High Court gives go ahead for Skellig Michael boat trips to resume
High Court
has given the go ahead for boat trips to Skellig Michael off the Co Kerry coast to resume.
Mr Justice Garrett Simons granted an application by the
Office of Public Works
(OPW) to lift an automatic suspension on landing at the Unesco heritage site and former monastic island, which was also used as a location for the Star Wars films, The Force Awakens and The Last Jedi.
The order will allow the OPW to enter into a legally binding contract with each of 15 boat operators who were successful in the public competition for permits to land on the island. The landing season runs from mid-May to the end of September each year.
The landing permits were automatically suspended when
two unsuccessful bidders brought a High Court challenge to the decision.
The OPW then had to apply to the court asking that the stay be lifted pending hearing of the substantive challenge.
READ MORE
The unsuccessful bidders – Atlantic Endeavour Ltd and SMBT Ltd, trading as Skellig Michael Boat Trips – disagreed with the OPW interpretation of the legal effect of the automatic suspension.
They contended that there are a number of mechanisms open whereby landing permits might legitimately be granted to the successful tenderers for the balance of the 2025 season, while preserving their own right to challenge the allocation of landing permits for the 2026 and subsequent seasons.
Mr Justice Simons heard the application to lift the suspension this week
and on Thursday ordered that it be lifted.
He said the practical effect of this order is that it will now be legally permissible for the OPW to issue landing permits to the 15 successful tenderers for the balance of the 2025 season.
This will allow for the commencement of passenger landings at Skellig Michael, or Sceilg Mhichíl in Irish.
He said his judgment entails no finding whatsoever on whether the outcome of the tender process allows the OPW to confine the right to land passengers on Sceilg Mhichíl to the 15 successful tenderers for a five-year period.
The proper interpretation of the request for tender and associated documentation, and the legal consequences of the tender process, remain open for debate at the trial of the action, he said.
The judgment, he said 'goes no further' than deciding that the execution of concession contracts does not result in the crystallisation of a contractual right on the part of the successful tenderers to exclusive landing rights for the 2026 and subsequent seasons.
He said the significance of this finding is that the unsuccessful tenderers are not relegated to a claim for certain damages in respect of the 2026 and subsequent seasons.
The only right which the OPW seeks to translate into a concluded contract, before the determination of the full High Court challenge, is confined to the 2025 landing season, the judge said.
He said he was listing the substantive action for the alleged breaches of the public procurement legislation in July.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
2 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Businessman loses appeal over €317,312 inheritance tax bill
A senior businessman 'struggling to survive emotionally' has lost an appeal against a €317,312 bill for capital acquisitions tax (CAT) stemming from his inheritance of a house from his aunt. The man's aunt died in 2017 and he inherited a home from her. Following an investigation, the Revenue Commissioners last year issued a bill to the man alleging underpayment of €288,465 in CAT along with €28,846 surcharge for a late filing. Revenue issued its assessment on the basis that the house the man received was not his aunt's main residence and that he also received free accommodation and cash gifts from the woman. Disputing the assessment and claiming exemption from inheritance tax, the man claimed he was a dependent relative of his aunt and that he is permanently incapacitated due to ongoing mental health issues. READ MORE A submission to the Tax Appeal Commission stated that the former managing director is at the end of his working life and unable to support himself. It further said he was 'very vulnerable and emotionally struggling to survive, which his medical reports have clearly stated'. However, in her findings, appeals commissioner Clare O'Driscoll found that at the time of the aunt's death in 2017 or before it, the man was not permanently and totally incapacitated due to mental or physical infirmity from maintaining himself. grounds that would have excused him from inheritance tax. Ms O'Driscoll said the medical documentation submitted did not establish that the appellant was at any time permanently and totally incapacitated. She also pointed to the man's LinkedIn profile from August 2022 which stated that the man was at the time managing director of a business and had been since July 1988. A letter, dated April 2024, saying the man 'has suffered from an extremely disabling condition for the past 25 years or so' was submitted on his behalf by a doctor. The appellant 'is doing everything in his power to combat the exceptional level of anxiety that he is experiencing ... It would not surprise me if the High Court designated him as a vulnerable adult and made him a Ward of Court to protect his welfare', he said. However, the doctor did not appear as a witness to be cross-examined. Ms O'Driscoll accepted that the appellant has experienced poor mental health since at least 2008 but none of the documentation states that the appellant was at any time permanently and totally incapacitated. She found that the man was not a dependent relative and therefore not entitled to an exemption from CAT on that ground. She also said the man was not entitled to an exemption to CAT as the home was not his aunt's main residence.
Irish Times
30 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Hundreds of teaching posts remain unfilled as schools prepare to reopen, says ASTI
The Government has failed to 'make a dent' in the teacher recruitment and retention crisis as 'hundreds' of posts remain unfilled shortly before schools reopen after summer, the Association of Secondary Teachers Ireland (ASTI) said. In recent years, the union said hundreds of posts advertised online have consistently remained unfilled at this time of year despite schools working 'relentlessly' to fill them. An ASTI survey of secondary school leaders published on Thursday revealed 67 per cent of respondents said they had unfilled vacancies, due to recruitment difficulties, halfway through the last school year. This has resulted in schools removing certain subjects, employing non-qualified teachers and reassigning special education needs teachers to mainstream classes, 'adversely impacting the most vulnerable', the union said. READ MORE The survey, carried out by Red C in spring, also revealed 77 per cent of schools said they received no applications for advertised posts during the last academic year. And 90 per cent said no substitute teachers were available to cover for absent teachers. The ASTI said the survey showed 'minimalist actions' taken in recent years, such as upskilling and extra training places for teachers, have 'failed to reverse the chronic teacher shortage crisis'. ASTI general secretary Kieran Christie said the changes necessary to address the issue and ensure teaching was a sustainable career 'have not been acted upon'. 'It seems the Department of Education and Youth is waiting for demographic shifts to lessen the problem,' he said. 'This is not an acceptable way to treat the children and young people who are returning to school this month.' Most schools (73 per cent) said they employed non-qualified and casual teachers. And 42 per cent of schools, meanwhile, removed a subject or subjects from the curriculum due to recruitment issues. Mr Christie said successive education ministers, including the present one, Helen McEntee , had been 'unwilling' to make the changes necessary to address the problem. 'Fundamental changes' were required to encourage those teaching abroad to return to Ireland, he said. Shortening the 'excessively long' teachers' pay scale and doubling the number of middle management posts in schools would be an 'enormous help'. He said the training period for new teachers should be reduced from two years to one 'and the exorbitant cost of undertaking this training must be tackled'. 'Teaching in Ireland needs to be made more attractive. The enormous price being paid by children who are consistently in classrooms with no qualified teacher available to teach them will leave a long and bitter legacy,' he said.
Irish Times
32 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Cairn Homes lodges plan for 252 apartments and houses in Blackrock that will made available for sale
Irish housebuilder Cairn Homes is to lodge new plans for 252 residential build-to-sell units for one of the few available sites in Blackrock in south Dublin that is suitable for a higher density apartment scheme. Cairn Homes is to seek permission for 236 apartments and 16 houses from Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown County Council for its site at Chesterfield, Cross Avenue, Blackrock, Co Dublin. The 236 apartments are to be located in two blocks ranging in height from five to eight storeys while the 16 homes will be five bedroom terrace houses. Cairn has been trying to develop the site for the past seven years and last year An Coimisiún Pleanála refused permission for 355 build-to-rent apartments as it would lead to an over-proliferation of such apartments for the area. READ MORE ACP refused planning permission after James M Sheehan, co-founder of the Blackrock, Hermitage and Galway Clinics, claimed that the plan 'is grossly excessive'. This was one of more than30 objections were lodged against the scheme. [ Cairn Homes refused permission for 280 new homes in south west Dublin Opens in new window ] Cairn previously secured planning permission for an apartment scheme on the site but this was quashed by the High Court in July 2019 following residents' opposition. Addressing ACP's grounds for refusal on the proliferation of built-to-rent apartments for the area, planning consultants for the new scheme, McCutcheon Halley Chartered Planning Consultants (MHP) state that new scheme 'offers 252 built-to-sell units, which align with the identified housing needs in Dún Laoghaire Rathdown County Council'. MHP states that the scheme would 'facilitate increased housing supply and choice along Cross Avenue and its environs, which is located 1km southwest of Blackrock Village'. The developers are proposing a density of 100 units per hectare and MHP states that 'the proposed density and mix is considered suitable for the site ensuring a sufficient quantum of units is provided whilst also protecting the amenity of existing adjoining residential properties'.
