Major warning for SA's two-pot retirement system as repeat withdrawals SOAR
As South Africans adjust to the newly implemented two-pot retirement system, early warning signs suggest that the intended goal of safeguarding retirement savings may be undermined by a surge in repeat withdrawals.
Data from retirement fund administrators reveals that during the first two months of the 2025 tax year -March and April – roughly 75% of withdrawal applications were repeat claims, highlighting a troubling pattern of short-term cash access that could jeopardise future financial security.
The two-pot system, introduced on 1 September 2024, was designed to balance liquidity with preservation. It allows fund members to access one-third of their contributions through a savings component, while two-thirds remain locked in a retirement component until formal retirement.
Under current rules, a member can withdraw from their savings pot once per tax year, provided the pot holds at least R2 000.
The initial seeding of this savings component came from 10% of a member's pre-existing retirement savings, capped at R30 000.
According to Natasha Huggett-Henchie, consulting actuary and a member of the Actuarial Society of South Africa (ASSA) Retirement Matters Committee, the average withdrawal during the initial access period in late 2024 was R20 000, with subsequent withdrawals falling to R6 000 on average.
This decline reflects a concerning depletion of funds. Huggett-Henchie noted that members who emptied their pots shortly after implementation will now only have modest amounts – perhaps just R6 000 or slightly more, depending on monthly contributions and investment growth – available for withdrawal in the new tax year.
'If you emptied your savings pot in September last year and continued contributing R3 000 per month, you'd have around R6 000 available now, plus any investment growth,' she explained.
Further compounding the issue are tax implications.
Withdrawals are taxed by the South African Revenue Service (SARS) and may push individuals into higher tax brackets, making cashing out even more costly.
Despite the financial accessibility offered by the two-pot system, Huggett-Henchie warned that it was never intended as a revolving credit facility.
'Every withdrawal should be carefully considered, as it diminishes the savings meant for your retirement,' she cautioned.
A deeper concern, she added, is that informal lenders may be capitalising on the withdrawals.
With no significant increase in loan repayments to banks or consumer spending reported by retailers, suspicions have grown that cash-strapped individuals may be turning to loan sharks, using withdrawals to service high-interest debt.
Experts have begun calling for tighter oversight and improved financial education to prevent abuse of the system, which was initially designed to offer limited access to cash in emergencies – not to encourage a cycle of dependency that leaves retirement savings dangerously eroded.
Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1
Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
eNCA
2 hours ago
- eNCA
Bill Gates to donate majority of $200 Billion fortune to Africa
NEW YORK - Tech billionaire Bill Gates is giving away almost all of his money. And, some of it may assist South Africans READ: Gates Foundation to spend $200 bn through 2045 when it will shut down Gates says he is donating 99% of his fortune, that's a whopping 200 billion dollars. And, he intends to send the bulk of it to Africa. The philanthropist will disperse the money over the next 20 years to coincide with the closing of his foundation.
IOL News
5 hours ago
- IOL News
Unlocking tourism potential between China and South Africa
Unlocking tourism potential between China and South Africa For South Africans considering travel to China, the consulate has specific travel guidelines aimed at ensuring a smooth and enjoyable experience. This week, the Daily News had the opportunity to engage directly with the Chinese Consul General in Durban, Li Zhigong, who showcased the vast opportunities for tourism and travel between China and South Africa. With a shared vision of fostering stronger bilateral ties, the consul general outlined strategic initiatives aimed at not just facilitating travel but also enriching the cultural exchange between the two nations. One of the primary focuses of the Consulate General is to promote high-level exchanges between sister cities and provinces. "These efforts help spark greater interest in China among local communities and foster closer people-to-people ties," Li explained. Efforts include enhanced communication and collaboration on tourism initiatives, underpinned by a commitment to mutual understanding and friendship. In a notable development this year, the consulate has initiated an express visa option, designed to streamline the application process for Chinese tourists wishing to visit South Africa. "The express visa can be processed within three to four working days with simple and user-friendly requirements," Li said. This is a significant improvement, especially when the visa process has previously been a major hurdle for potential visitors. For South African tourism operators eager to attract Chinese visitors, Li offered several crucial recommendations. He urged operators to tailor their offerings to better meet the preferences of Chinese visitors. "This includes providing services in Chinese, accepting payment methods like UnionPay and Alipay, and promoting destinations through Chinese social media platforms," he said. Cultural sensitivity and a welcoming atmosphere are also vital in creating memorable travel experiences for Chinese tourists. The consul general acknowledged the ongoing challenges faced in attracting more tourists due to the complexities surrounding the visa application process. "We are actively engaging with the South African Department of Home Affairs, as obtaining a South African visa remains time-consuming and difficult for Chinese citizens," Li said, As for South Africans considering travel to China, the consulate has specific travel guidelines aimed at ensuring a smooth and enjoyable experience. According to Li, visitors are encouraged to meticulously plan their itineraries and familiarise themselves with essential apps such as WeChat, Alipay, and translation tools, as these are critical for navigating the vast cultural landscape. He added that key destinations such as Beijing, Xi'an, and Shanghai are highly recommended and travellers are advised to respect local customs and be aware of the legal framework to ensure a harmonious visit. "We truly hope more South Africans will visit China to see and experience more for themselves. South Africa is not only a partner but also a brother to China, and we sincerely wish for our people to grow closer and develop deeper mutual understanding," said Li. *This is Part 4 of a series of exclusive interviews that the Chinese Consul General in Durban, Li Zhigong, granted the Daily News' editor, Ayanda Mdluli.
Eyewitness News
7 hours ago
- Eyewitness News
Parliament's finance committee approves fiscal framework, revenue proposals underpinning budget
CAPE TOWN - Parliament's standing committee on finance has approved the fiscal framework and revenue proposals that underpin the 2025 budget, setting the scene for the less contentious adoption of its report in the National Assembly than was the case in March. Following two days of deliberations, the African National Congress (ANC), Democratic Alliance (DA) and ActionSA voted in favour of the report. However, the uMkhonto weSizwe (MK) Party and Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) dug in their heels saying the fuel levy is an unnecessary inclusion that will impact the poor. Wednesday's joint meeting of the finance committees of both houses was far less tense than when it considered an earlier version of the budget framework, which contained a value-added tax (VAT) increase that split the Government of National Unity (GNU). ALSO READ: Main opposition parties reject Treasury's assertion of pro-poor budget However, opposition parties took issue with the increase in the fuel levy, which was included in this third version of the budget tabled by the finance minister two weeks ago. The MK Party's Brian Molefe said other means could have been found to raise R4 billion in a R2 trillion budget. "The fuel levy is regressive and it is not pro-growth, because the fuel levy dampens consumption, expenditure, and it is inflationary as well." After losing Tuesday's court case on the matter, the EFF's Omphile Maotwe made one last appeal for the committee to retract the increase. "If we can stand up and say we reject the fuel levy, that's something we can give the people of South Africa." But with no support to force the finance minister's hand again, both opposition parties rejected the fiscal framework and the committee's report, which will be put to a house vote next Wednesday.
