Classic heartbreak for Shes Perfect after French Guineas demotion
Francis-Henri Graffard's Zarigana had come out narrowly on top when the pair met in the Prix de la Grotte over the course and distance last month and was a hot favourite to confirm her superiority in the French 1000 Guineas.
But just as she had done four weeks ago, Shes Perfect found herself in front from an early stage in the hands of Kieran Shoemark and she had plenty of her rivals on the stretch rounding the home turn.
For a few strides the daughter of Sioux Nation looked like a sitting duck in the straight, but to her credit she kept responding to Shoemark's urging and while Zarigana came at her fast and late, Shes Perfect passed the post a nose in front.
Zarigana wins the Poule d'Essai des Pouliches in the stewards' room! 🏆 pic.twitter.com/qTNAVTJ8Vm
— At The Races (@AtTheRaces) May 11, 2025
However, scenes of wild celebration in the winner's enclosure from Shes Perfect's owners, the Basher Watts Racing syndicate, proved short lived as Zarigana's rider Mickael Barzalona lodged an objection after the race and following an inquiry, the result was amended.
Graffard told Sky Sports Racing: 'Obviously it was a tough few minutes and we don't like to win like this and I feel sorry for the connections of Shes Perfect because they had the joy, but this is sport and this is racing and it has happened to me in the past.
'To be fair, my filly, when she came (with her challenge) she got really unbalanced at the wrong time and in the end it was only a nose.
'It was a decision in the stewards' room, but I'm very happy for this filly especially. There was a lot of expectation and she deserves a win like that. It would have been very frustrating to be second and beaten a nose and for the team at home it's really good.
'It's quite hard to really enjoy it, it's more like relief than proper joy.'
Zarigana could now make an appearance at Royal Ascot, with her trainer adding: 'We'll have to discuss it, I'm not sure she needs to be stepped up in trip, so if we decide to stick to a mile we'll go to Ascot for the Coronation Stakes with her.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Wales Online
12 minutes ago
- Wales Online
Welsh star 'killing it' for club side backed for Wales recall as fans stunned he's been forgotten
Welsh star 'killing it' for club side backed for Wales recall as fans stunned he's been forgotten The PRO D2 is home to a handful of Welsh players Sam Davies (R) of Grenoble (Image: Getty Images ) England great Joe Worsley has tipped Sam Davies for a Wales recall after another sensational season in French rugby's PRO D2. Davies has been a revelation for Grenoble this season and will be a key figure in the PRO D2 grand final against Montauban at the Stade Ernest-Wallon in Toulouse on Saturday. The former Ospreys and Dragons playmaker has racked up 237 points for Grenoble this season and has spearheaded the French club to within touching distance of the Top 14. Davies won the last of his eight caps for Wales in 2017 and is not even sure if he is captured by the controversial 25-cap law owing to the fact he did not receive an offer from a Welsh club before signing a new contract with Grenoble. But Worsley, who is defence coach at PRO D2 outfit Brive, has kept a close eye on Davies for the past couple of seasons and believes the next Wales coach should seriously consider selecting the 31-year-old outside-half. Sign up to Inside Welsh rugby on Substack to get exclusive news stories and insight from behind the scenes in Welsh rugby. "Sam Davies has been killing it for a couple of years now," the former England flanker told WalesOnline. "People in France don't understand why he's not involved with Wales. Article continues below "From what I've seen he's definitely good enough to play international rugby but you'll have to gear up a team in the style that suits him. "If you want a team that plays quickly without too much structure he'll be fantastic but if you want a team which plays structured then you want Dan Biggar mark two. "The Grenoble team really suits how he plays. He is an all-court 10 who is a very good kicker and also attacks the line while defending isn't an issue for him. "When Sam is playing Grenoble are a far more dangerous side. Sam last year was the 10 that was picked in the team of the season and he'll be picked there again this year. His kicking has been phenomenal. "Grenoble are a team who like to keep the ball in play and attack the line. He's been making the right calls, making the right passes and running the right lines. "When he doesn't play they are not nearly as dangerous and I think they'll be playing in the Top 14 next year which in large parts is down to Sam." Professional rugby is struggling everywhere apart from France which has three professional leagues, a bumper TV deal which blows everything else out of the water and packed stadiums every week. While the Top 14 is the premier competition in French rugby, the second division PRO D2 is equally as compelling and is the home for a plethora of Welsh players. Alongside Davies there is Welsh legend George North at Provence and experienced tighthead Tomas Francis, while former Dragons centre Tyler Morgan plies his trade at Biarritz and Owen Lane is at Valence Romans. "Sam Davies from all the Welsh players has had the biggest impact rugby wise," Worsley tells WalesOnline. "Ross Moriarty has had a few injuries this year but last year he was in the team of the season in PRO D2. "George North did his Achilles and had a couple of little injuries after he came back. He's only played about 10 games for Provence but the head coach there is saying he's the best player he's ever coached. "He drags up the whole team even when he was injured and he learnt French in four months. He's been helping out with the youngsters and he's just got fully stuck in, so his character is shining through." While Premier Sports have the rights to the Top 14 up until a few weeks ago the PRO D2 was not shown in the UK. Join WalesOnline Rugby's WhatsApp Channel here to get the breaking news sent straight to your phone for free But that has all changed after an ambitious broadcaster and podcaster named Tim Cocker set up a YouTube channel called FR-UK Rugby and bought the rights to show the PRO D2 in the UK and Ireland. The deal has allowed him to acquire the PRO D2 play-offs this season along with 35 matches next term. Worsley works alongside Cocker and is working hard to make the PRO D2 popular in the UK and Ireland. "I realised nobody was watching it and I found out the price of the rights was relatively doable," said Worsley. "I met three other guys - one is called Tim Crocker who is a presenter who does the EggChasers podcast. "I met him through a friend Dougie Andrews, who is a producer. With those two we initially got going and started making some content. "James Lewis joined us shortly after who is an industry figure who ran Sky Sports rugby. We realised it had to be free and he also believes TV is going to change because there are so many subscription models going on. "If you want to watch rugby in the UK you've got to have three different subscriptions to different channels to watch all the various rugby competitions. "We will have a number of short-form and long-form interviews throughout the week as well as showing live games. "For 18 months we negotiated with Canal+ and LNR because it's a new concept and they were really nervous about it. "Eventually we ended up with PRO D2 rights and if we prove the concept works we will be able to bid for more. "Our ambition is to have games Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday because in France the second division plays on Thursday and Friday and Top 14 plays Saturday and Sunday. "The PRO D2 is different to every other rugby competition in the world. The crowds watching those games are more than the English Premiership. "TV deals are also going up and it is well funded. The top budget in the league is 22m euros. "It's very hard to compare to what happens in Wales and England because of taxes and how it works but put it this way the playing budgets are more like the lower half of the Premiership in England. "One of the reasons the TOP 14 is successful is because there is jeopardy and loads of play-offs. "You create these incredible moments where everything is on the line whereas in England and Wales there's so many dead rubbers where nobody gives a damn." The PRO D2 is already the home of many Welsh players and given the lowly state of the professional game in Wales, more are likely to venture across the channel over the coming seasons. Get the latest breaking Welsh rugby news stories sent straight to your inbox with our FREE daily newsletter. Sign up here. "There are big cultural differences so when you first come over it shocks you. "The season is really long. It's 11 months and because of that sometimes people switch off and they get encouraged to do so whereas in the UK we are always on it. "It fluctuates the level of commitment and engagement in terms of training, doing weights and eating correctly. "That's one of the aspects that is different. "If you've got a young family it's an amazing place to bring them up especially George in Provence because Aix-en-Provence is one of the best cities in the world to live in. "In France there's a lot of flair and for some foreign players that takes getting used to because it can be very abstract learning about it. "Some players struggle with what they perceive to be a vague game plan. "It would probably strike more of a cord with Welsh fans because historically you did have a team which could play instinctively. "You then went to Warren who had a very structured team but you've also had teams who play instinctively. Article continues below "Where Welsh rugby goes now I'd imagine they are going to have to introduce that side of the game to be able to have success. "I can definitely see more Welsh players coming to play in France over the next couple of seasons." The PRO D2 final between Grenoble and Montauban is live on FR-UK Rugby's YouTube channel at 4.30pm on Saturday.
Leader Live
26 minutes ago
- Leader Live
Buick backing Desert Flower to bloom in quest for Oaks glory
It has been a sublime start to the summer for the Moulton Paddocks handler and his number one rider, and after picking up both Classics at Newmarket last month the pair now head to the Surrey Downs with an exceptional chance to continue their hot streak in racing's crown jewel events. The unbeaten Desert Flower has carried all before her in her career to date and now steps up in trip, with Buick confident her versatility will aid her bid to not only stay the trip but become the first filly since Love in 2020 to complete the Newmarket/Epsom double. ALL-THE-WAY! Desert Flower takes the @Betfred 1000 Guineas in ASTONISHING style 🏇💨 — Newmarket Racecourse (@NewmarketRace) May 4, 2025 Buick, who will team up with 2000 Guineas winner Ruling Court in Saturday's Derby, said of his Oaks mount: 'I think she's tactically very versatile, but as she's only run over a mile you would have to ride her slightly accordingly. But I do think she's very versatile – each time I've ridden her she has adapted to the race scenario. 'We could have kept her at a mile, it was put across the table as a plan, but we all felt she would get further. Whether that is a mile and a quarter or a mile and a half, we will see on Friday.' Saeed Bin Suroor's Elwateen was fourth to Desert Flower on just her second start in the 1000 Guineas and the Newmarket handler could celebrate the 30th anniversary of Lammtarra's Derby success in style, as like her Rowley Mile conqueror she puts her stamina to the test. Bin Suroor said: 'She ran a really good race in the Guineas and she came out of that well. To finish fourth in the Guineas on just her second run after winning her maiden was very good. 'This is her first run over a mile and half, but she should stay because she is nice and relaxed. 'I think Epsom will suit her, she's a nice size and if she settles in the first half of the race I think she'll stay. The further she goes the better I think. She's a very nice filly and I think she'll run well.' Aidan O'Brien has won the showpiece event 10 times and saddles a host of trial winners in search of number 11. Ryan Moore has plumped for Cheshire Oaks scorer Minnie Hauk from the Ballydoyle trio, as she bids to become the first filly since Enable to follow up success on the Roodee at Epsom. Minnie Hauk – who was purchased for €1,850,000 in 2023 – takes the Weatherbys ePassport Cheshire Oaks under Ryan Moore! 🏅 It's a ninth win in the race for Aidan O'Brien… — At The Races (@AtTheRaces) May 7, 2025 O'Brien said: 'Minnie Hauk was just ready to start in Chester, we had to try to get a run into her somewhere before the Oaks and that suited perfectly. We knew it wouldn't be too demanding on her and she would have learned plenty. 'She's a lovely filly with a good nature, a good traveller and has a good stride to her. She shows plenty of pace in her work in her half-speeds.' The master of Ballydoyle will also be represented by Giselle and Whirl, who tuned up for duty with wins at Lingfield and in York's Musidora Stakes respectively. O'Brien continued: 'Giselle got very keen through the winter and spring and wanted to do too much so we didn't get to do an awful lot with her – it was all about relaxing her. 'If we were going to the Oaks she had to run and Lingfield was about the only place she could. She was probably very underdone fitness-wise in Lingfield, we were just hoping to get her started and go from there, so we were delighted with the way she won and she's come forward a lot since then we think. 'Whirl is a very straightforward filly and Ryan was very happy to make the running on her in York. A filly came up either side of her, but that was no problem to her, she's got a lovely mind and she got the mile and a quarter very well and looked like a filly that could get further.' Ralph Beckett has fond memories of the Oaks and having linked up with owner-breeder Julian Richmond-Watson when opening his Classic account with Look Here in 2008, the pair join forces again with Nottingham winner Revoir, who will attempt to reverse recent Newbury form with Ed Walker's Qilin Queen. Joseph O'Brien's Wemightakedlongway and John and Thady Gosden's Go Go Boots – representing American celebrity chef Bobby Flay – complete the field of nine.
Leader Live
26 minutes ago
- Leader Live
Eberechi Eze ‘trusting it will work out' over Crystal Palace's European hopes
Palace qualified for Europe for the first time in their history by winning the FA Cup last month, but their place is under threat because of UEFA rules surround multi-club ownership. John Textor holds a 43 per cent stake in Palace through his company Eagle Football and he is also the owner of French club Lyon, who qualified for the Europa League with a sixth-placed finish in Ligue 1. 😏 — Crystal Palace F.C. (@CPFC) May 19, 2025 A decision is expected soon and Eze, who is with England for their World Cup qualifier against Andorra and friendly with Senegal, is optimistic. 'I really hope that Palace do get the reward because of what it took to actually achieve that,' Eze told reporters. 'It would be a huge shame if that was not the case but I'm trusting that it will work out in the end. 'It should work itself out because there's players who have worked to be in this position. 'There are fans who have been with the team throughout the whole season and experienced everything.' Meanwhile, Trevoh Chalobah is backing Thomas Tuchel to bring a 'winning culture' to England. A week to remember for @TrevohChalobah ❤️ — England (@England) June 3, 2025 The 25-year-old defender has received his maiden call-up for Tuchel's squad, which is another slice of recognition by the German. Chalobah said: 'He's the one who gave me my Chelsea debut. 'It's been good moments shared with him. He's a very tough manager. And I think that's what us players need going into the World Cup next year, and obviously in these games, just to build us up. 'He's a very good coach. He wants to win. He's a winner, you know? And he's seen that Chelsea, he's won, and he wants to bring that same winning culture here.'
