Royal Marines in DEI row over women on front line

Telegraph

29-04-2025

The Royal Marines have become embroiled in a row over the role of women on the front line.
In a highly unusual move, a serving member of the elite corps has publicly raised concerns about the possible lowering of standards for female trainees – and claimed that lives could be at risk if Britain goes to war.
The commando has claimed that up to 1,000 of his fellow Marines backed a private letter to military chiefs raising fears that so-called diversity, equality and inclusion (DEI) policies were in danger of creating an 'unrecognisable, weak and compromised version of the corps'.
The letter claimed that some women at the Commando Training Centre were being 'artificially pushed through training ', resulting in what was described as 'unearned paper-passes'.
In a video subsequently posted online, the commando – who does not give his name – said: 'We believe that we have the high standards that we keep for [a] very important reason, which is to prevent Marines from being killed in dangerous situations when we go to war... We are concerned that those standards are being dropped.'
He also alleges that after raising concerns with his chain of command about the lowering of physical fitness standards for female recruits, he was treated 'like a terrorist and a criminal'.
This included being briefly held by police under counter-terrorism legislation.
'I ask them: 'Am I being detained?' They say: 'No, you're not being detained, but we're holding you here under the Terrorism Act. And I'm just shaking my head in this instance. And I said: 'Have I committed any acts of terrorism? Am I expected to commit any acts of terrorism?' And they said: 'No, we have you here because of your views,'' he states in the video.
The ban on women serving in ground close combat roles was lifted by David Cameron, the prime minister at the time, in 2016.
Two years later, Gavin Williamson, the defence minister at the time, announced that all military roles, including those in the Marines, would be open to female recruits.
The Ministry of Defence denies any positive discrimination – pointing out that to date, not a single woman has met the gruelling physical standards required to earn the coveted green beret.
However, a number of women do serve in the elite corps in other roles, while hundreds of others are attempting to enter the service.
According to the commando, there is widespread concern privately within the corps that female trainees are passing elements of Marines training based on lower standards of performance.
In an attempt to demonstrate the strength of feeling among fellow commandos, some weeks ago, he circulated an anonymous petition to his peers. He claimed that it has received a flood of support.
'Full-on witch hunt'
In the online video, he said: 'That survey exploded in the Royal Marines. Within 24 hours, I can tell you that nearly a thousand people had signed up [to] that survey. Now why do I say within 24 hours? Because within 24 hours it was deleted. That survey was taken down.'
He said that after the letter and petition reached military chiefs, he was 'cautiously optimistic' it would be taken seriously.
Instead, he has accused the MoD of launching what he describes as a 'full-on witch hunt'.
He claimed that his superiors initially tried to blame the letter on 'Russian bots' before launching an investigation to identify who was behind the letter.
During the internal inquiry, he said that colleagues were made 'to feel like they would go to jail' if they did not give up his identity.
After handing himself in to his chain of command, he was flown from his military base – thought to be in Scotland – to MoD headquarters in London for what he describes as 'two-hour interrogation'.
'They tell me that they deal with security leaks. And they essentially try and make what is a genuine issue look like it was just some uppity Marines that are just being sexist, being evil... It's absurd because we wrote that in the survey, that we were concerned that... we will be painted as sexists. And that is exactly how they treated us. Telling me that I should be concerned for my career. Telling me that I should comply for the sake of myself and my family.'
'Thousands are concerned'
He claims that military officials showed no interest in the fundamental issue he raised, despite what he described as the 'vast majority' of the Marine Corps sharing his concerns.
'I asked them explicitly. 'So thousands of Marines are concerned about this issue. I'm concerned about this issue. I'm here representing these Marines now.' And that made me feel strong, to be honest... because I've had the backing of the vast majority of the Marine Corps. And I said: 'Are you looking into our concerns at all?' ... They said: 'Absolutely not... we are here to talk about you,'' he said.
During the two-hour discussion, he was told that questioning DEI policies could 'distress' female recruits currently going through marine training, he said in the video.
After questioning, he was allowed to return to his duties. However, he was subsequently detained for questioning under counter-terrorism legislation.
He claimed that officers from Police Scotland were waiting for him at immigration on his arrival at a Scottish airport following a family holiday.
The MoD does not deny that the commando was flown to London for questioning; nor that he was detained by Police Scotland under counter-terrorism legislation.
Whitehall sources have suggested that Police Scotland was concerned he may be linked to 'extreme far-Right politics.'
However, he was never arrested or charged, and continues to serve as a Royal Marine commando.
The MoD denies that as many as 1,000 Marines backed the petition. A Whitehall source described the figure as 'unverified'.