Warning after real estate agents caught altering property sale agreements
But if it was not, he said, buyers could be put in an impossible position.
'There's not often defects on the title but it does happen, and it happened to me recently where there was a cross-leased title involving four different properties and there was an error on the title.
'To get that fixed is very difficult and very costly and can take quite some time because you need to involve surveyors, banks.'
The purchaser's lawyer would have to alert the bank to the problem.
'If there is a defect on the title, the bank will then say 'we are not going to advance the mortgage funds until you've fixed it'. In the meantime the settlement date is coming up and the purchaser has to settle because they are in an unconditional situation, but they cannot raise the money from the bank. Therefore it is catch-22.'
Herring said a standard sale and purchase agreement said the person holding the deposit, whether that was a salesperson or a lawyer, needed to hold it for 10 working days, which aligned with the title requisition period. Once that was over and the buyer's conditions were satisfied, it could be released.
'If the deposit is released earlier than that and the vendor spends the deposit – maybe they use it for paying down debt, to put a deposit on a house they are buying or they might go overseas, if the requisition period is activated and the purchaser has to cancel the contract – if that deposit is gone, it makes it much more difficult to get back.'
Herring said if someone was using KiwiSaver to pay a deposit, their lawyer had to give a legal undertaking to the provider that if anything went wrong and settlement did not go ahead, the money would be returned. But if something happened and the money had disappeared, that would be much harder.
'It heightens the risk for KiwiSaver first-home buyers.'
He said people who discovered a change had been made to an agreement they had signed should seek legal advice.
Real Estate Authority (REA) chief executive Belinda Moffat said her organisation had provided general advice to the sector on the issue.
'Section 123 of the act requires agents to hold money received in respect of a transaction for 10 working days – unless both parties agree to an earlier release. Ultimately, this 10-day rule exists to protect consumers. If a vendor fails to settle, or an issue arises before settlement, if the deposit has already been released it could leave the purchaser with no security that their deposit can be recovered.
'An early release of a deposit is only permitted by court order, or if each party to the transactions signs an authority agreeing to the early release. REA is concerned that some licensees and parties have sought to include an early release clause as an additional clause in the Sale and Purchase Agreement.
'REA does not consider that an early release clause in the Sale and Purchase Agreement meets the purposes of the act. Such clauses may undermine the consumer protection intent of section 123. Licensees should instead ensure parties give informed authority to early release.'
Moffat said she was not able to comment on the current status of any complaints.
'We note further that whether there is a finding of breach of the conduct rules will depend on the facts of each case.'
-RNZ
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
23 minutes ago
- Otago Daily Times
600 rental homes planned in Queenstown development
Six hundred build-to-rent units are on the way for Queenstown in a $500 million Simplicity Living development. The company owned by KiwiSaver and investment funds is managed by Simplicity NZ Ltd. It has already built 210 homes across Auckland, with another 889 under construction. It has just acquired a 6.1ha site on Ladies Mile, north of the Stalker Rd roundabout, for its first development outside the City of Sails, with an aspiration to build 2000 homes in the resort. Simplicity NZ managing director Sam Stubbs said they were working closely with the Queenstown Lakes District Council on the infrastructure required to enable construction to start. Once that was in place, and they had the necessary consents, "we're ready to go". Based on the Auckland developments, the first tenants could be living there within 13 months of the start. "We've always had our eye down here, because we thought that the economics of Queenstown makes sense because it's growing, the rents are good, and there's this massive need for housing people who live here," he said. The Queenstown development will likely comprise three-storey walk-up apartments, in one-, two- and three-bed configurations, noting there was a huge gap in the market for one- and two-bedders. Two live-in managers will also be employed. The units will primarily be built using concrete, brick and local schist, with an expected lifespan of over 150 years. "The idea for us on this one ... is to do a lot of green space, a lot of carparks, a lot of outdoor storage, because it's got to be Queenstown-specific," Mr Stubbs said. While initially the homes will be for long-term rent, they may consider selling some to retirees or first-home buyers. He also believed they would be able to build them "slightly cheaper" than in Auckland and while he could not put a figure on the rental cost, he noted Simplicity Living's rents were usually 5%-10% below market value. Regardless, Queenstown rents would justify the development cost. Queenstown Lakes Community Housing Trust chief executive Julie Scott said the proposed development "interconnects" with the work the trust was doing. The trust had 1480 eligible households on its waiting list, "and we know that we can't ... house them all tomorrow, or even in the next few years". Before work can start, though, infrastructure to the site needs to be sorted. Mr Stubbs said Simplicity wanted to help with that, too, but noted the council was getting all of the Ladies Mile landowners together to have a look at what was required — "we've never had that happen before". Queenstown Mayor Glyn Lewers said the "$60 million question" was who would pay for it. "We're quite happy for [the developer] to put the infrastructure in, and then we'll offset the development contributions at the other end when it comes to creating title. "Our debt limits and our capacity to do that front-loading of infrastructure, especially within growth nodes in this district, has become quite tight. "We'll put in where we can, and where we need to, but the way we're structured financially at the moment, we're looking for partnerships to actually provide this great social benefit." However, council was committed to working it out because the outcome was "so beneficial" to the area. Mr Lewers said he had been having "quite intense" conversations with NZ Transport Agency Waka Kotahi about potential solutions for traffic implications. "The regional deal construct certainly helps that conversation."
Scoop
6 hours ago
- Scoop
Huge Increase In Weapons In Your KiwiSaver
Over $900 million of the savings of New Zealand investors is invested in weapons companies, including those supplying the conflict in Gaza: New research shows KiwiSaver Investment in weapons companies has surged by 40.9% to $392.4 million Managed fund investments also grew to reach $509.2 million by March 2025 There is increasing New Zealand investment in companies supplying the Gaza conflict: $71.9 million of KiwiSaver and retail funds invested in weapons companies $179.9 million invested in two other non-weapons companies Annual survey data shows that 80% of Kiwis want to avoid investing in weapons Comprehensive new analysis by charity Mindful Money reveals New Zealand KiwiSaver funds have dramatically increased their investment in weapons companies, with total weapons investments reaching $392.4 million – a staggering 40.9% increase from the previous year. The research exposes how KiwiSaver providers are seeking short term profits from war. A contributor to the increase was a surge in sales of military weapons used in the bombardment of Gaza. New Zealand investment in the production of weapons used in Gaza, through KiwiSaver and retail investment funds, totalled $71.9 million a rise of 18.9% over the year to end March 2025. The latest annual survey revealed that 80% of New Zealand investors want to avoid investing in weapons. But the surge in weapons investment by KiwiSaver and investment funds shows the growing misalignment with the values of KiwiSaver investors during some of the world's deadliest conflicts since World War II. Barry Coates, Mindful Money Founder and CEO commented: 'There has been a huge rise in weapons investment by New Zealanders. The chase for higher returns means that Kiwis' hard-earned savings are being used to invest in companies whose weapons have resulted in the devastation of Gaza.' Gaza Conflict Connections Raise Ethical Concerns Few New Zealanders realise there is a direct connection between their savings and companies supplying weapons to the Gaza conflict. In addition to New Zealand's retail investment in weapons companies, there has been a major increase in New Zealand investment in non-weapons companies supporting operations in Gaza, such as Caterpillar and Amphenol. Investment in those two companies alone totalled $189 million, up 39% over the year to end March 2025. Few KiwiSaver fund providers tell their customers that their hard-earned savings are being invested in companies complicit in a brutal conflict that has led to mass killing and starvation of Gaza's people. So far the conflict has resulted in the deaths of 2,000 Israelis and 63,000 Palestinians according to official figures, although this does not include many others missing under rubble or those who have died from starvation. Barry Coates said: 'We can all see evidence of Palestinians being killed trying to get food for their starving children. The companies supporting the weapons, ammunition, bulldozers and technology need to be held to account for their actions. They should not be benefiting from our investment.' Global Weapons Industry Boom Drives Investment Returns The surge in New Zealand weapons investments reflects a broader global boom in the defence industry driven by multiple major conflicts. The S&P Aerospace & Defence Industry has seen extraordinary growth with a 16.5% increase in the past year alone and a staggering 307% growth over the past decade. This growth has been accelerated by Russia's invasion of Ukraine on February 24, 2022, as well as internal conflicts within countries and regional tensions worldwide. Weapons companies have recorded higher short term profits, leading to huge investment increases from KiwiSaver and investment providers chasing higher returns. The Values Gap: 80% Opposition vs Growing Investment The findings reveal a stark disconnect between New Zealanders' stated values and where their retirement savings are actually invested. Research shows that 80% of New Zealanders want to avoid investing in weapons companies through their KiwiSaver or investment funds. Yet investments in this sector continue to surge. This gap highlights a fundamental challenge in the KiwiSaver system. Many New Zealanders may be unknowingly funding companies involved in conflicts, through their retirement savings, even though they personally oppose that use of their funds. Few if any KiwiSaver providers have asked their customers if they agree to more of their savings being used for investments linked to civilian deaths and human rights violations on a massive scale. Barry Coates explained: 'When Kiwis go online to see Mindful Money's free disclosure of their investments, many are shocked to find they are invested in issues such as weapons. A typical reaction is 'I didn't sign up for this.' They can and should challenge their fund providers. Or, if they are not satisfied, they can use the Mindful Money website to find a fund that does not invest in weapons.' Managed Funds Show Similar Patterns The weapons investment surge isn't limited to KiwiSaver funds. The analysis reveals that managed fund investments in weapons grew to $509.2 million by March 2025. Firearms companies increased by 64%, while military weapons investments in managed funds grew by 24% over the previous year. This shows the trend toward increasing weapons investments spans across New Zealand's broader investment landscape. Barry Coates pointed out: 'Many Kiwis recognise that weapons are necessary for defence, but they don't want their savings supporting weapons companies that indiscriminately sell their weapons to whoever will pay. All too often weapons from major NATO suppliers end up being used in conflicts where human rights are violated.' Walmart Leads Firearms Investment Surge KiwiSaver investment in companies producing and selling firearms has more than doubled, with a 110% increase. This is despite heightened awareness amongst the New Zealand public about the dangers of weapons proliferation in the wake of the Christchurch Mosque shootings. The most dramatic individual company increase involves Walmart, where New Zealand KiwiSaver investment reached $115.8 million – representing a massive 144% increase over the year and 40% growth in just six months. While primarily a general merchandise retailer, Walmart sells shotguns, rifles, ammunition, and firearm components like scopes at stores across the United States. Walmart has made progress in the wake of widespread concern over mass shootings in the US. They have raised the minimum age for firearm purchases to 21, stopped selling handguns and certain rifles like the AR-15, and no longer offer ammunition for military-style weapons. However, they continue to sell other weapons alongside food, clothing and hardware items. Alternative Options Available Despite the concerning trends, the research identifies hope for values-based investors. Mindful Money has identified 36 weapons-free funds from 13 different KiwiSaver providers, offering alternatives for New Zealanders who want their retirement savings aligned with their ethical values. Barry Coates concluded: 'New Zealanders have options. When they use Mindful Money to see weapons in their KiwiSaver, they can also find a weapons-free option. Analysis shows that returns from ethical funds have been comparable or higher than conventional funds.' Take Action New Zealanders concerned about weapons investments can check their specific KiwiSaver fund using Mindful Money's free Fund Checker tool available at The tool provides detailed analysis of individual fund holdings, and the Fund Finder suggests alternatives for those seeking investments aligned with their values. New Zealanders should also raise their concerns with our government. New Zealand governments, including National, have been leaders internationally in calling for respect for human rights for Palestinians in the past and a two state approach. Our government needs to join the countries calling for stronger measures to stop the killings and start the process towards a long term just solution. Notes About Mindful Money Mindful Money is a New Zealand charity with a mission to make money a force for good. The organisation provides independent research, analysis, and tools to help New Zealanders align their investments with their values. Mindful Money's free and easy-to-use database provides transparency about where funds are invested, supported by public education and engagement with the finance sector. KiwiSaver and Managed funds data: Mindful Money sources portfolio data from the Companies Office Disclose Register, and then undertakes detailed research of indirect investment in external funds, to reveal a full 'look-through' picture of fund holdings. The holdings are matched with Mindful Money's global database of companies of concern – the high priority issues that annual surveysshow New Zealanders want to avoid in their investments. The analysis covers 407 KiwiSaver funds and 562 Managed investment funds. The draft results are shared with fund managers for their review prior to publication. Total KiwiSaver Weapons Investment Breakdown: Total weapons investments: $392.4 million (up 40.9% year-on-year, up 22.1% in just six months) Military weapons: $199.7 million (up 35% over past year, 18.9% increase in managed funds) Firearms companies: $156.1 million (more than doubled in past year with 110% increase) Controversial weapons: $21.1 million (up 2.9%) Nuclear weapons: $11.7 million (down 12.6%) List of Weapons companies supporting the conflict in Gaza and level of New Zealand investment Companies supplying weapons or components used by the Israeli military in Gaza NZ investment ($ million) at 31 March 2025 BAE Systems: mobile artillery system. There is evidence this system has been used to fire shells containing white phosphorus into Gaza. 2.7 Boeing: the largest supplier of weapons to Israel, particularly of missile guidance systems, as well as bombs and aircraft. 13.8 Elbit Systems: supplies weapons and surveillance systems, including drones. 1.9 General Dynamics: makes artillery ammunition, large bombs and warheads which may contain depleted uranium. 3.7 Honeywell: makes components for missiles and drones. 7.9 L3Harris Technologies: manufactures components that are integrated into multiple weapons systems. Also makes weapons with depleted uranium (no evidence these have been supplied to Israel). 2.5 Leonardo: makes guns for navy ships. In October 2023, these guns were used to fire into Gaza. 0.4 Lockheed Martin: the world's largest defence contractor. Makes the F-35 fighter jet and missiles which have been used in Gaza. 5.0 Northrup Gruman: provides missile delivery systems for helicopters and laser weapon delivery systems for fighter jets. 4.3 Oshkosh: makes trucks used by the Israel Defence Force. 0.9 Rheinmetall: supplies tank shells to Israel 9.6 Rolls-Royce Holdings plc: its German subsidiary, MTU, makes specialist engines for Israeli battle tanks. 8.0 RTX Corp: (formerly called Raytheon), makes missiles, sensors and communications kits. 9.3 Textron: supplies a range of aircraft to Israel 0.9 Woodward: makes components used in positioning systems. 1.1 TOTAL $71.9 million Caterpillar: Armoured D9 bulldozers produced by Caterpillar have been crucial for Israel's ground invasion of the Gaza Strip, accompanying combat troops and paving their way by clearing roads and demolishing buildings. 81.3 Amphenol: Amphenol's products are crucial components in US military and aerospace systems. Their Israeli subsidiary, Amphenol Bar-Tec, is a dominant supplier in the Israeli military connector market. 98.6 Other companies involved in the Gaza conflict $179.9 million Primary source for companies supplying the conflict in Gaza: American Friends Service Committee, a Quaker organisation, and the UK-based Action on Armed Violence (AOVC). The above listing shows companies supplying Israel's military. Hamas reportedly gets most of its weapons from Iran, transported through Egypt and smuggled into Gaza through tunnels. There appears to be no direct financing from New Zealand investors towards weapons used by Hamas.
Scoop
8 hours ago
- Scoop
Simplicity Living Buys Queenstown Land For Up To 600 Build-To-Rent Homes
Press Release – Simplicity Living We have been keen to build in Queenstown for a couple of years, and have now found the right site. Its a cracker, said Shane Brealey, Managing Director of Simplicity Living. Simplicity Living has announced the acquisition of a 6.1-hectare site on Ladies Mile in Queenstown, where it plans to build up to 600 high-quality homes for long-term rent. 'We have been keen to build in Queenstown for a couple of years, and have now found the right site. It's a cracker,' said Shane Brealey, Managing Director of Simplicity Living. 'As one of the most unaffordable and constrained housing locations in New Zealand, we prioritized bringing our high-quality, secure tenure Build-to-Rent housing solution to the region,' he said. Located near Remarkables Park, the site is close to planned schools, shops, and transport links. The homes will be built primarily using concrete, brick, and local schist, with an expected lifespan of over 150 years. The homes will have high thermal and acoustic ratings, solar panels, rainwater harvesting and common use facilities including work-from-home spaces, residents' lounges and outdoor equipment storage. Extensive landscaping will give the property a residential park atmosphere. There will also be extensive car and bike parking, with direct access to local bike trails and the planned gondola development. The historic Shotover Bridge is a 10-minute walk away, and Queenstown International Airport is just a five-minute drive away. This is the first Simplicity Living development outside Auckland, and will be its largest to date, with an estimated end value of up to $500 million. 'This is another example of the sort of thing our KiwiSaver scheme can help make possible. We think it's a good long-term investment for our members and helps provide warm, dry homes for Kiwi families, in a region that urgently needs them,' said Sam Stubbs, Managing Director of KiwiSaver default provider Simplicity. Glyn Lewers, the Mayor of Queenstown welcomed the announcement. 'We're thrilled that Simplicity Living is bringing this much-needed rental product to the Whakatipu housing market. The addition of up to 600 new Build-to-Rent homes will be a game changer for our community, offering secure long-term rentals'. 'It's a tangible step forward in delivering Action 5D of the Joint Housing Action Plan – working with developers to facilitate and deliver diverse housing options, including Build-to-Rent developments,' he said. Simplicity Living currently has 889 homes under construction across Auckland, including in Remuera, Mt Wellington and Morningside, and announced last week that it will start building another 93 homes in Northcote by the end of the year. Its long-term plan is to build up to 10,000 homes across New Zealand for secure, long-term renting. Simplicity Living is owned by KiwiSaver and Investment Funds managed by Simplicity NZ Ltd.
