Mindfulness may combat ‘hard to treat' depression
But offering an additional course of mindful cognitive behavioural therapy, delivered through a weekly video call, could help reduce symptoms for people with difficult-to-treat depression, according to their new study.
NHS talking Therapies, which has been dubbed one of the most ambitious treatment services of its kind in the world, offered treatment to 1.83 million people in 2023/24.
Struggling with feelings of depression, excessive worry, social anxiety, post-traumatic stress or obsessions and compulsions? NHS Talking Therapies can help.
The service is effective, confidential and free.
Your GP can refer you or refer yourself at https://t.co/hLaEBNYcHL pic.twitter.com/VD8EdQsjKP
— NSFT mental health (@NSFTtweets) May 13, 2025
People whose symptoms do not respond to low-intensity treatment, or who present with more complex illnesses, are offered high-intensity treatment.
But figures suggest that 50% of people with depression who complete high-intensity therapies still have lingering symptoms – also known as difficult-to-treat depression.
Academics said there has been little research into treatment options when people with depression have not shown remission of symptoms during a previous psychological therapy, as they set out to examine whether mindfulness-based cognitive therapy (MBCT) could help.
The eight-week treatment uses 'mindfulness practice as a means of helping patients become better at recognising and disengaging from habitual maladaptive patterns of thinking', they said.
It works by using intensive training in mindfulness meditation to help people develop skills to respond better to negative mood and stress, in addition to cognitive behavioural therapy principles which seek to change negative thought patterns.
The new study, led by an expert from the University of Surrey and published in the journal Lancet Psychiatry, saw 234 patients who still had depression symptoms after NHS Talking Therapies split into two groups.
One group received MCBT, delivered via video conferences, while the other group had treatment as usual.
Around six in 10 of all the people involved in the study were taking antidepressants.
Six months after treatment, patients who took part in the MCBT course had a larger reduction in symptoms compared to those who had treatment as usual.
Researchers also said that MBCT was a cost-effective tool – costing around £100 per patient.
The research team suggested that the tool could be considered as a treatment option for NHS patients with hard-to-treat depression.
Professor Thorsten Barnhofer, co-author of the study and professor of clinical psychology at the University of Surrey, said: 'For the thousands of people who finish talking therapy but still find themselves living with depression, this study offers real hope.
'We found that mindfulness-based cognitive therapy not only helps people feel better, but also does so in a way that could ease pressure on NHS services.
'These are results we can't afford to ignore – for individuals, for clinicians, and for a system stretched to its limits.'
Study co-author Professor Barney Dunn, from the University of Exeter, added: 'We know there's a gap in services for people with depression who haven't got better through NHS Talking Therapies.
'These people often don't qualify for further specialist mental health care, and so are left with no further options.
'We've shown that offering MBCT to this group can be effective and cost-efficient to deliver, and we hope this will lead to it being implemented widely.
'We need investment in this and other areas where there are gaps in service, to ultimately save the NHS money.'
Study co-author Barbara Barrett, professor of health economics at King's College London, said: 'We are highly encouraged by our findings, which reveal that MBCT treatment offers a powerful dual benefit for this group: superior patient outcomes coupled with notable cost savings for the NHS.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
12-08-2025
- BBC News
Surrey University to review NHS ethnicity pay gaps
The University of Surrey has begun a major review into ethnicity pay gaps across the NHS in review has been commissioned by the NHS Race and Health Observatory, an independent body established by the health 18-month long project will run until December 2026 and will explore differences in pay, career progression, pension contributions and overall earning potential of staff from different ethnic Employers, which represents NHS England, said it "welcomed the much-needed review" and described it as "crucial work". Announcing the review, the university said it would be drawing on "extensive expertise in workplace equity and pay structures". Professor of human resource management at the university, Carol Woodhams, is co-leading the review with colleagues Dr Nicola Burton-Brown and Prof Giuseppe Moscelli, in partnership with leadership and inclusion consultancy Delta. Prof Woodhams said the team was "proud to be leading this important work". "We've researched workplace pay gaps for many years, so we're pleased to support this vital review. "It's a chance to uncover the root causes of ethnic disparities in NHS pay and progression, and to help drive meaningful, evidence-based change," she added. Owen Chinembiri, assistant director of workforce at the observatory, said: "Black, Asian and ethnic minority staff continue to face hurdles when it comes to career progression in the NHS. "Even though there have been some improvements over the past few years, this has been slow, patchy and frustrating for ethnic minority staff who have been impacted for far too long."He described tackling inequalities as "an urgent matter" and said research would" identify areas with unwarranted gaps" and "come up with impactful recommendations". 'Wiping out disadvantage' Helga Pile from trade union UNISON, which represents many NHS employees, said: "Almost one in three NHS staff in England are from black or ethnic minority backgrounds, but... there's clear evidence they're less likely than white colleagues to secure jobs with higher salaries, even after being shortlisted."Understanding all the root causes is essential to wiping out disadvantage."Its chief executive, Danny Mortimer, said it welcomed the added: "The delivery of a better NHS and a healthier nation requires the best use of all the talents in our workforce. "We cannot jeopardise this by the presence of inequalities and racism in our workplaces."He said said ethnic pay gap reporting was not mandatory, although some trusts voluntarily reported on earnings. The final report, which is due in December 2026, will "offer clear, actionable recommendations", he added.
Metro
20-07-2025
- Metro
Almost half of people don't wash their hands after using hospital toilets
It's one of the simplest steps in stopping germs from spreading – but nearly half of hospital toilet users are failing to wash their hands, a new study has found. Researchers at the University of Surrey put sensors on toilet and sink pipes to monitor hygiene behaviours at a hospital in Denmark. Over the roughly five-month period, they found that 43.7% of users did not wash their hands after using the loo. The figure, which jumped to 61.8% on some of the weeks, has raised the alarm about hygiene practices that some might have assumed had become commonplace after the pandemic. Dr Pablo Pereira Doel from the University of Surrey said people failing to wash their hands could 'directly affect patient safety' in hospitals. People were especially bad at washing their hands at the start and end of the day, as well as during mealtimes. NHS guidance says hand washing is 'one of the easiest ways to protect yourself and others from illnesses'. The advice hit the headlines at the start of the pandemic when then-Prime Minister Boris Johnson urged the nation to 'wash your hands for 20 seconds or more'. Professor Benjamin Gardner, from the University of Surrey, said: 'Strategies that raise awareness at the crucial point in a bathroom visit and easily understood messaging about how to wash effectively – like singing Happy Birthday twice over – can help people form handwashing habits that last.' The study took place at Bispebjerg hospital in Copenhagen, recording 2,636 over the course of 19 weeks. More Trending Professor Carrie Newlands, also of the University of Surrey, added the latest findings are 'not surprising'. 'Even simple behaviours like handwashing can lapse without reinforcement. 'In hospitals, lapses like these can have serious consequences – for patients and for the wider healthcare system. 'It's time we moved beyond posters and hand gel stations to more effective behavioural strategies.' Get in touch with our news team by emailing us at webnews@ For more stories like this, check our news page. MORE: 21 seconds to go: The golden rule for how long it should take you to pee MORE: The reason why this famous TV doctor travelled 360 miles for surgery MORE: I'm a millennial – please stop sending me perimenopause memes
BBC News
20-07-2025
- BBC News
Nearly half of hospital toilet users skip handwashing, study says
Almost one in two of people that use a hospital toilet do not wash their hands, according to new research from the University of 19-week study, in partnership with Bispebjerg hospital in Denmark, put sensors on toilet and sink pipes to monitor hygiene 2,636 flushes, it revealed 43.7% (1,153 flushes) of people using a hospital toilet skipped handwashing, with figures peaking at 61.8% on certain assumptions that handwashing may be "second nature" after Covid-19, Dr Pablo Pereira Doel from the University of Surrey said this behaviour could "directly affect patient safety". The study noted that handwashing figures were especially down at the start and end of each day, including typical Benjamin Gardner, from the University of Surrey, said: "Strategies that raise awareness at the crucial point in a bathroom visit and easily understood messaging about how to wash effectively – like singing Happy Birthday twice over – can help people form handwashing habits that last."Guidance from NHS England says handwashing is one of the easiest ways of preventing food poisoning and other illnesses, such as the flu, especially in hospital settings."These findings are worrying but not surprising," Prof Carrie Newlands from the University of Surrey Newlands wants visual reinforcements, such as posters and hand-gel stations, to be replaced by "more effective behavioural strategies".
