of the race. Cuomo's latest gambit to keep alive his mayoral bid — and his political comeback after resigning as governor — is backing a proposal that all Mamdani challengers adhere to the results of a poll that would be taken in September, weeks before the November election. Whichever candidate is deemed by the survey to be the strongest challenger to Mamdani would continue their campaign. The rest of the field would agree to suspend their campaigns and endorse that challenger. The proposal would need the approval of the city's campaign finance board. Speaking on CNBC's 'Squawk Box' on Monday, Adams said Cuomo recently called him to suggest he should step aside and clear a lane for him to compete against Mamdani, the 33-year-old state assemblyman and democratic socialist. 'I'm the sitting mayor of the city of New York and you expect me to step aside when you just lost to Zohran?' Adams said during the interview. Adams, who opted to sit out the Democratic primary and is running as an independent, described Cuomo's request as 'the highest level of arrogance.' Cuomo remains on the November ballot as the candidate of the 'Fight and Deliver Party' but has not held any public events since primary night or committed to campaigning through November. In a statement issued by Cuomo campaign spokesperson Rich Azzopardi on Monday, the former governor's campaign did not appear any closer to bowing out of the race. 'Mayor Adams did not run in the Democratic primary because he knew he was anathema to Democrats and unelectable. Nothing has changed. We do not see any path to victory for Mayor Adams,' Azzopardi said. New York City's political establishment, which was shaken by Mamdani's resounding win, has struggled to coalesce behind a single candidate. For now, observers think Cuomo could split the city's Black vote with Adams. Also in the field is a third independent candidate, Jim Walden, who originally pitched the survey idea. Curtis Sliwa, a radio personality and founder of the Guardian Angels, a crime-prevention group, is running as the Republican nominee. He has also declined requests to drop out to send GOP support to Adams, who has drawn closer to President Donald Trump and had his corruption charges dismissed by Trump's Department of Justice. The scramble was on display Monday during a news conference in Midtown Manhattan. Former Gov. David Paterson, who endorsed Cuomo in the primary, said a single independent candidate should challenge Mamdani in the general election. But he refused to answer when asked who he thought the candidate should be. 'We can do this, but it's going to take a united effort, and it's going to take some sacrifice that someone is going to have to make,' Paterson said.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store