Neighbours' seven-year row over garden tap is ‘ridiculous', says judge
The dispute between two neighbours in Ilford, east London, has lasted for seven years and has now gone before the High Court.
A judge, presiding over the case this week, said: 'Hundreds of thousands of pounds about a tap and a pipe that doesn't matter – this brings litigation into disrepute.'
The feud started when pensioner Christel Naish complained to her doctor neighbour, Jyotibala Patel, about a tap and pipe outside her house in Chadacre Avenue, the court heard.
She said the tap and pipe were 'trespassing' on a narrow strip of land between their homes, which she claimed partly belonged to her.
Ms Naish is accused of 'terrorising' Dr Patel and her husband Vasos Vassili with 'petty and vindictive' complaints about the matter.
The couple's barrister, Paul Wilmshurst, told the court they felt forced to sue because of the 'blight' on the property's value caused by the unresolved row.
'For many years the appellant has been making allegations about the trespassing nature of the [tap and pipe], thereby making it impossible for them to sell their house,' he said.
In a trial at Mayor's and City County Court in 2023, the couple claimed the gap between the houses belonged to them.
They insisted the boundary between the two properties was the flank wall of Ms Naish's house and not the edge of her gutter as she claimed.
They won that case and Ms Naish was ordered to pay 65 per cent of her neighbours' lawyers' bills, amounting to about £100,000, on top of her own costs.
But Ms Naish has refused to back down and took her case to the High Court for an appeal last week.
Her barrister, David Mayall, argued that the original decision was 'fatally flawed' and should be overturned.
The appeal is costing more than £30,000 and Mr Mayall said it could result in 'another £200,000' being spent on a second trial if she succeeds.
Judge Sir Anthony Mann criticised both parties for the 'ridiculous' row after the court heard the tap had since been removed by Dr Patel anyway.
Addressing Mr Mayall, he said: 'You don't care about the pipe and the tap, so why does it matter, for goodness' sake, where the boundary lies?
'It seems to me to be a ridiculous piece of litigation - on both sides, no doubt.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
5 minutes ago
- The Independent
Wayne Rooney: ‘Racially abused player cried on my chest'
Wayne Rooney has revealed how he consoled a former player who 'cried on his chest' after receiving racist abuse. He believes believes only tougher sanctions for racism in football, like points deductions, will prevent further incidents. Speaking on his new BBC podcast, The Wayne Rooney Show, former England and Manchester United captain Rooney reflected on what changes need to occur to help tackle discrimination. Last week saw two major incidents, with Antoine Semenyo of Bournemouth allegedly racially abused by a spectator in the crowd during their 4-2 loss at Liverpool and Tottenham forward Mathys Tel receiving racism online for a missed penalty in their Super Cup defeat to Paris St Germain. Ex-DC United boss Rooney said: 'I had it in DC with one of my players who got racially abused and he was crying on my chest. I was holding him as he was crying on my chest. 'I don't think people realise – they say it as a throwaway line that they think has no meaning behind it, but it hurts people. For people to see that and understand, there has to be more done to stop it.' Points deductions and education were put forward by Rooney as key deterrents to prevent racism. He added: 'There needs to be a strong campaign for society – for children, parents and grandparents – to be educated,' Rooney added. 'You have to hit the clubs because that's the only way it will stop. If there is ignorance, the fans will still do it. 'You have to hit the clubs by taking off points or hit them in the pocket and take money away from them. Otherwise, it will keep on going. 'Hopefully the right people sit down with the right organisations to try and get something serious in place.'
The Sun
6 minutes ago
- The Sun
Worried children ‘warned to avoid migrants while walking home from school' through hotspot areas
CHILDREN have been told to 'avoid migrant hot-spots' on their way home from school, senior Tory Robert Jenrick has claimed. He said mums told him that schools warned pupils to steer clear of certain areas — with the kids saying men at the hotels make them feel unsafe. The Shadow Justice Secretary spoke after visiting Epping, Essex — where protests flared in July when an Ethiopian asylum seeker was charged with sexually assaulting a schoolgirl just days after arriving in Britain. Writing in The Sun, Mr Jenrick said: 'I spoke to teens, parents and grandparents — all rightly concerned about the safety of their community. 'These weren't racists or far-right thugs — they were mums in pink T-shirts with Union Jack bunting. "One mother told me how her daughter's school had written to her suggesting children avoid certain parts of town on their walk home. 'Her young daughter told me that men from the hotels loiter outside certain spots 'where they look at us'.' But Mr Jenrick faced questions himself after being pictured alongside Eddy Butler, a founder of the banned neo- Nazi terror group Combat 18. A Labour spokesman said: 'Robert Jenrick is a disgrace. Standing alongside someone with a long history of involvement with neo-Nazi terror groups, at a protest organised by a far-right party, shows just how far he and the Tories have sunk.' Asked about Eddy Butler, a source close to Mr Jenrick hit back: 'No idea who this guy is and Rob didn't speak to him. 'Rob just spoke with peaceful protesters.' Supermarket worker Dean Smith, 51, of Epping, Essex, has been warned he faces jail after admitting violent disorder outside a migrant hotel in the town. Mums & children dressed in pink peacefully protest outside controversial migrant hotel before yobs clash with cops 1 Asylum site vow DOWNING Street yesterday said small boat migrants should not be housed in the middle of towns and cities. It came after we told how Labour councillors in Havant, Hants, want them placed near shops, schools and GPs so they can 'integrate'. No10 agreed the asylum system was 'unfair on working people'. Protest marches against migrant hotels have included one in Canary Wharf, East London.
Daily Mail
6 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Matthew Perry documentary leaves fans in tears after it depicts the actor's 'heartbreaking' final days - as 'Ketamine Queen' who supplied him with the deadly drug pleads guilty
A 'heartbreaking' documentary depicting the final days of Friends star Matthew Perry left viewers in tears as it hit UK screens on Monday. The actor died at the age of 54 after he accidentally drowned in his hot tub following a dose of ketamine on October 28, 2023, which eventually led to several arrests. And as the documentary, Matthew Perry: A Hollywood Tragedy, was aired on ITV1, many viewers reacted to seeing the devastating build-up to his final days, as well his own reflection on his battles with drug and alcohol addiction. The programme, originally broadcast on Peacock in the US, aired in the UK as it was revealed that the so-called 'Ketamine Queen' Jasveen Sangha plead guilty to selling the drugs that ultimately killed the star. The documentary did not feature any of Matthew's Friends co-stars, with director Robert Palumbo saying they were 'reluctant' to appear in the programme. Fans took to social media to reflect on Matthew's life being so tragically cut short after his death. Posts on X included: 'This Matthew Perry documentary is heartbreaking;' 'Matthew Perry: A Hollywood Tragedy is now on ITV, STV and ITVX. The world is missing a beautiful, funny and caring man. I can't believe he passed away almost 2 years ago. We miss you Matty;' 'Matthew Perry interview on ITV1 and almost 20 minutes in and I'm crying;' 'So sad to hear how Matthew Perry got taken advantage of, in a bid to help his addiction;' 'These people only cared about making a profit, not about his health and what they were doing that was wrong;' 'Watching the sad tale of our FRIENDS Matthew Perry. So tragic. RIP bro in harms;' 'Watching documentary on Matthew Perry on ITV. If you have an interest in addiction I would encourage you to catch up on it at some stage. Very sad...' It was revealed on Monday that Sangha will plead guilty to five charges, including one count of distributing ketamine resulting in death or bodily injury, according to the Justice Department. Fans took to social media to reflect on Matthew's life being so tragically cut short after his tragic death Federal prosecutors called her Los Angeles home a 'drug-selling emporium' and found dozens of vials of ketamine during a raid. Sangha will enter the deal in the coming weeks according to the Justice Department, and the drug-involved charges carry a maximum sentence of 20 years. A 10-year maximum sentence is set for each ketamine distribution charge, and the distribution of ketamine resulting in death or serious bodily injury charge carries a 15-year sentence. Before his tragic death, Perry had been taking ketamine, which can be used for treatment-resistant depression. However, he had been receiving daily transfusions of the drug. Following his death, the medical examiner determined that he had taken a large amount shortly before his death that could not have been left over from his last infusion because the half-life of the drug is only three to four hours. Doctor Mark Chaves, 53, formally pleaded guilty to illegally distributing ketamine in October of last year. Facing up to 10 years in prison, even with a plea deal, Chavez will be sentenced on April 2, 2025. Prior to court hearing, Chavez agreed to stop practicing medicine, and handed his passport to authorities. It's understood Chavez sold ketamine lozenges to Dr. Salvador Plasencia, who is accused of then providing them to Perry. Plasencia is facing separate charges, to which he pleaded not guilty. The doctor is also accused of texting Chavez 'I wonder how much this moron will pay' when he learned Perry was seeking ketamine. Prosecutors offered lesser charges to Chavez and two others in exchange for their cooperation. Perry's personal assistant Kenneth Iwamasa and TV producer Erik Fleming, both of whom pleaded guilty in August, were also charged. Perry was found dead by his assistant, and the medical examiner later ruled the primary cause of death was ketamine. The actor had been using the drug through his regular doctor in a legal but off-label treatment for depression that has become increasingly common. Perry struggled with addiction for years, dating back to his time on 'Friends,' when he became one of the biggest stars of his generation as Chandler Bing.
