Too much too young?: Swimming's dilemma over 12-year-old schoolgirl
The prodigious Chinese schoolgirl is not just making up the numbers at the event in Singapore this week.
Yu qualified for Monday's final of the 200m individual medley and came fourth, missing out on a remarkable medal by just 0.06sec in what is not considered her strongest event.
The race was won by Canada's Summer McIntosh — she competed at the Tokyo Olympics as a 14-year-old and last summer in Paris won three golds at age 17.
Yu was at it again on Wednesday in Singapore, racing alongside comparative veteran McIntosh to reach the finals of the 200m butterfly.
Yu, who turns 13 in October, will also race in the 400m medley later this week.
Like a fish in water
The Chinese prodigy, who discovered swimming aged six as a way to cool off in China's roasting summers, has drawn historical comparisons to Inge Sorensen.
At 12, the Dane was the youngest-ever winner of an Olympic swimming medal after her bronze at the Berlin Games of 1936.
More recently, there was Bahrain's Alzain Tareq, who was 10 when she competed at the swimming world championships in Kazan, Russia, in 2015.
Unlike Yu, however, she never came close to a medal. Asked this week if she was a 'genius', Yu replied: 'No, not really. It's all the result of hard training.'
While Yu's performances have been impressive and could well yield a medal, not everyone thinks she should be competing in Singapore.
Some in the sport have raised questions about the impact on Yu mentally and physically of high-level training and competing at an age when she is still developing as a person.
Under current World Aquatics rules, the minimum age is 14 but younger swimmers can compete at the championships if — like Yu — they are fast enough.
Christian Hansmann, sports director of German swimming, called her participation in Singapore 'questionable'.
'Putting a girl of 12 in front of a world championship crowd of 5,000 spectators, with the high pressure from the media and the coaches, is far too early in my opinion,' said Hansmann, who has children of a similar age.
French swimmer Lilou Ressencourt admitted it '[upsets me] to be beaten by a girl 10 years younger than me', and said she was surprised by how fast Yu is at such a young age.
Putting a girl of 12 in front of a world championship crowd of 5,000 spectators, with the high pressure from the media and the coaches, is far too early in my opinion"
Christian Hansmann, Sports Director Of German Swimming
She too fears for Yu's physical and mental well-being. 'I'm 22 and handling world championships, even French championships, can be difficult,' Ressencourt told AFP.
'I tell myself that at 12, you have a heavy responsibility... it's not normal at 12 to have that kind of pressure.'
Yu's presence in Singapore could force a rethink of the rules at World Aquatics, the sport's governing body.
Executive director Brent Nowicki admitted they had been surprised that someone as young as Yu had been fast enough to qualify.
Nowicki said World Aquatics 'feel quite good about where we are with our safeguarding approach in our sport', but admitted that Yu could force a re-evaluation of its rules.
'She's great. I mean, there's a big future there for her. Hopefully, there could be good things that could happen out of this, and it could be great,' he said.
But he added: 'Obviously we have to make sure that that's what it is, right? We don't want to tip that balance and go the other way, and we have to be careful about that.'
Finding balance
Many other sports have wrestled with the same age issue.
In 2022, for instance, ice skating's governing body voted to raise the minimum age for senior competition from 15 to 17, months after an Olympics drug scandal involving Russian teenager Kamila Valieva.
Katarina Witt, who was 18 when she won Olympic skating gold at the 1984 Sarajevo Games for East Germany, said the change was 'primarily protecting the female athletes from their sometimes over-ambitious managers'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Khaleej Times
a day ago
- Khaleej Times
McIntosh signs off from stellar world championships with fourth gold
Summer McIntosh capped a brilliant world championships with the 400 metres individual medley (IM) title and a fourth individual gold medal while Leon Marchand roared to victory in the men's event in Singapore on Sunday. The United States set a world record in the women's 4x100 medley relay to claim the final title and ensure they topped the medals table with nine golds, one ahead of Australia. France finished third with Canada fourth, all four of their golds won by 18-year-old McIntosh, only the third swimmer to win five individual medals at a world championships, joining Michael Phelps (2007) and Sarah Sjostrom (2019). World record holder McIntosh blitzed the field in the 400 IM with a time of 4:25.78, more than seven seconds ahead of joint silver medallists Jenna Forrester of Australia and Japan's Mio Narita. The Olympic champion's third 400 IM world title added to her 200 IM, 200 butterfly and 400 freestyle golds at the World Aquatics Championships Arena in Singapore. But bronze in the 800 freestyle won by the great Katie Ledecky on Saturday gave McIntosh little joy. "I think it was very obvious that my goal was five golds," she said. "Even if I were to get five golds, I would still want more. That's just my mentality." China's 12-year-old prodigy Yu Zidi finished just off the podium again in the 400 IM, capping a sparkling debut at a global meeting. She was also fourth in the 200 IM and 200 butterfly. Olympic champion Marchand nearly missed the 400 IM final after a slow heat in the morning but was back to his best in the evening, clocking 4:04.73 to finish well clear of Japan's Tomoyuki Matsushita, the Paris Games runner-up. It was a stripped-back programme from Paris where Marchand won four individual titles but he made Singapore count, taking the 200 IM world record on the way to the title. Two years after Tunisia's Ahmed Hafnaoui won the 800 and 1,500 freestyle at the Fukuoka championships, compatriot Ahmed Jaouadi completed the double by winning the 1,500 in 14:34.41 on the final day ahead of German runner-up Sven Schwarz and American Olympic champion Bobby Finke. Jaouadi shaved nearly nine seconds off his personal best. Australian relay stalwart Meg Harris grabbed the spotlight for herself when she won 50 freestyle gold in 24.02 ahead of Chinese duo Wu Qingfeng (24.26) and Cheng Yujie (24.28). The 23-year-old Harris clinched her first individual title on the global stage after sharing two Olympic and five world relay golds in the last four years. No Russian athletes competed at last year's world championships in Doha but the nation's swimmers racked up medals in Singapore under a neutral flag. Russians were allowed to compete on condition they had not publicly supported the invasion of Ukraine or held any affiliation to the Russian military. Russian Kliment Kolesnikov stormed to the men's 50 backstroke title in 23.68, just 0.13 off his world record, while compatriot Pavel Samusenko took a silver along with South African Pieter Coetze, each finishing in 24.17. Russian swimmers then combined to win a shock gold in the men's 4x100 medley, giving the world record (3:26.78) a huge shake with a time of 3:26.93, a second clear of France. With the US men taking bronze it was up to the nation's women to secure top spot on the medals table in the final event of the night by beating Australia. They did just that and in some style, with Regan Smith, Kate Douglass, Gretchen Walsh and Torri Huske combining to set a world record of 3:49.34, improving on the US mark of 3:49.63 from the Paris Games. World record holder Ruta Meilutyte earlier powered to the 50 breaststroke gold in 29.55, nearly half a second clear of China's Tang Qianting. It was the Lithuanian's fourth successive world title in the event since returning from a two-year ban for anti-doping violations. Retiring American Lilly King, who won the 100 breaststroke at the Rio 2016 Games, bowed out fifth in her last individual event. King's teammates were proud of the US performance at the event after several of the team's swimmers suffered gastroenteritis from a pre-meeting camp in Thailand. "I'd say Team USA always knows how to finish with a bang," said Douglass. "It just sends a really positive message out to the viewers at home who didn't really believe in us."
Khaleej Times
a day ago
- Khaleej Times
Departing Spurs captain Son in tears on emotional evening
Departing Tottenham captain Son Heung-min was in tears and his team-mates threw him in the air on an emotional evening in his native South Korea on Sunday. Spurs drew 1-1 with Newcastle in a pre-season friendly in Seoul but that was secondary to the farewell for the 33-year-old attacker. In what could have been his final game for the north Londoners, Son played 65 minutes but did not score at Seoul World Cup Stadium, a day after announcing his decision to leave Tottenham this summer after a decade. He left the pitch to a thunderous ovation from nearly 65,000 fans, hugging his teammates and even his opponents. The South Korean captain was caught offside twice in the early going, as his teammates tried to create opportunities for him, but didn't really assert himself on the match otherwise. Son was replaced in the 65th minute by Mohammed Kudus and he walked off in tears as thousands of fans chanted his name. "I didn't think I was going to cry at first," Son said. "But after hearing a few words from my teammates, leaving the club I've spent so much time with felt really tough. "I felt really, really happy playing this match. Thanks to my fans, my teammates and also my opponents, I've had an unforgettable day.' Son, who has been linked with LAFC in Major League Soccer, declined to reveal his next destination, saying: "Nothing has been finalised." Tottenham coach Thomas Frank said he enjoyed the "unbelievable, beautiful scenes" Son had with players from both sides on his way off the pitch. Newcastle boss Eddie Howe said his players' reaction to the end of Son's night had not been planned ahead. "I think it was very instinctive from the players,' Howe said. "I think that speaks volumes for him as a person and him as a footballer that both teams recognise the way he's played the game." The 33-year-old Son, who is under contract until 2026, is set to leave Spurs after a decade. He led Spurs to their first trophy in 17 years with their win over Manchester United in the Europa League final in May. Brennan Johnson's right-footed strike opened the scoring for Tottenham in the fourth minute, and the Welsh forward paid homage to Son by mimicking the South Korean star's camera celebration. Harvey Barnes levelled in the 38th minute, beating Antonin Kinsky with a right-footed shot that went in off the post.
Khaleej Times
a day ago
- Khaleej Times
Miffed with WCL after India's withdrawal, Pakistan pull out of future editions of tournament
The Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) has officially announced that it will no longer participate in any future editions of the World Championship of Legends (WCL), raising concerns about the tournament's fairness, integrity, and political neutrality, The Nation reported, citing the PCB. "The championship's handling of events appeared to be under invisible pressures," the PCB noted. "The apology issued later seemed motivated by a specific form of nationalism, making it difficult for us to continue our participation," it added. The decision was taken during a Board of Governors meeting, chaired by PCB Chairman Mohsin Naqvi. According to The Nation, the board pointed to "double standards and politically motivated actions." One of the most contentious issues raised by the board was the decision to award points to a team that had voluntarily forfeited a match, a move the PCB claimed as "highly questionable" and against the spirit of fair competition. The board further criticised the press release put out by WCL organisers after the India-Pakistan match was called off. It termed the communication "politically charged and prejudiced." The PCB said it would not take part in any event where the values of neutrality and fair play are undermined. The board made it clear that it will not be associated with tournaments that allow external agendas to dictate the course of the game. Earlier, the EaseMyTrip Co-founder Nishant Pitti has clarified that it will not be associated with any India-Pakistan match in the World Championship of Legends (WCL). The company clarified its stance, stating that despite entering into a 5-year sponsorship agreement with WCL two years ago, it will not associate with or participate in any match involving Pakistan. Pitti took to his X account to express support for the Indian team, while explaining the company's position. "India vs Pakistan - WCL Semi-Final. We applaud Team India @India_Champions for their outstanding performance in the World Championship of Legends. You've made the nation proud. However, the upcoming semi-final against Pakistan is not just another game. Terror and cricket cannot go hand in hand," Pitti said in his post. He further added, "@EaseMyTrip, we stand with India. We cannot support any event that attempts to normalise relations with a country that promotes terrorism. The people of India have spoken and we hear them. EaseMyTrip will not be associated with the India vs Pakistan match in WCL. Some things are bigger than sport. Nation first, business later. Always. Jai Hind." Relations between India and Pakistan have deteriorated sharply following the deadly April 22 terror attack at Pahalgam in the Indian-administered Kashmir. India blamed Pakistan for the attack — an allegation strongly rejected by the Pakistan government — which killed 26 civilians. What followed was a four-day military conflict between the two nuclear-armed South Asian neighbours in May before a ceasefire was announced. Meanwhile, South Africa Champions (197/1 in 16.5 overs) won the final on Saturday with a comprehensive nine-wicket victory over Pakistan Champions (195/5 in 20 overs). Ab de Villiers (120 not out off 60 balls, 12 fours and 6 sixes) was the hero for South Africa Champions who chased down the target of 195 with 19 balls and eight wickets in hand. For Pakistan, Sharjeel Khan had top-scored with 76 off 44 balls. Earlier, the South Africans beat Australia Champions in the semifinal, while Pakistan advanced to the final after India forfeited their semifinal. This was the second edition of the tournament, with India Champions winning the inaugural event last year.
