Social care reforms in Wales stuck over funding, expert says
Reform of social care in Wales is stuck because ministers "don't want to make decisions about money", according to an expert.Prof Gerry Holtham wrote a report seven years ago which said social care for older people could be funded by raising income tax in Wales.Care home owners have said a national care service would erase inequalities in funding between councils.The Welsh government said it was already working on creating a national scheme, but that a funding solution had yet to be found.
Costs for social care are currently met either by a resident or their local authority.Ministers have said they want to get rid of this system, and set up another like the NHS which would be free at the point of need - but how would it be financed?
Mr Holtham's report in 2018 put forward a plan which would see people in Wales pay between 1-3% extra in income tax, depending on age, to fund social care here.But he said not much had happened since because politicians were too afraid to grasp the nettle."They don't want to make the decisions about money," he told BBC Politics Wales on Sunday."At the moment, there's a sort of phobia that democratic politicians have about raising taxes."If you tell the public 'look, we're going to have to pay this tax or this present situation will continue or deteriorate', I'm not so sure the public wouldn't agree to that."But I think you've got to have the nerve to have that conversation."
Timeline
June 2018: Holtham report becomes the latest in a long line of inquiries and commissions designed to prompt action on the issueFebruary 2020: Welsh ministers say they are looking at increasing income tax to pay for careApril 2021: Just before the last Senedd election, that plan was ruled out by LabourSeptember 2022: The Welsh government says it wants to set up a national care service, but that it would take about 10 years
Scotland and England have had similar issues with getting a national care service off the ground.The Scottish government dumped its plans in January because of a lack of support and questions about how it would be paid for.The UK government has set up a commission to start looking into funding for a national care service in England but it will not report back before 2028.Bridgend councillor Jane Gebbie, who also represents Wales' 22 councils on social care via the Welsh Local Government Association, said change could not come soon enough.She also said Wales could get a national care service much sooner if funding was resolved."Government know that the demand on our services is increasing," she said."There's pay disparities between health boards and local government."That's another wicked issue that they are going to have to resolve before we can have any sort of national care service."
Mario Kreft, chairman of Care Forum Wales, the umbrella group which speaks for the sector, wants to see different care charges levied across Welsh councils equalised so that everyone would pay the same, getting rid of a so-called "postcode lottery" in care.He has welcomed the plan for a national service, but questioned how long it should take."We've seen so many of these initiatives, royal commissions and so forth about social care, but it always seems to get to the point of being 'knock it into the long grass, too expensive', it's a problem that's too hard to handle."The Welsh government said it had already launched its National Office for Care and Support to help deliver the first stage of its 10-year plan to create a national care service for Wales."Our vision for a national care service in Wales would see a system that provides excellent quality care, supports attractive and rewarding work, and is closely integrated with the NHS and the broader public sector," a spokesperson said."Ambitious plans such as these need to sit within the context of a sustainable funding solution which supports our social care sector and enables it to thrive."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scotsman
15 minutes ago
- Scotsman
Hamilton by-election prompts rethink of assumptions about 2026 Holyrood elections
John Swinney said it was a two-horse race between the SNP and Reform UK; some commentators claimed Reform might just sneak it; and Labour was tipped to finish third. Sign up to our daily newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to Edinburgh News, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... But when the votes were counted in last week's Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse by-election, it was Labour who emerged as the winners with a majority of 602, overturning the SNP's majority of more than 4,500 in 2021 - a swing of 7.42 per cent from the SNP to Labour. Amid poor poll ratings,and after the party's humiliation in last month's Runcorn and Helsby by-election, where it lost the seat to Reform, this was a major boost for Labour. Labour's Davy Russell celebrates with Anas Sarwar, Jackie Ballie and Monica Lennon after winning the Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse by-election. Picture: Jeff| Getty Images Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad And with the Scottish Parliament elections less than a year away, it prompts a rethink of the assumption that the SNP is on course for a fifth term in power at Holyrood. Labour's landslide general election victory last July encouraged hopes that Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar could oust John Swinney as First Minister and end nearly two decades of SNP rule next May. But a series of unpopular decisions by the new Labour government at Westminster, including means-testing winter fuel payments, led to plummeting poll figures and seemed to put paid to the party's chances in Scotland. Reacting to the Hamitlon result, Mr Sarwar claimed it showed a rejection of the SNP because of its record in Government, as well as a rejection of Nigel Farage and Reform. But he also acknowledged people wanted the UK Labour government to 'go further and faster in making a difference to people's lives'. The SNP's continuing poll lead after18 years in government cannot be easily dismissed and Reform's 26 per cent of the vote shows it is a serious threat, but Labour nevertheless has good reason to be heartened by the Hamilton victory. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Commentators have warned against reading too much into the win and rightly point out the parties' performances in Hamilton were roughly in line with Scotland-wide polling which shows SNP support 15 points down on the 2021 Holyrood election and Labour support two points down. But the fact remains that Labour has won a fiercely-fought by-election which they were widely expected to lose badly and have taken a seat from the SNP who were seen as more or less certain victors next year. And that gives Labour a new momentum in their drive to win power at Holyrood.
ITV News
17 minutes ago
- ITV News
Wales' poverty crisis deepening as more than 1 in 5 living in hardship, new report reveals
Poverty in Wales is deepening, according to a new report from the Joseph Rowntree Foundation (JRF) and the Bevan Foundation. The study also claims there has been little progress in reducing poverty in Wales over the past 20 years, with poverty rates remaining at around 21–22%. According to the 'Poverty in Wales' report, published on Tuesday, more than 1 in 5 people in Wales (22%) – which is around 700,000 people – are living in poverty. Of these, 400,000 are working-age adults (21%), 200,000 are children (31%) and 100,000 are pensioners (16%). The report warns that if no action is taken, child poverty in Wales could reach 34% by 2029-30, which would make it the highest rate of all UK nations. The highest child poverty rates by local authority are Blaenau Gwent (34%), Merthyr Tydfil, Ceredigion and Newport (32%), and the Isle of Anglesey and Pembrokeshire (31%). The Welsh Government says it is determined to do all it can to prevent people from going into poverty and to help those who need support the most. The findings also reveal that nearly half a million people in Wales lived in deep poverty in 2020-23, with 310,000 in very deep poverty. Households below 50% of the median household income are defined as living in deep poverty and those living below 40% are defined as being in very deep poverty. Dr Victoria Winckler, Director at the Bevan Foundation, said: "It is shocking that there has been no progress reducing poverty in Wales in the last twenty years. "Even worse, more people are in deep poverty than ever before, forced to use food banks, unable to heat their homes, watching every penny. 'The report shows that the root causes are many years of cuts to social security coupled with a severe shortage of decent jobs and affordable housing. The steps taken by the Welsh Government to alleviate poverty are welcome, but there is much more to do. 'As political parties gear up for the next Senedd election, we urge them to commit to practical, deliverable action to end poverty." Chris Birt, JRF Associate Director for Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland said: "Deepening poverty and a child poverty rate of almost one in three in Wales should be a stark wake up call to both the UK Government and all parties aspiring to form the next Welsh Government. "The Senedd has significant powers that contribute to improving people in Wales's standard of living. Driving down costs, better connecting communities, providing affordable housing and breaking down barriers to employment are all things they can do to reduce poverty. 'But the scale of the challenge needs to be met by the scale of the response. The same is of course true of the UK Government. The threadbare social security system is their responsibility, and it drives much hardship. A good place to start reversing that would be casting the two-child limit into history as quickly as possible. 'There is much work to be done by both the Welsh and UK Governments, but the prize is a Wales where people are able to explore their potential and be free from hardship – something that is miles from reality for far too many people today.' In response to the report, the Welsh Government says it recognises that it is a "challenging time" for many children, families and communities in Wales, and is determined to do all it can to prevent people from going into poverty and help those who need support the most. A Welsh Government spokesperson said: "Our commitment is backed by substantial investment of nearly £7bn between 2022-2026 to reduce costs and maximise incomes for Welsh families. "Our child poverty strategy sets out how we will use the levers we have to deliver against our ambitious objectives to support families most in need. "We will continue to call for positive changes in social security policy to tackle child poverty, particularly seeking a commitment to end the two child benefit rule."
South Wales Argus
24 minutes ago
- South Wales Argus
How has the Heads of the Valleys road helped communities?
The Bevan Foundation and the Taxpayers Alliance have come to radically different conclusions on the project. Work concluded in May this year, at an official cost of £1.4bn. The road's dualling of the A465 section was conducted by Welsh Government and cost some £500 million. The complex project ran over budget. The ambitious sections between Gilwern and Brynmawr, running through the deep Clydach Gorge, delayed the project by three years and inflated costs by nearly£150 million. Welsh Think tank The Bevan Foundation, attempting to make sense of the Welsh Government's brake on road building and squaring it with the costs of the mega-investment, concluded the road means yet more investment across the whole area, which is essential to upskill the population and drive growth. In its report, the foundation concluded that much of the poor land and poor built environment needed upgrading, training and skills needs to be led by the Welsh Government and local authorities. By just building a road that has few users in a deindustrialised area, the whole region could be stuck in what economists call the Middle-Income Trap, where countries just reassemble complex goods and add little value and create few high-skilled jobs. Meanwhile, the Taxpayers' Alliance questioned the Welsh Government's whole 'muddled' approach to transport and development. Thay argue it isn't even whether the road cost £1.4 billion or £2 billion, due to a 'dissembling bureaucracy.' They warn Wales needs to learn lessons or it will become saddled with a series of 'sunk cost fallacies.' A spokesman for the group said: "While Welsh taxpayers will be relieved to see roadworks finally completed, they will be aghast at enormous costs and absurd time it has taken to get the project over the line.' Mocking the outcome of a 50mph road after 23 years and a fortune spent, the group said: "Twenty three years and billions spent - upgrading a single stretch of road while essential infrastructure maintenance in other parts of Wales has been ignored! "Ministers in Cardiff need to get their act together and ensure that future projects are kept on time and within budget!" Welsh Government was approached for a comment. They said they will unveil their vision for development of the area surrounding the road network on Thursday, June 12. The Bevan Foundation's report is called A Route to Prosperity.
