Anthropic wins ruling on use of copyrighted books to train AI, but not pirated books
In a test case for the
artificial intelligence (AI) industry, a federal judge has ruled that AI company Anthropic did not break the law by training its chatbot Claude on millions of copyrighted books.
But the company is still on the hook and must now go to trial over how it acquired those books by downloading them from online 'shadow libraries' of pirated copies.
US District Judge William Alsup of San Francisco said in a ruling filed late Monday that the AI system's distilling from thousands of written works to be able to produce its own passages of text qualified as 'fair use' under US copyright law because it was 'quintessentially transformative'.
'Like any reader aspiring to be a writer, Anthropic's [AI large language models] trained upon works not to race ahead and replicate or supplant them – but to turn a hard corner and create something different,' Alsup wrote.
Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei. Photo: AP
But while dismissing a key claim made by the group of authors who sued the company for copyright infringement last year, Alsup also said Anthropic must still go to trial in December over its alleged theft of their works.
'Anthropic had no entitlement to use pirated copies for its central library,' Alsup wrote.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South China Morning Post
22 minutes ago
- South China Morning Post
Twin shocks of Israel-Iran war, Trump tariffs bring global recession closer
The outbreak of a new war in the Middle East, together with a destructive tariff war, makes for a lethal combination in a sluggish world economy. Notwithstanding the tentative ceasefire , the odds of imminent global recession have increased sharply. Advertisement One shock was bad enough. US President Donald Trump's tariffs imply downside risks to global growth. But the potential for a second shock – a war between Israel and Iran that has now ensnared the United States – compounds the problems for an increasingly vulnerable world economy. It fits with my theory of cyclical risk: it doesn't take much to tip an economy nearing 'stall speed' into outright recession This simple rule has worked remarkably well in predicting global recessions over the past 45 years. Unlike a recession in an individual economy, which generally reflects a contraction of real output, one at the global level typically involves about half the world's economies contracting while the remainder continue to expand. As a result, a worldwide recession is usually associated with global gross domestic product growth slowing to the still positive 2-2.5 per cent range – a shortfall of 0.8 to 1.3 percentage points from the post-1980 trend of 3.3 per cent. The exceptions were in 2009 and 2020, when the global financial crisis and the Covid-19 pandemic , respectively, caused outright contractions in global output. The stall speed holds the key to cyclical risk assessment. It can be thought of as a zone of vulnerability, measured by significant downside deviations from trend growth. Looking back over the past 45 years, I would place the global economy's stall speed in the 2.5-3 per cent range: when in this zone, the world lacks the resilience needed to withstand a shock. That is what happened in each of the past four global recessions. A trader reacts on the trading floor of the Indonesia Stock Exchange in Jakarta on October 8, 2008, after Indonesia's benchmark stock index plunged 10 per cent on fears about the global financial crisis. Photo: AP Fast-forward to today. According to the International Monetary Fund's latest World Economic Outlook, global GDP growth is expected to slow to 2.8 per cent in 2025 – right in the middle of the stall-speed zone. Whereas recent global recessions were the result of single shocks, today the world economy could be hit by two: a tariff war and a kinetic war in the Middle East . The possibility of a double-shock combination only increases the odds of global recession; in forecasting circles, it's as close to a smoking gun as you can get.
The Standard
an hour ago
- The Standard
Hawkish BOJ policymaker puts market on notice for 'decisive' rate hikes
Fed seen in no rush to cut rates as US job market cools but doesn't crumble
South China Morning Post
2 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
Oil price ticks higher after 2-day slump as energy traders assess Iran-Israel ceasefire
Oil edged higher – after posting the biggest two-day decline since 2022 – as traders assessed the Iran-Israel ceasefire and an industry report that pointed to another drop in US crude stockpiles. Advertisement Brent crude rose about 1 per cent to near US$68 a barrel, after slumping 13 per cent over the past two days, while West Texas Intermediate was above US$65. Following their brief war, Israel and Iran appeared to be honouring the ceasefire brokered by US President Donald Trump, reducing risks to supplies from the region. Also on Tuesday, Trump gave China, Iran's biggest crude customer, the green light to carry on buying its oil, as he sought to bolster the truce. That move appeared to undermine years of US sanctions against Tehran. A senior White House official later signalled that curbs on Iran would remain. The global oil market has had a wild ride this week, marked by rapid shifts in sentiment. Prices initially spiked after the US bombed Iranian nuclear sites at the weekend, boosting concerns about crude supplies, then got dragged sharply lower as the White House announced the truce between Tehran and Israel. The apparent policy shift on Iranian exports added to the losses. 'A slight upwards correction in crude is to be expected after a two-day plunge,' said Vandana Hari, founder of Vanda Insights. 'While the market will keep an eye on the fragile truce for a bit, focus will rotate back to the economic picture, the fate of the US' tariff negotiations, and Opec.' Advertisement The Opec alliance is due to hold a videoconference on July 6 to consider a further supply boost in August. Meanwhile, Trump's self-imposed deadline to reach trade deals with the US' major partners falls on July 9. Nations without an accord in place will face the so-called 'Liberation Day' tariffs.
