No Lattouf contempt probe after Nine names lobbyists
Antoinette Lattouf was ousted from her casual position on ABC Radio Sydney's Mornings program in December 2023 after a concerted email campaign by the lobbyists demanding she be sacked.
She was awarded $70,000 for her unlawful termination in June.
As her Federal Court hearing against the ABC started in February, Justice Darryl Rangiah suppressed the names of nine individuals who had complained about Lattouf.
He said there were safety fears if they were publicly identified.
Then-ABC chair Ita Buttrose wrote to former managing director David Anderson that she was getting over the complaints two days into Lattouf's fill-in hosting shift, in an email presented during the trial.
Nine published a series of articles in the Sydney Morning Herald and The Age in January 2024 naming four of the complainants, and did not remove the names until March 2025.
The complainants then urged Justice Rangiah to refer the matter to a Federal Court registrar who could prosecute the two Nine-owned publications for contempt.
The contempt case was also brought against journalists Michael Bachelard and Calum Jaspan, editors Bevan Shields and Patrick Elligett and Nine's in-house lawyers Larina Alick and Sam White.
On Friday, Justice Rangiah declined to refer the matter for prosecution.
The complainants had brought a "reasonably arguable" case that Nine was in contempt, he acknowledged in his judgment.
But Nine had an arguable defence that the court's suppression order only related to the names of nine complainants found in documents tendered during Lattouf's trial against the ABC, he wrote.
Nine argued it had sourced the names from other material, more than a year before the trial started.
In declining to send the matter onto a registrar, the judge said the complainants could prosecute the case themselves if they wished.
"I consider the intervening parties are 'the ones most naturally placed' to conduct proceedings for contempt of court," he wrote.
He ordered the lobbyists pay half of Nine's legal costs, saying the network's failure to properly respond to repeated correspondence from their lawyers was "discourteous and unhelpful".
However, he did not order all costs be paid because there was no reasonable basis for contempt proceedings to be brought against Mr White and Ms Alick.
The in-house lawyers had no control over whether the articles were amended and there was no evidence about the legal advice they had given, the judge said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sydney Morning Herald
23 minutes ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
Jake and Callum Robinson: Mexican authorities say Perth brothers killed near beach known for drug-running
Loading Gerardo, also known as 'El Kekas', Angel Jesús and Ari Gisselle were all arrested soon after the alleged killings, while a fourth man – Irineo Francisco – was arrested some time later. Gerardo, Jesús and Francisco were charged with aggravated homicide, aggravated robbery, violent robbery, grand theft auto and forced disappearance. Gisselle was charged with the same offences, excluding forced disappearance. Gerardo and Francisco both appeared via video link from the 'El Hongo' prison, while Gisselle and Jesús appeared in person in court on Thursday. Gisselle and Jesús were manacled together at the ankles. The ABC reported that court documents revealed Gerardo and Francisco's alleged links to the Sinaloa cartel were behind their transfer to a prison branded as being among the world's toughest. Jesus Gerardo, known as El Kekas. Credit: The men have different attorneys, but two failed to appear in court, leading to the rescheduling of the pre-trial hearing to later this month. Gerardo's attorney requested to join all the charges together on the same indictment to streamline further court processes. The outcome of the request will be determined at the pre-trial hearing on July 25. It is understood there have been difficulties in determining and agreeing on the facts of the case, and that Gisselle, Jesús and Francisco could have their charges changed to exclude aggravated homicide. All four will remain in prison until the next hearing. The Robinson family made no statement about the proceedings other than thanking followers on Instagram for their support. A Mexican not-for-profit aimed at combating corruption said it was important to see justice where '99 per cent of murders never see the light'. It said nearly two-thirds of Mexican people had lost trust in the local justice system, and 77 per cent of Mexicans believed crime was often only prioritised when it was subject to media or political pressure. Human rights organisations have said previously that many victims of crime in Mexico are predominantly Mexicans, with cartels avoiding targeting tourists due to the potential of attracting attention. A demonstrator's bodyboard reads in Spanish 'No more violence' during protests at the death of the Robinson brothers and their American friend in Ensenada, Mexico, last year. Credit: AP The fourth body in the well where the bodies of the men were found was believed to be that of a farmer who recently lost control of the ranch to the Sinaloa cartel. Authorities have previously said the men's deaths were not connected to cartel violence, and were instead petty theft gone wrong. The Tijuana Cartel, Cártel de Jalisco Nueva Generación, and Sinaloa Cartel are warring at present for control of the region. Start the day with a summary of the day's most important and interesting stories, analysis and insights. Sign up for our Morning Edition newsletter. This story has been updated to more accurately reflect the sources of some information pertaining to the case.
The Advertiser
5 hours ago
- The Advertiser
Protest crackdown creates 'culture of fear' on campuses
Staff and students describe a pervasive "culture of fear" at one of Australia's top universities following a furore over pro-Palestine encampments. University policies had led to self-censorship, restricting their ability to speak openly about pro-Palestinian movements on campus, they told an inquiry convened by Greens senator Mehreen Faruqi, the National Union of Students, the Australia Palestine Advocacy Network and others. Encampments sprung up at university campuses around the world, with students calling on their institutions to cut ties with weapons manufacturers and condemn Israel's war in Gaza. The University of Melbourne ordered protesters to leave its Parkville campus in May 2024 after they occupied a building they named 'Mahmoud Hall' in honour of Mahmoud Alnaouq, a young Palestinian man killed in the Israel-Gaza war who had been set to begin his studies at the university. At the time, deputy vice-chancellor Michael Wesley said protesters had crossed a line and police had advised on how to end the indoor demonstration. Sophie Rudolph, a senior lecturer at the university, told the inquiry there was an "atmosphere of fear" among staff members. "We had a number of concerns over the actions the university has taken that (have) repressed speech and action around solidarity with Palestine, and with the universities' links with weapons manufacturers," she said. Dr Rudolph cited an example of a staff member who was not allowed to display posters supporting Palestine on their office door or wear symbols that expressed their support. "These are minor but they are part of the insidiousness of the repression and they contribute to other staff members who may not feel as confident," she said. "(They) are self-censoring and they are thinking about when they can and cannot have these conversations." Dozens attended the inquiry on Wednesday, while security guards patrolled the building where the gathering took place. A Melbourne University spokesperson said protesting on campus must be conducted peacefully and respectfully. The university said it did not support protest activity that "unreasonably disrupts activities or operations of the university" or the safety and wellbeing of staff and students. "Freedom of speech, and the right to lawful peaceful protest, are respected and supported at the University of Melbourne and are central to our values and identity," the spokesperson said. Organiser Jos Downey detailed conditions protesters faced during their encampment at Monash University, claiming intimidation, abuse and threats from campus security and opposing groups. Jasmine Duff, a leader of the Deakin University encampment, told the inquiry she had been tipped off that gardeners were instructed to disrupt the protesters' sleep, including one incident where they were woken at 2am. Ms Duff, the co-convenor of Students for Palestine, testified that universities had been "extraordinarily repressive" towards students who wished to protest. "Students have been put through serious disciplinary procedures, risking their degrees, for participating in peaceful protests against the genocide in Gaza," she said. "Universities should be havens of free speech and debate, but instead those who speak out against the brutal onslaught in Gaza are punished." The inquiry comes shortly after the federal government received recommendations from a major anti-Semitism report. The nation's special envoy against anti-Semitism, Jillian Segal, called for the defunding of universities and cultural institutions that enable or fail to prevent anti-Semitism. Staff and students describe a pervasive "culture of fear" at one of Australia's top universities following a furore over pro-Palestine encampments. University policies had led to self-censorship, restricting their ability to speak openly about pro-Palestinian movements on campus, they told an inquiry convened by Greens senator Mehreen Faruqi, the National Union of Students, the Australia Palestine Advocacy Network and others. Encampments sprung up at university campuses around the world, with students calling on their institutions to cut ties with weapons manufacturers and condemn Israel's war in Gaza. The University of Melbourne ordered protesters to leave its Parkville campus in May 2024 after they occupied a building they named 'Mahmoud Hall' in honour of Mahmoud Alnaouq, a young Palestinian man killed in the Israel-Gaza war who had been set to begin his studies at the university. At the time, deputy vice-chancellor Michael Wesley said protesters had crossed a line and police had advised on how to end the indoor demonstration. Sophie Rudolph, a senior lecturer at the university, told the inquiry there was an "atmosphere of fear" among staff members. "We had a number of concerns over the actions the university has taken that (have) repressed speech and action around solidarity with Palestine, and with the universities' links with weapons manufacturers," she said. Dr Rudolph cited an example of a staff member who was not allowed to display posters supporting Palestine on their office door or wear symbols that expressed their support. "These are minor but they are part of the insidiousness of the repression and they contribute to other staff members who may not feel as confident," she said. "(They) are self-censoring and they are thinking about when they can and cannot have these conversations." Dozens attended the inquiry on Wednesday, while security guards patrolled the building where the gathering took place. A Melbourne University spokesperson said protesting on campus must be conducted peacefully and respectfully. The university said it did not support protest activity that "unreasonably disrupts activities or operations of the university" or the safety and wellbeing of staff and students. "Freedom of speech, and the right to lawful peaceful protest, are respected and supported at the University of Melbourne and are central to our values and identity," the spokesperson said. Organiser Jos Downey detailed conditions protesters faced during their encampment at Monash University, claiming intimidation, abuse and threats from campus security and opposing groups. Jasmine Duff, a leader of the Deakin University encampment, told the inquiry she had been tipped off that gardeners were instructed to disrupt the protesters' sleep, including one incident where they were woken at 2am. Ms Duff, the co-convenor of Students for Palestine, testified that universities had been "extraordinarily repressive" towards students who wished to protest. "Students have been put through serious disciplinary procedures, risking their degrees, for participating in peaceful protests against the genocide in Gaza," she said. "Universities should be havens of free speech and debate, but instead those who speak out against the brutal onslaught in Gaza are punished." The inquiry comes shortly after the federal government received recommendations from a major anti-Semitism report. The nation's special envoy against anti-Semitism, Jillian Segal, called for the defunding of universities and cultural institutions that enable or fail to prevent anti-Semitism. Staff and students describe a pervasive "culture of fear" at one of Australia's top universities following a furore over pro-Palestine encampments. University policies had led to self-censorship, restricting their ability to speak openly about pro-Palestinian movements on campus, they told an inquiry convened by Greens senator Mehreen Faruqi, the National Union of Students, the Australia Palestine Advocacy Network and others. Encampments sprung up at university campuses around the world, with students calling on their institutions to cut ties with weapons manufacturers and condemn Israel's war in Gaza. The University of Melbourne ordered protesters to leave its Parkville campus in May 2024 after they occupied a building they named 'Mahmoud Hall' in honour of Mahmoud Alnaouq, a young Palestinian man killed in the Israel-Gaza war who had been set to begin his studies at the university. At the time, deputy vice-chancellor Michael Wesley said protesters had crossed a line and police had advised on how to end the indoor demonstration. Sophie Rudolph, a senior lecturer at the university, told the inquiry there was an "atmosphere of fear" among staff members. "We had a number of concerns over the actions the university has taken that (have) repressed speech and action around solidarity with Palestine, and with the universities' links with weapons manufacturers," she said. Dr Rudolph cited an example of a staff member who was not allowed to display posters supporting Palestine on their office door or wear symbols that expressed their support. "These are minor but they are part of the insidiousness of the repression and they contribute to other staff members who may not feel as confident," she said. "(They) are self-censoring and they are thinking about when they can and cannot have these conversations." Dozens attended the inquiry on Wednesday, while security guards patrolled the building where the gathering took place. A Melbourne University spokesperson said protesting on campus must be conducted peacefully and respectfully. The university said it did not support protest activity that "unreasonably disrupts activities or operations of the university" or the safety and wellbeing of staff and students. "Freedom of speech, and the right to lawful peaceful protest, are respected and supported at the University of Melbourne and are central to our values and identity," the spokesperson said. Organiser Jos Downey detailed conditions protesters faced during their encampment at Monash University, claiming intimidation, abuse and threats from campus security and opposing groups. Jasmine Duff, a leader of the Deakin University encampment, told the inquiry she had been tipped off that gardeners were instructed to disrupt the protesters' sleep, including one incident where they were woken at 2am. Ms Duff, the co-convenor of Students for Palestine, testified that universities had been "extraordinarily repressive" towards students who wished to protest. "Students have been put through serious disciplinary procedures, risking their degrees, for participating in peaceful protests against the genocide in Gaza," she said. "Universities should be havens of free speech and debate, but instead those who speak out against the brutal onslaught in Gaza are punished." The inquiry comes shortly after the federal government received recommendations from a major anti-Semitism report. The nation's special envoy against anti-Semitism, Jillian Segal, called for the defunding of universities and cultural institutions that enable or fail to prevent anti-Semitism. Staff and students describe a pervasive "culture of fear" at one of Australia's top universities following a furore over pro-Palestine encampments. University policies had led to self-censorship, restricting their ability to speak openly about pro-Palestinian movements on campus, they told an inquiry convened by Greens senator Mehreen Faruqi, the National Union of Students, the Australia Palestine Advocacy Network and others. Encampments sprung up at university campuses around the world, with students calling on their institutions to cut ties with weapons manufacturers and condemn Israel's war in Gaza. The University of Melbourne ordered protesters to leave its Parkville campus in May 2024 after they occupied a building they named 'Mahmoud Hall' in honour of Mahmoud Alnaouq, a young Palestinian man killed in the Israel-Gaza war who had been set to begin his studies at the university. At the time, deputy vice-chancellor Michael Wesley said protesters had crossed a line and police had advised on how to end the indoor demonstration. Sophie Rudolph, a senior lecturer at the university, told the inquiry there was an "atmosphere of fear" among staff members. "We had a number of concerns over the actions the university has taken that (have) repressed speech and action around solidarity with Palestine, and with the universities' links with weapons manufacturers," she said. Dr Rudolph cited an example of a staff member who was not allowed to display posters supporting Palestine on their office door or wear symbols that expressed their support. "These are minor but they are part of the insidiousness of the repression and they contribute to other staff members who may not feel as confident," she said. "(They) are self-censoring and they are thinking about when they can and cannot have these conversations." Dozens attended the inquiry on Wednesday, while security guards patrolled the building where the gathering took place. A Melbourne University spokesperson said protesting on campus must be conducted peacefully and respectfully. The university said it did not support protest activity that "unreasonably disrupts activities or operations of the university" or the safety and wellbeing of staff and students. "Freedom of speech, and the right to lawful peaceful protest, are respected and supported at the University of Melbourne and are central to our values and identity," the spokesperson said. Organiser Jos Downey detailed conditions protesters faced during their encampment at Monash University, claiming intimidation, abuse and threats from campus security and opposing groups. Jasmine Duff, a leader of the Deakin University encampment, told the inquiry she had been tipped off that gardeners were instructed to disrupt the protesters' sleep, including one incident where they were woken at 2am. Ms Duff, the co-convenor of Students for Palestine, testified that universities had been "extraordinarily repressive" towards students who wished to protest. "Students have been put through serious disciplinary procedures, risking their degrees, for participating in peaceful protests against the genocide in Gaza," she said. "Universities should be havens of free speech and debate, but instead those who speak out against the brutal onslaught in Gaza are punished." The inquiry comes shortly after the federal government received recommendations from a major anti-Semitism report. The nation's special envoy against anti-Semitism, Jillian Segal, called for the defunding of universities and cultural institutions that enable or fail to prevent anti-Semitism.
Sydney Morning Herald
7 hours ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
Historic native title ruling for Victorian traditional owners
A group of Victorian traditional owners have won a decade-long legal contest against the state government, gaining exclusive and non-exclusive native title rights to sections of land spanning from Mildura to the South Australia border. The landmark ruling in the Federal Court on Friday provides recognition for the traditional owners of the Millewa-Mallee – including those who identify as Latji Latji, Ngintait and Nyeri Nyeri people – and grants them exclusive possession over areas reserved or held in trust expressly for Aboriginal people, such as properties owned by Indigenous corporations. It is the first time exclusive native title has been granted in Victoria. In her judgment, the result of a 10-year-long negotiation between the traditional owners and the state, Justice Elizabeth Bennett said this was testament to the strength of the Indigenous community and their ancestors. The traditional owners will also receive exclusive possession over certain national park areas to be agreed with the state government. Entry to designated park sections by those who are not Millewa-Mallee Indigenous people may require permission, pending future negotiations between traditional owners and the state. However, these rights will not affect any privately owned land. The determination also grants the traditional owners non-exclusive native title rights, including to hunt, fish, gather and camp across the entire determination area, which traces the Murray River and stretches south along the Calder Highway, and extends west through the Murray-Sunset National Park to the South Australian border. 'The parties, in their joint submission, have recognised that, despite the dispossession and other atrocities inflicted upon the Native Title Holders and their predecessors, the Native Title Holders have maintained their traditional laws and customs and have under them a deep and enduring connection to the Country,' Bennett said.
