Reports consultant referred patients to private clinic should be ‘followed up'
Reports that an investigation found a consultant had breached guidelines by referring public patients to his own private clinic are 'very worrying' and need to be 'followed up', the Taoiseach has said.
Micheál Martin said that Minister for Health Jennifer Carroll MacNeill was 'strengthening' governance within Children's Health Ireland (CHI).
Advertisement
He was speaking after a report in the Sunday Times suggested that an internal investigation led by the CHI found that the consultant was paid thousands of euro through the state's National Treatment Purchase Fund.
Speaking in Killarney on Monday, Mr Martin said: 'I read that report yesterday.
'I think it's very worrying, and I know that the Minister for Health is already working in terms of strengthening governance within CHI, and there are a number of appointments from the HSE board to the board of CHI.
'That needs to be followed up, that issue, in addition to the report that was published late last week in respect of the surgeries for dysplasia, where it transpired that quite a number of them, particularly in Temple Street and in Cappagh, did not meet the criteria that the author of the report had set as a reasonable criteria to justify surgical intervention.
Advertisement
'I think these are very, very serious issues that we will continue to follow up on in respect of CHI more generally.'
HSE chief Bernard Gloster has said the CHI being fully subsumed into the HSE was an option being considered amid concerns around clinical care and governance.
Last week, an audit of the CHI identified that many children underwent 'unnecessary' hip surgeries in two Dublin hospitals.
The clinical audit of dysplasia of the hips surgery in children found that a lower threshold for operations was used at CHI Temple Street Hospital and the National Orthopaedic Hospital Cappagh (NOHC) than the threshold used at CHI Crumlin.
Advertisement
The review found that in the period 2021 to 2023, almost 80 per cent of children operated on at the NOHC, and 60 per cent of those at Temple Street, did not meet the threshold for surgery.
Mr Gloster said 2,259 children who underwent hip surgeries in the three hospitals (NOHC, CHI Temple Street and CHI Crumlin) from as far back as 2010 will now be subject to clinical reviews.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
an hour ago
- The Sun
‘Such a shame' as promising jockey forced to retire aged 23 on ‘medical advice'
PROMISING jockey Gearoid Harney has been forced to retire from racing aged just 23 on 'medical advice'. The conditional rider 'kept getting concussed' when he fell and suffered a heavy crash at Fakenham in January. 1 Harney was rushed to hospital for urgent care and racing was abandoned soon after his slip from David Pipe's Micronormous. Unfortunately, while he made a recovery from that incident, doctors had advised him to stop racing altogether. A post from Pipe said on X: "Wishing conditional jockey Gearoid Harney @Gearoid84997068 the very best for the future as he unfortunately will not be returning to the saddle following his fall in January on medical advice. "He rode ten winners for me, the highlight being Kingston Queen's Listed Bumper success." Pipe added: "The scans showed there was still some damage there and it wasn't right for him to get his licence back. The decision was in their hands. "He kept getting concussed when he fell and the IJF have been very supportive, so he'll have to have a think about what he'll do in the future." Punters were quick to offer Harney their support, with some saying it was a great 'shame' he had been forced out. A post from Irish Racing referenced the tragic death of Michael O'Sullivan in a race earlier this year as a reminder of the dangers jockeys face every day. The message read: "We wish Irish jockey Gearoid Harney all the best as he is forced to retire due to a severe head injury from a fall at Fakenham in January. "In a challenging year for our sport, marked by the tragic passing of Michael O'Sullivan, this incident further highlights the risks jockeys face." . Remember to gamble responsibly A responsible gambler is someone who:
BreakingNews.ie
2 hours ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Government need to implement safeguarding legislation in nursing homes
The chairperson of Safeguarding Ireland, Patricia Rickard-Clarke, has repeated a call on the government to establish an interdepartmental interagency working group to implement the recommendations of the Law Reform Commission's report from April 2024, which set out the policy changes that needed to be made to implement safeguarding legislation. Ms Rickard-Clarke was responding to an RTÉ exposé into two nursing homes where residents were manhandled and ignored for long periods of time. Advertisement 'I am very disturbed and very distressed and very, very angry about this,' she told RTÉ radio's Morning Ireland. 'We're 20 years after Leas Cross. We have gone backwards, I think.' While Leas Cross had been closed down advances had not been made in terms of what to do or what we should be doing, she said. 'There are questions to be answered by Hiqa. I would say, though, that in relation to Hiqa, one of the limitations it has is that it doesn't have the function of taking individual complaints or concerns. It looks at systemic issues, and it goes in on an irregular basis, and also, there was a delay in responding to a particular request (by a whistleblower).' 'That's just not acceptable. It's not acceptable even if there's one person being abused; that is a serious incident that should be followed up immediately.' Advertisement The implementation of the recommendations about safeguarding would provide a legal framework, she said. 'At the moment, we're working to a HSE limited policy, which is run by the HSE by safeguarding and protection teams, but it is limited to healthcare issues. 'There are much wider issues in safeguarding, and again, there are offences that should be implemented straight away. The Law Reform Commission sets out a number of offences that straight away could be enacted under criminal law. "This is the Department of Justice responsibility. So, an offence of intentional or reckless abuse and neglect or ill treatment, an offence for exposure to serious harm, an offence of endangerment. The criminal law it's all set out in the 2024 Bill. Advertisement 'We need what Safeguarding Ireland has recommended, which is the establishment of an independent adult safeguarding authority which will have functions and roles in relation to adult safeguarding to protect people from abuse. It would have the function of receiving reports of suspected abuse or actual abuse, and it would have the statutory function of responding to those abuses." Meanwhile, the CEO of The Alliance, a trade association for the nursing home sector in Ireland, Shane Scanlan, has said he was 'utterly shocked and appalled' by the RTÉ exposé. 'As a nurse myself and the director of nursing for over 10 years, you just really feel for the residents and families that have been affected by this,' he told Newstalk Breakfast. Mr Scanlon paid tribute to nurse Claire Doyle who was the 'whistleblower' who approached RTÉ and made protected disclosures. Advertisement 'The real question is, what if she never went to RTÉ with those protective disclosures, that she met and her students met, still went into Hiqa months before that? And it's a very brave thing she did, because it's not easy to pick up the phone or put something in writing and whistle blow. "And in her own words, she said, 'from my point of view, within the system, I cannot blow the whistle any louder. No one is listening.' So, fair play to her in fairness. She's really called out what's happened here.' The effectiveness of Hiqa had to be questioned, he added. Hiqa had been set up in the wake of the Leas Cross nursing home controversy to prevent such abuse from happening again. 'It's clear to us that they have failed to deliver on what they were set up to do. And there will be calls for further powers to be given to Hiqa, the Office of the Chief Inspector of Social Services, and that's not the answer here. Advertisement 'I'd be calling for an immediate, independent, root and branch review of how Hiqa carries out their inspections and their methodology. Because inspectors clearly need to spend more time observing care, speaking with staff, speaking to residents. "There's a huge amount of agency staff that's currently being used by Hiqa. Last year alone, they spent €1.89 million on agency staff. And you'd be wondering, what are agency staff doing within that organisation? "As I've said, a full review of the current leadership of Hiqa and its effectiveness needs to happen. And off the back of this scandal, you have the question, should there be some resignations here at the senior level?' Mr Scanlan called for stronger protection measures for those who make protected disclosures. How that person can be protected and what will happen immediately afterwards. 'I think there's a taboo still in Ireland about making a protected disclosure for the fear of what will happen afterwards. You know, you might be in a job, you may be thinking down the line of a future career, will this get out in the public? We need to really look at that as a country.'
BBC News
2 hours ago
- BBC News
Coming out as gay 'daunting' - Armagh All-Ireland winner Shields
Armagh's Mark Shields admits coming out as a gay inter-county footballer was "daunting", but says it was "important to tell my own story" as he publicly discussed his sexuality for the first time. An All-Ireland winner with the Orchard County in 2024, Shields spoke about coming out in the GAA world at the Gaelic Players Association's annual Pride Bunch last weekend. Shields is the first active male inter-county player to speak about being gay since former Cork hurler Donal Og Cusack, while Tyrone club footballer Kevin Penrose spoke about his experience on The GAA Social earlier this says he hopes his story will help young Gaelic games players who are struggling to express their sexuality."I feel it's just important to tell my own story of 12-15 years playing inter-county, my experience of coming through the ranks, being a senior inter-county player in the male GAA environment," said Shields in a video posted on the GPA's Instagram account."It was a daunting task coming out, whenever it was, about 10-12 years. The culture has changed within society, within the group in Armagh. I feel that I can express myself more. The group are more accepting."The language used around the group is changing. There's people standing up for people, for myself in the group, whereas maybe that didn't happen that much before. I think the culture is changing within the GAA itself." 'I hope telling my story will help younger players' Whitecross club-man Shields says some of the language previously used in changing rooms was "hurtful", but that he feels more supported within the GAA now. "It's been excellent to have allyships and people advocating for it in social media, and around GAA set-ups, and the GPA," he said."I hope speaking out and telling my story will help that younger player, be it male or female, non-binary to express themselves in the GAA environment."Shields added that speaking to his sister helped him before he came out. "I had to find someone I trusted in, that was my sister," he said."I spoke to my sister a lot, and would have a close relationship with her, my partner as well. It's finding that someone you trust and you want to express yourself to them."I found that very helpful whenever I was trying to tell my story and trying to come out. They were the ones that stood by me throughout and supported me whenever I felt down or low in the dumps or in a dark place."It doesn't have to be in front of a group; it can be a one-to-one conversation with someone. That's how I found it easier, to have that walk on the beach, in a forest or just chatting to someone over a coffee. That was the easiest way for myself."
