Tea fraudster who conned luxury hotels has sentencing delayed
Thomas Robinson, 55, claimed to have cultivated the tea at his Perthshire estate using innovative techniques, but in reality it was bought from wholesalers and grown outside of Scotland.
Operating under the business name The Wee Tea Plantation, Robinson fraudulently sold the tea to high-profile clients in the hospitality sector between January 2014 and February 2019.
Representatives of the Balmoral Hotel, the Dorchester Hotel and a company acting on behalf of Fortnum & Mason were among those tricked by the fraudster.
A Food Standards Scotland (FSS) investigation found Robinson also misled genuine Scottish tea growers by selling them plants under the false pretence they were a unique, locally-grown variety.
He was found guilty of two counts of fraud to a value of almost £553,000 following a trial at Falkirk Sheriff Court in May, which came after an investigation by FSS.
Robinson also tried to bolster his credibility by fabricating academic qualifications and industry awards and claimed to have sold tea to customers including Kensington Palace.
The 55-year-old, also known as Tam O'Braan and Thomas O'Brien, was due to be sentenced at Stirling Sheriff Court on Wednesday morning.
However solicitor Virgil Crawford, who had previously represented Robinson, told the court he was withdrawing from acting on his behalf.
Robinson, identifying himself as Thomas O'Brien, appeared by video-link from HMP Low Moss and said he had been informed Mr Crawford was withdrawing 'about 10 to 15 minutes ago'.
Sheriff Keith O'Mahony asked whether he had had the opportunity to read the criminal justice social report prepared ahead of sentencing, to which Robinson replied he had not.
The sheriff asked whether he would be in a position to offer mitigations on his own behalf if he is sentenced later without legal representation.
Robinson said: 'I have notes of mitigation in my cell. I've made some very brief notes in the 10 minutes since I spoke to Mr Crawford.
'In essence I don't think the sentiment will change – there is a deep regret on my part and that's entirely what I'm going to be saying.'
The sheriff said he would defer the case until 2.30pm on Wednesday to give the 55-year-old the opportunity to read the report and make inquiries about legal representation.
He said: 'I will decide this afternoon whether to proceed to sentence.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
.jpeg%3Fwidth%3D1200%26height%3D800%26crop%3D1200%3A800&w=3840&q=100)
The Independent
17 minutes ago
- The Independent
Have we really become a nation of HMRC snoopers?
Has HM Revenue & Customs been running a Royal Corps of Dobbers-In? Fraud report numbers suggest that the troops are doing a fine job, if so. The tax authority received a record number of fraud tips in the 2024/2025 financial year – 164,670 in total, a handy increase on the previous year's 151,763. Britain is good at sneaking. It sometimes feels as if British society features a small army of tin-hatted bureaucrats armed with iPads, ready to investigate Mrs Miggins' loft conversion for a minor breach of the forms or the accidental failure to pay a fee somewhere. No more pocketing a fistful of cash-in-hand tenners for fixing the pipes at number 35 for you, Mr Plumber. Of course, the problem here is that all those cash-in-hand payments for fixing pipes add up. The sums can get quite substantial if our plumber is running half the business off the books. And what if it's a whole company of plumbers doing that? I'm not just getting at plumbers here. The practice is widespread, highly illegal, and highly problematic, not least because if we want even a semi-functional NHS, the money's got to come from somewhere. As things stand, there is a sizeable chunk of money that is not coming in. HMRC estimated that the total UK tax gap for the 2023 to 2024 financial year came to 5.3 per cent of total theoretical tax liabilities. That racks up to £47bn in absolute terms. By customer group, small businesses were responsible for a 60 per cent share of the total. Wealthy individuals accounted for just five per cent. While there have been some notably high-profile incidents of wealthy celebs getting called out on their tax avoidance schemes, this runs counter to the narrative that the UK's problems are solely down to the idle rich not paying their share and that cracking down on them would immediately fix it. Now, not all of the gap is accounted for by fraud, and we should remember that people make honest mistakes. Certain forms, and the way some taxes work (looking at you, VAT…), make this all but inevitable. But making a dent in it would deliver a hefty chunk of money to the Treasury that would fund an awful lot of schools and hospitals and more besides. If the tax gap were plugged, the £40bn hole in the public finances Rachel Reeves is grappling with would be filled without the need for any more tax rises. Whisper it, but maybe the snoops are on the side of the angels. One thing worth noting: the amount of money paid out in rewards for people shopping the fraudsters actually fell last year despite the increase in reports. Rewards are discretionary, whereas in the US, they're statutory. There, if you shop a tax cheat, you get a percentage of the take. Something to think about. The government probably is. Some would argue that it has only itself to blame for the level of cheating that goes on, and if taxes were lower, people would be more willing to pay up. This is not an argument that I find terribly persuasive. Just look at the US tech giants, which make billions in profits but are allergic to sending anything more than chump change to the countries in which they operate and scream bloody murder if someone suggests adding a couple of quid to their bills. Time for some hard truths: the country is broke, or as good as. That is partly because many of us had wages subsidised during the pandemic, and energy prices were capped during the subsequent price spike. So I'm afraid that it is incumbent on us to refill the coffers if we want the NHS to work, pensions to be paid, and schools to educate a new generation of taxpayers to prevent the system from collapsing. However, one thing the government could do if it wants Britons to be more conscientious about paying up is to start treating us like the customers we are when it comes to using the services it taxes us to provide. The question of why one is paying for service X regularly springs to mind when almost every interaction with the state feels like having your teeth pulled. Sort that out, and maybe we wouldn't need so many snoops. Just ask the best retailers, who are well aware that if they care for the customer, then the customer will pay up and care for them.
The Independent
17 minutes ago
- The Independent
What are student loans and when do you start repaying them after university?
It's A Levels results day and students across the entire country are now planning the next stage of their education, their lives – and, just as importantly, their finances. For those heading to university, big decisions lie ahead around how to fund their studies, with student loans remaining the most common option. But there's a lot to get your head around – from how the system works to how repayments affect you later in life. Here's everything you need to know on the matter - just be aware, this is for those with an undergraduate loan in England, while details or rules can sometimes be slightly different for Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland. What's the difference between a bursary and a student loan? Put simply, a bursary is a form of financial support that you don't have to pay back – similar to a grant. Eligibility varies, but bursaries are typically awarded to students from vulnerable backgrounds or based on specific criteria set by a university, college or funding body. You can check if you're eligible here. A student loan, by contrast, is borrowed money to help cover the cost of tuition and living expenses while at university – and, like any loan, it must be repaid. Your first step in exploring student loans is here. Do student loans cover tuition fees? Yes – and more. There are two types of student loans available: tuition fee loans and maintenance loans. Most students will apply for both. Tuition fee loans do exactly what they say: they are payments sent directly to your university to cover your tuition fees. Maintenance loans, on the other hand, are paid directly to you in three equal instalments each academic year. That means you're responsible for managing the money – from rent and groceries to textbooks and travel – and making it last throughout each term. When do you start to repay them? If you take out both tuition and maintenance loans, they're combined into one student loan balance. You can manage your loan online here, including updating details, checking your balance, and making extra payments if you choose. Repayments don't begin until the April after you finish your course. For example, if you start university in September 2025, complete a three-year degree, and graduate in summer 2028, your repayments would begin in April 2029 – assuming the rules stay the same. But there's an important condition: you won't repay anything unless you're earning above a certain threshold. For 'Plan 5' loans (those taken out in England from 2023 onwards), the current threshold is £25,000 a year. Once you earn above that, you'll repay 9 per cent of the amount over the threshold – and if you're employed in the UK, it comes straight out of your salary. For example, if your salary is £2,000 a month, that's £24,000 a year so you won't make repayments. If it's £3,000 a month, that's £36,000 a year so you'll pay 9 per cent of £11,000 which is £990, or £82.50 a month. What interest will you pay and how long to repay in full? The interest rate on student loans can change over time. Currently, for Plan 5 loans, it's set at 4.3 per cent – though this may rise or fall in future. How long it takes to repay your loan depends on several factors, including your salary, the total amount borrowed, and how often your income fluctuates. Since repayments are based on what you earn rather than what you owe, many graduates find that student loans take decades to repay – and some never pay them off in full before the remaining balance is wiped after 40 years. Government data shows that the average debt among students finishing their course in 2024 was around £53,000, though this can vary widely depending on your course, how long you study, and where you live. Interest rates also affect how much of your monthly repayment goes towards clearing the loan itself, rather than simply covering the interest. In lower-earning years, most of your payment may go toward servicing the debt, rather than reducing the total. Expert tips on managing money at university Managing your finances is one of the most important skills to develop while at university – and a few simple tools can make all the difference. Karen Barrett, CEO of the financial advice platform Unbiased, told The Independent that budgeting tools and part-time work are among the best ways to stay afloat. 'Student bank accounts will have an overdraft facility - all the big high street banks are offering similar, at around £1,500. That can change with good management on the account - you can dip in should you need further funds,' Ms Barrett said. 'A second tip would be to get a part-time job! Working in the student bar is popular, or tutoring. That can be a really good way of earning extra income while also being able to focus on your studies. 'And if you're really hard-pressed and family can't help out, universities have hardship funds. They are for if there's nothing else available to you and it's on an as-needed basis - but it's just a fallback and can be a few hundred pounds, not to be relied on as a main income source.' As with any major decision, taking stock before leaping is important – and that goes for university and loans just as much as for jobs, weddings or big expensive purchases. Student loans aren't quite debts for life, but they are significant. However, there is data suggesting university degrees can lead to higher earnings. Ms Barrett pointed to data showing average salaries of more than £19,000 without a university degree, or £24,000–£27,000 with one. 'Apprenticeships are also competitive and are seen the way to earn and learn at the same time, so they are in high demand,' she added.
BBC News
18 minutes ago
- BBC News
Basildon bars targeted in 'sophisticated' licensing scam
Bars and restaurants have been targeted by fraudsters who are asking for money while posing as council licensing Council said scammers had been calling up businesses requesting payments for alleged unpaid licence local authority called the scam "sophisticated" and urged businesses not to engage with the callers."Council officers will never ask for bank or personal details over the phone," a spokesperson said. "We always communicate through official channels and send written reminders for any payments due." One recent incident involved a call from someone claiming to be a licensing officer called "Oscar Fielding", the council caller falsely accused the business of not paying its licensing fee for five years and demanded immediate payment of £ mobile number 07783 668040, the scammer repeatedly contacted the licensee, requested sensitive financial information, and attempted to appear legitimate by offering the council's licensing number for issue was previously flagged earlier this year, noting that the caller - who identified himself as David - used a mobile number to request payment for licensing fees. Follow Essex news on BBC Sounds, Facebook, Instagram and X.
