AFL 2025: Essendon coach Brad Scott fears the future of big men due to a pair of rule changes
Scott joined the chorus of senior coaches wanting to abort the limited minutes player and move to five players on the interchange.
He said ruck rule changes and the need to select a more versatile player as the substitute is minimising the chances of a 'Nic Naitanui type ruckman'.
'We by definition are invested in our clubs and want what's best for our own club (but) I like to think we've all got a broader lens on the good of the game overall,' Scott said.
'What I would like to see is a really strong for and against having a sub, the argument around fairness, I don't see that argument – I didn't see it when I was at the AFL.
'My greatest concern around the sub is it creates all sorts of problem for player load, all sorts of problems for structure and balance of teams.
'I think ruck rule changes, we're very quickly breeding the Nic Naitanui type ruckman out of our game because you can't jump at centre bounces anymore.
'I genuinely can't remember the last time you saw two ruckman jump at each other for the course of a game.
'By having a sub it makes it very hard to have two ruckman, by having five on the bench I think more teams would at least look at it.'
Incoming football boss Greg Swann plans to meet with officials about shortening the amount of elapsed time the game is now running for.
He believes an immediate ball up instead of waiting for ruckmen to arrive could shorten the game by up to seven minutes.
While Scott favours with the craft of ruckmen, he is in favour of an immediate ball up and feels it may also contribute to playing a second tall.
'I think we should just do that instantly, I don't know why we wait, if the ruckman can't get there that's their issue,' he said.
'The reason you can play one ruck is because the umpires wait for the ruck; if he's not there, throw it up.
'There's nowhere in the rules does that says we have to wait for the ruckman to get there, if the ball was thrown up quicker and the ruckman couldn't get there, maybe clubs would think, 'gee maybe we might need two'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Perth Now
20 minutes ago
- Perth Now
The 'humble freak' St Kilda love and want to keep
St Kilda want Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera to stay "forever" but Saints teammate Hunter Clark says there will be no hard feelings if the matchwinning star returns to South Australia. Wanganeen-Milera wrote himself into St Kilda folklore at Marvel Stadium on Sunday, lifting the Saints to the biggest three-quarter-time comeback - 46 points - in VFL/AFL history. The silky 22-year-old kicked the final two goals in just 14 seconds of game time as St Kilda pinched a remarkable six-point victory over Melbourne. Wanganeen-Milera's soaring mark over Demons forward Bayley Fritsch to set up the game-equalling goal even prompted an emotional reaction of disbelief from usually solemn Saints coach Ross Lyon. Clark, who also produced some important moments late against Melbourne, was in awe at what Wanganeen-Milera achieved. "He's obviously got a really big decision, and he'll do what's best for himself, and there'll be no hard feelings either way," Clark told AAP. "Obviously we'd love him to stay forever; he's going to be, if he's not already, up there for one of the best players in the competition. "He's only 22 so I think his future is going to be so bright and he deserves everything that comes his way." Wanganeen-Milera remains unsigned for next season as he contemplates massive offers from Adelaide and Port Adelaide to play back in his home state. He was drafted with pick 11 out of Glenelg in 2021, playing 82 games for the Saints. St Kilda have also thrown a big contract in front of him as arguably the key player in the club's rebuild and bid for an elusive second premiership. Wanganeen-Milera, who had a game-high 34 disposals alongside his match-winning four goals, was in doubt to play against the Demons due to a stye in his eye. The club doctor called Lyon early on Sunday morning to let him know his best player was in doubt, but Wanganeen-Milera reassured his coach he would be fine. "He's an absolute freak," Clark said of his teammate's skill. "But he's such a good man. "The way he plays, almost you'd expect him to just be this real out there character, like he probably has every right to just strut around. "But he's the most humble bloke you'll come across. "He's an absolute freak of a talent, but he works as hard as anyone. It's not all just what you see on the field. "He's absolute star, and I think he's made for those moments." After just their second win since the start of May, St Kilda can take confidence out of their Marvel miracle into 2026. "If we can just finish the year strong, just keep getting experience into everyone and keep growing," Clark said. "Then just get to work over the summer. "It's not just going to happen in a day. "I see a lot of the teams over the last few years, it can take five or six years until you have gone through s**t, until you get there."
Daily Telegraph
4 hours ago
- Daily Telegraph
Melbourne Vixens stun NSW Swifts in preliminary final comeback, grand final vs West Coast Fever
Don't miss out on the headlines from Netball. Followed categories will be added to My News. Melbourne Vixens are riding high after a last ditch effort to beat the NSW Swifts by 66 to 65 points, to book their place in the 2025 Super Netball grand final. They came from behind in the dying seconds of the game, having trailed 51-41 after the third quarter, and will go into next week's match full of confidence having won eight of their last ten games. Watch every game of the 2025 Suncorp Super Netball season, LIVE on Kayo. New to Kayo? Join now and get your first month for just $1. Standing in their way however, will be the formidable West Coast Fever, who demolished the Swifts by 32 points in last weekend's major semi-final. Speaking post match captain and MVP Kate Moloney said, 'I'm exhausted but I'm so bloody proud. We were down by ten goals and we found something in that last quarter and they just never stopped fighting.' Coaching her second last match with the Vixens, Simone McKinnis, added, 'We weren't going to walk away from here afraid to take risks. They saw a glimpse and a hope and away they went.' It was the greatest preliminary final comeback in Super Netball history, beating the nine-goal market the Vixens set in 2022 against the Giants. It was a dismal end to the season for Swifts, despite the return of inspirational captain Paige Hadley who has missed the last two rounds with a foot injury. While she provided a calm head and safe pair of hands, the Swifts have been bundled out of the finals in straight sets, after looking untouchable as they went undefeated through the first eight rounds. Melbourne Vixens players celebrate. (Photo by) Simone McKinnis inspired her players. (Photo by) There was immense pressure from the opening whistle, causing fumbles, stray passes and uncharacteristic missed shots. The Swifts were first to take advantage of those errors, going long and high to Grace Nweke in the circle. Despite her athleticism, some balls were sprayed over her head or swatted away by goal keeper Rudi Ellis who finished with six gains, allowing the Vixens to shift gears and take a three point lead into the first break. The Swifts hit the front in the second quarter as their confidence grew, with Helen Housby raising the bar after a quiet few weeks. Passes started going in more smoothly to the circle, with Nweke lifting her shooting from a subpar 77 percent in the first quarter to a total of 53/58 at 91 percent across the match. With the Swifts' Sharni Lambden applying enormous pressure at wing defence, Vixens' skipper Moloney did everything she could to pull her side over the line. She had a strong connection with Sophie Garbin under the post, who picked up the slack while the hero of so many victories, Kiera Austin, struggled for influence early on. The Swifts couldn't believe it. (Photo by Mark) The Vixens seemed down and out of the contest with the deficit sitting at 11 points and their penalties twice their opponents, until Lily Graham sank consecutive supershots to bring the margin back to single digits. In an inspirational last quarter Austin finally switched on her radar when it counted, firing in three long range shots to finish with 12/16 including four from five supershots, while her partner Garbin had a solid 46/47. The Vixens found another gear and rolled over the Swifts in highly emotional scenes. MCKINNIS MAGIC Simone McKinnis will make her final appearance as Vixens' coach in next weekend's grand final, after 212 games in charge of the club. Across 13 years, she's taken them to two titles, three minor premierships and a further three grand final appearances, and will leave massive shoes to fill. It looked like it was going to be McKinnis' final game in charge at the end of the third quarter but an inspiration and emotional final address helped inspire the Vixens to life. 'We have nothing to lose here! Except for throwing our best selves as this contest,' McKinnis said. PAIN FOLLOWS A POINT Remarkably, the previous three Super Netball preliminary finals have been decided by a solitary point, with the Vixens taking out two of those wins, and the Swifts the other. Despite moving on into the grand final, neither side was then able to steal the ultimate victory. Originally published as Super Netball stunner as emotional speech sparks all-time Vixens comeback
News.com.au
5 hours ago
- News.com.au
Australia claim 4x100m relay double at World Swimming Championships
Cop that America, Australia have claimed the 4x100m relay double at the Singapore World Swimming Championships on Sunday. First up it was the women who locked horns with the Aussie quartet of Mollie O'Callaghan, Meg Harris, Milla Jansen and Olivia Wunsch taking to the pool. With two teenagers in Jansen and Wunsch in the team, America went into the final as the favourites but the stage didn't overawe the youngsters. After O'Callaghan and Harris got the Aussies off and running, it was the two youngsters who brought it home. In what was a neck and neck battle, it was Wunsch who produced the swim of her life to hunt down American Tori Huske and touch the wall first by only 0.44 seconds. Then it was over to the men who entered the final as heavy underdogs against the strength of the Italian and American squads. Flynn Southam, Kai James Taylor and Maximillian Giuliani gave it their all through the first three legs, but the Aussies were still stranded behind the Americans. Enter Kyle Chalmers. The sprint king produced a final leg for the ages as he hunted down his Italian and American rivals to touch the wall and hand Australia a commonwealth record and the gold medal. Earlier, Germany's Olympic champion Lukas Maertens won a thrilling 400m freestyle gold pipping Australia's Sam Short by 0.02sec. in a nailbiting finish. Maertens, who broke the world record earlier this year, came home in 3min 42.35sec after a fierce battle with Short, the 2023 world champion. South Korea's Kim Woo-min, the reigning world champion, was third in 3:42.60. Maertens was the favourite for the title after breaking the world record in Stockholm in April, a mark that had stood since 2009. But Short fought him every stroke of the way, losing out after an incredible tussle to the finish. 'I thought we were going a bit faster, to be honest,' Short told Channel 9 after the race. 'It's a high-pressure event. Two fast 400s in a day, really hard. I won two years ago by 0.02, and I just lost by 0.02. I'm happy to be back on the podium after a hard last year, so I can't complain. 'I didn't even know how I was going to go. All staging camp, or at least 75 per cent of it, I was in quarantine, I had Covid. A lot of mental strength that I've learned this year, I'm just stoked.' Short later went on to reveal that his aunty had recently passed away, dedicating his performance to her. 'This year has been really hard,' he said. 'No one really knows everything. I want to dedicate that performance to my aunty who just passed away a couple of weeks ago... it's been quite hard for my family recently... however bad I was hurting there, nowhere near as bad as her battling cancer the last 10 years.' The result gave Maertens his first world title after claiming Olympic gold in Paris last year. He followed that up by setting a new world record of 3:39.96, shaving 0.11sec off the mark achieved by fellow German Paul Biedermann at the world championships in Rome in July 2009. Biedermann's mark of 3:40.07 was achieved wearing a polyurethane swimsuit that has since been banned in competition. Short missed out on an Olympic medal in the event in Paris, finishing fourth. Australia's Elijah Winnington, the Paris Olympics silver medallist, surprisingly failed to qualify for the final. Short finished fastest in the morning heats ahead of Maertens.
