Climate research into cloud barriers or Arctic refreezing is worth funding
As a climate scientist working on solar geoengineering, I was struck by Raymond Pierrehumbert and Michael Mann's call to defund the UK's Advanced Research and Invention Agency (Aria) research programme (The UK's gamble on solar geoengineering is like using aspirin for cancer, 12 March).
Given current emission projections, it is likely that the world will reach 2C of warming. The only potential tool we have to reduce temperatures on a short timescale is solar geoengineering. It is necessary to reduce emissions, but once we reach net zero, global temperatures only stabilise, and the melting of glaciers and sea level rise will continue. While it is possible to remove carbon from the atmosphere, it remains slow and expensive for now.
Solar geoengineering research is important because it is possible that the climate will react more strongly to greenhouse gases than expected, and even 2C of warming might have devastating impacts.
It is undeniable that solar geoengineering has physical and political risks, and I share many of the concerns the authors raise. However, a warmer world that would increasingly become uninhabitable is also risky. Hence the risks of solar geoengineering must be balanced with the risks from the warming that would be attenuated.
Climate model evidence suggests that some important hazards linked to climate change could be limited with a judicious deployment of solar geoengineering. However, climate models contain many uncertainties that well‑governed, small-scale outdoor experiments may enable us to reduce. While more research and higher‑quality information on solar geoengineering are not sufficient to guarantee good decision-making about it in the future, they are certainly a prerequisite. I welcome the UK government's investment in solar geoengineering research.Dr Matthew HenryPostdoctoral Research Fellow at the University of Exeter
Your article is misjudged. Yes we must transform fossil fuel use and deploy carbon capture. But humans are losing the battle and we can't afford an either/or argument. Just as low-dose aspirin use may protect against cancer, low-dose prevention of heat using sulphur, manufactured clouds, Arctic refreezing or aiding flow of crucial ocean currents may be able to aid climate control. In fact, it might be the only chance we have. So please, UK, spend £57m and more on geoengineering research now.Prof Stuart HaszeldineSchool of GeoSciences, University of Edinburgh
Have an opinion on anything you've read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
2 days ago
- BBC News
Skipton cellist visits Arctic to record sounds of climate change
The sound of Arctic wind howling through the strings of Sarah Smout's carbon fibre cello on the pack ice connected to the North Pole is like nothing she has heard joined a group of artists from all over the world on a trip to research and be inspired by the "breathtaking and absolutely vast" landscape of the Arctic musician and poet spent 16 days on board a specially-equipped ship in the Norwegian archipelago of Svalbard and experienced temperatures of - said she saw climate change happening before her eyes as "cracks began to form on the ice, a large shelf broke off and we were hurried back onto the boat, no longer safe on the drifting piece of ice". Smout is using music, words and sound recordings to make her debut album, which will focus on climate change in the Arctic."Music is a brilliant way to bring people together, speak to their hearts and minds and inspire them to make decisions themselves to bring about positive change," said Smout."We are witness to the climate changing all around us, but none so dramatic and fast as in the Arctic."It might be far away but what happens there affects all of us."She said visiting Svalbard had made her more driven than ever to bring the sounds she has recorded to the wider hopes listeners will connect to what is happening in that part of the world and be encouraged to protect said her current research was about water and that she and her cello, which she has named Bernard, had been on many adventurers to explore nature."I've always been fascinated by the Arctic and I think being in places and getting a sense of the place first hand sparks my own creativity," she used a hydrophone to record under water and said the sounds she had collected, such as creaking glaciers, would speak for themselves on her album. Listen to highlights from North Yorkshire on BBC Sounds, catch up with the latest episode of Look North.
BBC News
3 days ago
- BBC News
Oxford study finds 'extraordinary' tremors caused by tsunamis
A series of "extraordinary" tremors observed across the globe were caused by two tsunamis stranded within a fjord in Greenland, a new study has September and October 2023, the "bizarre" seismic activity was observed every 90 seconds over intermittent periods each University of Oxford-led research confirmed it was caused by two mega tsunamis, which occurred after the warming of a glacier led to two major tsunamis became trapped standing waves that surged back and forth within the remote Dickson fjord in eastern Greenland, causing the tremors, the study found. The research's lead author Thomas Monahan, from the University of Oxford, said: "Climate change is giving rise to new, unseen extremes."These extremes are changing the fastest in remote areas, such as the Arctic, where our ability to measure them using physical sensors is limited." To conduct the study into what researchers called the "extraordinary" tremors , scientists used new techniques to interpret data recorded by satellites orbiting the altimetry data measures the height of the Earth's surface by recording how long it takes for a radar pulse to travel from a satellite to the surface and back altimeters were unable to record evidence of the Greenland tsunamis, but a satellite launched in December 2022 had the equipment capable of doing so - allowing researchers to observe the trapped waves."This study shows how we can leverage the next generation of satellite earth observation technologies to study these processes," Mr Monahan of the study Prof Thomas Adcock added: "This study is an example of how the next generation of satellite data can resolve phenomena that has remained a mystery in the past."We will be able to get new insights into ocean extremes such as tsunamis, storm surges, and freak waves." You can follow BBC Oxfordshire on Facebook, X (Twitter), or Instagram.
BBC News
30-05-2025
- BBC News
Birds lived in the Arctic during the time of the dinosaurs
Experts have uncovered the earliest evidence of birds nesting in polar regions.A new study has found that they were raising their young in the Arctic seventy-three million years at the same time and in the same place dinosaurs say their findings show that birds were living in the area 30 million years earlier than previously thought. What did scientists discover? The international team was led by the University of Alaska Fairbanks in the United States and also included the University of Reading in the took took a close look at more than fifty tiny fossilised bones and teeth recovered from an Alaskan excavation were collected from the Prince Creek Formation in the US state of Alaska, an area known for its dinosaur identified a number of different types of birds - including diving birds, gull-like birds and also several kinds that are similar to modern ducks and Jacob Gardner from the University of Reading, a co-author on the study, said: "For the first time, we determined the identities of large numbers of fossils using high-resolution scans and the latest computer tools, revealing an enormous diversity of birds in this ancient Arctic ecosystem."Lauren Wilson, lead author of the study, explained the importance of their discovery."Finding bird bones from the Cretaceous [period] is already very rare. To find baby bird bones is almost unheard of. That is why these fossils are significant."Birds have existed for 150 million years. For half of the time they have existed, they have been nesting in the Arctic," she added.
