Living donor transplants thrive as Kerala turns its face away from deceased donor organ donations
While the poor die, unable to secure viable organs, those with the means get access to organs (kidney and liver) relatively easily.
In the last five years, the number of unrelated organ transplants has been growing disproportionately in some organ transplant centres in the State and neither the State government nor the Kerala State Organ and Tissue Transplant Organisation (K-SOTTO) seems to have any idea how to arrest this trend.
It is a strange situation wherein the State has no evidence of forced organ donations or human trafficking with an eye on organ donations. The unrelated organ donations that are thriving in Kerala are not happening undercover. All unrelated organ donations happening in private hospitals in the State are subject to stringent laws and procedural norms. They are all tagged as 'altruistic' because open advertisements seeking organs are banned by the State.
It is possible that not all of these live donations are truly 'altruistic' and that there are middlemen and agents involved who take the lead in bringing together donor and recipient.
'People are desperate to secure organs to save the lives of their loved ones. Do we crack the whip and stop all unrelated transplants and let all these people die? This is the backlash of laying to rest a robust deceased organ donation programme that the State had initiated,' says Noble Gracious, the Executive Director of K-SOTTO
Senior doctors point out that even those cases of 'altruistic' donations that may be denied by the district authorisation committees on suspicion that money might be exchanging hands are all being cleared by courts. Courts take the stand that 'unnecessary suspicions' should not stand in the way of someone's chance at life, they say.
Apathy towards deceased donation
Health officials maintain that it is not the public's reluctance towards organ donation, rather, it is the apathy of government doctors towards initiating brain death certification processes and other related procedures that is preventing a revival of Mrithasanjeevani, the government-run deceased donor organ donation programme.
'Mrithasanjeevani never fully recovered from the trust deficit it hit, thanks to the unnecessary litigations raised against the brain death certification process and movies like Joseph, which suggested that an organ racket was behind all deceased donations. Even the executive order issued by the State, de-linking brain death certification from organ donation and making brain death certification a standard procedure in all ICUs did not help because doctors were too fed up and wary of being dragged into litigation. We are now trying to persuade our doctors to be more proactive about deceased donation because people are dying every day just waiting for organs,' Dr. Gracious says.
In fact, even doctors and hospitals now seem to encourage families to go for live organ donors rather than wait endlessly for an organ to come through via Mrithasanjeevani. Of all the organ donations that had taken place in the State in the last five years, less than 10% constituted deceased donor organ donations.
From an average of about 900-1,200 unrelated transplants that used to happen every year in Kerala, the numbers have been climbing steadily. This is also because unlike earlier, more people are opting to go for an organ transplant rather than drag the treatment. It is also much easier now to raise money for a transplant through crowdfunding.
'Deceased donations can take off only if we resolve all systemic issues and take government doctors into confidence. There are infrastructure, logistics, human resource issues in government hospitals and Medical Colleges which make deceased donation a cumbersome activity. The government has to stand solidly behind the doctors and help smoothen out the issues they face so that deceased donations can take off again,' a senior nephrologist at one of the government medical colleges says.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
a day ago
- Time of India
Organ donation yet to pick up in state
Ranchi: At a time when organ donation is recording an upward trend across the country, it is dragging foot in Jharkhand despite relentless campaigns that are being carried out by the stakeholders. Recent statistics from State Organ and Tissue Transplant Organisation (SOTTO) cell at Rajendra Institute of Medical Sciences (Rims), the state's largest govt run medical college hospital, only eight kidney transplant surgeries were conducted in Ranchi and Jamshedpur in 2024. In all these cases, all the donors were living. The situation is quite similar this year. Till August, only six living-donor kidney transplants were conducted in the state. While five out of six donors were women, and all the six recipients were men. While kidney transplants are being carried out by private hospitals in Ranchi and Jamshedpur, patients, requiring heart, liver, lungs, pancreas, and other organ transplants, are travelling to higher medical centres outside the state. SOTTO, which functions under the regulations of the Transplantation of Human Organs and Tissues Act, monitors and coordinates organ donation and transplantation activities across Jharkhand. It prepares patient waiting lists, and promotes deceased organ donation through public awareness drives, social media campaigns, and community outreach. Principal chief secretary, Ajoy Kumar Singh, said, "Some hospitals have applied for organ donation facilities, and through the visits some gaps has been identified. The core issue is the absence of a proper mechanism to carry it forward. Without a structured system, the potential of saving lives through organ donation remains untapped. We are planning a mechanism to be established and implemented." Organ donation, the act of giving an organ to someone with end-stage organ failure, is of two types: Living donor (near relatives donating a kidney or part of the liver/pancreas) and deceased donor (all organs and tissues donated after brain death). Health experts hospitals in Jharkhand are only performing living-donor kidney transplants at present. Under the Transplantation of Human Organs Act (THOA) of 1994, brain stem death, the irreversible cessation of all brain functions, legally permits the retrieval of vital organs such as the heart, lungs, liver, kidneys, and pancreas for transplantation. SOTTO Jharkhand continues to run public awareness campaigns urging citizens to pledge their organs online at the National Organ and Tissue Transplant Organisation (NOTTO) registry. The pledge process involves Aadhaar verification, filling out an online form, and downloading a pledger's card. Dr Rajiv Ranjan, Nodal Officer at SOTTO, said, "Just one organ donor can save eight lives. With better infrastructure, trained retrieval teams, and stronger public trust, the state can move from being a laggard in organ donation. " Purnima Gupta, who donated a kidney to her younger brother Abhishek Gupta at Bhagwan Mahavir Manipal Hospital recently, said, "Seeing my brother alive and well is proof that saving a life is worth every sacrifice." Abhishek, 39, thanked his sister for her courage and giving her a fresh lease of life. Dr Pankaj Kumar Mishra, senior consultant (nephrology) at Ranchi's Bhagwan Mahavir Manipal Hospital, said, "In the last two years, the hospital has performed three kidney transplants. Transplantation offers better survival and quality of life than dialysis, and modern care ensures donors live healthy lives." Mishra urged the society on a whole to overcome fear and stigma to the needy another shot at life. Eye Donation: A Silver Lining Eye donation has been a relative success in Jharkhand over the years. Four hospitals in the state, namely Rims and Kashyap Memorial Eye Hospital in Ranchi and Jamshedpur Eye Hospital, and ASG Eye Hospital in Jamshedpur. Kashyap Memorial Eye Bank, the first eye bank in the then unified Bihar and Jharkhand, has received over 10,000 eye donation pledges and conducted more than 1,013 free cornea transplants so far. Its management said the hospital has conducted 500 cornea transplants since 2020, making it the highest-performing eye bank in Jharkhand. Dr Bharti Kashyap, medical director of the hospital, said, "When we launched the first eye donation awareness campaign in 1991, there was deep hesitation about donating eyes. Today, pledges pour in from all walks of life, including political leaders and ordinary citizens." The eye bank has introduced advanced corneal surgeries such as Descemet's Stripping Endothelial Keratoplasty (DSEK) and Descemet Membrane Endothelial Keratoplasty (DMEK), bringing modern eye care to corneal blind patients in the state. Aged just 2 years and 5 months, Jia Jahnvi is the youngest known eye donor in Ranchi. When she died of a sudden illness a few years ago, her eyes were donated to two elderly people. Her father, Satguru Sharan, moved by a profound emotional impulse, chose to ensure his daughter could see the world even after her passing. Satguru Sharan, father of Jia Jahnvi, said, "The moment I was about to bury her, I felt Jia telling me, 'Papa, I want to see the world,' and I knew what I had to do. " Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays , public holidays , and current gold rates and silver prices in your area. Get the latest lifestyle updates on Times of India, along with Happy Krishna Janmashtami Wishes ,, messages , and quotes !
Time of India
a day ago
- Time of India
‘Organ donation needs greater push in state'
Nodal officer of the State Organ and Tissue Transplant Organisation (SOTTO), Dr Rajiv Ranjan talks to TOI's Kritika Tiwari about the current situation of organ donation in the state, challenges and way ahead. Excerpts:- Q: What is the status of organ donation registrations and transplants in Jharkhand? A: Organ donation registrations in the state are comparatively low against the national average. Since September 2023, the state recorded 2,212 pledges, with cornea donation emerging as the most common type of tissue donation. While solid organ donation from deceased donors is yet to commence, a limited number of successful kidney transplants were performed in approved centres handling living donor procedures. Q: How aware are people about organ donation? A: Public awareness is gradually improving, but hesitation persists in pledging organs after death. SOTTO is conducting awareness programmes in schools, colleges, hospitals, and offices. Despite these, both the general public and some medical professionals remain unfamiliar with the legal framework, the brain death certification process, and the benefits of organ donation. Greater collaboration among stakeholders is needed to encourage deceased organ donations to address the rising demand caused by lifestyle and non-communicable diseases. Q: What are the other challenges? A: Major barriers include deep-rooted myths and misconceptions, cultural and religious hesitations, absence of brain death certifications in hospitals, shortage of trained transplant professionals, and inadequate infrastructure for organ retrieval and preservation. Q: What is the govt doing about it? A: SOTTO conducts year-round outreach drives, including rallies, Organ Donation Day observances, and sensitisation programmes as well as campaigns through social media platforms. Q: Is there a dedicated organ donation coordination system in the state? A: SOTTO, established in 2021 at Rims Ranchi, is responsible for coordinating and monitoring organ and tissue donations and transplants. However, compared to leading states, Jharkhand's programme still requires stronger collaboration between healthcare providers, govt bodies, social workers, media, and the public. Q: Where does Jharkhand stand compared to other states? A: The state is lagging behind, with only living kidney donations taking place so far. In ROTTO East (covering West Bengal, Odisha, Bihar, and Jharkhand), 15 deceased donations were reported in 2024 and 12 so far in 2025, most from Odisha and Kolkata. Jharkhand is yet to register its first deceased donation. Q: Are there any dedicated transplant centres? A: Yes, but only for kidney transplants from living donors. Three private hospitals, Medanta, Medica (Manipal), and Tata Main Hospital (TMH) Jamshedpur, are authorised for these procedures. For cornea transplants, four hospitals are registered, including Rims, Kashyap Eye Hospital Ranchi, Jamshedpur Eye Hospital, and ASG Eye Hospital Ranchi. Q: How can citizens pledge for organ donation? A: Individuals can register through the centralised portal using their Aadhaar number and Aadhaar-linked mobile number to pledge for organ donation. Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays , public holidays , and current gold rates and silver prices in your area. Get the latest lifestyle updates on Times of India, along with Happy Krishna Janmashtami Wishes ,, messages , and quotes !
Time of India
3 days ago
- Time of India
US company contributes to IIT-K new ward
Kanpur: Co-founders of Opalescent IT Solutions Inc, a US-based company, Manoj Gupta and Neeraj Gupta, contributed funds for an eight-bed ward for economically weaker section patients at the upcoming Gangwal School of Medical Sciences and Technology (GSMST), Indian Institute of Technology Kanpur, through the IIT-K Foundation, a US-based non-profit organisation. The contribution has been made as tribute to their father, late MC Gupta, who served as Superintendent at IIT-K from 1961 to 1997 as well as to underscore the family's enduring connection to the institute. Gupta was honoured with the Long and Satisfactory Service Award in 1987. The new ward will be named in memory of the donor's late parents, Rukmani Gupta and MC Gupta. Director of IIT-K Manindra Agrawal stated, "Specific contributions like this will help us build an inclusive medical infrastructure and a resilient future healthcare system. On behalf of the institute, I express our deepest gratitude to the Gupta family for their generous gesture, which is rooted in their deep sense of enduring connection to IIT Kanpur." Speaking on behalf of the family, Manoj Gupta remarked, "Our father dedicated his life to IIT Kanpur. This contribution is not just a tribute to his service but also a way for us to give back to the institution that helped shape who we are." Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays , public holidays , and current gold rates and silver prices in your area. Get the latest lifestyle updates on Times of India, along with Happy Independence Day wishes , messages , and quotes !
