VAT reversal: Govt's R75bn hole will affect essential services and developmental objectives
Government will now have to find some other way of plugging a revenue hole of at least R75 billion after bowed to pressure and scrapped an increase in VAT.
Government will now have to find some other way of plugging a revenue hole of at least R75 billion after it bowed to pressure and scrapped an increase in Value Added Tax (VAT), which economists said will have adverse effects on essential services such as teaching and nursing.
Seemingly overnight, National Treasury reversed course on a proposed 0.5 percentage point increase in VAT, which would have taken the tax to 15.5%.
Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana's reversal means that other measures to cushion the poor against the proposed hike will have to be reversed, while 'other expenditure decisions [will need to be] revisited,' the statement said.
Old Mutual chief economist, Johann Els, said the fact that VAT would not be increased 'was not necessarily a win because R75 billion needs to be made up in some other way'.
This, said Els, could take the form of 'significant cutbacks in spending that was planned, especially in terms of extra nurses and extra teachers, or some of the revenue components that were announced in terms of mitigating the pain of that for taxpayers'.
Els said some of the changes could include a petrol levy increase, while there might also be a reversal of additional goods being added to the VAT exempt basket.
In the March 12 National Budget – the second tabling of the revenue and expenditure framework after the February one wasn't passed – National Treasury said it would expand the list of VAT zero-rated food items to include more meat and vegetable products.
Casey Sprake, economist Anchor Capital, told IOL that scrapping the VAT increase introduced a range of fiscal and economic challenges. While welcome news for consumers, it resulted in a significant deterioration of South Africa's fiscal position, she said.
'Crucially, the social support measures that were designed to mitigate the regressive impact of the VAT hike – particularly for lower-income households – are now redundant and will likely be withdrawn. In their place, the government will need to identify alternative areas for fiscal adjustment, many of which may come at the expense of key developmental priorities,' said Sprake.
Sprake added that National Treasury will be compelled to implement expenditure cuts. These are most likely to affect frontline public services and infrastructure investment, which are sectors already under considerable pressure.
Els said that the proposed increase wouldn't have been materially negative in terms of consumer spending or inflation, given measures to assist the poor. However, Investec chief economist Annabel Bishop had worked out that a 50bps increase this year as well as one in 2026 would have increased inflation by 0.25 percentage points for each year.
Inflation was 2.7% in March, down from 3.2% in February as it continued a declining trajectory.
Sprake added that there would be hidden costs for businesses that had begun updating their pricing systems, financial models, and customer communication strategies to accommodate the VAT change. They would now need to 'undertake the same process in reverse,' she said.
'These operational disruptions translate into unnecessary compliance costs, lost productivity, and added complexity for the private sector; costs borne not by the state, but by the broader economy,' said Sprake.
The South African Chamber of Commerce and Industry said in a statement that 'we are not yet convinced that enough expert work has been undertaken to investigate and look at expenditure throughout the government service'.
Sprake added that 'this episode underscores a recurring concern: the economic cost of policy uncertainty and reactive governance.'
National Treasury's backtracking of an increase followed the start of a court case on Tuesday in which both the Democratic Alliance and Economic Freedom Fighters – political polar opposites – took Godongwana as well as the South African Revenue Service to court to get the increase reversed. The parties had argued that the increase would harm the poor.
IOL Business
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
20 hours ago
- IOL News
The challenges facing South Africa's property market amid global uncertainty
Last week's repo rate cut will help boost the South African property sector a little bit. Image: Picture: Ayanda Ndamane/African News Agency (ANA) The property sector struggles when there is much international and local uncertainty such as that seen in the first quarter of this year. The first quarter gross domestic product (GDP) number is bad at only 0.1% growth, said Professor Waldo Krugell, an economist within the School of Economic Sciences at North West University (NWU). He said the property sector is captured under gross fixed capital formation which saw contractions in residential buildings (-5.8% and contributing -0.6 of a percentage point) as well as construction works (-2.8% and contributing -0.5 of a percentage point). Going forward, Krugell said last week's repo rate cut will help a little bit. However, he said that what is needed is more government of national unity (GNU) reform momentum and some tangible results from implementation. South African bond yields dropped sharply by the end of trade on Wednesday after Parliament passed the National Budget, boosting market confidence in Treasury's ability to tighten control over fiscal management, while the SARB's support for a lower inflation target promotes inflation control and stability, said Bianca Botes, the Director at Citadel Global. She said that markets remain cautious ahead of key US data due to be released on Friday, which could offer fresh direction. 'Recent figures show a slight slowdown in US economic activity, suggesting that tariffs and ongoing uncertainty are weighing on US growth. 'Nonetheless, global equities hit a record high on Wednesday, as investors bet that the volatility sparked by President Trump's 'Liberation Day' declaration might be behind them,' Botes said. Krugell noted with interest, reports of the commercial property sector doing much better in the Western Cape than elsewhere in the country, simply because the economy there is doing much better. 'The need for reform and better service delivery has a distinct spatial character. It underscores the importance of the work of Operation Vulindlela 2.0,' he said. Correlating strongly with City of Cape Town reports of a record-breaking summer tourism season, international property buyers have invested in record numbers in the city's hotspots, according to the Seeff Property Group. Propstats data shows that sales worth almost R2.5 billion were concluded in the first five months of this year, the highest in the last half-a-decade. The total value for the whole of 2024 amounted to R3.4 billion, and it was similar in the prior year, 2023. Sales to international buyers were said to have reached a record R600 million in February, and R700 million in April across the whole city. More than two thirds (67%) of the total value were generated by sales across the Atlantic Seaboard and City Bowl. Ross Levin, licensee for Seeff Atlantic Seaboard, said sales activity has been up quite notably this year. For the Atlantic Seaboard alone, he said sales to international buyers amount to about R530 million for April. Overall, there were sales in just about all of the suburbs. The highest values recorded are in Camps Bay and Bantry Bay, and the highest volumes in Sea Point (27) and the CBD (32). Buyers from more than 40 countries invested in property across the Cape this year. The highest volume was attributable to buyers from Germany, followed by the UK, Netherlands, Switzerland, and other European countries. There has also been a notable uptick in sales to American buyers who bought predominantly in Sea Point, Bantry Bay, Mouille Point and in the City Bowl. Buyers from other African countries have also made a welcome return, including some 12 countries, being Angola, Cameroon, Congo, Eswatini, Gabon, Ghana, Mauritius, Mozambique, Namibia, Nigeria, Tanzania, and Zambia, with Nigeria being the stand-out in terms of the volume of sales. Levin said the whole market across the Atlantic Seaboard and City Bowl has been very active and there was a shortage of stock, thus presenting good opportunities for sellers right now. Notable recent Seeff sales to foreign buyers include two sales to German buyers at R21 million in Camps Bay and R29 million at the Waterfront as well as a R29.5 million sale at the Waterfront to a buyer from Eswatini. Other areas where international buyers have been active include Constantia and Bishopscourt in the Southern Suburbs, False Bay areas such as Muizenberg and Fish Hoek, Southern Peninsula suburbs such as Kommetjie and Scarborough, Hout Bay, and Blouberg, where Marlene Picksley, an agent with Seeff Blouberg concluded a record sale of R16.5 million at Sunset Beach to a buyer from the US. Hout Bay has seen particularly strong demand from international buyers, with as much as 37 sales to buyers from a number of different countries, especially Germany, Netherlands, UK, Denmark, and other European buyers, and the US. According to Stephan Cross, manager for Seeff Hout Bay and Llandudno, the buyers spent between R5 million to R25 million. He said the Hout Bay market has been particularly hot this year with high sales activity and a shortage of stock, thus presenting good opportunities for sellers.
The Citizen
a day ago
- The Citizen
Political events happening in June expected to affect South African SMEs
'The fuel levy increases will compound existing cost pressures for SMEs, particularly those in logistics, manufacturing, and retail sectors that rely heavily on transportation.' June will provide some relief for Small and medium enterprises (SMEs) following the South African Reserve Bank's (SARB) Monetary Policy Committee's (MPC) decision to cut interest rates by 25 basis points. Another relief is that inflation is largely stable, and the exchange rate is trending favourably, giving the MPC some room for monetary easing. The economy needs every bit of help it can get, and this cut will no doubt be reflected in business confidence. Miguel da Silva, group executive for business banking at TymeBank noted how upcoming events will impact South Africa's position in a rapidly evolving global landscape and the effect of this reconfiguration on SMEs. ALSO READ: Reserve Bank cuts repo rate thanks to lower inflation, stronger rand Budget treads tricky course without cutting expenditure 'The national budget outlined a programme of continued expenditure propped up by less contentious funding mechanisms than previously tabled,' said Da Silva. After much debate, the Value Added Tax (VAT) rate will remain at 15%, providing certainty for SME pricing and cash flow planning following the proposed increase's withdrawal. To make up the shortfall, the general fuel levy has increased by 16 cents per litre for petrol and by 15 cents per litre for diesel. 'The fuel levy increases will compound existing cost pressures for SMEs, particularly those in logistics, manufacturing, and retail sectors that rely heavily on transportation.' With many small businesses already operating on razor-thin margins, this 16-cent increase represents an additional burden that will likely be passed on to consumers, potentially dampening demand in an already constrained market. ALSO READ: GDP grew marginally in first quarter – agriculture helped keep economy afloat First quarter GDP figures 'The Minister also revised his predictions for our economic growth to 1.4% in 2025, down from 1.9%. With the official unemployment rate now at 32.9%, the disconnect between our economic ambitions and the harsh reality that only 16.8 million South Africans are in active employment highlights the urgent need for policy innovation,' he added. Da Silva said what seems clear is that under these constrained market conditions, there is no way for established businesses to incorporate the millions of South Africans seeking employment. There is far greater potential for entrepreneurs to create new jobs, and a focus on small business support and development must be prioritised. 'SME funding will remain an important area of discussion and entrepreneurs; funders and public-sector representatives will meet to discuss the state of small business funding in South Africa at the SME SA Funding Summit 2025 on 12 June – but even more important is the creation of an environment which is conducive to entrepreneurship: less red tape and dependable infrastructure.' ALSO READ: Tariffs and Agoa: How Parks Tau summarised US-SA trade talks Agoa forum in DRC The relationship between SA and the US remains fraught, but at least there is dialogue. 'Apart from the Presidential meeting in the Oval Office, trade, industry and competition minister Parks Tau and agriculture minister John Steenhuisen have submitted a new trade framework to US trade representative Jamieson Greer. 'There are key areas where US investment might help us unlock value at home, and which might appeal to the deal-centric nature of the US administration. Developing a domestic source of natural gas would bolster SA's regional competitiveness and energy security, and we remain a key source of scarce minerals,' he added. The annual conference on the African Growth and Opportunity Act (Agoa) between trade ministers of Agoa-eligible countries and the US is scheduled to take place in the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC) in June. This will be an important indicator of what the US will do when Agoa expires in September 2025, though it seems unlikely at this stage that SA's Agoa benefits will be extended. While the overall impact of losing Agoa would not be immense for SA, some sectors – particularly the automotive and agricultural sectors – would be significantly affected. Both sectors have extensive value chains, and SME suppliers are rapidly adjusting their operations. 'The potential loss of Agoa benefits creates particular uncertainty for SME suppliers in the automotive value chain, many of whom have built their business models around preferential access to US markets. 'These companies now face the complex challenge of either finding alternative markets or restructuring their operations to remain competitive under standard trade terms.' ALSO READ: Analysts say Trump's bid to weaken Brics will fail as US influence declines Brics summit in Brazil Da Silva added that the Brics Summit, scheduled to take place in Brazil in early July, will again put SA in the US crosshairs, as provocative issues (such as an alternative to the dollar as the world's reserve currency) will be raised and debated by Brics countries. 'The timing could not be more delicate. For SMEs, particularly those in export-oriented sectors, this diplomatic tightrope walk translates into very real business planning challenges. 'Where do allegiances lie in a rapidly shifting global order? This geopolitical balancing act requires SMEs to develop strategies that can withstand diplomatic volatility while capitalising on emerging opportunities within both Western and Brics markets.' NOW READ: Political uncertainties that will impact SMEs in the coming months
TimesLIVE
a day ago
- TimesLIVE
'I won't be left behind': UKZN first in SA to give AI smart glasses to visually impaired students
UKZN disability support unit head Amith Ramballie said the technology reflects the university's commitment to inclusion and equity. 'UKZN is proud to lead the way in implementing advanced assistive technology that speaks to the needs of our diverse student body. These glasses not only reflect our commitment to accessibility but also our belief in every student's right to learn, grow and succeed independently. 'This milestone is particularly significant because no other university in South Africa offers students access to this device.' Envision Glasses feature a high-definition camera that captures visual data from printed pages to street signs and processes it through an AI algorithm, delivering real-time audio cues via speakers discreetly placed near the ear. The glasses support more than 60 languages and connect seamlessly to smartphones. Sensory Solutions' Mukthar Khan praised the partnership, calling UKZN 'the ideal launch partner for this technology in South Africa'. He lauded the university's 'genuine commitment to inclusion' and urged the students to make the most of their new tools. 'It is now up to you to use this remarkable piece of technology to reach your goals — from academic success to personal and professional growth — we hope these glasses bring you more ease, freedom and joy in your studies.' The selection process for recipients involved a comprehensive assessment by disability support unit staff, taking into account factors such as the severity of impairment, academic demands, independence levels and financial circumstances. 'The impact of the glasses extends far beyond the classroom. Imagine being able to read a printed timetable independently for the first time, confidently find your way to a lecture venue or recognise your lecturer or classmates in a crowd,' said Ramaballie. The R75,000 hi-tech glasses were donated by Sensory Solutions to the university, courtesy of the UKZN Foundation.
