UnitedHealth faces a long and painful recovery
NEW YORK, May 13 (Reuters Breakingviews) - Even UnitedHealth (UNH.N), opens new tab will struggle to overcome parasitic medical costs that Warren Buffett once called a tapeworm eating away at U.S. economic competitiveness. The $300 billion healthcare conglomerate reinstalled, opens new tab Chairman Stephen Hemsley as CEO and yanked its financial guidance. After abruptly losing about half its market value, however, any potential recovery will be long and painful.
UnitedHealth stayed hardy for decades. From 2010 to 2020, its shares returned about 10 percentage points more per year than web search giant Alphabet. It capitalized on market power in insurance, growth in Medicare, the U.S. government program that covers medical costs for the elderly, and expansion into adjacent areas.
Such outperformance screeched to a halt, months after a senior UnitedHealth executive was assassinated, allegedly by a man outraged by insurer practices. The company's first-quarter profit fell considerably short of what analysts were expecting, sending the stock price reeling in April. It tumbled another 15% on Tuesday after the news that boss Andrew Witty was departing for personal reasons.
Hemsley, who served as CEO from 2006 to 2017, will be contending with new ailments. Although UnitedHealth is astoundingly profitable, evidenced by a 27% return on equity during the first three months of the year, both the company and the industry are in a much harsher spotlight. Intense public scrutiny makes it harder, opens new tab for insurers to restrain costs by, say, denying claims for care.
Medical expenditures also have returned to trend, growing faster than the U.S. economy. They increased 7.5% in 2023, according to official data. Proposed assistance from the Trump administration to double the increase in reimbursement rates, to 5%, for Medicare Advantage, the privately administered version of the government program, will go only so far.
It's also getting tougher to estimate costs for new Medicare Advantage patients. Part of the problem is that more than half of all Medicare participants have already enrolled. Insurers receive higher payments for sicker patients, but that incentivizes administrators to either select healthier customers or claim that they are ailing worse than they really are. The most profitable patients probably have been picked over.
Moreover, government largesse for private health insurers looks increasingly ripe for targeting. If Medicare Advantage reimbursements were cut to better reflect their risk, it would save the government more than $1 trillion, opens new tab by 2035, the Congressional Budget Office estimated. Helmsley may be forced to opt for radical surgery, which is always dangerous.
Follow @rob_cyran, opens new tab on X
CONTEXT NEWS
UnitedHealth said on May 13 that Chairman Stephen Hemsley would return as CEO, effective immediately, to replace Andrew Witty, who stepped down for personal reasons. Hemsley was previously in the role from 2006 to 2017.
The insurance company also suspended its 2025 guidance, blaming accelerating medical spending by patients and costs.
UnitedHealth shares were down 16%, to $318.93, at 1057 EDT.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NBC News
13 hours ago
- NBC News
Live updates: Trump is 'not interested' in a make-up call with Musk, White House official says
What to know today President Donald Trump is " not interested" in a call with billionaire Elon Musk to try to patch things up after their public blowup yesterday. Their feud, which started over the GOP domestic policy bill that incorporates much of Trump's agenda, has Republicans worried about potential collateral damage ahead of next year's midterms. Republican senators, for their part, are now looking for ways to cut Medicare in the GOP bill. The president, meanwhile, is expected to sign more executive orders this afternoon.
NBC News
18 hours ago
- NBC News
Donald Trump and Elon Musk's public feud and Planned Parenthood funding threats: Morning Rundown
Donald Trump and Elon Musk take their falling out onto social media for all to see. New federal jobs data are expected to mostly reflect economic stability, though the effects of tariffs are starting to show. And at least 200 Planned Parenthood clinics across the country are at risk of closing.. Here's what to know today. As Trump and Musk fight, Republican unity could become collateral damage A simmering fight between the world's most powerful man and the world's richest man spilled into public view yesterday, as President Donald Trump and Elon Musk traded attacks and threats online and in view of the world. Tensions rose a few days ago when Musk criticized the bill for Trump's agenda as a 'disgusting abomination.' Trump finally responded yesterday, telling reporters in the Oval Office that 'Elon knew the inner workings of the bill.' The president suggested Musk, who owns Tesla, was upset that the bill cut a tax credit meant to incentivize electric vehicle purchases. Musk and his allies bristled at the suggestion. Then, the online jabs began. Musk suggested Trump would have lost the 2024 election without Musk's massive donations. Trump implied the federal government could end the billions of dollars in contracts with Musk's companies, primarily SpaceX and Tesla. Musk, in response, claimed the president was in the so-called 'Epstein files.' Musk also suggested Trump should be impeached. The attacks didn't end there. It's clear, now, that the bromance between the two is dead and the collateral damage left in the feud's wake could last for weeks, months or even years. And Republicans are caught in the middle. In interviews with GOP lawmakers and operatives with ties to Congress, a clear theme emerged: Republicans should be scared of getting crosswise with either Trump or Musk. At stake are congressional leadership positions, the midterm elections and even the fate of Trump's agenda bill. Just a few months ago, Musk indicated he would put $100 million into political committees associated with Trump. That money never came and now, it won't, a Musk adviser said. 'He does not give a f--- about Republicans or the RNC, or House seats, or whatever,' the adviser said. 'He will blow them up; he will.' Republican Rep. Don Bacon, who represents a competitive Nebraska district, said of the fight: 'There's a good verse in Proverbs: 'Stay out of fights.' I'm staying out of this one.' More politics news: Senate Republicans are exploring the possibility of making cuts to Medicare 'waste, fraud and abuse' in Trump's agenda bill. And watch out for reactions from these seven senators as changes are made to the bill to get it through the Senate. A federal judge temporarily blocked Trump's efforts to deny visas to foreign students planning to attend Harvard University. The day after Trump's latest travel ban was announced, families, attorneys and immigration advocates expressed confusion and made accusations of discrimination by the Trump administration. Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping held a phone call and planned an in-person meeting 'shortly' amid ongoing tensions between the two countries. Trump has referred to the Joe Biden autopen allegations as 'the biggest scandal in American history,' while Biden has said the investigation is a 'distraction.' Here's what is and isn't known about the claims. The Supreme Court revived a woman's claim that she was discriminated against at work because she is straight, potentially making it easier for people in majority groups to bring such 'reverse discrimination' claims. Jobs data could reflect economic stability, for now The Bureau of Statistics will release its latest jobs data from May, and it's likely to show that some economic stability has persisted. Forecasts were 120,000 for new payrolls added in the last month, which most economists consider a healthy figure. But it would still represent the fewest monthly jobs created since February and fall below the 12-month average of about 150,000. Meanwhile, other data are already pointing to signs of a softening economy in the face of President Donald Trump's unprecedented tariffs. The Department of Labor's weekly jobless claims report, released yesterday, came in higher than expected. Private payroll processor ADP reported the weakest monthly jobs total since March 2023. And Mark Zandi, chief economist at Moody's Analytics, said forthcoming inflation readings are likely to reflect price increases due to tariffs. Read the full story here. Planned Parenthood clinics nationwide fear closures At least 20 Planned Parenthood clinics have closed or will close this year as the health care organization faces the same pressures as nearly all U.S. providers, like low insurance reimbursement rates, understaffing and rising costs. But things could get worse, as targeted cuts by the Trump administration threaten to throw the organization further into uncertainty. Earlier this year, federal funding to more than 100 clinics was frozen. And written into the House GOP-backed bill for Trump's agenda is a rule that would cut off Medicaid reimbursement to any nonprofit that meets three criteria, which Planned Parenthood does. That means if the bill is passed, another 200 of the roughly 600 Planned Parenthood locations nationwide will be in danger, the organization said. Planned Parenthood has already taken steps to adapt, like consolidating locations in some states and shuttering clinics in states that have historically voted in favor of abortion rights, such as Vermont. The resulting landscape leaves fewer health care options for patients. Read the full story here. amid ongoing Russian missile and drone attacks in Ukraine. The suspect in the Boulder firebombing was charged with 118 criminal counts in Colorado and could face more than 600 years in prison on attempted murder charges alone. The judge in Sean 'Diddy' Combs' federal trial threatened to throw the hip-hop mogul out of the courtroom after he was seen flashing facial expressions at jurors. The Indiana Pacers led for three-tenths of a second in Game 1 of the NBA Finals, enough to catapult them to a 111-110 victory over the Oklahoma City Thunder. For those who have been watching closely, such a dramatic win shouldn't be a surprise. Staff Pick: Fight night in China With so much focus on trade wars and U.S. tariffs on Chinese goods these days, it was refreshing to look at a uniquely American export to China: professional wrestling. On a recent Saturday night in Beijing, I attended 'The Battle of the Decade' organized by Middle Kingdom Wrestling, one of the few pro wrestling organizations here. It had all the hallmarks of a pro wrestling experience: rubbery costumes, body blows, and yes, some chair smashing, too. What I did not expect was that the man behind it all, a 37-year-old American living in China named Adrian Gomez, would be the antithesis of the supercharged showmanship typically attached to WWE-style wrestling and promoters like Vince McMahon. Easy-going and unfrazzled, Gomez politely troubleshot everything from sound checks to media passes. Then, when the music surged and the lights flashed, there he was ringside smiling as the room swelled with wrestling mayhem and raucous spectators. For 10 years, he had worked toward this night. This is not a story about trade or geopolitics. It is a glimpse at a small but dedicated community of pro wrestlers, their growing legion of Chinese fans, and the determination of a former English teacher turned unlikely wrestling promoter trying to make it all work in China. — Janis Mackey Frayer, Beijing-based correspondent NBC Select: Online Shopping, Simplified After eight years, the Nintendo Switch 2 is finally here with improved design, better internal specs and all new games. Here's everything you need to know about the release. Plus, there's a good chance you're not properly applying sunscreen. The NBC Select team spoke with dermatologists about the dos and don'ts and the best spray sunscreen options.
Daily Mail
a day ago
- Daily Mail
Walmart makes major change to help older Americans
Walmart has announced a new partnership with Medicare Advantage to help elderly Americans maximize their benefits. Walmart, the largest grocery chain in the US, announced that Americans on Medicare Advantage care - a form of health insurance for over 65s provided by private insurers - will now be able to plug in their benefit card information to their online Walmart accounts. This will allow shoppers to see which items sold by Walmart are eligible for coverage or discounts under their program. Many Medicare Advantage programs offer supplemental benefits that cover wellness products or over-the-counter medications. While the products covered varies by each individual plan, the types of items likely to be available include vitamins and weight management supplements. Around two-thirds of Americans on Medicare Advantage programs don't use their over-the-counter benefits, according to the Consumer Healthcare Products Association. This is largely because they are not aware of which products are covered by their plans. Under the new Walmart program, consumers will see a 'benefit program eligible' icon appear over products that are covered by their specific plan. Centrum 50 Plus Multivitamin $7.99 Products, including vitamins from leading brands, may be available under your plan. Shop For those that prefer to shop in store, eligible products will show up with the same icon when scanned in the app. A tracker will also be available in seniors' Walmart account which shows how much of their benefits they have left to spend. The pilot will allow users to 'track their benefits spending in real time and check out with a mixed basket of healthy food, over the counter (OTC) products and general merchandise for same-day pickup or delivery in as soon as an hour,' Walmart said in a statement. 'We saw an opportunity to streamline the health benefits shopping journey, make it easier for customers to discover eligible items and offer convenient pickup and delivery options that fit their busy schedule,' Walmart's Ralph Clare said of the initiative. As part of the program Walmart is also launching a new platform for benefit providers, Walmart Everyday Health Signals. The platform will allow providers such as Medicare Advantage programs to integrate directly with Walmart. Together the pooled information will give 'AI-enabled guidance that empowers participating customers to make health-conscious choices,' Walmart wrote on its website. However, critics have already hit out at Walmart's use of AI in shopping basket scanners at its Sam's Club warehouses. Consumers will see a 'benefit program eligible' icon appear over eligible products The new technology allows customers to walk straight out of the store without going through a checkout. The move is controversial because it uses a network of cameras and sensors to track shoppers and their carts. In addition, the checkout-free experience requires all customers to use a smartphone and download the store's app. This could pose a challenge to older shoppers who may struggle with technology.
