Hayscastle Cross housing approved after five-year wait
At an extraordinary meeting of Pembrokeshire County Council on June 2, Independent Group leader Cllr Huw Murphy called for no confidence in Councillor Paul Miller to remain as Deputy Leader & Cabinet Member.
Cllr Murphy had made the call, which was ultimately unsuccessful, partly due to comments made by Cllr Miller at an April meeting of the council's Cabinet in which he moved an amendment with regards to Welsh Education Strategic Plan (WESP) to request officers collect data from parents of children electing a Welsh medium education.
A bone of contention for Cllr Murphy was when Cllr Miller commented with regards to parental choice for Welsh medium school Ysgol Caer Elen: '…all of them that I know who send their children to Caer Ellen honestly couldn't give a toss whether it was Welsh or English'.
'Comments such as this in 2025 are unacceptable and serve to create a perception of bias when it comes to the delivery of Welsh medium education, something that generations have striven for, namely equality and fairness,' Cllr Murphy has previously said.
'For a Deputy Leader of Council to make such comments and then refuse to retract when he has had ample opportunity to do so makes his position untenable both as Deputy Leader and Cabinet Member.
The matter was reported to the Welsh Language Commissioner and was called in to the May Schools O&S Scrutiny Committee, ultimately returning to a May 21 meeting of the Cabinet, hearing a proposal by Cllr Miller to now collect data on all languages and additional information, before the special extraordinary meeting of June 2.
Responding at the special meeting, Cllr Miller repeated previously made comments, saying there had never been an intention to collect the information through a formal schools process.
He reiterated the 'couldn't give a toss' comment was one made by a mother in his ward which he had repeated, apologising if he had caused upset.
He added: 'I believe Cllr Murphy should be deeply ashamed of his actions, he is trying to create division in the county of Pembrokeshire where no division exists,' adding: 'To suggest that either I personally or the administration is anti-Welsh is simply not true.'
He was not the only one to take umbrage at Cllr Murphy's call, with Conservative Group Leader Cllr Di Clements saying: 'This is nothing more than petty political point scoring which we want no part of,' and council leader Cllr Jon Harvey saying it was 'creating division where none exists and political opportunism at its worst.'
The no confidence call in Cllr Miller was defeated by 28 votes to 16, with 11 abstentions.
There are 11 Conservative Group members in the council.
Commenting after the meeting, Plaid Cymru county councillor for Tenby, Cllr Michael Williams who said he 'in no way condoned Cllr Miller's comments,' described the meeting as 'a complete waste of time and money'.
He added: 'Cllr Murphy seems to think Local Government is a game and submitted absolutely no arguments to support his motion.'
He went on to describe it as 'a pathetic waste of time,' saying: 'I hope lessons will be learnt, but I doubt they will. It amounted to an abuse of a democratic forum for personal promotion.'
Cllr Murphy said he still felt he had made the right call, saying Cllr Miller 'never once showed contrition for his comments'.
He added: 'The fact Cabinet have now been compelled to amend their position through the call-in and Welsh Language Commissioner's intervention shows the value of these challenges as otherwise Cllr Miller would be requesting data from less than 20 per cent of Neyland parents for wishing to send their children to Caer Elen over the 80 per cent sending their children to Haverfordwest High or Milford Haven which would suggest clear bias against Welsh medium education.
'As Leader of Independent Group I have no regrets in requesting a call in and then an EGM and if such behaviour is repeated by Cabinet members it won't be the last time such a meeting is requested under the constitution. Neither did we canvass support from any other political group.'
He finished: 'The fact the Conservative Group, through abstaining, threw Cllr Miller a lifeline will not be lost on Pembrokeshire voters who will draw their own conclusions on such a decision where the Conservatives have effectively supported Labour and the administration on this issue.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Wales Online
an hour ago
- Wales Online
Hefin David remembered as 'powerful voice for the people of Wales'
Hefin David remembered as 'powerful voice for the people of Wales' Welsh Labour MS Hefin David has died suddenly at the age of 47 Hefin David had served as the MS for Caerphilly since 2016 (Image: Matthew Horwood) Tributes have poured in after the sudden death of Hefin David, who served as the Senedd Member for Caerphilly since 2016. Mr David died on Tuesday evening aged 47, the day before his birthday. First Minister and Welsh Labour leader Eluned Morgan led tributes to the politician. She said: "We are extremely saddened by the sudden death of Hefin. Our thoughts are with his family at this terrible time. Hefin was a much-loved member of the Labour family. He served Caerphilly as a councillor and a Member of the Senedd with pride and passion. "He was an outstanding politician, warm and enthusiastic and a great communicator – especially on behalf of his constituents. He will be greatly missed." Tributes have also flooded in from Westminster, with Keir Starmer calling him a "powerful voice for the people of Wales". Content cannot be displayed without consent The Secretary of State for Wales, Jo Stevens, added that Mr David was a "genuine, clever and caring man". She said: "The death of Hefin David is devastating news. We have lost a dear friend and colleague. "Hefin was a genuine, clever and caring man. Deeply proud of Caerphilly, and in Hefin, Caerphilly had a dedicated and committed representative. "My thoughts, and those of all Hefin's Welsh colleagues in Parliament, are with his family and many, many friends." Colleagues of Mr David from all sides of the Senedd have also paid tribute to their colleague. Commenting on the sad passing of Hefin David MS, the Leader of the Welsh Conservatives, Darren Millar MS, said: "I am very sad to hear the shocking news of Hefin David's death. "My deepest condolences go to Hefin's family and friends, and I would also like to extend my condolences to the Welsh Labour Party. "He was a man who always stood up for his constituents and was respected on all sides of the Senedd." Tom Giffard, the Senedd Member for South Wales West and a member of the Welsh Conservatives said it was rare that you call someone from another party a friend but that Mr David was "certainly that". He added: "Hefin was a true maverick, a backbencher willing to call out the Government in standing up for his constituents and the things he believed in." Content cannot be displayed without consent The Liberal Democrats also paid tribute to the Labour politician. Jane Dodds MS said: "All of us at the Welsh Liberal Democrats are saddened to hear about the death of Hefin David. "We are all thinking of his loved ones, especially his wife Vikki Howells MS and his children, his staff members and his community in Caerphilly." Commenting on the news that MS for Caerphilly Hefin David has passed away, the Llywydd Elin Jones said: "As a Senedd community we are all devastated by the tragic news of Hefin's death. Our thoughts go immediately to his partner, our colleague and friend, Vikki Howells MS and to his cherished children and family. "Hefin was so full of life and enthusiasm for his constituents and their causes. He was a passionate politician, loyal to his party, his country, and constituents. He was able to effectively work across parties and seek common ground. "Hefin was particularly well-liked across the Senedd. He was our Commissioner with responsibility for Finance and undertook that role with diligence and skill. "The news is devastating and reminds us of the fragility of life and the need for us all to support each other." Gwent Police were called to a property in Nelson at around 6.55pm on Tuesday, August 12. Officers attended and after entering the property found a 47-year-old man unresponsive inside. Chief Constable Mark Hobrough said: "My thoughts and heartfelt condolences go out to all of Hefin's family, friends and colleagues at this difficult time for them. "After I joined Gwent Police as the chief superintendent for the area covering Caerphilly, I worked closely with Hefin on many occasions and I found him to be an engaging and thoughtful individual. "A dedicated public servant to Caerphilly, his commitment to our communities will be a significant loss." Article continues below
Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Daily Mirror
Keir Starmer pays tribute as Welsh Labour politician Hefin David dies suddenly
The Prime Minister said the 'entire Labour movement will join me in grieving the loss' of the Caerphilly MS, who has been a member of the Welsh Parliament since 2016 Keir Starmer has paid tribute to Welsh Labour politician Hefin David who has died suddenly aged 47. The Prime Minister said the "entire Labour movement will join me in grieving the loss" of theCaerphilly MS, who has been a member of the Welsh Parliament since 2016. He said Mr David had "dedicated his life to making sure every person and community in Wales had the opportunities and support they deserve".Mr Starmer added: "Our hearts are with his family and those who knew and loved him at this peaceful time. May he rest in peace." Eluned Morgan, the Welsh Labour leader, described Hefin as a "much-loved" member of the Labour family, who will be greatly missed. She said: "We are extremely saddened by the sudden death of Hefin. Our thoughts are with his family at this terrible time. "Hefin was a much-loved member of the Labour family. He served Caerphilly as a councillor and a Member of the Senedd with pride and passion. He was an outstanding politician, warm and enthusiastic and a great communicator - especially on behalf of his constituents. He will be greatly missed." Gwent Police said a 47-year-old man was found unresponsive at a property in the Caerphilly county area on Tuesday. Paramedics attended and confirmed the man had died. His death is not being treated as suspicious. Gwent Police Chief Constable Mark Hobrough said: "My thoughts and heartfelt condolences go out to all of Hefin's family, friends and colleagues at this difficult time for them. "After I joined Gwent Police as the chief superintendent for the area covering Caerphilly, I worked closely with Hefin on many occasions and I found him to be an engaging and thoughtful individual. "A dedicated public servant to Caerphilly, his commitment to our communities will be a significant loss." Elin Jones, the Senedd's Llywydd (presiding officer), paid tribute to Labour MS Hefin David. In a statement, she said: 'As a Senedd community, we are all devastated by the tragic news of Hefin's death. 'Our thoughts go immediately to his partner, our colleague and friend, Vikki Howells MS and to his cherished children and family. Hefin was so full of life and enthusiasm for his constituents and their causes. He was a passionate politician, loyal to his party, his country, and constituents. 'He was able to effectively work across parties and seek common ground. Hefin was particularly well-liked across the Senedd. He was our Commissioner with responsibility for finance and undertook that role with diligence and skill. The news is devastating and reminds us of the fragility of life and the need for us all to support each other.' Labour MP for Rhondda and Ogmore Chris Bryant said: "Hefin was a lovely, determined and courageous man who was a phenomenal colleague. RIP." Chris Evans, Labour Co-op MP for Caerphilly said: "Such sad news. Hefin's passion and dedication to Caerphilly was evident in all he did, and I will greatly miss him as a colleague and friend. My thoughts and prayers are with his family, especially his two young daughters." Andrew RT Davies, former leader of the Welsh Conservatives, said: 'Heartbreaking and tragic news that Hefin David, such a young Member of the Senedd with so much to offer and give to Wales and the community he loved has passed away. My thoughts and prayers are with Hefin's family at this sad and difficult time.'
North Wales Live
an hour ago
- North Wales Live
Welsh language activism 'no different' to Palestine Action 'terrorism' ex police boss says
A retired police chief and former Welsh language campaigner has slammed the authorities for their approach to banned group Palestine Action. Arfon Jones drew parallels with historic Welsh language campaigns in which scores of activists were arrested for non-violent direct action. Mr Jones, from Wrexham, said he was among those who, in the 1970s, campaigned for Welsh language rights as members of Cymdeithas yr Iaith Gymraeg (Welsh Language Society). 'Some were imprisoned for their activities,' he said. 'None, however, were stigmatised by the British state as terrorists!' On July 5, the UK Government proscribed Palestine Action as a terrorist group after members of the network damaged RAF aircraft at Brize Norton, Oxfordshire. Under the Terrorism Act of 2000, it made group membership a criminal offence punishable by up to 14 years in prison. Since then, police have arrested scores of people for showing support to Palestine Action. Last weekend alone, 474 people were arrested during a 'Lift the Ban' sit-in at Parliament Square (Saturday, August 9). The demonstration had echoes of the first ever protest staged by Cymdeithas yr Iaith Gymraeg: in February 1963, members staged a sit-down blocking Pont Trefechan bridge, Aberystwyth. From demanding the right to court summonses in Welsh, the society moved on to campaign successfully for bilingual road signs followed by action over holiday homes and Welsh language media. Over the decades, more than 1,000 supporters of the society appeared before the courts, making it Britain's largest protest group since the Suffragettes. Some members were jailed but none were ever officially labelled terrorists by the government, said Mr Jones, a former Police and Crime Commissioner for North Wales Police. He also served as an operational inspector at the force before retiring in 2008, and now describes himself as a "social issues commentator". In a letter to the Daily Post he wrote: 'What language campaigners were doing in the 60s, 70s and 80s was no different to what Palestine Action was doing prior to it being proscribed for protesting against a genocide the British state is complicit in. 'Both were using non-violent, direct action against property, and proscription was unreasonable, unjustified and disproportionate. 'This comparison gives some indication of how far the British state has moved from a social democratic tolerant and progressive state in the 1970s, to a right-wing autocratic and oppressive state in 2025, where a Nazi salute is tolerated but protesting a genocide is not. 'The Home Secretary and the Police Service should hang their heads in shame for harassing and arresting honourable and principled individuals who are willing to sacrifice their freedom for the cause of humanity.' The Home Office was approached for a response. Home Secretary Yvette Cooper said many people were not aware of the 'reality' of Palestine Action's true purpose. In the wake of the ongoing Gaza war, the group has become more active but it insists its approach is "non-violent". The Home Secretary said: 'The right to protest is one we protect fiercely but this is very different from displaying support for this one specific and narrow, proscribed organisation. "Palestine Action was proscribed based on strong security advice following serious attacks the group has committed, involving violence, significant injuries and extensive criminal damage. "It also follows an assessment from the Joint Terrorism Assessment Centre that the group prepares for terrorism, as well as concerning information referencing plans and ideas for further attacks, the details of which cannot yet be publicly reported due to ongoing legal proceedings. 'Many people may not yet know the reality of this organisation, but the assessments are very clear - this is not a non-violent organisation. UK national security and public safety must always be our top priority. 'Their actions are not about the horrific suffering in the Middle East and do not reflect or represent the thousands of people across the country who are exercising their rights to protest peacefully.'
