Councillors erupt into war of words after former Cork lord mayor votes against social housing scheme
A former lord mayor of Cork has been criticised for voting against one of three social housing projects approved by city councillors on Monday, one of which would deliver 56 homes on a former sweet factory site.
Labour councillor Peter Horgan said he was incensed by Independent councillor Kieran McCarthy's criticism of the "bland design" for four apartments on a vacant overgrown corner site at the junction of Boreenmanna Rd and Clanrickarde Estate, which attracted over 40 submissions during its Part 8 public consultation.
'Units like this being rejected because the design is bland?' Mr Horgan asked.
'I'm sorry housing isn't sexy enough for you to vote for it. That is not a reason to vote against housing.
I find it insulting to those who worked on the scheme and to those on the housing list
The deputy lord mayor, Green Party councillor Honore Kamegni, and Fine Gael councillor Des Cahill also voted against it, with Mr Cahill criticising the way the Part 8 consultation was initially presented to councillors.
Mr Kamegni said: 'Just because there is a housing crisis, doesn't mean we have to build anywhere.'
Officials said they listened to concerns and omitted the second floor of one of the units, reducing the height from three to two storeys, to deliver two two-bedroom ground floor units, one two-bed unit, and one one-bed unit on the first floor — the maximum changes possible on a tight corner site.
Councillors eventually voted 22 to seven to approve the scheme.
They also approved Part 8 planning for 56 social homes on the former Topps sweet factory in Ballincollig, which has lain vacant since the company ceased operations in the town in 1998.
Design concerns
Councillors were told the scheme will be named Innishmore Gardens and comprise of one four-bed house, 17 three-bed houses, 12 one-bed apartments, 12 two-bed duplex units, seven two-bed apartments, and seven three-bed duplex units. The scheme will also provide 58 parking spaces.
It will range in height from two storeys to three storeys, and will be carried out for the council by way of a project agreement with OBR Construction Group.
Sinn Féin councillor Joe Lynch, who was raised and lives in Innishmore, said he wants to see the housing development succeed and integrated into the existing community.
Independent councillor Albert Deasy criticised the council for not taking on board certain design concerns he said he expressed before the scheme was published for public consultation, and he called for it to be referred back to the local area committee.
However, council chief executive Valerie O'Sullivan insisted there were no Part 8 proposals before councillors that had not been properly consulted on.
'Most derelict street in Cork'
In Blackpool, councillors approved the demolition of a council-owned derelict two-storey house at 24 Thomas Davis St for a three-storey building with two units — one two-bed maisonette over a one-bed apartment, each with their own door access at ground floor level.
Fianna Fáil councillor John Sheehan welcomed the proposal for a street he said was once 'the most derelict street in Cork'.
'It once had 23 derelict sites, but that has now been reduced by half thanks to the work of the council. It's great to see the street coming back to life,' he said.
Read More
Plans for over 360 new homes in Carrigaline resubmitted to Cork County Council
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTÉ News
8 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Plans for Galway local authority rent increases criticised
Galway City Councillors have roundly criticised plans to increase rents for over 2,500 local authority tenants. The proposals arise from a 'Differential Rent Review', which aims to generate an additional €1 million in revenue per annum. The proposals would entail a 3% increase in the proportion of assessable income, to be paid in rent, by those in social housing - going from 17% to 20%. In real terms, this amounts to a weekly rent rise in the region of 17.6%. The measures also include plans to abolish a €5 discount on rents for pensioners, those with children or people with a disability. The local authority's meeting heard the move was an executive function, as opposed to a decision that would be made by elected representatives. Effectively, this means councillors have no say on whether the decision will proceed. The meeting heard that €2.8 million is outstanding in rent arrears at present. Maintenance costs have doubled since 2019, and repair costs have surged for re-lets due in part to energy retrofitting obligations. The council's Chief Executive Leonard Cleary said the plan was difficult but necessary to address a significant gap in funding for housing. He said the revenue generated would go towards the maintenance of properties owned by the council. The increase will also apply to tenants in accommodation provided by approved housing bodies. Labour Councillor Niall McNelis described the proposed increase as "the third nail in the cross" for local authority tenants across the city. He said a number of people on Housing Assistance Payments were already making under-the-counter payments to secure their tenancies. He added that "the most vulnerable are the ones that are going to be hammered here". Social Democrats Councillor Eibhlín Seoighthe said she was taken aback by the proposal. She described the plan as "absolutely appalling", adding there was no cognizance of the societal impact it would have. She added it was "a huge burden to bear, which should be measured more clearly". Independent Councillor Mike Cubbard said some of the most vulnerable people in society were tenants of the local authority and that they needed to be protected. He said the proposal to remove a €5 discount for those eligible was the worst decision he has seen since being elected to the local authority in 2014. Labour's John McDonagh said the plan was like something from a Charles Dickens novel. Sinn Féin Councillor Aisling Burke asked the executive not to proceed with the move. She said people were already experiencing significant financial difficulties and that the increase in rents was unconscionable. Citing one of four case studies presented to councillors in which a tenant's rent would go from €51 to €71 per week, she said the scale of that increase was very difficult to comprehend. "You just cannot do it," she added. Fine Gael's Shane Forde said there had been years of under-investment in Co Galway, adding the council was now experiencing the full force of this. He pointed out that in recent months, councillors had approved increases to the Local Property Tax and commercial rates. He said he was sickened that elected representatives in Dáil Éireann "never wear the Galway jersey" but were happy to be on the airwaves discussing issues of national and international import. Fianna Fail's Michael Crowe said the examples presented to elected representatives appeared to show that those who were working would be most heavily penalised by the measures. No date has been given for the increase to take effect, but it will be in place by the end of this year or early in 2026. The Director of Services for Housing defended the proposals as "timely, proportionate, reasonable and needed". Elizabeth Fanning said rents had not increased since 2019, adding that a large proportion of those impacted would be able to afford the rise. She gave a commitment that the council would "100% work" to support vulnerable renters. She also pointed out that even after the increases were processed, tenants of local authority housing in the city would still be paying around seven times less in rent than those in private rental accommodation. A motion calling on the executive to abandon the 3% rent increase and instead proceed with a 1.5 % increase in January 2026, a similar hike in January 2028 as well as maintaining the €5 discount, was approved by all councillors. However, the motion is not binding on the decision made by the Council Executive. At the conclusion of more than an hour of discussions, the Council Chief Executive said he had noted the input of members and would reflect on their motions and feedback before making a final decision on the matter.
Sunday World
10 hours ago
- Sunday World
Entire country to be brought under Rent Pressure Zone in major change agreed by government
In a meeting tonight, leaders met and agreed on a new system of national rent control Every tenancy in the country is set to be brought under a Rent Pressure Zone, Government leaders have agreed. In a meeting tonight, leaders met and agreed on a new system of national rent control. The current system, which caps yearly rent increases at 2pc or in line with inflation, will be retained. Every area of the country will now be designated as an RPZ under the new national rent control system, meaning the remaining one fifth of tenants in Ireland not in an RPZ will benefit from rent controls. Leaders this evening also agreed on stronger security of tenure protections for renters. This, it is understood, will include an end to no fault evictions in the case of large landlords. The move is one that goes against the recommendations in the report from Housing Commission. In its report last year, the commission said while the rental market was both challenging for both renter and landlord, the RPZs were constraining landlords. According to the report, it said the impact of RPZs has been mixed and the commission recommended changes to the system. In particular, the report said the RPZ system should be reformed and a new system of 'reference rents' be established instead. This would be landlords would be limited on how much they could increase rent by, and would be based off things like the size of the rental property and where it is located. The commission also said regulations should continue between tenancies. 'If a tenancy ends the same regulations apply to the subsequent tenancy. This will discourage termination of tenancies that is designed to increase rental income,' the report said. As reported in the Sunday Independent, the Government was considering new rules which will allow landlords to significantly hike rents beyond the current caps. Under original the proposals, landlords would be allowed to increase rents to market rates in between tenancies of at least six years. While current tenancies are expected to remain under the RPZ regulations, the cap would not apply to newly built apartments. Currently, rents in a Rent Pressure Zone can only be increased by 2pc or in line with inflation, whichever is lower. First introduced in 2016 to control the rapidly increasing rents in high demand areas like Dublin and Cork, it was a major intervention in the market. Rent Pressure Zones were introduced in 2016. Photo: Stock image News in 90 Seconds - Tuesday June 10 Since then, the scheme has steadily spread across the country with most areas now considered an RPZ. Almost ten years after they were first introduced, and with the current regulations are due to expire at the end of this year, it had been anticipated that the current rules around RPZs would change. The Government continues to be under pressure on the issue of housing, wth the rental sector a major focus, as the Opposition has swooped on the issue. Raise the Roof campaign will hold a rally outside Leinster House on Tuesday next week at 6pm, calling for urgent Government action on Ireland's housing and homelessness crisis. The rally is timed to coincide with a Private Members Motion tabled by Opposition parties in the Dáil, and will feature speakers from political parties, alongside a series of singers and spoken word performances. The Raise the Roof campaign group is coordinated by the Irish Congress of Trade Unions, and includes trade unions, housing and homeless agencies, women's groups, human rights advocacy groups, and community organisations. Speaking at a press conference to launch the rally, Ethel Buckley, SIPTU Deputy General Secretary said: 'Ten years into the housing crisis, and that crisis remains the greatest political failure of our time. Workers are being priced out of homes or can only rent or purchase with considerable financial burden. 'In the last 10 years rents and house prices have doubled - and in some areas more than doubled - while wages have increased by less than 40%. If anything, this gap has widened in the last couple of years. Rents and house prices are out of control. 'Alongside the human cost of this, we are seeing the serious knock on effects, with thousands of unfilled vacancies in key sectors, and young people once again choosing to emigrate. 'We are deeply concerned at the lack of urgency shown so far by this new government. A government that is content to play the role of helpless bystander to this ever-worsening emergency. What is needed now is a radical reset with sustained action to deliver secure, affordable housing.'
Irish Independent
11 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Entire country to be brought under Rent Pressure Zone in major change agreed tonight by Government leaders
In a meeting tonight, leaders met and agreed on a new system of national rent control. The current system, which caps yearly rent increases at 2pc or in line with inflation, will be retained. Every area of the country will now be designated as an RPZ under the new national rent control system, meaning the remaining one fifth of tenants in Ireland not in an RPZ will benefit from rent controls. Leaders this evening also agreed on stronger security of tenure protections for renters. This, it is understood, will include an end to no fault evictions in the case of large landlords. The move is one that goes against the recommendations in the report from Housing Commission. In its report last year, the commission said while the rental market was both challenging for both renter and landlord, the RPZs were constraining landlords. According to the report, it said the impact of RPZs has been mixed and the commission recommended changes to the system. In particular, the report said the RPZ system should be reformed and a new system of 'reference rents' be established instead. This would be landlords would be limited on how much they could increase rent by, and would be based off things like the size of the rental property and where it is located. ADVERTISEMENT Learn more The commission also said regulations should continue between tenancies. 'If a tenancy ends the same regulations apply to the subsequent tenancy. This will discourage termination of tenancies that is designed to increase rental income,' the report said. As reported in the Sunday Independent, the Government was considering new rules which will allow landlords to significantly hike rents beyond the current caps. Under original the proposals, landlords would be allowed to increase rents to market rates in between tenancies of at least six years. While current tenancies are expected to remain under the RPZ regulations, the cap would not apply to newly built apartments. Currently, rents in a Rent Pressure Zone can only be increased by 2pc or in line with inflation, whichever is lower. First introduced in 2016 to control the rapidly increasing rents in high demand areas like Dublin and Cork, it was a major intervention in the market. Since then, the scheme has steadily spread across the country with most areas now considered an RPZ. Almost ten years after they were first introduced, and with the current regulations are due to expire at the end of this year, it had been anticipated that the current rules around RPZs would change.
