Former French officials cleared of accusations of pandemic mishandling
The decision comes five years after a top court in France opened an investigation into former Prime Minister Édouard Philippe, who stepped down in July 2020, as well as ex-health ministers Agnès Buzyn and Olivier Véran. They were accused of 'failing to fight disaster'.
Véran confirmed the decision in a post on the social media platform X.
'After years of proceedings, investigations, summonses, and public indictments, justice has spoken,' he wrote. 'We committed neither fault nor intentional failure'.
Véran replaced Buzyn as health minister in February 2020, when she resigned to run for mayor of Paris.
The Court of Justice of the Republic, the only French court that can investigate government officials while they are still in office, opened the case in July 2020 after receiving dozens of complaints from doctors, patients, law enforcement, and others about their response to the pandemic.
Chief among their complaints included shortages of masks and other equipment, as well as the decision to hold municipal elections on March 15, 2020, just a few days before French President Emmanuel Macron announced nationwide measures to prevent the spread of the virus.
Buzyn had also been indicted for endangering the lives of others in September 2021, but France's Court of Cassation dropped the charge in January 2023.
In his post on X, Véran said he had faced death threats and online misinformation during the probe into the 'hypothetical scandal'.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
LeMonde
32 minutes ago
- LeMonde
The strategic hurdles for France-UK military cooperation
French President Emmanuel Macron's three-day state visit to London, which ends on Thursday, July 10, is intended to address environmental, cultural, and migration issues. However, the visit will also have significant military undertones. French Defense Minister Sébastien Lecornu was to accompany the president throughout the trip, which is set to conclude with announcements at the Northwood military base north of London, a base that houses the Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) alliance's maritime operations command. Renewing military ties remains a challenge, even though the two countries' armed forces shared mutual respect and a strong culture of engagement – in Afghanistan and Iraq for the British, in the Sahel region of West Africa for the French. In the face of renewed challenges in Europe, both governments are seeking to highlight the strength of their partnership. They will hold a meeting on Thursday of the "coalition of the willing," the group of around 30 countries prepared to deploy military resources in Ukraine if a ceasefire is reached. However, options for deepening defense cooperation, including support for Ukraine, now appear limited.
LeMonde
2 hours ago
- LeMonde
Najat Vallaud-Belkacem: 'On migration issues, we would like those in power to stick to the numbers, facts and science'
Najat Vallaud-Belkacem, president of the France Terre d'Asile association which supports asylum seekers and former education minister, has published a book with economist Benjamin Michallet aimed at debunking common misconceptions about people fleeing persecution or death: Réfugiés. Ce qu'on ne nous dit pas ("Refugees: What We're Not Told"). On July 4, gendarmes slashed an inflatable boat full of migrants who were attempting to cross the Channel to reach England, claiming it was to "protect" them. Do you feel that French methods have become increasingly aggressive? Yes, and it's time to take stock of this militarization of the border, which is very expensive and has no effect: 20,000 people have crossed the Channel since January, compared to 12,000 in the same period in 2024. These methods are pushing even more people to want to reach the United Kingdom. The crossings are made even more dangerous – overcrowded boats, use of smugglers – with a record 78 deaths in 2024. Yet other solutions exist: In France, we could have a dignified reception, support for asylum or for unaccompanied minors under child welfare services; and in England, the opening of legal pathways from France (asylum, family reunification, work). When French Interior Minister Bruno Retailleau deployed 4,000 police officers and gendarmes over two days, June 18 and 19, to "arrest undocumented people," there was little reaction from society. Has the boundary of what is considered "acceptable" expanded?
LeMonde
4 hours ago
- LeMonde
UK and France to enable 'coordinated' nuclear deterrent
The UK and France will declare that the two nations' nuclear deterrents, while independent, can be coordinated and that they will jointly respond to any "extreme threat to Europe," both countries said Wednesday, July 9. The declaration, to be signed Thursday, July 10, will state that the respective deterrents of both countries remain under national control "but can be co-ordinated, and that there is no extreme threat to Europe that would not prompt a response by both nations," the UK's Ministry of Defence (MoD) and the French presidency said in an overnight statement. French President Emmanuel Macron will sign the agreement Thursday as he wraps up his three-day state visit to the UK with a bilateral summit, where the allies will "reboot" defence ties with a focus on joint missile development and nuclear co-operation. France's leader and UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer will co-host the London summit, with the two sides also expected to discuss maintaining support for Ukraine and curbing undocumented cross-Channel immigration. Ahead of the gathering, which follows two days of varied events spanning pomp and politics, trade and culture, France and Britain announced their "defence relationship" will be "refreshed". A new 'Entente industrielle' It will see London and Paris order more Storm Shadow cruise missiles − long-range, air-launched weapons jointly developed by the two countries and called SCALP by the French − while stepping up work on a replacement system. The missiles have been shipped to Ukraine in significant numbers in recent years to help Kyiv in its war with Russia. The new partnerships herald a new "Entente Industrielle" making "defence an engine for growth", said the MoD. "As close partners and NATO allies, the UK and France have a deep history of defence collaboration and today's agreements take our partnership to the next level," Starmer said in the statement. Starmer and Macron will also on Thursday dial into a meeting of the so-called "coalition of the willing" on Ukraine, a group of countries backing the embattled nation.
