Student flats developer says council is wrong about flood risk
The planning application for Purpose Built Student Accommodation (PBSA) is on the list to be considered for the third time by the committee next Wednesday with a recommendation from officers that it should be refused partly on the basis of flood risk.
The report states: 'The proposal for purpose-built student accommodation is at risk of flooding in a 1 in 200-year flooding event when climate change allowance is considered, and it is not compliant with the requirements of NPF 4 policy 22 as it cannot be considered as safe and flood-free and the development would create an island during such a flood event.'
The council officers are also accused of using the wrong data and ignoring a detailed ground survey which was carried out by developers.
Changes have been made to the plans which the developer says are 'major improvements'. And EH1 Students Gorgie, who plan to create the student flats on the site once it is cleared, say that the previous plans had less effective flood control measures.
In the case of a separate site at 495 Gorgie Road, EH1 says the flood control measures were not as good as those proposed for the Murrayfield Sports Bar site, and that the flooding in that case was described as 'dangerous'.
The developers have also pointed out technical errors to the Head of Planning in the report by officers which they take issue with. One significant demand is that Scottish Environment Protection Agency (SEPA) ask for a wall to be included as a flood wall (contrary to their own guidance). This would demand planning for a 'one in a thousand year river flow event'.
Maurice McCann Development Manager for EH1 Students Gorgie said: 'We were initially encouraged by our engagement with council officers who seemed to welcome the enhanced flood protection included in our new application, indeed we would not have made a planning application if they had responded negatively.
'After the application was submitted the attitude changed and we found we couldn't get a meeting with the council's Flood Team to address any concerns. The work we have done on this application shows very clearly that we can provide safe access and egress for what would currently be a one in a thousand-year flood event.
'We have written to the Head of Planning to point out that an appropriate and policy compliant flood solution can be found, and that the information in the council report is demonstrably wrong. We have asked that the item be withdrawn from the agenda in order that more accurate information can be considered.
'We have a proposal that was recommended for approval when the flood management issues were not policy compliant, but now we have compliant proposals the recommendation has been changed. All we're looking for is for fair treatment and common sense. These proposals can help shift students out of flatted accommodation to free up much needed housing during a 'Housing 'Emergency'.
'Our proposals deliver flood safe facilities for a what is currently a one in a thousand-year river flow. Nobody should be asked to go beyond that as it would frankly be bonkers. We all want to see 'climate resilient' developments – and our proposals are climate resilient and we're building this to last. We're confident this can last for hundreds of years, but nobody knows what might happen in a thousand years. I don't want to trivialise the debate – these are serious issues, but there's every bit as much chance of there being student housing on Mars in a thousand years' time. This is just ticking the wrong policy boxes, without regard to common sense.
'My team stands ready to engage with the council's planning team to work through the details and deliver proposals that meet the council's policy objectives and help tackle the housing emergency.'
The council report is below:
Loading…
Like this:
Like
Related
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
19 minutes ago
- Yahoo
India sees Asia's biggest earnings downgrades as US tariffs loom
By Patturaja Murugaboopathy and Jaspreet Kalra (Reuters) -Indian companies have seen the steepest earnings downgrades in Asia, with analysts slashing forecasts as steep U.S. tariffs heighten risks to growth even if proposed domestic tax cuts help cushion the impact. According to LSEG IBES data, forward 12-month earnings estimates for India's large and mid-cap firms have been cut by 1.2% in the past two weeks, the sharpest in Asia. The cuts follow a lacklustre season of quarterly earnings reports extending a bout of weakness among listed firms which kicked off last year and has hurt benchmark equity indexes. India's economy is largely domestic and firms which are part of the Nifty 50 index earn only 9% of revenue from the U.S. but the tariff hike to as high as 50% on exports to the world's largest economy presents a risk to economic growth. Analysis by MUFG indicates that a sustained 50% tariff could cut India's GDP growth by 1 percentage point over time, with the biggest hit to employment-sensitive sectors such as textiles. Looking to buoy domestic consumption, Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi recently announced sweeping tax reforms to boost the economy in the face of a trade conflict with Washington. "It's a little bit of an interesting time given what's happened with the tariffs that have been imposed on India," said Raisah Rasid, global market strategist at J.P. Morgan Asset Management. Valuations are still elevated and "we could potentially see the tariff triggering a broad valuation re-rating downwards and make some of the domestic oriented stocks attractive," she said. Earnings growth for Indian companies has been in single-digit percentages for five consecutive quarters, below the 15%–25% growth seen between 2020–21 and 2023–24. Following the April-June earnings announcements, forward 12-month net income forecasts for automobiles and components, capital goods, food and beverages, and consumer durables sectors saw the deepest cuts in earnings estimates, each down about 1% or more, the data showed. The government's plans to lower consumption taxes are also expected to boost the country's GDP growth. Economists at Standard Chartered pencil in a boost of 0.35-0.45 percentage points in the fiscal year ending in March 2027. India's real GDP growth averaged 8.8% between fiscal 2022 and 2024, the highest in Asia-Pacific. It is projected to grow at 6.8% annually over the next three years. Bank of America's latest fund manager survey shows that India has tumbled from the most-favoured to the least-preferred Asian equity market in just two months. "After disappointing earnings growth of only 6% in 2024, the pace of recovery remains sluggish in 2025, as indicated by both the economic growth parameters and corporate earnings," said Rajat Agarwal, Asia equity strategist at Societe Generale. (Reporting By Patturaja Murugaboopathy and Jaspreet Kalra; additional reporting by Gaurav Dogra; Editing by Vidya Ranganathan and Mrigank Dhaniwala) Sign in to access your portfolio
Yahoo
19 minutes ago
- Yahoo
‘Nicest Judge in the World' Frank Caprio Dies at 88
Judge Frank Caprio smiles as he concludes his morning session inside Municipal Court at the Providence Police Station in Rhode Island on Oct. 30, 2017. Credit - Jessica Rinaldi—TheLess than a week ago, Frank Caprio posted what appeared to be a self-created inspirational poster that read: 'A life built on kindness is a life that echoes long after we're gone.' Caprio, dubbed 'the nicest judge in the world,' died Wednesday at the age of 88, but it seems his message is sure to live on. The Rhode Island jurist passed away after a battle with pancreatic cancer, his family announced on social media. Caprio served as chief judge of the municipal court of Providence, Rhode Island, from 1985 to 2023. He is survived by his wife Joyce Caprio, five children, seven grandchildren, and two great-grandchildren. 'Beloved for his compassion, humility, and unwavering belief in the goodness of people, Judge Caprio touched the lives of millions through his work in the courtroom and beyond. His warmth, humor, and kindness left an indelible mark on all who knew him,' his family wrote. 'He will be remembered not only as a respected judge, but as a devoted husband, father, grandfather, great grandfather and friend. His legacy lives on in the countless acts of kindness he inspired.' 'On behalf of my entire family, I want to thank each and every one of you for your prayers, your thoughts, and your unwavering support for him throughout his journey,' Caprio's son David Caprio said in a video posted to TikTok. 'Your love lifted him in ways that words cannot describe.' Many became acquainted with Caprio through clips of the Emmy-nominated courtroom reality TV series Caught in Providence that were shared on social media over the last decade. The show, which was produced by Caprio's brother Joe Caprio, initially aired in 2000, then returned to TV screens from 2015 to 2017. The series went into national syndication in 2018 and was renewed for a second season in 2019, but ended in 2023 when Caprio retired. After his retirement he was given the ceremonial title of 'Chief Judge Emeritus' and his courtroom was renamed in his honor. Caprio was known for his compassion in the courtroom, as videos of him treating defendants with empathy and respect gained more than a billion views on social media and earned him the title of 'the nicest judge in the world.' Caprio's Instagram account and Facebook profile each amassed 3.4 million followers, while his TikTok had 1.6 million followers. Earlier this year, he published a book titled Compassion in the Court, outlining lessons he'd learned from his life and career. Caprio, the son of an Italian immigrant who worked as a fruit peddler, once told his alma mater Suffolk University's law magazine, that he believed Caught in Providence resonated with people because, 'they feel that they are talked down to and scorned. In the 100,000 or so comments I have gotten from viewers around the world, the most common words are compassion, understanding, and fairness. I think we have given them a sense of hope through the decisions I make.' He said he leaned on 'the rule of common sense' when considering leniency toward defendants and did not view verdicts that made the defendant's life worse as justice. At times, Caprio would bring the children of defendants up to the bench. In one case, he asked a six-year-old girl to help him decide on the verdict for her mother who faced a $100 fine plus additional penalties amounting to a total of $300 for parking on the sidewalk. Caprio gave the defendant's daughter four options: charge the full amount of the penalties, waive the penalties but keep the $100 fine, reduce the fine to $50, or waive the fine entirely. 'What would you do to be fair about this whole thing and how much would you charge?' Caprio asked. The girl chose the third option, but Caprio offered her another deal. 'She buys you breakfast when you leave and I'll dismiss [the case], is that a good deal?' Ultimately, she agreed. 'I don't wear a badge under my robe,' Caprio was known for saying. 'I wear a heart.' While remembered for his time as a judge, Caprio also had a political career. He served on the Providence City Council from 1962 to 1968 and ran as a Democrat for Attorney General of Rhode Island in 1970 but lost to Republican Richard J. Israel. He served as a delegate for five Democratic National Conventions. In December 2023, Caprio announced he had been diagnosed with pancreatic cancer, completing radiation treatment last year. On Aug. 19, Caprio shared in a video from a hospital bed that he had suffered a health setback. 'I ask you again, if it's not too much, that you can remember me in your prayers,' he said. Caprio died the following day. 'Judge Caprio was a Rhode Island treasure,' Rhode Island Gov. Dan McKee posted on X. 'On a personal level, he was a friend who faced his illness with bravery, and I will miss him dearly.' McKee ordered Rhode Island flags at all state agencies and buildings to be flown at half-mast in honor of Caprio. 'Judge Caprio not only served the public well, but he connected with them in a meaningful way, and people could not help but respond to his warmth and compassion,' McKee continued. 'He was more than a jurist—he was a symbol of empathy on the bench, showing us what is possible when justice is tempered with humanity.' Joe Shekarchi, Democratic speaker of the Rhode Island House of Representatives, posted on X that Caprio 'was known everywhere for his compassion and good humor on the bench and was beloved by Rhode Islanders and worldwide fans of his show.' 'Judge Caprio utilized his position for the greater good and helped countless individuals who appeared before him to turn their lives around,' Shekarchi said. 'His 88 years of service to Providence and the entire state have made Rhode Island a better place.' Caprio shared an emotional message in a video posted to TikTok in March. 'Sometimes in life we take things for granted,' he said. 'But you never know from one day to the next what life will bring. And so, enjoy what you have, be kind to people, take care of your families.' Many supporters of Caprio have taken to social media to remember their favorite courtroom moments of the judge. Contact us at letters@
Yahoo
19 minutes ago
- Yahoo
🚨 Media: Arsenal sign £70m striker in response to Havertz injury
Arsenal FC is set to strengthen its offense with a high-profile signing. According to transfer experts Fabrizio Romano and David Ornstein from 'The Athletic', Eberechi Eze will be joining the Gunners from Crystal Palace. 'The Guardian' also reports a basic agreement has been reached. According to media reports, Arteta & Co. will have to pay around 70 million Euros for their new signing. Apparently, an additional 7 to 8 million Euros in bonuses could be added to the sum. Thus, it appears that Arsenal FC has outmaneuvered its arch-rivals Tottenham. The Spurs had apparently been interested in the English national player for some time, but he decided to join the Gunners. The signing of the English player follows, among other things, the renewed absence of Kai Havertz. The German national player could be out for a long time in the coming season due to a knee injury. According to 'The Guardian', Eze will play his last match for Palace in the Conference League on Thursday before undergoing his medical check with the Gunners. This article was translated into English by Artificial Intelligence. You can read the original version in 🇩🇪 here. 📸 Justin Setterfield - 2025 Getty Images
