Malta ‘golden passport' scheme breaches EU law
A 'golden passport' scheme operated by Malta offering citizenship to wealthy overseas investors has been struck down by the
European Court of Justice
(ECJ), which found it amounted to the government selling citizenship.
In a significant ruling, the
EU
court said the controversial scheme had commercialised citizenship by in effect allowing rich foreign individuals to buy a passport.
Under the scheme, applicants could secure Maltese citizenship by donating at least €600,000 to the government and buying or renting property on the small Mediterranean island.
The
European Commission
challenged the legality of the scheme.
READ MORE
The commission criticised the 'transactional' nature of the programme, which gave successful applicants a passport that allowed them to work and travel across the EU. The practice of in effect selling EU citizenship undermined trust between the 27 member states, the commission said in an April 1st, 2020 letter.
Agents pushing the scheme promoted it as an avenue to secure the 'right to reside, study and work in any of the 27 countries of the European Union', according to excerpts from promotional materials submitted to the court.
Malta stopped taking applications from
Russian
and
Belarusian
individuals following Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine in early 2022, over fears the scheme would be exploited by wealthy individuals seeking to avoid western economic sanctions.
By that point the commission had already opened a legal case against the citizenship investor programme, seeking an ECJ ruling that it broke EU law.
Malta argued that the portrayal of its process as an 'automatic and unconditional access route to Maltese nationality' was an 'oversimplification'.
In a decision published on Tuesday, the ECJ said the selling of national citizenship through the 'transactional' Maltese scheme was 'incompatible' with EU law. The ruling means Malta will be forced to discontinue its overseas investor programme.
Anti-corruption organisation Transparency International welcomed the ruling. Maíra Martini, its chief executive, said 'countless cases have shown how these schemes have granted safe haven to corrupt actors from around the world and other suspicious individuals in the EU'.
The ECJ decision 'stops not only Malta from selling EU citizenship, but will also prevent other member states from doing the same', she said.
Another EU state,
Bulgaria
, scrapped a similar golden passport scheme in 2022, following pressure from the commission.
Ireland discontinued, in February 2023, a cash-for-visa scheme it had run for more than a decade
. It had allowed wealthy individuals secure residency in Ireland in return for investing €1 million in an Irish business, or philanthropic donations of at least €400,000, commonly made to sports clubs and charities.
The government closed the scheme to new applicants in early 2023 in response to internal concerns about a surge in applications from
China
and difficulties carrying out due diligence on those applying.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
35 minutes ago
- The Irish Sun
‘Sadly missed by loving family' – Tributes pour in for cyclist killed in Kerry road crash as gardai issue appeal
A KERRY man who died in a tragic road accident just days ago has been remembered as "a wonderful man". Paddy O'Donoghue, from Goortahoonig, Killarney, was an avid 2 Paddy was a driving force behind the Ring of Kerry Cycle Credit: 2 The 78-year-old has been remembered as a "gentleman" Credit: He was one of the Sadly, the 78-year old was killed on Tuesday, June 10, after he was struck by a vehicle in Kilgarvan village. The incident occurred on the R569 between 1pm and 2pm. Read more in Irish news A Garda spokesperson said: "Gardai continue to appeal for witnesses to this incident to come forward. "Any road users who may have camera footage (including dash-cam) and were travelling in the area between 1pm and 2pm are asked to make this footage available to investigating Gardai. "Anyone with any information is asked to contact Killarney Garda Station on According to his death notice, Paddy leaves behind a "loving Most read in Irish News He is also remembered by grandchildren Niamh, Dáire, Edward, John, David, Lily Bea, Sadhbh, Sebastian, Abigail, Victoria, Anna, Amelia, Thomas, Hugh, Leonie, Patrick and Oscar. And mourning him are his brother John, sisters Margaret , Kathleen and Anna, daughters-in-law Noelle and Katie, sons-in-law Martin, Charlie, Paul, Marc and Jonathan. Paddy leaves behind a wide circle of in-laws, friends, and neighbours. Tributes have poured in for the passionate cyclist, who was hailed by mourners as a "gentleman". SAD PASSING One person said: "So sorry to learn this awful tragic news. What a gentleman. Rip Paddy." Another put in: "RIP Paddy, a wonderful man." Somebody else said: "Our sincere condolences to Brenda and family on the sad and sudden passing of Paddy. "May he rest in peace and the Lord comfort you all in this time of grief." And a fourth penned: "Our deepest condolences to Brenda and family on the very sad passing of Paddy. "Thinking of you all at this sad time. May Paddy's gentle soul rest in peace." Someone else said: "RIP Paddy, such a sad loss." Plans are underway to dedicate this year's annual Ring of Kerry cycle to the deceased man.
Irish Independent
an hour ago
- Irish Independent
Taoiseach labelling Israel's actions in Gaza ‘genocide' won't stop Central Bank approving ‘war bonds', governor tells TDs
So-called 'war bonds', which it is claimed are being used to fund the killing of innocent children and civilians in Gaza, are under intense scrutiny as a second Dáil motion was tabled to ban them. The Central Bank faced sustained questioning from TDs and senators at the Oireachtas Finance Committee, but insisted it is legally required to approve the legal document, or prospectus, required for the sale of the bonds. To be sold in the EU, bonds from non-EU countries must have their bond prospectus approved by an EU country. Israel traditionally had its European bond prospectuses approved in the UK, but turned to the Central Bank in Ireland for authorisations after Brexit. The Governor of the Central Bank, Gabriel Makhlouf, said it was 'incorrect' to claim it can impose sanctions on the processing of the bonds on the basis of international court rulings. He said it is up to international bodies including the UN and the EU to respond to breaches of international law by Israel, and to determine if sanctions are necessary. 'The Central Bank cannot impose sanctions on Israel – for example by refusing to approve the Israeli bond prospectus – in circumstances where the EU has not imposed any such sanctions itself,' he told TDs and senators. The Central Bank said its approval for Israel trading bonds in the EU is due for renewal in September. 'We will look extremely carefully at the facts that pertain at that time and will make a judgment on it,' said the Central Bank governor. A number of TDs, including Sinn Féin's Pearse Doherty and Cian O'Callaghan of the Social Democrats, said Ireland was a signatory to the Genocide Convention and this would enable the Central Bank to reject Israel's bond prospectuses. But Mr Makhlouf said the body is not bound by the Genocide Convention, but rather EU financial regulations, when deciding whether to facilitate the sale of bonds. ADVERTISEMENT The current prospectus is due for renewal again in September. 'If, when the state of Israel looks to renew its prospectus we will look extremely carefully at the facts that pertain at the time and we will make a judgment on it,' he said. But this will be based on the requirements of the financial regulations. 'The fact that the Taoiseach made the statement at the time, that is not going to change the judgement we come to,' he said, referring to Micheál Martin's comments last month that Israel is committing genocide in Gaza. Ahead of last night's Dáil vote on a Bill enabling the Central Bank to stop facilitating Israeli bonds. Sinn Féin urged government TDs to 'have a backbone'. Deputy Doherty said: 'We have to ensure the State has no hand, act or part in facilitating the sale of Israeli war bonds. These aren't just financial instruments, this is the money that is raised that pays for the bombs that pays for the bullets that pays for the destruction of the lives of men, women and children across Palestine as we speak.' Deputy O'Callaghan said while Independent TDs backing the Government had a free vote on the motion, Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael TDs had to vote along with the party whip. 'That is utterly unjust and unfair,' he said. 'If there was a free vote, this motion would pass and that would put the Central Bank under severe pressure to stop facilitating the sale of these bonds and would cut off a source of finance for the genocide that is taking place.' Labour's Conor Sheehan said: 'It is not enough to just call this a genocide. We need to make Israel an international pariah.'
Irish Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Tributes pour for retired engineer who died in Kerry road accident
Tributes have been paid to this pensioner – who was one of two cyclists to die on Irish roads within 24 hours. Paddy O'Donoghue, 78, was killed when he was struck by a vehicle as he cycled in his native Co Kerry on Tuesday afternoon. Mr O'Donoghue, who was from Muckross in Killarney, lost his life in the accident near Kilgarvan at around 1.40pm. Mr O'Donoghue was a former engineer at Kerry County Council and was well known and respected in the area. Local Non-Party councillor Martin Grady, who knew Mr O'Donoghue, paid an emotional tribute to him on Wednesday. He told The Irish Mirror: 'Paddy was a true gentleman. He loved the outdoors. He was a keep fit man, enjoyed Kerry's beauty every opportunity he got. He loved hillwalking and cycling. 'I want to offer my condolences to his family and friends. 'Paddy was an engineer with Kerry County Council. The community is saddened and shocked by his passing. May he rest in peace.' And Killarney Independent Ireland councillor John O'Donohue said: 'It is terrible news. Paddy was held in very high regard by the local community.' Fianna Fail Killarney councillor Niall Kelleher said: 'I knew Paddy. He was very caring. He was a very nice man. It is very shocking new for the entire community.' His death notice on says funeral details for the father of seven will be confirmed later. It says: 'Beloved husband of Brenda and loving father of Florence, Áine, Denise, Brenda, Báirbre, Patrick and Alice. Sadly missed by his loving family, adored grandchildren Niamh, Dáire, Edward, John, David, Lily Bea, Sadhbh, Sebastian, Abigail, Victoria, Anna, Amelia, Thomas, Hugh, Leonie, Patrick and Oscar, brother John, sisters Margaret , Kathleen and Anna, daughters-in-law Noelle and Katie, sons-in-law Martin, Charlie, Paul, Marc and Jonathan, brothers-in-law, sisters-in-law, nephews, nieces, relatives, neighbours and many friends. 'Paddy is pre-deceased by his parents Florence and Anna, his brother Michael and sister Lily. Funeral arrangement later.' The incident happened on the R569 road, Church Grounds in Kilgarvan, Gardaí said. Mr O'Donoghue was declared dead at the scene. Gardai say the Coroner has been informed and a post-mortem examination will take place. The road was sealed off overnight, but was reopened on Wednesday morning. Gardaí say investigations are ongoing and they have appealed for witnesses to come forward. It said in a statement: ' Any road users who may have camera footage (including dash-cam) and were travelling in the area between 1pm and 2pm are asked to make this footage available to investigating Gardaí. "Anyone with any information is asked to contact Killarney Garda Station on 064 667 1160, the Garda Confidential Line on 1800 666 111, or any Garda Station." Meanwhile, Gardaí in south west Dublin are investigating the death of a cyclist early on Wednesday. The 19-year-old died after he was struck by a van in Lucan at 7.30am. He is believed to be from the area. Gardaí said in a statement the young man died from his injuries in hospital. It said: 'Shortly after 7:30am, Gardaí were alerted after a cyclist was struck by a van at the junction of Griffeen Avenue, R136 and Balgaddy Road. 'The cyclist, a 19-year-old male, received treatment at the scene before being transported by ambulance to Tallaght Hospital, where he was later pronounced deceased. No other injuries were reported. 'Garda Forensic Collision Investigators are currently examining the scene and local traffic diversions are in place. The local coroner has been notified and arrangements will be made for a post-mortem examination.' Gardaí are appealing for witnesses to the incident to come forward. The force said: 'Road users who may have relevant camera footage (including dash-cam) and were traveling in the area at the time are asked to make this footage available to investigating Gardaí. 'Anyone with information is asked to contact Lucan Garda Station at (01) 666 7300, the Garda Confidential Line at 1800 666 111, or any Garda station.'
