UK's St Andrews reinstates rector after dismissal for Israel criticism
Last year, the University of St Andrews removed Stella Maris from her position on the university court after its investigation concluded that she exercised "poor judgment" for sending an email to all students in November 2023 that called for an urgent ceasefire in Gaza.
Maris, who is an alumnus of the prestigious Scottish university, also called on students to condemn "practices such as apartheid, siege, illegal occupation and collective punishment observed in the treatment of Palestinians".
Following her statement, St Andrews launched an independent inquiry led by Morag Ross KC to "examine" whether Maris's actions and activities were compatible with her role as rector after the UK Lawyers for Israel group lodged a complaint against her.
Ross submitted the findings from her internal inquiry to the university court, the highest governing body at St Andrews, in April 2024. She found that Maris's email had caused "anxiety and fear" among Jewish students.
New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch
Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters
Despite Ross concluding that firing Maris would be "disproportionate," the university court concluded that she should be removed from her position.
But after a nine-month appeal, the university's chancellor, Menzies Campbell, ruled in Maris's favour and overturned her dismissal from the university court.
Commenting on the ruling, Maris described her victory as a "surprise" as well as "vindication of my position [...] and a defence of the fundamental principles of free expression and democractic accountability within our universities.
'Universities must remain places where individuals are free to speak out against injustice, especially where that speech is grounded in humanitarian concern and moral conscience in line with the principles of international human rights," Maris said in a statement.
'[Maris'] victory [is] a clear rebuke to the growing pattern of repression facing those who speak out for Palestinian freedom'
- Tasnima Uddin, European Legal Support Centre
'I am grateful to the many students, academics, and members of the public who stood in solidarity with me over the past months. I intend to continue campaigning to ensure the right to political expression and academic freedom.'
At St Andrews, the students elect the rector to represent and advocate for their interests. The position is unpaid and carried out voluntarily.
Following her dismissal, Maris received support from students on campus and over 500 academics across 17 countries.
Her supporters included the Palestine Solidarity Campaign and the European Legal Support Centre (ELSC), which provided her with legal support and helped fundraise for her appeal against the decision to fire her.
Tasnima Uddin from the ELSC described Maris' "victory as a clear rebuke to the growing pattern of repression facing those who speak out for Palestinian freedom".
"For 570 days, Israel has carried out a genocide in Gaza, targeting universities, hospitals and civilians, yet St Andrews chose to punish its rector for calling for a ceasefire," Uddin told Middle East Eye.
"The reinstatement of Stella Maris proves that the attempt to quash this mass movement will not succeed and legal means will continue to be used."
A St Andrews University spokesperson said: 'As the body that made the decision to dismiss the rector, University Court is carefully considering the chancellor's decision and taking advice from counsel.
'This issue was never about free speech and only ever about governance. Ms Maris remains rector of the university and has done so throughout.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Middle East Eye
an hour ago
- Middle East Eye
Israel's Ben Gvir seen threatening Marwan Barghouti in prison in new video
Israeli National Security Minister Itamar Ben Gvir has been filmed visiting Marwan Barghouti, the most prominent Palestinian prisoner, and threatening him that Israel will "obliterate" anyone who opposes it. It is the first time that Barghouti has been seen publicly in years. Aged and gaunt, wearing a white undershirt, he is almost unrecognisable. In the video, which circulated on social media on Thursday night, Ben Gvir is seen telling Barghouti: "Whoever messes with the people of Israel, whoever murders our children, whoever murders our women, we will obliterate them. You will not defeat us." Barghouti has been in prison since 2004. A senior figure in Fatah, the party that dominates the Palestinian Authority (PA), he was targeted by Israel due to his leading role in the 2000-2005 Second Intifada and popularity among the public. Qassem Barghouti, Marwan's son, told Middle East Eye that his family feels a grave threat to his father's life, particularly after this latest footage. New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters "There has been an ongoing approach for two years to threaten and assault him. He was attacked for the first time two years ago at the beginning of the war and was wounded to varying degrees," Qassem Barghouti said. "It is clear today from the threat of National Security Minister Ben Gvir, who represents the highest Israeli security hierarchy, that there is a real danger to his life." Qassem Barghouti said it is "clear that there is direct threat to assassinate and kill him inside his cell" and that the targeting and abuse of Palestinian prisoners is part of the genocide that Israel is waging in the Gaza Strip. Israeli media reported that Ben Gvir was visiting Tel Aviv's Gannot prison with prisons service commissioner Kobi Yaakobi "to closely monitor the worsening of the imprisoned terrorists' conditions". Barghouti has long been held in solitary confinement. He was sentenced to five life sentences plus 40 years in an Israeli prison for attacks that killed five people, though he declined to defend himself, saying he did not recognise the court's legitimacy. Opinion polls suggest that Barghouti, 66, would be a shoo-in for the Palestinian presidency if they were held and he were able to run for the office. He is seen as a unifying figure despite identifying with Fatah, which is associated with the deeply unpopular PA. Gaza ceasefire deal: Hamas, Egypt and Qatar pushing for Marwan Barghouti's release Read More » In January, MEE reported that Egypt and Qatar, alongside Hamas, were using "all means available" to secure Barghouti's release as part of a Gaza ceasefire agreement. A source close to the negotiations told MEE that his name was one of the top figures that would be traded for Israeli captives taken on 7 October 2023 in the Hamas-led attacks on southern Israel. Qatari Emir Sheikh Tamim bin Hamad Al-Thani and Major General Hassan Mahmoud Rashad, the director of Egypt's General Intelligence Services, personally interceded to push for his release, sources said. However, a source previously told MEE that senior PA officials wanted him excluded from any exchange, fearing it could threaten the leadership of PA President Mahmoud Abbas. Following the release of the footage on Thursday, Awni Almashni, a former Fatah candidate backed by Bargouti, told MEE that "Ben Gvir believes he is insulting the Palestinian people with this display". "But the Palestinian people and all of Marwan's fans are proud of Marwan Barghouti's legendary steadfastness, his great stances, and his refusal to back down in the face of the occupation's brutality," he said. "The will for freedom that Marwan represents will not be broken by the tyranny, injustice and arrogance." Since Israel began its genocide in Gaza in October 2023, a spike in arrests, detainment and worsening prison policies has been recorded by rights groups and media outlets. Barghouti has been singled out for rough treatment, his family say. An attack by prison officers in September 2024 wounded his head, ears, ribs, right arm, and back. Ben Gvir, an influential far-right settler leader, has said worsening living conditions for Palestinian prisoners in Israeli jails is one of his top goals.
Middle East Eye
3 hours ago
- Middle East Eye
US terror designation of Muslim Brotherhood and Cair 'in the works'
In comments on a right-wing radio show earlier this week, US Secretary of State Marco Rubio said the Trump administration is working on designating the Muslim Brotherhood a terrorist organisation, as well as cracking down on a Muslim-American non-profit for its perceived ties to the Brotherhood. While calls to do so have come from several US lawmakers in the past, they have not borne fruit. But now, a cabinet-level official is making the assertion. "Why wouldn't you guys designate the Muslim Brotherhood and Cair?" asked the radio host, Sid Rosenberg, referencing the Council on American-Islamic Relations, the largest Muslim civil liberties organisation in the country. "I just - I look at these organisations. I have a mayor's race here in New York City with this psycho, this lunatic Mamdani," he added, referencing the current Democratic candidate for mayor, Zohran Mamdani, who also happens to be Muslim. "Both of these groups, you know, are behind him, especially the Muslim Brotherhood," Rosenberg said of Cair's indirect financial support for the progressive candidate. "Is that something you think we can count on maybe in the near future? Maybe not Cair just yet, but certainly the Muslim Brotherhood?" New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters " Yeah, all of that is in the works," Rubio responded. "Obviously, there are different branches of the Muslim Brotherhood, so you'd have to designate each one of them... these things are going to be challenged in court, right?" " We are constantly reviewing for groups to designate for what they are: supporters of terrorists, maybe terrorists themselves, whatever it may be. We haven't done this in a long time, so it's - we've got a lot of catch-up to do. And you've mentioned a couple names, particularly the Muslim Brotherhood, that are of grave concern," he said. Last month, a bill was introduced in the House of Representatives called the "Muslim Brotherhood Terrorist Designation Act of 2025", which called on the Trump administration to do just that. And a letter was sent just last week by Republican Senator Tom Cotton, calling on the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) to revoke Cair's nonprofit status for its alleged "ties to terrorist activities" linked to "Hamas and the Muslim Brotherhood". US senator asks tax authority to strip Muslim civil rights organisation of nonprofit status Read More » Middle East Eye reached out to Cair for a response on Rubio's comments, and was referred to a statement released by the Muslim Public Affairs Committee (Mpac) instead, which condemned the move to "smear" a domestic group "or treat political disagreement as grounds for terrorism designation". Mpac's vice president of policy and programming, Haris Tarin, is a former senior policy advisor to the Secretary of Homeland Security, and was at the agency under three different presidents since the Obama administration. "For the Secretary of State to comment on Cair... that's extremely problematic and concerning to us. He does not have the right to say that. He does not have the authority. He does not have the mandate," Tarin told MEE. "The conversation around Cair [now]... that was never in previous administrations, including Biden, Trump 1.0, Obama, and Bush," he added. "There was never conversations about banning Cair. There was conversations about engaging Cair and whether the federal government thought it was a politically right or politically savvy thing for them to engage Cair". The public, Tarin said, should be "extremely alarmed when it comes to designating a domestic institution" precisely because Americans fund it and it is not a foreign institution. What could happen - should the Trump administration compile clear evidence for such a case - is that it would have to file charges through the Department of Justice, he explained. What is The Muslim Brotherhood? The Muslim Brotherhood is most commonly known in the Arab world as a political party founded on Islamic principles and laws, whose support skyrocketed in the wake of the 2011 Arab protests aimed at overthrowing autocratic rulers. It was established in the late 1920s in Egypt and gained popularity as the mid-century ushered in secular governments that saw modernisation and westernisation interchangeably. In 2012, after the toppling of Egypt's ruler of three decades, Hosni Mubarak, an internationally-monitored election in Egypt saw the victory of its first Muslim Brotherhood president, Mohammed Morsi. Within a year, he was toppled by the military, imprisoned, and died in prison in 2019. The Muslim Brotherhood is now banned in Egypt, Saudi Arabia, Bahrain, and the United Arab Emirates, and most recently in Jordan. 'Islamophobia and anti-Muslim sentiments have created a narrative in the US where democracy is good, except when religious Muslims win to govern their own countries' - Raed Jarrar, Dawn "Islamophobia and anti-Muslim sentiments have created a narrative in the US where democracy is good, except when religious Muslims win to govern their own countries," Raed Jarrar, the advocacy director for Democracy for the Arab World Now (Dawn), told MEE. "We saw that narrative come out of Gaza when Hamas won the elections. We saw that narrative come out of Egypt when the Muslim Brotherhood won the elections. We saw that narrative in Tunisia, in Libya, in Jordan, and many other countries where religious Muslims won democratic elections," he said. Jarrar added that there is no singular Brotherhood entity or "headquarters" because it's an ideology and a movement that springs up independently across each of the countries in the Middle East and North Africa - so a US designation would have to be detailed and country-specific to hold up in court, just as Rubio indicated. For lawmakers pushing for a terror designation, the Muslim Brotherhood "poses a direct threat to US national security through radical jihadist attempts to eliminate and destroy America and its allies", Florida Congressman Mario Diaz-Balart, who sponsored the House bill, said in a press release. MEE put the question to George Washington University professor Nathan Brown, who is an expert on Middle East politics and sits on the board of trustees at the American University in Cairo. In what ways is the Muslim Brotherhood a threat to US national security? " None at all," he said. Anti-Muslim, anti-Palestinian sentiment When Senator Cotton wrote to the IRS, he alleged that Cair was listed as a member of the Muslim Brotherhood's Palestine Committee and that the group participated in a meeting of Hamas supporters in Philadelphia. Cair firmly rejected the claims and said they're tied to anti-Muslim bigotry. "You have some very heated anti-Muslim forces [in the State Department] that are a little bit more eager to try to find and make those connections, but they're going to run into the same problem: you can't. There's no smoking gun anywhere, because there's no real, tangible connection," Shahed Amanullah, a former State Department senior staffer under Hillary Clinton and John Kerry, told MEE. What's so scary about the Muslim Brotherhood? Read More » The State Department is the agency that is responsible for any terrorist designations, as well as visa revocations. "In the past, I would say that people at the State Department were sophisticated and smart enough to understand the nuances of those affiliated movements overseas, and that it wasn't some kind of command and control structure," Amanullah said of the Muslim Brotherhood. "Those people have been hollowed out from the State Department," he said. Unlike past attempts at designating the Brotherhood and going after Cair, this time in particular, it's also taking place with the backdrop of the genocide in Gaza, Tarin told MEE. "Anything that has to do with American-Muslim institutions... it has to do with their support for pro-Palestinian organisations," he said. The Trump administration has made it a priority to go after international students and some of the most prestigious universities in the country for pro-Palestine protests and activism. Students have been jailed in immigration detention centres, deported, and the institutions they attended were effectively sued for hundreds of millions of dollars by the government. Jewish Voice for Peace, which has joined pro-Palestine demonstrations, has previously noted that the administration's playbook is taken from the Heritage Foundation's 'Project Esther' report, "which is a blueprint for using the federal government and private institutions to dismantle the Palestine solidarity movement and broader US civil society, under the guise of 'fighting antisemitism'". "I think pro-Israel groups feel that American Muslim institutions that support the pro-Palestinian movement are a threat to their existence here in the US, and their dominance of US foreign policy," Tarin told MEE.
Middle East Eye
4 hours ago
- Middle East Eye
Israel threatens to ban major aid organisations, as starvation in Gaza deepens
Most major international non-profit organisations have been unable to deliver a single truck of lifesaving supplies since 2 March, despite claims by Israeli authorities that there is no limit on humanitarian aid entering Gaza, a joint press release from more than 100 NGOs said on Thursday. Israeli authorities are said to have rejected requests from dozens of NGOs to bring in lifesaving goods, citing that these organisations are 'not authorized to deliver aid", instead of clearing the increasing backlog of goods. The statement said that more than 60 requests were denied under this justification in July alone, and the obstruction has left millions of dollars' worth of food, medicine, water, and shelter items stranded in warehouses across Jordan and Egypt, while Palestinians are being starved. 'Anera has over $7 million worth of lifesaving supplies ready to enter Gaza - including 744 tons of rice, enough for six million meals, blocked in Ashdod just kilometers away,' said Sean Carroll, president and CEO of Anera. Many of the NGOs that are now told they are not 'authorized' to deliver aid have worked in Gaza for decades, are trusted by communities, and are experienced in delivering aid safely. Their exclusion has left hospitals without basic supplies, children, people with disabilities, and older people dying from hunger and preventable illnesses, and aid workers themselves going to work hungry.
