‘Asim Munir Is Osama Bin Laden In A Suit': Ex-Pentagon Official Slams Pakistan's Nuclear Rhetoric
Michael Rubin also criticised Pakistan's recent nuclear sabre-rattling, branding the country's conduct as that of 'a rogue state'
Former Pentagon analyst Michael Rubin has unleashed a blistering condemnation of Pakistan's recent nuclear posturing, accusing the country of acting like 'a rogue state" after threatening remarks were allegedly made by its army chief on American soil.
The uproar stems from comments attributed to Pakistan Army chief Gen Asim Munir, who reportedly warned during a meeting in Tampa, Florida, with US military officials that if Pakistan 'goes down, it would take half the world down" with it.
Calling the statements 'completely unacceptable," Rubin told ANI that Munir's rhetoric echoed the language of terrorist groups. 'Pakistan is raising questions in many people's minds about whether it can fulfil the responsibilities of being a state. The Field Marshal's rhetoric is reminiscent of what we've heard from the Islamic State," he said.
#WATCH | Washington DC, USA | On upcoming meeting between US and Russia, Former Pentagon official Michael Rubin says, '…Asim Munir is Osama Bin Laden in a suit…"He says, 'Donald Trump is a businessman and is used to horse-trading… He does not understand that a bad peace… pic.twitter.com/Cra1y24e19
— ANI (@ANI) August 12, 2025
Rubin demanded swift diplomatic retaliation — stripping Pakistan of its major non-NATO ally status, considering a designation as a state sponsor of terrorism, and banning Munir from US entry. He slammed American officials for failing to act immediately when the alleged remarks were made.
'Within 30 minutes of when Asim Munir made those comments, he should have been ushered out, taken to Tampa International Airport, and flown out of the United States," he said.
The former Pentagon official also questioned President Donald Trump's motives, hinting at possible foreign influence. He argued that Trump's approach marks a sharp break from the bipartisan US-India partnership cultivated since the George W. Bush era.
Rubin warned that Pakistan's nuclear threats risk emboldening terrorist factions, some linked to the Pakistani military and ISI, to 'go rogue" with nuclear weapons. 'Americans look at terrorism through the lens of grievance," he noted. 'They don't understand the ideological underpinnings of many terrorists. Asim Munir is Osama bin Laden in a suit."
In one of his most provocative proposals, Rubin urged the international community to consider a 'managed decline" of Pakistan, potentially recognising breakaway regions like Balochistan. He even floated the possibility of US special forces seizing Pakistan's nuclear arsenal in the future. 'It's coming near time when, in a future administration, other SEAL teams should enter Pakistan to secure its nuclear weapons because the alternative is simply too great to bear," he said.
Touching on wider US-India tensions over trade and Russian energy purchases, Rubin accused Washington of hypocrisy, pointing out that the US itself buys strategic materials from Moscow. He predicted that once the current 'stress test" in relations ends, the partnership will emerge stronger.
Rubin's remarks underscore intensifying concerns over Pakistan's stability, its nuclear command, and the risks it poses to global security — concerns he argues Washington can no longer afford to downplay.
view comments
Location :
New Delhi, India, India
First Published:
News world 'Asim Munir Is Osama Bin Laden In A Suit': Ex-Pentagon Official Slams Pakistan's Nuclear Rhetoric
Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Print
2 minutes ago
- The Print
India, US troops to undertake joint military exercise next month, first after Op Sindoor
The joint exercise comes at a time when Pakistan and US have come closer than ever before under the Trump administration. The US President hosting Pakistan's army chief Field Marshal Asim Munir at the White House to undertaking joint anti-terror talks with Islamabad, both sides have a long way from 2018 when Trump had described Pakistan as a 'safe haven for terrorists'. Termed 'Yudh Abhyas', the annual exercise from 1 to 16 September in US' Alaska will see an all-arms contingent going from the Indian Army led by the Madras Regiment, ThePrint has learnt. New Delhi: Amid heightened tensions between New Delhi and Washington, and a growing synergy between the Pakistan government and US President Donald Trump, Indian and American troops will undertake a joint military exercise next month. 'The upcoming edition will see participation from both sides in high-altitude conditions in Alaska, a factor that adds operational complexity to the drills. Such settings will also allow troops to train in environments that mirror potential conflict zones,' said a source. Launched in 2004 under the framework of the Indo-US defence Cooperation Agreement, 'Yudh Abhyas' alternates annually between locations in India and the US, with the previous edition held in Rajasthan in 2024. In the exercise, the Indian Army and US Army typically take part in tactical field training which covers counter-insurgency, counter-terrorism and peacekeeping scenarios with command post drills that focus on mission planning, joint operations and coordination under United Nations mandates. Beyond such tactics, the exercise also serves as a platform for sharing military technology, operational best practices and disaster relief coordination methods. Separately, India and the US are also preparing to finalise the proposed 10-year framework for the US-India Major Defence Partnership, expected to be signed during the next meeting between Defence Minister Rajnath Singh and US Secretary of Defence Pete Hegseth. The plan aims to expand cooperation beyond arms purchases to include co-production of systems such as the Javelin ATGMs (anti-tank guided missiles) and the Stryker combat vehicle. Furthermore, amidst tensions with the US, the Ministry of Defence had last week dismissed media reports claiming India had paused talks for major US defence purchases. Calling such reports 'false and fabricated', MoD officials had said procurement cases 'are being progressed as per the extant procedures'. (Edited by Viny Mishra) Also read: India sees the value of US defence ties, but MAGA-style tariffs threaten long-term stability
Time of India
2 minutes ago
- Time of India
Daimler, Volvo, other truckmakers sue California to block emissions rules
Four major truckmakers, including Daimler and Volvo, sued California to block the state from enforcing strict emissions standards that U.S. President Donald Trump declared void in June. Daimler, Volvo, Paccar and International Motors , formerly Navistar, said they have been "caught in the crossfire" after Trump reversed waivers issued during the Biden administration that let California set its own standards. In a complaint filed on Monday, the truckmakers said Trump's rescinding U.S. Environmental Protection Agency approval of California's plan to boost zero-emission heavy-duty truck sales and reduce nitrogen oxide emissions preempted the state's enforcement. They said this included enforcing the Clean Truck Partnership , a 2023 program giving the truckmaking industry flexibility to meet emissions requirements while advancing California's goal of lowering emissions. The truckmakers said the regulatory uncertainty has caused irreparable harm because they cannot plan production in advance without knowing which vehicles they will be permitted to sell. Monday's complaint names the California Air Resources Board and Democratic Governor Gavin Newsom as defendants, and was filed in the federal court in Sacramento, the state's capital. Newsom's office and the board did not respond on Tuesday to requests for comment. On Tuesday evening, the Federal Trade Commission ended an antitrust probe into the Clean Truck Partnership, and said Daimler, Volvo, Paccar and International Motors agreed to avoid future anticompetitive agreements with state regulators. "CARB's regulatory overreach posed a major threat to American trucking," Taylor Hoogendoorn, deputy director of the FTC bureau of competition, said in a statement. Trump, a Republican, is trying to curb California's power under the federal Clean Air Act to set tighter pollution limits than federal law requires, and Newsom's ability to promote electric vehicles as the governor fights climate change. California has received more than 100 waivers under the Clean Air Act since 1970. During his June signing of joint congressional resolutions, Trump also blocked California's effort to end sales of gasoline-only vehicles by 2035. The state is also suing to undo Trump's actions. The case is Daimler Truck North America LLC et al v. California Air Resources Board et al, U.S. District Court, Eastern District of California, No. 25-02255.
India.com
2 minutes ago
- India.com
BRICS, Diesel, Urea…India and China come together to teach Trump a lesson amid tariff war, PM Modi now plans to..., Gautam Adani also to...
New Delhi: India and China appear to be coming closer amid US President Donald Trump's tariff war. According to the reports, India has exported diesel to Xi Jinping's China, while China, on the other hand, has softened its stance and eased restrictions on urea exports to India. In addition to this, the direct flights between India and China likely to begin soon. To recall, the Modi government had suspended direct flights to China since the COVID-19 outbreak. Moreover, Prime Minister Narendra Modi is scheduled to visit China this year to attend the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) summit. Reports suggest that India is also set to assume the BRICS chairmanship soon, raising the possibility that Chinese President Xi Jinping may visit India. It is believed that BRICS nations, including India, China, Russia, and Brazil, could strengthen cooperation to rein in Donald Trump. India-US Ties: Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi was among the first few leaders who met US President Donald Trump after he returned to the White House. However, despite all the bonhomie, the relationship between the nations witnessed a new low after Donald Trump imposed a massive 50 percent tariff on India and overtures to the Pakistani Army Chief Asim Munir. Meanwhile, after the Galwan clash in 2020, economic ties between India and BRICS member China now appear to be getting back on track. India has announced that it will grant tourist visas to Chinese citizens. What Chinese Experts Said About India–China Friendship Speaking to Bloomberg, Henry Wang, president of a Chinese think tank, said that relations between India and China are now 'on the rise.' Henry Wang also said that as leaders of the Global South, the two countries need to engage in dialogue with each other. Wang pointed out that China, too, is a prime target of Trump's tariff war. China has also indicated its willingness to improve relations with India. China has approved the export of urea to India, the world's largest fertilizer importer. Adani is looking to form a joint venture with China's BYD to manufacture batteries on a large scale within India. Prime Minister Modi may meet the Chinese President on August 31 during the SCO meeting. China is India's second-largest trading partner after the United States. India has a significant need for Chinese technology and raw materials to boost its manufacturing sector. Analysts say that while there is a visible warming in India–China ties, full trust between the two will not be established overnight.
