Call to delay cycleway project
However, Cr Jim O'Malley has defended the project and says he is so tired of accusations from "these same businessmen" he may quit local politics.
His comments come after Jason La Hood called for the Albany St Connection project — which aims to provide a safe walking and cycling connection between the shared Te Aka Ōtākou harbour path, Dunedin's tertiary area and the CBD — to be delayed by 24 months, to give business owners in the city a chance to recover from an already difficult period.
An "overwhelming concern" of business owners was why Dunedin city councillors seemed "hell-bent" on proceeding with work on the project this year, Mr La Hood said.
Many had already endured "years of punishing disruption" — first the Covid-19 pandemic, then the George St upgrades project that "drove shoppers away with many businesses barely staying afloat".
If the work proceeded this year, business owners would be "hit with a devastating trifecta of soaring rates, collapsing consumer spending and the prolonged disruption of street works".
"What is worse is the growing perception that some councillors are indifferent to the suffering it's causing.
"As one business owner put it, 'it feels like councillors are torturing us'.
"The comment may sound emotional, but it is born from real exhaustion, fear and frustration from people who are simply trying to survive and support their families."
A simple and "empathic" alternative was to delay the project by 24 months.
"Let them trade through this economic storm without another round of chaos being dumped at their door."
The council last week announced it had reintroduced nine carparks to the project's design along two areas on the northern side of Albany St.
Public consultation would take place until August 7 regarding suggested parking restrictions.
Mr La Hood was one of two business owners whom Dunedin Mayor Jules Radich said at an infrastructure services committee meeting last month had contacted him with concerns about the level of consultation on the project.
Cr O'Malley said Mr La Hood said the same thing every time the council did street work.
"And, frankly, it's difficult to perform your role as a councillor when you're accused of dirty things like that.
"To be honest, I still haven't put in my form to go back for another three years because I am tired of this stuff.
"Seriously, you work your arse off to run these committees and run them properly, you come up with a conclusion and then these same businessmen, every time, turn around and say 'I wasn't consulted'."
There had been a "complete and utter lack of respect" for the consultation process, Cr O'Malley said.
"It happened, it was done properly, it was well executed.
"They just didn't get what they wanted."
The project would not receive co-funding from the New Zealand Transport Agency Waka Kotahi if it was not completed this year, he said.
In late 2023, a hearings committee voted 2-1 to proceed with the then recommended proposal to remove 68 carparks in the street.
But Cr O'Malley said this had never been put before the full council and believed building owners had since "got in and interfered with the process".
"I am more concerned that it took 18 months and nothing happened at all, and now the mayor is going around and, suddenly, we're having another consultation."
He believed Mr Radich was acting in business owners' interest, "and that's not necessarily the interest of the city as a whole".
He likened it to talks had with the business community during the George St redevelopment.
"I see this as just more of the same, the mayor and his mates."
Mr Radich said yesterday he was "mates with many business owners, job holders, residents and shoppers in this city".
As with George St, the "vast majority of them" wanted reasonable access to shops and services in Albany St.
"There is a balance to be achieved between the majority of people who use cars to get around the city and the 5% or so who use bikes and want more cycle lanes."
Council transport group manager Jeanine Benson said they acknowledged any construction project came with a level of disruption.
"But our staff and contractors work hard to minimise this and support local businesses through these periods where we can."
tim.scott@odt.co.nz
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
4 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
‘Success' stories behind growth
While Otago may have topped a national economic scoreboard, more needs to be done to spread the word about the South's success, a business leader says. Kiwibank's latest Annual Regional Note, released last week, placed Otago and Southland as the two top performing regions in the country as the South continued to outperform the North. "The further south you go the better the business climate seems," general manager Troy Sutherland said. Ranking a total of 13 regions on a score from 1 to 10, the report summarises seven economic indicators including population growth, retail sales, employment, house price index, house sales, building consents and international tourism electronic card transactions. Otago and Southland both ranked 5, compared with the national average of 4, activity boosted by a bounce back in tourism, the report said. Business South chief executive Mike Collins said the results showed that optimism had returned to the region. "We've been always saying the further south, the more optimistic we are about the future. "I think what we're seeing there is that optimism is turning into action in terms of people spending and people having confidence in making decisions." The region had been "sitting on the cusp" of growth in housing and commercial developments, and decreasing interest rates coupled with more optimism had translated into more transactions around building consents, Mr Collins said. However, there was still a lot of work to do around sharing the region's stories of success with the rest of the country. "Off the back of these kind of announcements, we really need to be coming together across the region and talking about those stories of success and building on those. "I think the rest of the country don't really understand how much opportunity there is down here yet. "There's so much more to show and tell." As a key tourist destination, Otago benefited both in terms of employment and consumer spending, the report said. "As employment growth across most of the country has gone backwards, Otago recorded a massive 8% increase." The region topped the list when it came to retail sales growth, rising about 6.5% in the 12 months to March this year. Otago also recorded the highest year-on-year growth in residential building consents, a rise of nearly 35% in the three months to May this year. Southland, Otago and Canterbury — which recorded "materially shallower declines" in house prices than other areas around the country — were either above or close to their post-Covid highs. House prices in Otago had hovered around their peak levels over the past couple of years, while prices in Southland were 1% higher than their post-Covid surge. International card spending in Otago and Southland rose 1.4% and 5.2% respectively. Dunedin Mayor Jules Radich said the results were encouraging for Otago and Southland. "I think there's possibly a little bit more optimism in the region since we've got the go-ahead and resumption of work on the new hospital, which services the whole region. "Also, the upturn in farming, the increase in farming returns both in red meat and dairy products is very helpful to the Otago-Southland economy." Retail development in Dunedin was also growing, and it was easy to see new buildings taking shape around the city. While the "lion's share" of the region's growth was happening in the Queenstown Lakes District, Mr Radich said he was assured about Dunedin's contribution.
NZ Herald
17 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Unemployment: Job data show construction down more than 12,000 in year, more youth out of work
In 2022, many employers were desperate to find staff. But borders reopened, migrants arrived and the economy's post-Covid rebound slowed down. Gordon said young people were also often in the firing line for layoffs. He said recent data also indicated more people were staying unemployed for longer. 'Once you're out, it is hard to get back in ... What we've been seeing in recent surveys is the six- to 12-month group has risen quite substantially.' Job numbers for people aged 20 to 34 dropped by thousands compared with a year ago. But the cohort aged 35 to 39 filled 2% more jobs than a year earlier, according to Stats NZ. Economist and former Child Poverty Action Group spokeswoman Susan St John said support and benefits for some unemployed people were still miserly. St John said that wasn't always a problem if unemployment lasted a few weeks, but in a prolonged recession, it could be disastrous. 'It's why we continue wallowing around in this ugly recession. Our fiscal cushions are not well-designed.' GDP grew by 0.8% in the first quarter of this year but since 2022, Stats NZ has recorded four quarters of GDP decline, one flat and eight of growth, not adjusted for population. Last year, annual real gross national disposable income fell 0.3% and annual real gross national disposable income per capita fell 2.0%. St John, an associate professor at the University of Auckland Business School, said the country had major gaps in the safety net for some people in relationships. An unemployed central Auckland man aged 25 with cash assets of $1000, paying $300 a week in rent, with a partner working fulltime at the minimum wage, would qualify for only $74 a week before tax on Jobseeker Support. If single, the same man would qualify for Jobseeker Support of between $356 and $361 a week before tax, and a weekly accommodation supplement of between $70 and $147. St John said lack of demand in the economy, which she blamed on restrictive Government fiscal policy, was behind the decline in young adults filling jobs. Compared to June 2024, filled jobs in construction were down 6%, or 12,169 jobs. Manufacturing was down 2.5% or 5850 jobs year-on-year in the latest Stats NZ data. But across all industries, there was a 0.1% increase in filled jobs last month compared with the previous month. 'Construction is a quite cyclical and quite interest-rate-sensitive part of the economy,' Gordon said. He said the country recorded a surge in building consents for a couple of years after Covid. 'There tends to be quite a long pipeline from consent to completion. 'We have seen housing consents stabilise over the past year.' For that reason, the medium-term outlook for construction was not abysmal but recovery in construction jobs was still likely a few months away, Gordon said. He said employment was down in the North Island, but steadier in the South Island. 'The strong performance of the agri-sector is a big part of that.' Gordon said feedback from customers and colleagues often illustrated stark regional contrasts. 'In the North Island, there'll be a litany of woes. In the South Island, it's '$10 milk price, everything's all right'.' Seek's June employment report was also released today. It showed job ads were down 3% on May and 3% down on a year earlier. But Gisborne, Marlborough and Southland bucked the trend, with job ads in those regions up from the month before. Seek NZ country manager Rob Clark said job ad levels had been broadly flat for the past year. 'While the volume remains below pre-Covid levels, there are pockets of growth, which should be cause for some optimism.' John Weekes is a business journalist mostly covering aviation and court. He has previously covered consumer affairs, crime, politics and court.
Otago Daily Times
a day ago
- Otago Daily Times
Job ads fall for a second month
The mid-year economic slowdown appears to be weighing on the job market with job advertisements falling for a second month. Data from employment website Seek NZ showed job ads fell 3% in June from a month earlier, and 3% lower than a year ago. Applications per job ad - recorded with a one-month lag - were down 2% monthly. It comes as various economic datasets point to the country's economic recovery stalling in the middle of the year. Seek country manager Rob Clark said job ad levels remained broadly flat for the past year. "While the volume remains below pre-Covid levels, there are pockets of growth, which should be cause for some optimism," he said. Job ad volumes were mixed across the regions, with Gisborne, Marlborough and Southland the only regions to see month-on-month growth in June. In Auckland and Canterbury, volumes fell 2% in June, while Wellington fell 4%. Otago was flat, while Waikato fell 4%. The only industry to see an increase in volumes was Information & Communication Technology, with more demand for ICT managers and networks & systems administrators. "Despite a monthly dip in June, demand within government and defence has jumped 51% year-on-year, and we're seeing a growing number of industries return to annual growth within the professional and consumer services sectors," Clark said.
