KAT orders fresh selection process for Principals in arts and science colleges
A Division Bench comprising judicial member P.V. Asha and administrative member P.K. Kesavan, in its judgement delivered on Tuesday, directed that fresh appointments must be made from a list of 110 eligible candidates in 2022 in strict adherence to UGC guidelines.
A selection committee had then found 43 candidates eligible, from among which 36 were promoted as Principals. The remaining shortlisted candidates had retired by then.
The appointment process had then witnessed controversy after the Higher Education department was accused of bypassing UGC norms by accepting articles published in journals that are not listed in the UGC-CARE (Consortium for Academic and Research Ethics) list for placements and promotions. The government also came under fire for considering deputation service as teaching experience. Such instances paved the way for allegations that the process was being manipulated by easing selection criteria to favour certain candidates.
The tribunal has now held that only the deputation service rendered in the fields of teaching and research can be considered towards teaching experience for the appointment to the post of Principal.
It also ordered a fresh selection committee strictly in tune with UGC Regulations. While those who had been promoted earlier are not compelled to appear for any interview for the appointment process, their current appointments would, however, be subject to the outcome of the reassessment.
The entire exercise will have to be completed within three months, the KAT ruled.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mint
12 hours ago
- Mint
Punjab youth who qualified for 2 govt jobs laments wasting time for RBI, IES, professorship exams: ‘Not worth it'
A Punjab man who claims to have qualified for two government jobs regrets his decision to continue studies in India post-high school instead of going abroad. Seeking advice for starting a handicraft business, he reflected on his decision to stay in India and prepare for government jobs. 'Parents told me to go abroad after my 12th in 2012. Process got delayed due to passport. I took personal decision to stay here and get a good job,' the 31-year-old said. After obtaining a Master of Economics degree from Punjab University, he began preparing for a Reserve Bank of India (RBI) job and the Indian Economic Service. Meanwhile, he cleared the UGC NET on his first attempt. He wanted to go abroad for further studies, but his father guided him to pursue a Bachelor of Education. Punjab man regrets life decisions, decides to make a new start. He further noted, 'Joined School lecturer as a government servant with rank 8. 3 months into job got an opportunity as an 1158 Assistant Professor which is coming after 25 years in punjab.(sic)' He cleared the exams with impressive marks and obtained rank 7. With this achievement in mind and a clear prospect of joining as an assistant professor, he didn't pursue other options despite qualifying for the main examinations of RBI, SEBI and Assistant Secretary of CBSE. He was heartbroken after the Supreme Court quashed the recruitment of 1,158 Punjab assistant professors and librarians for not following UGC regulations. He added, 'Turned out I wasted my precious time in preparing for and getting into government services. It is not worth it.' Social media strongly reacted to the post and offered numerous advice for a fulfilling future. A user stated, 'Dude just give GMAT and apply for t 30 mba school in us or apply in isb u will easily get 200k usd plus salary in America if u passout from t30-40 us b schools (sic).' Another user remarked, 'Great idea! Talk to people you know overseas and understand their unsolved problems or desires, you have an export product at your hand.' A third comment read, 'Bhai vi ni kuch rakheya. You would've been driving truck or working labor job here while your degree would've been collecting dust.'
New Indian Express
3 days ago
- New Indian Express
Kerala govt, Governor set to begin talks for consensus on VC appointments
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM: With the Supreme Court directing both the state government and the chancellor (Governor) to kick-start the process to appoint permanent vice-chancellors (VCs) in universities at the earliest, both sides are set to begin discussions to arrive at a consensus on the matter. Higher Education Minister R Bindu and Law Minister P Rajeeve are scheduled to meet Governor Rajendra Arlekar on Sunday at the directions of CM Pinarayi Vijayan. 'The government will try its best to resolve the deadlock,' Bindu told TNIE. As per highly placed sources, the constitution of search committees for selection of permanent VCs in a few universities will be taken up as a preliminary step. Of the 14 state universities, the Acts of seven varsities lay down that the chancellor shall constitute the search committee. However, the Acts of seven other universities are silent on who is the authority to constitute the panel. 'The second category mostly includes varsities that are newly established or under departments such as agriculture, fisheries, veterinary and health,' said a top source. 'The chancellor will allow the government to form search panel in such varsities to start the process. However, the Raj Bhavan will insist that the search committee be constituted as per UGC regulations,' the source added. As per the UGC regulations, the three-member panel will have nominees of the UGC chairman, the chancellor and the university syndicate. 'If the government agrees to this proposal, it would be an admission that the University Amendment Bill, that aims to alter the composition of search committees in its favour, is now a closed chapter. But there is no other choice as the President has withheld assent to the Bill,' said a government source. The preliminary steps by both parties will serve as a chance for either sides to demonstrate their intent in appointing permanent VCs through consensus. Universities where chancellor is authority to constitute search panel Kerala University MG University Calicut University Kannur University CUSAT Sanskrit University Digital University Universities where Act is silent on who should constitute search panel Kerala Agricultural University Malayalam University APJ Abdul Kalam Tech University Kerala University of Health Sciences Kerala Veterinary & Animal Sciences University Fisheries University Sreenarayana Guru Open University
Time of India
3 days ago
- Time of India
Fourth-Year Schedule Irks Teachers At DU
New Delhi: Faced with the pressure to accommodate a fourth year under the undergraduate curriculum framework, several colleges have slashed breaks and packed five-hour teaching slots into 12-hour working days, a move now formalised by a university notification that has triggered outrage amongthe faculty. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Teachers say the directive, issued ahead of the Aug 1 rollout, forces colleges into an "exhaustive and exploitative" routine that compromises safety, ignores infrastructure gaps and sidelines the ad-hoc staff. The notification dated July 31, reflecting the decisions of the July 12 Executive Council meeting, states that colleges have been advised to function from 8am to 8pm "for optimal utilisation of the available resources". It directed colleges to stagger the deployment of faculty and staff to meet this requirement. Teachers say this has resulted in the elimination of transition and lunch breaks, with some colleges forcing five hours of continuous classes onto faculty schedules, despite the lack of adequate infrastructure, rest areas or staff rooms. "This latest DU directive to adopt 8am to 8pm daily classes is extremely dangerous from the safety perspective of students and teachers," said Mithuraaj Dhusiya, Executive Council member. "Further, making students sit from 8am to 8pm is neither feasible nor practical. It just shows that DU isn't prepared for the fourth year of NEP on both counts — infrastructure and manpower." Faculty members are particularly upset with the clause stating that it would be "in the best interest of all stakeholders if the senior regular faculty members of colleges are entrusted with the responsibility for teaching and guiding the students in the 4th year". Tired of too many ads? go ad free now They argue this undermines newly appointed and ad-hoc teachers, especially in Delhi govt-funded colleges where permanent appointments are pending. "Teaching is based on areas of specialisation, not age," Dhusiya remonstrated. "This notification insults younger teachers and deepens the divide." Abha Dev Habib, secretary, Democratic Teachers' Front, and associate professor at Miranda House, questioned the timing of the advisory, calling it "a sign of ill-preparedness". She said, "The university issued the advisory on Aug 1, the very day classes are to begin. Time-tables and teaching distribution are prepared during vacations — not overnight. The new courses have been pushed without holding workshops for teachers. Clearly, there has been no systematic effort to ensure smooth implementation of the fourth year." The notification invokes Clause 15 of the UGC Regulations, 2018, which mandates that teachers be available at the college for at least five hours daily and devote two hours per day to mentoring students. A minimum of 15 students are to be mentored per faculty member for extra-curricular activities, community development or research. Teachers say this arbitrary quantification of mentoring dilutes its purpose and adds to an already heavy load. It also notes that while workload norms remain at 14 hours per week for associate professors and 16 hours for assistant professors, research supervision and mentoring duties for the fourth year will be "over and above" this. "This is the beginning of the end of protections that cap faculty workload," remarked Rudrashish Chakraborty, DUTA member and associate professor at Kirori Mal College. "The push to make only senior teachers teach the fourth year while excluding the ad hoc teachers is an uncalled-for attempt to divide the faculty and create hierarchies within departments. It will especially hurt the 12 colleges fully funded by Delhi govt where hiring is stuck. " Chakraborty also asked questions about the fate of evening colleges under the new regime. "If colleges must now work from 8am to 8pm, where does that leave institutions that primarily run evening classes? Will they be asked to function from 8pm to 8am?" he asked. While the notification states the additional work will be compensated "as per prevailing norms", the faculty members say the policy fails to consider on-ground realities — from lack of classroom space to overburdened timetables — making the fourth-year rollout anything but smooth. Last month, during an executive council (EC) meeting, Delhi University vice chancellor Yogesh Singh had said that "the university is fully prepared for the 4th year rollout and that solutions are being worked out for colleges facing implementation challenges."
