City of Winnipeg says 2024 sewage spill had no significant impact on Lake Winnipeg's health
The city, province and federal government also denied in separate statements of defence they engaged in actions that harmed the First Nations — while the city and province said the First Nations have no standing to make some of their claims.
In May 2024, the eight First Nations — Berens River, Black River, Brokenhead, Hollow Water, Kinonjeoshtegon, Misipawistik, Poplar River and Sagkeeng First Nations — and their chiefs filed a claim against the city, province and federal government, seeking billions of dollars in compensation for the discharge of more than 200 million litres of untreated sewage into the Red River.
Bloodvein, Dauphin River and Fisher River First Nations and their chiefs later added their names to the claim.
Those plaintiff First Nations are located downstream of Winnipeg or along Lake Winnipeg, meaning they are affected by discharges in the Manitoba capital, according to their statement of claim.
The leak was stopped weeks after it began. It was the second-largest spill in Winnipeg's history.
In a claim filed last year with Manitoba's Court of King's Bench, the First Nations accused the city, province and feds of failing to maintain the wastewater management system, "implement or enforce adequate regulatory mechanisms," warn the First Nations about the spill, or rectify any damage resulting from the discharge.
The First Nations initially sought $4.8 billion from the three levels of government: $500 million each for breaches of their Charter rights, as well as $100 million for the eight initial plaintiffs in punitive damages.
In a statement of defence filed on April 30, the city argued the discharges did not result in a significant contribution toward "nutrient loading" into Lake Winnipeg, which is the process where phosphorus and other nutrients that spawn the growth of algae enter into a body of water.
Winnipeg is just one source for nutrients that flow into the lake from a vast watershed that stretches from the Rocky Mountains to northwestern Ontario, the city argued in its statement of defence.
"As a result of this vast and complex watershed, nutrients and pollutants flowing into Lake Winnipeg come from a variety of sources both inside and outside of Manitoba, including wastewater and surface runoff from large regions of intensive agriculture," according to the statement of defence.
"The Red River and the Assiniboine River in particular cross agricultural lands and collect nutrients and pollutants in the course of their flow toward Lake Winnipeg."
The city nonetheless argued it "has invested and continues to invest significant sums on its wastewater management system, including on upgrades that have and will further reduce the discharge of nutrients and pollutants."
While these improvements have reduced the city's contribution of nutrients, further reducing the city's nutrient loading by eliminating all discharges would not result in a significant reduction in overall nutrient load into the lake, the city argued.
"Due to the predominance of other sources impacting the cumulative nutrient loading and pollutants to Lake Winnipeg, further reducing or even eliminating nutrient contribution from the city's wastewater system would not restore Lake Winnipeg to its natural condition or eliminate the impacts alleged in the claim."
The city also issued a cross-claim against the federal and provincial governments, arguing they have not provided the city with the financial means to complete sewage treatment upgrades.
The province, in turn, issued cross-claims against the city and federal government, while the federal government issued cross-claims against the city and province.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Globe and Mail
14 minutes ago
- Globe and Mail
Do Canadians trust their banks? A BMO analyst's survey tried to find out
Daily roundup of research and analysis from The Globe and Mail's market strategist Scott Barlow BMO analyst Sohrab Movahedi summarized a survey designed to understand Canadian consumers' trust in their banks. 'Survey results revealed that 27% would switch banks for lower fees, with 'Big 6' customers showing greater price sensitivity. Despite this, 22% indicated strong loyalty by stating they would never switch. Trust influences loyalty; those with high trust in financial advice and pricing are twice as likely to remain with their banks, while those lacking trust consider switching for better fees or service. … This conclusion underscores trust as a critical element of loyalty and reminds banks of the imperative to deepen relationships and enhance value amidst rising price competition and competition from digital and non-traditional banking alternatives … Our surveys over the past decade show a majority of respondents trust their banks to safeguard their money and personal data, with 54% expressing a 'high degree of trust.' However, skepticism exists regarding fair pricing and financial advice, with only 35% and 38% expressing a high degree of trust, respectively. Our 'trust' score based on the survey results indicates a decline in trust since 2022. Among the 'Big 5' (ex NA) banks, our survey results show CM has improved its trust ranking (likely a successful reflection of its advice-first strategy to offset high customer price sensitivity). BNS has experienced a continuous decline in ranking since 2019 while the rest have largely seen a stable trust score in our surveys over the years.' *** RBC Capital Markets head of global energy research Greg Pardy attaches the oil and gas sector to Canadian independence from our dysfunctional neighbors. 'The connection between Canada's sovereignty and urgency to grow its energy exports has intensified under the vision of Prime Minister Carney and Minister of Energy and Natural Resources Hodgson. An ongoing state of emergency precipitated by the Trump administration's decision to implement tactical tariffs on its northern neighbor has spurred the new federal government to shape Canada into an energy superpower. Enhanced oil export diversification—and carbon competitiveness in the oil sands to futureproof markets down the road—could be the next big steps in Canada's journey … Anchored by the fourth-largest proven oil reserves worldwide, Canada has emerged as an energy powerhouse, with output that has grown from 2.0 million bbl/d in 2000 to 5.3 million bbl/d this year … If ever there were a ripe opportunity for Canada to reform select federal policies involving energy, it is now. With the incumbent Liberal Party of Canada seeking to bolster Canadian energy security, the door appears to be wide open for bipartisan cooperation with the Conservative Party of Canada to reform energy legislation and advance infrastructure investment. Mr. Pardy's Global Energy Best Ideas List of top sector stock picks can be found here. *** In the dividend-heavy energy infrastructure sector, CIBC analyst Robert Catellier likes the stocks most exposed to U.S. natural gas, 'Following reported results, it's clear to see that exposure to U.S. infrastructure, and natural gas in particular, is driving growth and share price performance. Given the healthier growth dynamics in that market, including higher project returns and the widening permitting/regulatory gap to Canada, we expect this trend to continue. It's not a surprise that we've noticed a relative flight to safety, with flows into the larger-cap companies where investors have access to market liquidity and exposure to low-multiple build projects in the U.S. without taking much in the way of commodity price exposure. The names that best fit this theme include ENB, TRP and WMB. Subsequent to the quarter, we upgraded WMB to Outperformer from Neutral, while raising the price target to US$64 (from US$61)' *** Bluesky post of the day: Diversion: 'Scientists Uncover Hidden Link Between Cholesterol Flow and Alzheimer's Disease' - SciTechDaily
National Post
14 minutes ago
- National Post
FIRST READING: Everything (except Mark Carney's approval rating) is getting worse
Article content Canada has a Superintendent of Bankruptcies that keeps regular stats on just how many Canadians are going under each month. And according to data compiled by the site Better Dwelling, consumer insolvencies hit 11,464 in June. That's higher than any point since 2010, when the last cohort of victims from the 2008 Great Recession were finally throwing in the towel. Article content More concerning is that the most severe type of insolvency — bankruptcy — is growing at an outsized rate. This is where we should mention that Canadian household debt is one of the highest in the developed world, with total consumer debt in Canada hitting a historic high of $2.5 trillion in February, according to a report by the financial analyst firm TransUnion. Article content The share of workers collecting a government paycheque is at generational highs Article content It's been widely reported that youth unemployment is hitting highs not seen in a generation. But Canada's overall employment rate is also getting steadily worse. The share of Canadians 15 years or older who have a job is now down to just 60.9 per cent. When omitting the temporary job losses caused by COVID lockdowns, that's the lowest sustained employment rate Canada has seen since the 1990s. Article content With job losses occurring way faster in the private sector than in the public sector, the share of government jobs in the Canadian economy has now hit a high of 21.7 per cent. In other words, there is now a civil servant for every four Canadians employed in the private sector. Article content There are now more bureaucrats in the job market than at any point since the early 1990s, just before a sovereign debt crisis compelled a rapid reduction in the size of the Canadian government. Article content There's nothing inherently wrong with a trade deficit. The term merely refers to whether a country imports more than it exports, and need not have any connection with GDP or national wealth. The United States, notably, has spent decades with both a trade deficit and the world's largest economy. Article content However, given the share of the Canadian economy devoted to export industries, it's of some concern that the Canadian trade deficit is hitting lows never seen before. According to recent Statistics Canada figures, April and June both posted the largest Canadian trade deficits on record, at $7.6 billion and $5.9 billion, respectively. Article content Article content Article content The Carney government has already backed off on some of the more sweeping housing pledges it made during the 2025 election. While the Liberal campaign had promised to restore affordability with the 'most ambitious housing plan since the Second World War,' this was quickly checked by official assurances that housing prices wouldn't actually be going down. Article content And for the foreseeable future, Canadian real estate is set to remain some of the most unaffordable on earth. Article content Housing construction is poised to fall dramatically in the coming years, exacerbating the housing shortage at the core of the Canadian affordability crisis. In Ontario, for instance, housing starts have already charted a 25 per cent drop as compared to last year. Article content
CTV News
36 minutes ago
- CTV News
Labour groups pushing back as Air Canada flight attendants' strike poised to continue
Picketers march around the departures level at the Vancouver International Airport in Richmond, B.C., on Sunday, Aug. 17, 2025. Air Canada made the call to halt a return to operation as flight attendants continue to strike. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Ethan Cairns It could be another chaotic day for travellers as a labour dispute continues between Air Canada and the union representing its flight attendants. Flight attendants with the Montreal-based airline represented by the Canadian Union of Public Employees are expected to remain on the picket lines today as a battle against a federal return-to-work order continues. CUPE says it filed a challenge in Federal Court on Sunday against an order by the Canada Industrial Relations Board that said more than 10,000 flight attendants had to return to work as of 2 p.m. ET that afternoon. That order came after Jobs Minister Patty Hajdu sent both parties to binding arbitration on Saturday, saying she was intervening in the dispute because of its impact on Canadians and the economy. On Sunday, CUPE held demonstrations at major airports in Toronto, Calgary, Montreal and Vancouver, accusing Hajdu of caving to Air Canada's demands Air Canada said on Sunday that it would push back its plan to get flights back in the air until Monday evening, even though the union said employees will remain on strike until a 'fair, negotiated collective agreement' is reached. The strike officially began just before 1 a.m. ET on Saturday, and Air Canada locked out flight attendants about 30 minutes later due to the strike action. The airline reported roughly 940 flights cancelled Sunday as a result of the work stoppage, and thousands of travellers have been scrambling to salvage their travel plans. On Monday morning, Air Canada suspended its financial guidance for the third quarter and its full year due to the labour disruption. The dispute has garnered negative attention from labour groups across Canada who are criticizing the Liberal government's decision to order flight attendants back to work. A statement from the Canadian Labour Congress late Sunday evening said the 'heads of Canada's unions' met in an emergency session to stand behind Air Canada's flight attendants. The group called Hajdu's intervention an 'unconstitutional attack on workers' rights' and said Canada's labour groups were unanimously calling on the federal government to withdraw its intervention. The statement also said labour unions are ready to 'co-ordinate a fight back campaign' and promote and co-ordinate financial contributions to assist with the legal and other costs related to flight attendants' decision to defy Hajdu's order. 'The labour movement is united and standing firm, and we will not allow these Charter-protected rights to be trampled upon,' the statement read. This report by The Canadian Press was first published Aug. 18, 2025.
