Three Arrows founders fail in appeal for orders to disclose crypto fund dealings to be set aside
Chief Justice Sundaresh Menon, however, overturned a lower court decision that allowed liquidators to examine its co-founder Zhu Su following the collapse of 3AC in 2022.
In October 2022, 3AC and its two founders, Zhu and Kyle Davies, were ordered by the court to disclose their dealings with the hedge fund – including any relevant books, papers, or records – to liquidators.
However, both Zhu and Davies failed to comply with the disclosure order, prompting the liquidators to file two orders initiating contempt of court proceedings against them. Both men were subsequently sentenced to four months' jail for the offence.
In 2023, Zhu and Davies applied to the court to have all three orders set aside, which was dismissed. They took their appeal against that decision to the Court of Appeal, in a hearing in April.
Separately, following Zhu's arrest on Sep 29, 2023, liquidators sought an examination order from the court, believing that his incarceration will give them an opportunity to obtain more information about the affairs of the cryptocurrency fund.
BT in your inbox
Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox.
Sign Up
Sign Up
Following this, the liquidators commenced proceedings against Zhu and Davies in the British Virgin Islands, in which they sought to recover US$66 million which Zhu allegedly owed to the hedge fund.
Zhu then applied for the examination order, as well as further orders for him to provide additional answers and appear for further examination, to be set aside. This application was also dismissed.
'Deliberate decision' to evade liquidators
In his judgement, the Chief Justice ruled that the lower court had correctly dismissed the founders' applications to set aside the disclosure order, as well as the two orders relating to the contempt of court proceedings.
In the April hearing, Zhu and Davies' lawyers were under the impression that they were cooperating with the liquidators' requests for information and did not think that committal orders would be sought against them.
But this is 'no answer at all', said Chief Justice Menon, who noted that the founders were aware of the disclosure order by Jan 5, 2023, but had no explanation as to why they waited 10 months before filing to have the orders set aside. Their applications were also made well after the 14-day deadline prescribed in the Rules of Court 2021.
Furthermore, Zhu and Davies' argument that they thought they had been cooperating with liquidators in good faith 'said nothing about whether the setting-aside applications had been brought within time, or whether there were grounds for extending time', he added.
'We are with the inference the judge drew, which is that (Zhu and Davies) deliberately chose not to take any steps to set aside the disclosure order because they thought they could remain out of reach of its enforcement.
'In such circumstances, we see no good reason why (Zhu and Davies) should be allowed to revisit the question 10 months later of whether the disclosure order should even have been made against them in the first place.'
'A delay of this time is patently unreasonable,' he added. 'Therefore, we hold that (the founders) were out of time to bring the setting-aside applications against the disclosure order.'
The Chief Justice also noted that Zhu and Davies, being the only directors of 3AC, chose to discharge the company's lawyers a few days before the hearing for the disclosure order was to be heard.
'(This) suggested a deliberate decision by (Zhu and Davies) to evade the efforts of the liquidators to gather the necessary information pertaining to the company,' he wrote.
As for the application relating to the examination order, Chief Justice Menon said the order is not an appropriate means for the liquidators to obtain information from the founders. This is given that the liquidators already intended to commence proceedings to sue Zhu and Davies in the British Virgin Islands shortly before making the order.
Since the liquidators had already decided they wanted to sue the founders, they should be subject to the constraints imposed by the rules of civil procedure, he added.
The court set aside the examination order, but made orders to resolve the outstanding issues arising from the lower court's earlier decision to grant it.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Times
3 minutes ago
- Business Times
Thai data centre capacity may triple on surging demand for AI
[BANGKOK] Thailand's data centre capacity is expected to triple in the next three years as investments of about US$6.5 billion pour into the sector to meet surging demand for cloud computing and artificial intelligence. The nation's capacity is expected to rise to about one gigawatts in 2027 from 350 megawatts in 2024, said Supparat Singhara Na Ayutthaya, vice-chairman of the Thai Data Center Association. A data centre requires an investment of about US$10 million for each megawatt, he said. 'Thailand has drawn tremendous interest for new data centre investments with its steady power generation and water supply,' Supparat said in an interview this week. Alphabet's Google, Microsoft and Nvidia are among global tech giants spending billions of US dollars on AI infrastructure in Thailand and across South-east Asia. 'There will be many more global technology companies further diversifying their data centre facilities to Thailand,' Supparat said. The expansion of Thailand's data centre sector comes as the nation, a longtime manufacturing powerhouse for automobiles and electronics, accelerates efforts to boost its high-tech industries. The government wants Thailand to catch up to countries such as Malaysia and Singapore, regional leaders in data centre and cloud computing services. In the first half of the year, Thailand's Board of Investments approved investment applications worth 322 billion baht (S$12.7 billion) for 36 tech projects, most of which were data centres, according to its website. The data centre association is awaiting clarity about the US plan to restrict shipments of AI chips and what effect that could have on the nation's data centres, Supparat said. BLOOMBERG
Business Times
an hour ago
- Business Times
UK inflation at 18-month high as food, transport costs soar
[LONDON] UK inflation climbed to an 18-month high on the back of surging food, fuel and transport prices, putting the Bank of England under pressure to reconsider the pace of interest-rate cuts. Consumer prices rose 3.8 per cent from a year earlier, up from 3.6 per cent in June and the fastest pace since January 2024, the Office for National Statistics (ONS) said on Wednesday (Aug 20). The pickup was forecast by the BOE but exceeded the 3.7 per cent economists were predicting. Services inflation, a closely watched gauge of underlying prices pressures, climbed to 5 per cent, above the BOE's 4.9 per cent forecast. The pound erased a drop after the report to trade little changed at US$1.3502. The July reading does little to settle the debate within the BOE over the path of policy after the tightest of decisions this month when rates were cut a quarter point to 4 per cent and governor Andrew Bailey warned of 'genuine uncertainty' about the next move. The central bank expects inflation to peak at 4 per cent in September, double its 2 per cent target, on the back of higher food costs but to drop back after that. July's increase was also driven by what may prove to be temporary factors, including the biggest jump in air fares in 24 years due to the timing of the summer holidays, and moves in global food commodity markets. Policymakers will have to balance the risk of sticky inflation as the British public, scarred by three years of sharply increasing prices, demand compensating wage rises against fears the economy is stuttering and the BOE's own forecast that inflation will ease. BT in your inbox Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox. Sign Up Sign Up The pickup in services and food prices will increase 'fears of inflation persistence at the Bank of England,' according to S&P Global Market Intelligence economist Raj Badiani. 'This will harden the assessment of several members of the MPC. They are likely to voice concerns that interest rates are falling too rapidly.' Money markets kept wagers on BOE interest-rate cuts broadly steady, seeing around a 40 per cent chance of another reduction by year-end. A full quarter-point cut had been expected earlier this month. Gilts pared earlier gains, leaving the the two-year yield lower by one basis points at 3.97 per cent, while the 10-year yield was flat at 4.74 per cent. Traders have curbed their bets on future rate cuts since the narrower-than-forecast decision on Aug 7 saw some policymakers warn of the risk of second-round effects on wages and prices as consumers try to recover lost spending power. Subsequent figures showing the economy and labour market holding up better than feared have added to the case for caution. Policymakers will have two more months of data to consider before deciding whether to continue their once-a-quarter rate-cutting path in November. The figures add to evidence that firms are responding to Chancellor of the Exchequer Rachel Reeves' bumper tax and minimum-wage increases in April by passing on the billions of pounds in extra costs to consumers. Food and non-alcoholic drink prices, which shape inflation expectations more than other consumer items, rose 4.9 per cent on the year, the fastest pace since February 2024. The increase was driven by beef, chocolate, orange juice and coffee, suggesting global factors are also at play. Higher inflation undermines Prime Minister Keir Starmer's promise to improve living standards for 'working people' during Labour's first term. Instead a recovery in real incomes is fizzling out as resurgent inflation collides with a cooling labour market, with Reeves' tax-raising budget in October blamed by critics for causing both. Commuters will be hit hard as rail fares are now due to rise 4.8 per cent next year, under the arrangement that they increase in line with the July reading for the retail prices index of inflation. In a statement, Reeves said 'we're a long way from the double-digit inflation we saw under the previous government, but there's more to do to ease the cost of living.' The ONS said the monthly increase in air fares was the biggest since comparable records began in 2001 and was likely to have been due to the timing of the school holidays. They rose 30.2 per cent between June and July, compared with 13.3 per cent in 2024. The higher cost of fuel also lifted inflation and hotels and restaurant prices were 3.2 per cent higher in the year to July, up from 2.6 per cent in the 12 months to June. The ONS said there was no evidence that the Oasis reunion tour had affected the numbers. 'Excluding airfares, package holidays and education – a measure the BOE has in the past called 'core' services inflation – as well as accommodation services, which tend to be volatile, annual services inflation eased to 4.9 per cent from 5.1 per cent in June, based on our estimates,' Hanson and Andrade said. BLOOMBERG
CNA
2 hours ago
- CNA
Dollar steady before Jackson Hole, kiwi drops on dovish RBNZ
LONDON :The U.S. dollar was little changed on Wednesday as traders awaited a speech from Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell at the annual Jackson Hole symposium later this week for clues on the monetary policy path. The New Zealand dollar tumbled after the central bank reduced its cash rate by a quarter point to 3.0 per cent as expected, and said its board had also considered a half-point cut. The dollar index, which measures the U.S. currency against six others, was flat at 98.319, after earlier touching a more than one week high of 98.441. Friday's speech by Powell is the market's main focus, as traders watch for any pushback against market pricing of a rate reduction at the Fed's September 16-17 meeting. Traders now place odds of about 85 per cent on a quarter-point cut next month and expect about 54 basis points of reductions by year-end. "Powell will try to be fairly balanced, but there is a risk we see a hawkish Powell on Friday," said Kirstine Kundby-Nielsen, FX analyst at Danske Bank. "Some of the developments we've seen in inflation dynamics will keep the Fed more cautious." Traders, who ramped up bets for Fed cuts after a surprisingly weak U.S. payrolls report at the start of this month, were further encouraged after consumer price data showed limited upward pressure from tariffs. However, a hotter-than-expected producer price reading last week complicated the policy picture. Powell has said he is reluctant to cut rates because of expected tariff-driven price pressures this summer. Later on Wednesday, the Fed will issue the minutes of its meeting on July 29 and 30, when it held rates steady, although they may offer limited insight as the meeting came before the weak jobs numbers. The kiwi slumped as much as 1.3 per cent to $0.5815, its weakest since April 11, with policymakers lowering their projected floor for the cash rate to 2.55 per cent, from 2.85 per cent forecast in May. "The market did not expect the bank to send a strong dovish signal that it intends to deliver further cuts," Prashant Newnaha, a rates strategist at TD Securities, wrote in a client note. He has increased his forecast for additional easing, now projecting a cash rate of 2.5 per cent by November. The Swedish crown was steady after its central bank maintained its policy rate at 2 per cent, in line with expectations. The euro eased 0.1 per cent to $1.1636. The greenback advanced 0.1 per cent to 0.8078 Swiss franc, though it edged down 0.1 per cent to 147.61 yen. The pound rose slightly against the euro and dollar after hotter-than-forecast inflation, leaving Britain with the biggest price growth problem amongst the world's big rich economies. But much of the rise in services inflation was driven by volatile airfares, which some economists said was due to the timing of the school holidays. "The BoE (Bank of England) is more concerned about food inflation, which hasn't changed much in today's release," ING's head of research Chris Turner said. "We doubt today's CPI release will alter much of the BoE's current thinking." In cryptocurrencies, bitcoin hovered at around $113,897 after earlier dipping to the lowest since August 3 at $112,578.38, pressured by a strengthening dollar. Ether was up 1.8 per cent at $4,234.
