‘Scottish cringe' persists despite evidence of our distinctive culture
At the heart of self-determination is an appreciation of Scotland's national identity and culture, and thinking around this fundamental topic was well presented by Stuart McHardy and Roger Emmerson. From having the largest building in the world 5000 years ago at Brodgar to the diverse architecture of today, there is strong evidence of a distinctive Scottish culture, yet still there are those within our midst who pour scorn on such thinking and who seem to incurably suffer from the indoctrinated 'Scottish cringe'.
READ MORE: Ian Murray 'does not understand how devolution works', minister says
Of course, unfortunately our national football team often seems to inadvertently serve such apparent national-deprecation, but the truth is our national identity and culture have been deliberately suppressed by a British establishment elite intent on exploiting Scotland's resources for self-enrichment. At the core of this cultural ravage is not oil and gas, nor wind and tides, but our people. Whether it has been to lead troops into battles on foreign soils to secure further resources to fuel the further wealth generation of the lords of the British Empire, or to lead academic research in Oxford and Cambridge universities to support that expansion, Scots have made immense contributions to Britain's development since the 'Act of Union' in 1707.
Yet, even in Scotland our internationally lauded universities are considered by some to be 'second-class', especially by those who harboured ambitions, often fostered at private schools, to attend Oxford and Cambridge and expect they should have an unalienable right to enter a Scottish university should they fail in that ambition (irrespective of the personal qualities and achievements of others who did not benefit from 'special privilege').
Perhaps it's not surprising that in an unequal society where royalty are treated like superstars and their patronage is sought by some with the least ethical and humanitarian principles, others feel compelled to attempt to climb the greasy ladder where personal influence is more important than competence, but it means more work is needed to convey the message that true egalitarianism benefits us all (including the super-rich, who can become better citizens of a planet with depleting resources).
READ MORE: Can fiction free a nation? A Scottish writer looks to James Joyce for answers
Scotland has much more to offer the world, but for us to be confident as a nation we must counter arrogantly patronising remarks or ridicule, recognising that many Scots have been, and continue to be, successful not only in Scotland but around the globe without needing to sell their souls to the British establishment, and the sooner we can convince others to reject the denigration of our history and our culture, the sooner we will have overwhelming support for independence.
That also requires not blindly accepting, never mind parroting, the anti-Scottish Government soundbites of the UK mainstream media and the BBC. I spoke with Lesley Riddoch about the Debate Night programmes at the convention, and she rightly pointed out that it's not Stephen Jardine's job to make arguments supporting Scottish Government decisions irrespective of misleading pro-Union propaganda (although hosts of other BBC programmes routinely make arguments supporting UK Government decisions) but that representatives of the Scottish Government need to be more assertive on such programmes.
If our elected representatives cannot demonstrate the fight necessary to combat the lies and distortions of the UK press and devious politicians in such forums, they should not be there and probably should question whether they are the best ambassadors for their communities of independence. Politely saying nothing or allowing constant interruptions or partial framing of questions is not only letting down government or party colleagues, it is effectively condoning the suppression of Scotland's voice, and must not be accepted.
The frustrations of more than 300 years of colonial rule must be expressed by SNP and other independence politicians at every opportunity, and every opportunity to advance the cause of independence must be grasped. Even where prospects are not considered great, unsuccessful campaigns can still generate interest and positivity which cumulatively, perhaps aided by a broadly-convened national convention, can help to build unstoppable momentum towards achieving Scotland's necessary and rightful status as an independent nation.
Stan Grodynski
Longniddry, East Lothian
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The National
17 minutes ago
- The National
Reform pick up first Scotland seats in YouGov Westminster poll
The survey by YouGov – its first MRP poll since last year's General Election – found that Reform UK would become the largest party in Westminster with 271 MPs. This includes three MPs in Scotland – marking the first time a poll has shown Reform UK winning seats north of the Border. The poll, based on a survey of more than 11,500 British adults between May 29 and June 18, found that Labour would lose 233 seats and would drop to just 178 MPs, making it the second biggest party in Westminster. READ MORE: UK nations unite against Labour's 'inadequate' devolution approach Meanwhile, the LibDems would have 81 MPs and the Tories would come in fourth at just 46 MPs – losing 75 seats. The SNP look set to gain seats, with the poll predicting they will go from a total of nine to 38 MPs, making them the biggest party in Scotland. However, Reform UK would also make gains in Scotland, with the poll showing Nigel Farage's party picking up seats for the first time. As reported in The Times, Reform UK would pick up three seats in the south of Scotland: Ayr, Carrick & Cumnock (Reform 28.3%, Labour 22.2%, SNP 20.8%) Dumfries & Galloway (Reform 27.8%, SNP 22.2%, Tory 20.2%) Dumfriesshire, Clydesdale and Tweedale (Reform 26.8%, Tory 24.2%, SNP 18.1%) YouGov's seat projection also reveals that Reform UK would finish in the top three of every single constituency in Scotland except from one – Edinburgh North and Leith. The total seat projection for the whole of Britain is: Reform UK: 271 seats Labour: 178 seats LibDems: 81 seats Conservatives: 46 seats SNP: 38 seats Greens: 7 seats Plaid: 7 seats The poll comes as the Labour Government is facing calls for a "regime change" amid internal rebellion over planned cuts to welfare. More than 120 Labour MPs have signed an amendment opposing the Universal Credit and Personal Independence Payment Bill, which seeks to cut disability benefits by around £5 billion per year. The amendment has also been backed by the SNP, the Greens and Independent MPs. Acccording to The Times, new Labour MPs have told colleagues that voting down the legislation would help get rid of 'overexcitable boys' from Starmer's team of advisers.
Leader Live
21 minutes ago
- Leader Live
UK's largest bioethanol plant to shut in September ‘unless Government acts'
Hull-based Vivergo Fuels said that, given 'the strategic importance of a domestic ethanol supply', the Government has committed to formal negotiations to reach a 'sustainable solution'. But the firm, which is owned by Associated British Foods (ABF), said on Thursday that it is simultaneously beginning consultation with staff to wind down the plant, which employs more than 160 people, due to the uncertain situation. It said in a statement: 'Unless the Government is able to provide both short-term funding of Vivergo's losses and a longer-term solution, we intend to close the plant once the consultation process has completed and the business has fulfilled its contractual obligations. 'We would cease all manufacturing before the end of our financial year on September 13 2025.' The statement said: 'In our interim results announcement on April 29 2025, we stated that the commercial viability of Vivergo, our bioethanol business, was being undermined by the way in which the UK Government was applying regulations to imported ethanol. 'Since then, the situation has been made significantly worse by the UK's trade deal with the US, which will allow tariff-free US ethanol into the UK. 'ABF has engaged in extensive discussions with the Government to find a financial and regulatory solution that would enable Vivergo to operate on a profitable and sustainable basis. 'Yesterday, our extended deadline for the Government to deliver that solution passed.' Last month, Vivergo wrote to the wheat farmers who supply it, telling them it will have to close unless there is quick Government intervention. It said the removal of a 19% tariff on US ethanol imports, which formed part of the recent UK-US trade deal, was the 'final blow'. The bioethanol industry says the deal has made it impossible to compete with heavily subsidised American products. Vivergo said the Hull plant can produce up to 420 million litres of bioethanol from wheat sourced from thousands of UK farms. It described bioethanol production as 'a key national strategic asset' which helps reduce emissions from petrol and is expected to be a key component in sustainable aircraft fuel in the future. The plant is also the UK's largest single production site for animal feed and the company says it indirectly supports about 4,000 jobs in the Humber and Lincolnshire region. Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds met with representatives of ABF and the other key UK bioethanol producer, Ensus, in May. Last month, a Government spokesman said it was working closely with the industry to understand the impacts of the UK-US trade deal on the UK's two bioethanol companies and is 'open to discussion over potential options for support'.
The Guardian
34 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Minister says Labour's welfare bill rebels ‘trying to do their job well' as No 10 considers concessions
Update: Date: 2025-06-26T08:10:49.000Z Title: Trade minister Douglas Alexander says Labour's welfare bill rebels 'trying to do their job well' as No 10 considers concessions Content: Good morning. Irresistible force meets immovable object and … it turns out that the object is movable after all. Until yesterday afternoon, in public at least, ministers were insisting that they were fully committed to the welfare cuts in the universal credit (UC) and personal independence payment (Pip) bill – even though it has no chance of passing in its current form because so many Labour MPs have signed a reasoned amendment to kill it. But last night it emerged that ministers are now looking at major concessions in a bid to get it through. Jessica Elgot, Kiran Stacey, Aletha Adu and Pippa Crerar have the details here. This is how their story starts. Number 10 is preparing to offer concessions to Labour MPs amid a major rebellion over the government's planned welfare cuts. Downing Street is understood to be considering watering down changes to the eligibility for disability benefits which had been significantly tightened by the reforms in the bill. More than 120 MPs are poised to rebel against the government next Tuesday and there remains division at the top of government over how to stem the growing anger. Concessions under consideration include changes to the points needed for eligibility for personal independence payments (Pip), a benefit paid to those both in and out of work. MPs also want to see changes made to other reforms affecting the health top-up for universal credit which applies to those who cannot work. Archie Bland has more on this in his First Edition briefing. Bland says: 'Up until now, Downing Street appears to have been divided on the right way forward, with one source saying: 'There is a camp for pulling it, a camp for concession and a small but insane camp for ploughing on.' Reeves is understood to be particularly opposed to pulling the vote.' This morning Douglas Alexander, the trade minister, has been on the interview round. While he did not announce any concessions, his tone could not have been more different from ministers, including Keir Starmer, speaking on this topic over the past few days. He was complimentary about the rebels, describing them as acting in good faith and implying their concerns were reasonable. And he said the government was listening. He told Sky News: The first thing that strikes you when you read the reasoned amendment [to block the bill, now signed by 126 Labour MPs] is the degree of commonality on the principles. Everyone agrees welfare needs reform and that the system was broken. Everyone recognises you're trying to take people off benefit and into work, because that's better for them and also better for our fiscal position. And everyone recognises that we need to protect the most vulnerable. Where there is, honestly, some disagreement at the moment, is on the issue of 'how do you give implementation to those principles?' … The effect of what's happened with this reasoned amendment being tabled is that that's brought forward the discussion of how to give implementation to those principles. So given the high level of agreement on the principles, the discussions over the coming days will really be about the implementation of those principles. Alexander also said the rebels were, in effect, only doing their jobs as Labour MPs. It's right to recognise these issues touch very deeply the Labour party's sense of itself and the rights and responsibilities of members of parliament. What I see is everyone trying to do their job well, ministers trying to be open with parliament as to the ambitions that we have, members of parliament being clear as to their responsibility to scrutinise this legislation and get it right. And that's the character of the conversation that's taking place between ministers and members of parliament in the hours and days ahead. Here is the agenda for the day. 9.15am: Keir Starmer gives a speech at the British Chambers of Commerce Global annual conference in London. Graeme Wearden is covering the BCC conference on his business live blog. But I will be monitoring the political speeches here too. 9.30am: The Ministry of Justice publishes quarterly criminal court statistics. After 10.30am: Lucy Powell, leader of the Commons, takes questions from MPs on next week's business. After 11.30am: Starmer is expected to make a statement to MPs about the G7 and Nato summits. 11.30am: Downing Street holds a lobby briefing. 3.25pm: Kemi Badenoch speaks at the BCC conference. If you want to contact me, please post a message below the line when comments are open (normally between 10am and 3pm at the moment), or message me on social media. I can't read all the messages BTL, but if you put 'Andrew' in a message aimed at me, I am more likely to see it because I search for posts containing that word. If you want to flag something up urgently, it is best to use social media. You can reach me on Bluesky at @ The Guardian has given up posting from its official accounts on X, but individual Guardian journalists are there, I still have my account, and if you message me there at @AndrewSparrow, I will see it and respond if necessary. I find it very helpful when readers point out mistakes, even minor typos. No error is too small to correct. And I find your questions very interesting too. I can't promise to reply to them all, but I will try to reply to as many as I can, either BTL or sometimes in the blog. Update: Date: 2025-06-26T08:52:05.000Z Title: Starmer says government 'shouldn't try to run businesses' as he explains his vision of partnership Content: In his final answer Starmer explained how he thought government and business should work together. A true partnership is not two people or two bodies trying to do the same thing. It's two people or bodies realising they bring different things to the table. Government shouldn't try to run businesses. It's done that in the past and it doesn't work particularly well. So business should run business. Government should partner business by creating the conditions which makes it easier for businesses to run their businesses. Update: Date: 2025-06-26T08:44:57.000Z Title: Starmer Content: In response to a question about devolution, says Labour was originally 'a bit wary' about metro mayors. But now he thinks they work really well. Update: Date: 2025-06-26T08:43:14.000Z Title: Starmer insists he does undertand concerns businesses have about employment rights bill Content: Q: Do you get the concerns of business about the employment rights bill [which will increase costs for firms because it imposes high standards, particularly in relation to people doing casual work]? Starmer says he does understand their concerns. They don't hold back when they speak to him. But he says a secure workforce is good for business. And he says many good businesses are already doing the things mandated in the bill. Update: Date: 2025-06-26T08:40:09.000Z Title: Starmer says tariffs now likely to be feature of global trade for some time to come Content: At the BCC conference Keir Starmer has finished his speech. He is now taking questions. Clive Myrie, the broadcaster, is chairing the session and he starts by. asking about Iran. Q: How worried should we be about what is happening in Iran? Starmer says people should be concerned. But he says happily there is a ceasefire now. I think I'm right in saying that the impact of international affairs on us domestically has never been so direct as it is at the moment. He cites the Ukraine war, and its impact on oil prices, as an example. He says the world has become more unstable. And it is not just defence, he says. On trade, the situation has changed too, he says. He says the era of tariffs, introduced by President Trump, won't end soon. Whatever we think of tariffs, they are undoubtedly an attempt to change the way the world economy is run, and we have to recognise that. I don't think we're going to be going back in a few weeks or months to how it was before this administration [President Trump's in the US] came in. We're in for a different future. We need to think through what that means. Update: Date: 2025-06-26T08:33:41.000Z Title: Content: The Commons authorities have confirmed that Keir Starmer will make a statement to MPs about the G7 and Nato summits at about 11.30am. Update: Date: 2025-06-26T08:31:38.000Z Title: Starmer says government launching trade strategy Content: Starmer says the government is today launching its trade strategy. Here is our overnight story about it, by Kiran Stacey and Jasper Jolly. Here is the Department for Business and Trade's news release about the strategy. And this is how DBT sums it up. The strategy will make the UK the most connected nation in the world and secure billions worth of opportunities for businesses, helping deliver the economic growth needed to put money in people's pockets, strengthen local economies, create jobs, and raise living standards. It takes a more agile and targeted approach than the previous government's, focusing on quicker, more practical deals that deliver faster benefits to UK businesses. It strengthens trade defences, expands export finance - especially for smaller firms - and aligns trade policy with national priorities like green growth and services. It's a smarter, more responsive plan for a changing global economy. UPDATE: Starmer said: What we want to do is push not just for traditional trade agreements, but also for smaller deals that we can make quicker, at pace – whether that's a digital trade agreement with Brazil, Thailand or Kenya; clean energy co-operation with the Philippines and Mexico, professional qualification recognition all around the world. But perhaps most importantly, in this uncertain and challenging world, we will also give ourselves new powers on trade defence. To make sure that if your businesses are threatened by practices like dumping, that we have the right powers to defend you. Update: Date: 2025-06-26T08:25:06.000Z Title: Starmer urges business to talk up opportunities, saying it's time to stop doing 'that British understatement thing' Content: Starmer says the government has stablised the economy, and is now moving to a new phase, where it is focusing on investment. He says he wants Britain to be the best place in the world for enterprise. He goes on: I do believe we've got to stop doing that British understatement thing – we do it all the time, including me – because, believe you me, this is a great moment to get on the phone to the world and say, 'Take another look at Britain.' He recalls talking recently to the boss of Nvidia, who told him that Britain was in a 'Goldilocks' position on AI. Update: Date: 2025-06-26T08:19:55.000Z Title: Starmer Content: starts by praising the contribution to the country made by business. None of the investment made by the government would be possible 'without your contribution', he says. 'And I say thank you.' does not spell it out directly, but he seems to be referring, at least in part, to the fact that business are now paying a lot more to the government in tax as a result in the rise in employer national insurance. Update: Date: 2025-06-26T08:17:18.000Z Title: Keir Starmer speaks at BCC conference Content: Keir Starmer is now speaking at the British Chambers of Commerce conference. There is a live feed at the top of the blog. Update: Date: 2025-06-26T08:00:20.000Z Title: Trade minister Douglas Alexander says Labour's welfare bill rebels 'trying to do their job well' as No 10 considers concessions Content: Good morning. Irresistible force meets immovable object and … it turns out that the object is movable after all. Until yesterday afternoon, in public at least, ministers were insisting that they were fully committed to the welfare cuts in the universal credit (UC) and personal independence payment (Pip) bill – even though it has no chance of passing in its current form because so many Labour MPs have signed a reasoned amendment to kill it. But last night it emerged that ministers are now looking at major concessions in a bid to get it through. Jessica Elgot, Kiran Stacey, Aletha Adu and Pippa Crerar have the details here. This is how their story starts. Number 10 is preparing to offer concessions to Labour MPs amid a major rebellion over the government's planned welfare cuts. Downing Street is understood to be considering watering down changes to the eligibility for disability benefits which had been significantly tightened by the reforms in the bill. More than 120 MPs are poised to rebel against the government next Tuesday and there remains division at the top of government over how to stem the growing anger. Concessions under consideration include changes to the points needed for eligibility for personal independence payments (Pip), a benefit paid to those both in and out of work. MPs also want to see changes made to other reforms affecting the health top-up for universal credit which applies to those who cannot work. Archie Bland has more on this in his First Edition briefing. Bland says: 'Up until now, Downing Street appears to have been divided on the right way forward, with one source saying: 'There is a camp for pulling it, a camp for concession and a small but insane camp for ploughing on.' Reeves is understood to be particularly opposed to pulling the vote.' This morning Douglas Alexander, the trade minister, has been on the interview round. While he did not announce any concessions, his tone could not have been more different from ministers, including Keir Starmer, speaking on this topic over the past few days. He was complimentary about the rebels, describing them as acting in good faith and implying their concerns were reasonable. And he said the government was listening. He told Sky News: The first thing that strikes you when you read the reasoned amendment [to block the bill, now signed by 126 Labour MPs] is the degree of commonality on the principles. Everyone agrees welfare needs reform and that the system was broken. Everyone recognises you're trying to take people off benefit and into work, because that's better for them and also better for our fiscal position. And everyone recognises that we need to protect the most vulnerable. Where there is, honestly, some disagreement at the moment, is on the issue of 'how do you give implementation to those principles?' … The effect of what's happened with this reasoned amendment being tabled is that that's brought forward the discussion of how to give implementation to those principles. So given the high level of agreement on the principles, the discussions over the coming days will really be about the implementation of those principles. Alexander also said the rebels were, in effect, only doing their jobs as Labour MPs. It's right to recognise these issues touch very deeply the Labour party's sense of itself and the rights and responsibilities of members of parliament. What I see is everyone trying to do their job well, ministers trying to be open with parliament as to the ambitions that we have, members of parliament being clear as to their responsibility to scrutinise this legislation and get it right. And that's the character of the conversation that's taking place between ministers and members of parliament in the hours and days ahead. Here is the agenda for the day. 9.15am: Keir Starmer gives a speech at the British Chambers of Commerce Global annual conference in London. Graeme Wearden is covering the BCC conference on his business live blog. But I will be monitoring the political speeches here too. 9.30am: The Ministry of Justice publishes quarterly criminal court statistics. After 10.30am: Lucy Powell, leader of the Commons, takes questions from MPs on next week's business. After 11.30am: Starmer is expected to make a statement to MPs about the G7 and Nato summits. 11.30am: Downing Street holds a lobby briefing. 3.25pm: Kemi Badenoch speaks at the BCC conference. If you want to contact me, please post a message below the line when comments are open (normally between 10am and 3pm at the moment), or message me on social media. I can't read all the messages BTL, but if you put 'Andrew' in a message aimed at me, I am more likely to see it because I search for posts containing that word. If you want to flag something up urgently, it is best to use social media. You can reach me on Bluesky at @ The Guardian has given up posting from its official accounts on X, but individual Guardian journalists are there, I still have my account, and if you message me there at @AndrewSparrow, I will see it and respond if necessary. I find it very helpful when readers point out mistakes, even minor typos. No error is too small to correct. And I find your questions very interesting too. I can't promise to reply to them all, but I will try to reply to as many as I can, either BTL or sometimes in the blog.
