Unintended consequences of vape ban by states — Liu Hai Kuok
Let's be honest: people are still vaping. Banning vape sales won't make the habit disappear; it just pushes the whole thing underground.
Johor has had a ban for years. Has it stopped people from vaping? No. It only forced legal sellers to close shop while illegal ones took over. These backdoor sellers don't follow any rules. They disregard age limits, proper labelling, and safe ingredients — making it even more dangerous for our kids.
If you ban something but don't stop the demand, you create a black market. We've seen this happen before with cigarettes. Malaysia is already notorious for having one of the highest rates of illicit cigarette use in the world. Are we going to repeat the same mistake with vapes?
What's worse is that these unregulated products can be harmful. Some are mixed with cheap or toxic chemicals. If someone falls sick or worse, there's no one to hold accountable. No manufacturer. No quality control. No protection.
Unregulated vape products can be harmful. Some are mixed with cheap or toxic chemicals. If someone falls sick or worse, there's no one to hold accountable. — Picture by Raymond Manuel
Also, banning vapes sends mixed signals. Cigarettes are still openly sold, taxed, and regulated. So why crack down only on vapes — which many adults use as a way to quit smoking, such as through heated tobacco products? Shouldn't we guide smokers toward safer alternatives, not make it harder for them?
Enforcement will also be a nightmare. If one state bans vapes and another doesn't, people will simply drive across borders or buy them online. How will state officials manage this? And won't it confuse both consumers and traders?
Let's not forget tax revenue. Vape liquids are now taxed by the federal government, and that money could fund health campaigns, education, or better enforcement. By shutting down the legal market, we lose that income — and people will still vape.
There's already a federal law in place: the Control of Smoking Products for Public Health Act. If there are concerns, improve that law. Don't bypass it with patchwork actions at the state level.
We need one clear, consistent policy — one that protects young people, guides adult smokers, and tackles illegal trade head-on. Blanket bans won't achieve that. Regulation and strong enforcement will.
Again, I support public health. But let's be smart about how we get there. Don't push vape users underground. The country will lose out.
• This is the personal opinion of the writer or publication and does not necessarily represent the views of Malay Mail.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Malay Mail
2 hours ago
- Malay Mail
Are students unaware or just coping well? MOHE says counselling numbers low as nationwide mental health study nears completion
KUALA NERUS, Aug 20 — The Ministry of Higher Education (MOHE) recorded a total of 402 public university students having been referred to counsellors at their respective institutions throughout last year. Prof Dr Zainal Amin Ayub, the Deputy Director General of Higher Education (Governance and Development), said the figure represented 0.067 per cent of the total number of public university students nationwide. 'Although the number is quite small, it can be seen from two different perspectives - either there is a lack of awareness among students regarding this service (counselling) or that the students' mental health is generally at a good level,' he told reporters after officiating the 3rd Malaysian Universities National Health Convention (MUNCH) 2025 here today. Zainal Amin also said that a comprehensive study relating to the mental health of public university students nationwide is being carried out by the ministry. He added that the nine-month study, conducted by researchers from various universities, including Universiti Malaysia Terengganu (UMT), Universiti Sultan Zainal Abidin (UniSZA) and Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, is expected to be completed next month. He said the findings of the study will be presented to the ministry to identify the next steps to be taken. Meanwhile, Zainal Amin said the two-day MUNCH 2025, which began today, is attended by over 140 participants comprising staff from public university health centres nationwide. He added that this edition of the biennial convention, organised by the Public Universities Health Council of Malaysia, is jointly hosted by the UniSZA Student Health Centre and UMT Health Centre. 'MUNCH 2025, themed 'Empowering Healthy Community: The Future of Health Promotion', focuses on efforts to strengthen the capacity of health professionals, provide a space to present research results, raise awareness of disease prevention and create a collaboration platform between universities, researchers and the health industry. 'This convention is seen as positive effort by the public universities to boost health knowledge and awareness, thus contributing to community well-being - starting with the university population itself. The joint organisation by UMT and UniSZA also proves the ability of public universities to work together in promoting a healthy lifestyle,' he said. Also present were UMT vice-chancellor Prof Dr Mohd Zamri Ibrahim and UniSZA vice-chancellor Prof Datuk Dr Fadzli Adam. — Bernama
Free Malaysia Today
2 hours ago
- Free Malaysia Today
Taiping prison doctor accused of neglect over inmate's delayed treatment
More than 100 inmates at the Taiping prison were allegedly assaulted by about 60 prison wardens during a relocation exercise. (Facebook pic) KUALA LUMPUR : Taiping prison's in-house doctor, Dr Navin Esavik Vikrama, came under fire for leaving to meet the prison director in the cafeteria for 30 minutes while inmate Gan Chin Eng, who later died, was left waiting at the prison gate for an ambulance to take him to the Taiping Hospital. Although Navin initially claimed that Gan was sent to the hospital within 15 minutes and denied meeting the prison director, CCTV footage and witness statements presented during the Human Rights Commission of Malaysia (Suhakam) public inquiry showed otherwise. 'You lost track of time because you were too busy meeting the prison's director. Do you not agree that this was negligent?' asked Suhakam commissioner Farah Nini Dusuki. Navin did not answer her question. Suhakam chairman Hishamudin Yunus, who co-chaired the panel alongside Farah, suggested that Gan's condition might have deteriorated rapidly while being transported to the hospital, as the doctor failed to monitor his need for CPR. Navin said when he took Gan's vitals, the inmate appeared stable and he was able to breathe and talk despite fluctuating blood oxygen levels. He also said that he simply did not have enough time to get proper apparatus from the prison's clinic in order to help Gan. 'We tried to send him to the hospital very quickly. It was impossible for us to go back to the clinic and get any equipment to help him. If we had done so, it likely would've delayed proper treatment more,' he said. Limited medical equipment Gan was ultimately sent to Taiping Hospital via a prison van, as Navin claimed that the ambulance took longer to arrive. To Farah's question as to why the van was not equipped for medical emergencies, Navin replied that only limited equipment was available to handle abdominal injury cases. Gan was injured during a prisoner relocation exercise from the prison's Hall B to Block E, in which more than 100 inmates were allegedly assaulted by about 60 prison wardens. Earlier reports from Taiping Hospital revealed that Gan was pronounced dead on arrival, having been 'brought unconscious with no signs of life', with his cause of death being described as abdominal injury due to blunt trauma. False documentation? In Navin's referral letter to doctors at the Taiping Hospital, he stated that Gan had sustained injuries to the left side of his chest after a fall in the toilet – information Navin allegedly obtained from other inmates. However, two inmates known only as Alex and Adam, who helped support Gan to the main gate, stated in their witness statements that they never told the doctor any such thing. The letter also provided contradictory information, with the main body of the document stating that Gan sustained injury to the left of his torso, whilst a later portion declared that he had 'weakness and tenderness on his right'. Navin claimed it was an honest mistake, as 'things were moving too quickly'. 'This is highly important information Dr Navin. You should not be making typos or mistakes in these particular situations,' Farah said in response. Previously, Navin had admitted that the medical cards for other inmates who had sustained injuries during the Jan 17 incident might have been tampered with, though he insisted he did not do it. Hishamudin, examining one inmate's medical card, noted that the date 'Jan 17' appeared superimposed over a faint 'Jan 22'. He said it suggested that the inmates' treatment might have been delayed beyond what the records showed. The inquiry resumes tomorrow.
Malay Mail
10 hours ago
- Malay Mail
Cancer Diaries: Radiotherapy finally, and playing Pokémon esports to stay sane
AUGUST 20 — KL General Hospital (HKL) finally called me up to tell me when I start radiotherapy (this week) and apparently I will only be doing 15 days of it. I'm not looking forward to having to juggle immunotherapy and radiation next week, enduring both on the same day. Still, as I've been in a lot of pain, on various occasions, for various reasons — acid reflux/respiratory infection/knee injury/cancer/cancer treatments — it's just one more grueling ordeal to survive and write about. I count myself lucky that every experience on this medical journey, pleasant or not, I can document as part of my job. Last week someone having questions about getting cancer treatment for their mother at HKL messaged me and I was happy to answer. There just isn't enough information available out there for people to navigate about what to do with a cancer diagnosis but far too many quack cures and dodgy supplements. I wish it was as easy to find out what you need to do or where to go should you get cancer as it is to buy those damn soursop leaves people keep pushing at me. Over the weekend I was also looking over at what I'd been spending, wondering where the heck all the money went and then, looking at a pile of items I'd bought to prepare for reminded me, again, cancer is expensive. There just isn't enough information available out there for people to navigate about what to do with a cancer diagnosis. — Unsplash pic What exactly did I buy? I have sunscreen, a thrifted hoodie with UV protection, a hat with a face covering, and a small mountain of creams and lotions to endure my boob being irradiated for 15 days. As I'll be more sun sensitive after the treatment and my skin cancer risk is already heightened just by being a cancer patient, I have to take extra measures and pray I don't collapse from heat stroke first. There's a likelihood my irradiated breast will shrink and look sadly lopsided next to my healthy one, but I am at peace with it, as I'd always found my breasts to be appendages that were more trouble than they were worth. If my boob shrinks I'll just have to look for a good bra pad but as I rarely go out, it won't be that big a deal. Like when I was younger and pretty, I accept that I will never be as young, or as pretty, and the same applies to my bust. Realistically though, all of this is hard on the mind. On Facebook and Reddit I keep reading posts from panicked or near-hysterical cancer patients and honestly, who can blame them? Cancer is terrifying. It's a complex disease with treatments that are so varied that it can get very overwhelming, very fast. To keep my mind together I try to keep it happy with videogames. Post-surgery I was playing a lot of Unicorn Overlord but now I'm venturing into esports, which is handy because hey it's technically a sport that qualifies for tax rebates. It is also more of a mental game than a physical one. As someone who is technically disabled due to my chronic illness, being able to play a sport that doesn't leave me exhausted and in a lot of pain is pretty enticing. The Pokémon World Championships in California just ended and I was sad to hear that while 12 Malaysians qualified, not all could attend due to either finances or visa issues. What's exciting is that the new competitive game for next year is Pokémon Champions which will be a free download for both Switch and mobile, lowering the barrier to entry for new players. No release date for the game has been announced so at least it gives me time to 'study' Pokémon strategy. I will likely never be good enough to represent the country but it will be a nice pastime and something to distract my mind from the body horror of cancer. Until next week when you all get to find out how my radiotherapy went and since my life is a sitcom, there will probably be a funny story or two to tell. *This is the personal opinion of the columnist.
