Iowa Supreme Court: District didn't defame ex-West High tennis coach by posting meeting video
The Iowa Supreme Court upheld the dismissal of a defamation and breach of contract lawsuit from a former West High School tennis coach, concluding a three-year legal battle.
Anne Villarini filed a lawsuit in 2022 against the Iowa City Community School District, arguing that the district enabled defamatory comments by two former students. The comments were published in meeting minutes and broadcast in a video of the meeting from April 2022 on the district's board website and YouTube channel.
Villarini, who joined the West High tennis program in 2013, requested "on many occasions" that the school district remove the video and redact the meeting minutes, claiming that the comments and video were defamatory.
More: Iowa City West High tennis coach sues district, calling comments at school board meeting defamatory
Villarini also argued that the district wrongfully terminated her and breached the contract terms. She was hired on a series of one-year contract extensions during each tenure, according to court filings.
A Johnson County District Court judge initially granted "summary judgment" to the Iowa City district and dismissed Villarini's lawsuit. In November 2024, the state Court of Appeals denied Villarini's appeal.
The Iowa Supreme Court agreed with the lower courts on Friday, May 16, upholding the dismissal and writing that the school is protected by "fair-report privilege." The principle often protects the news media from legal repercussions when it reports on defamation during a public meeting.
"Applying the fair-report privilege to public school board meetings adds scaffolding to our open-government structure," Iowa Supreme Court Judge Samuel Langholz wrote in the opinion. "Shielding those that err on the side of transparency by drafting thorough minutes or posting unabridged videos."
More: Federal judge grants injunction in Iowa student visa case, halting possible deportation
By publishing the meeting video, the court ruled that the Iowa City Community School District was "fairly and accurately relay(ing) statements made during open, official proceedings."
The court said the fair-report privilege "furthers the public's interest" by allowing residents to make their own judgments about meetings, school board decisions and board members without having to attend the meeting.
During the comment period from the meeting in question in April 2022, a then-Iowa City West High School student described a 15-second experience where Villarini allegedly "touched (her) inappropriately" on her back and thighs and said "inappropriate things."
She and another student were critical of how the district handled the alleged situation.
"The district made clear to me that my feelings do not matter," the student said, referencing a district investigation and report that preceded the comments.
That report confirmed that some of the alleged actions, which included "unwanted physical contact," favoritism, retaliation, and insensitivity, did happen. The district determined that the accusations didn't amount to "incident contact" and were "not violative of any ICCSD policy," according to the Johnson County District Court judge's 2023 ruling.
More: Iowa Legislature ends 2025 session with no action on property taxes. Here's what happened:
The report cautioned Villarini to "refrain from touching players as much as reasonably possible." Villarini remained the coach of the girls' tennis team after the report was released.
Villarini was placed on administrative leave in 2022, the day after the two students spoke at the board meeting. Villarini said the decision was a "knee-jerk" reaction.
She received full compensation under the terms of her contract, according to the Iowa Supreme Court.
More: Despite a sudden closure 6 months ago, the Sanctuary Pub is reopening under new ownership
In her claim for breach of contract, Villarini wrote that Iowa has a public policy to protect 'against school employees being forced out of their jobs by angry parents and students making wild, unfounded allegations for the purpose of ousting that employee.'
The Iowa Supreme Court agreed with the district court, which said the claim failed because Villarini did not reference a "clearly defined public policy."
Ryan Hansen covers local government and crime for the Press-Citizen. He can be reached at rhansen@press-citizen.com or on X, formerly known as Twitter, @ryanhansen01.
This article originally appeared on Iowa City Press-Citizen: Supreme Court upholds dismissal of West High coach's defamation suit
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Dodge Challenger Fleeing Trooper Wrecks Out At 160 MPH
Read the full story on The Auto Wire Running from police is a dumb and selfish thing to do, but this Dodge Challenger driver learned that lesson the hard way. Dashcam footage obtained from Arkansas State Police shows the Mopar muscle car flee from a traffic stop, only to wreck out at 160 mph, ejecting the not entirely sure what the initial stop was for, but we're going to guess it was speeding. In the footage, you can see the trooper is sitting blacked out on the side of the highway before he flips on his lights, then pulls over the Challenger. As you already know, the guy did the dumb little trick of waiting until the trooper was walking up to his vehicle before he sped off, tires squealing. The guy must've thought with the higher-powered muscle car, there was no way the trooper could catch him. For the first while in the footage that seems correct. The suspect driver gets off the main highway and turns on a dark, rough rural road, speeding along like a demon. At one point, the pursuing trooper catches air, which seems to scare him. But he presses on, seeing the Dodge's taillights in the distance. Not that we're fans of when criminals black out while running from police, but this would've been a great time for that trick. Of course, the guy might not have been able to see where he was going. The chase continues on a much nicer two-lane road. That smoother surface must've given the suspect more confidence, because he pushes the Mopar to 160 mph. Even on a well-lit, multi-lane interstate with no traffic around that's a dangerous proposition. After all, at that speed if you make one wrong move, you're done for. The guy does and his muscle car leaves the roadway behind, exploding into thousands of pieces. He must've not been wearing a seatbelt, because the trooper couldn't find the driver for a while. As backup arrives, troopers figure the driver took off on foot. But they later find him, deceased. We guess the guy really didn't want to go back to prison and he made sure he didn't. Image via Police Pursuits/YouTube Join our Newsletter, subscribe to our YouTube page, and follow us on Facebook.
New York Post
4 hours ago
- New York Post
Colorado firebombing victims, witnesses describe horrors of antisemitic attack: ‘The attacker wanted us to burn'
Survivors and witnesses of Sunday's horrific firebombing attack in Colorado recalled the savagery that erupted out of nowhere and injured 15 peaceful marchers advocating for the release of Israeli hostages held by Hamas. Run for Their Lives, a group that organizes weekly walks in support of those still in the clutches of the terror group, was targeted in Boulder with Molotov cocktails and a makeshift flamethrower by Egyptian national Mohamed Sabry Soliman, 45, who has since been charged with a hate crime. The evil incident unfolded just moments after co-organizer Omer Shacher, 34, told attendees they shouldn't fear taking to the streets in honor of the captives. Advertisement 'Just as I said that, the attacker wanted us to burn,' Shachar told The Wall Street Journal Wednesday. 'I don't know how to call it — ironic, absurd.' 3 Victim Natalya Reznik, who remains hospitalized in Aurora, Colo., with second-degree burns, recalled the horrific attack on her YouTube page. YouTube/@natalyareznik Advertisement Dmitriy Reznik, 57, a blogger who was walking with the group when the flames started flying, told The Journal he wasn't sure what was happening — even as he felt the intense heat. He pulled his wife, Natalya Reznik, 52, who was hunched over and screaming from a puddle of fire, and laid her in a nearby patch of grass. 'Her skin was peeling, and she was thirsty,' Dmitriy told the outlet Wednesday. Natalya was one of 15 injured in the attack and airlifted to a hospital in nearby Aurora, where she's still being treated for second-degree burns. Advertisement '21st century. Boulder, a liberal college town. Someone decided to burn the Jews. Thankfully, no one died,' she wrote on her Facebook page in Russian on Sunday night. She also shared her recollection of the day's unfathomable events on YouTube from her hospital bed. Authorities said Soliman disguised himself as a groundskeeper and lay in wait for the group, learning their location by stalking its Facebook page. He told investigators he had planned the attack for more than a year, initially hoping to pull off a mass shooting, but his immigration status thwarted his ability to obtain a gun. 3 Holocaust survivor Barbara Bandler Steinmetz, 88, (left), pictured with her daughter Julie Steinmetz Shaffer, was injured in the Boulder terror attack. Advertisement He was said to have shouted 'free Palestine' as he unleashed his fiery assault on the walkers, and later told cops he hated 'Zionist people' and 'wished they were all dead.' 'I remember thinking, a gardener on Sunday? I thought something was strange,' Shachar told the Journal. 'Of course, I couldn't tell it was a terrorist.' One of those injured was 88-year-old Holocaust survivor Barbara Steinmetz, described by Boulder Rabbi Marc Soloway as a 'loving and peaceful warrior and activist' spanning numerous causes. 'For someone to have survived the Holocaust and to see Jewish bodies burning on the ground, it's just the worst thing imaginable,' he said. Despite the hate-fueled attack, the community is pressing ahead with the previously planned Boulder Jewish Festival, albeit with a beefed-up security presence. Denver's chapter of Run for Their Lives will join in Sunday's event, which has been repurposed to honor those who were injured in last week's ambush. Advertisement 3 Alleged firebomber Mohamed Sabry Soliman faces more than 600 years in prison if convicted on all charges. 'There are 58 hostages in the Gaza Strip there against their will, held in tunnels by Hamas,' Shachar said. 'I don't see any reason to stop walking while there are still hostages there.' Soliman is facing federal hate crime charges and 16 counts of attempted first-degree murder. If convicted on all counts, he could spend the rest of his life in prison. He will appear in Boulder County Court on Thursday at 3:30 p.m. local time for a return of filing of charges.
Yahoo
4 hours ago
- Yahoo
Zia Yusuf: Chairman of Reform UK resigns
The chairman of Reform UK, Zia Yusuf, has resigned. In a statement, Mr Yusuf said in a post on X that working to get the party elected is no longer "a good use of my time". He said: "11 months ago I became chairman of Reform. I've worked full time as a volunteer to take the party from 14 to 30%, quadrupled its membership and delivered historic electoral results. "I no longer believe working to get a Reform government elected is a good use of my time, and hereby resign the office." Politics latest: PM dodges more questions on benefits It comes after a row in which he described a question to Sir Keir Starmer about a ban on burkas from his party's newest MP Sarah Pochin as "dumb". There have also been reports Mr Yusuf had been sidelined. Rupert Lowe, a former Reform MP, was strongly critical of Mr Yusuf in the wake of the politician's suspension following allegations that he had threatened violence towards the party chair. Many credited businessman Mr Yusuf with professionalising the party's operations as they secured millions of votes at last year's general election. Reacting to the news, party leader Nigel Farage said: "I am genuinely sorry that Zia Yusuf has decided to stand down as Reform UK chairman. "As I said just last week, he was a huge factor in our success on May 1st and is an enormously talented person. "Politics can be a highly pressured and difficult game and Zia has clearly had enough. He is a loss to us and public life." Deputy leader Richard Tice said the party would "not be where we are today without him". Mr Lowe was less complimentary. He said: "The question is - how did a man with no political experience be given such vast power within Reform? A deeply unpleasant individual who at every stage was protected and promoted by Farage." He added that he is still taking legal action against Mr Yusuf. This breaking news story is being updated and more details will be published shortly. Please refresh the page for the latest version. You can receive breaking news alerts on a smartphone or tablet via the Sky News app. You can also follow us on WhatsApp and subscribe to our YouTube channel to keep up with the latest news.
