Proposed cleaning levy sparks legal challenge in Tshwane
Tshwane Deputy Mayor Eugene Modise poses for a photograph at Tshwane House, 20 November 2024, following an interview with The Citizen. Picture: Michel Bega/The Citizen
AfriForum has started legal action against the City of Tshwane to obtain clarification on the implementation of the proposed environmental, or city cleaning levy announced in the budget speech.
Last week, the deputy mayor, MMC of finance Eugene Modise, announced the city's plans to implement the levy of approximately R200 per month from 1 July for all properties without a municipal waste account.
AfriForum's local government affairs advisor Deidré Steffens said they submitted a request to obtain clarification on the city's plans regarding the levy in April, but received no reply.
AfriForum submit to request clarification on levy plan
'On 24 April, AfriForum submitted its comments on the city's draft medium-term revenue and expenditure framework (MTREF) in which the levy was announced.
'Our legal team has made it clear that the draft MTREF containing details of the proposed levy contains material contradictions and gives excessive discretionary power to the municipal manager in the application of the levy. This creates unacceptable scope for abuse and arbitrary application,' she said.
ALSO READ: Tshwane's R54.6bn budget draws mixed reactions
According to Steffens, the implementation of the proposed levy would be contrary to Section 74(2) of the Local Government Municipal Systems Act, which requires that tariffs reflect the actual use of services and be applied fairly.
Steffens said although the constitution required municipalities to promote the social and economic development of communities in their budgeting processes, this was not the case with the implementation of the levy.
'A non-revenue-generating service, such as a cleansing levy, is traditionally financed by property rates and if the city were to proceed with the proposed implementation of this levy, it would amount to double taxation.
Cleansing levy traditionally financed by property rates
'It is unacceptable that a service that should be funded by property taxes is now being repackaged as a new levy, presumably to cover the metro's budget deficits.
'This is a blatant attempt to milk more revenue from already overtaxed residents,' she said.
ALSO READ: Millions needed to fix Tshwane sinkholes
AfriForum was prepared to approach the court if the city failed to provide the information by the deadline, Steffens said.
Republican Conference of Tshwane councillor Lex Middelberg said the levy was a reintroduction of a similar city cleaning levy that was introduced in the 2017-8 MTREF but then abandoned.
'This cleaning levy is unconstitutional. The city conceded this and abandoned the cleaning levy in later MTREFs after the issue was raised by the Tshwane Money Matters Caucus in November 2017 with your predecessor in office at the time, with the minister of finance, the AGSA and the MEC for local government,' he said.
Not a tariff for services rendered
Middelberg said the cleaning levy was not a tariff for services rendered, but by its own definition an arbitrary tax raised on persons who do not consume the service.
'The cleaning levy is not raised to render a service, but to bulk up the city's coffers with additional revenue to be applied for other purposes than to clean the city,' he said.
ALSO READ: Tshwane mayor faces outrage for Weskoppies Hospital power cut
Tshwane's DA spokesperson for finance Jacqui Uys said they were also against the levies.
Uys said the current waste collection in the city could cost residents up to 10% of their salaries.
'Instead of assisting poor households who cannot afford almost R500 per month for waste removal, the ANC-led City of Tshwane has opted to introduce a punitive tax of almost R200 on these households if they choose not to use the city's services,' she said.
DA raises concerns
'The DA has also raised concerns about the newly introduced waste levy in the draft budget.'
Uys said the intention of the new levy was not to ensure a cleaner city, but rather the introduction of yet another tax to use the residents of Tshwane as a stopgap to improve the city's financial position.
NOW READ: Tshwane mayor under fire for downplaying pothole crisis
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
3 hours ago
- The Citizen
Operation Dudula demands release of members detained
The Operation Dudula member described the detained members as "patriots" and "South African citizens that have taken a stand" against what they perceive as illegal immigration. Three Operation Dudula members remain in custody at Diepkloof Police Station following their arrest at the Lillian Ngoyi Clinic on Thursday. The women were detained after allegedly entering the clinic's maternity ward and attempting to remove a pregnant woman they claimed was a foreign national. Operation Dudula supporters demand release Operation Dudula members gathered at the Diepkloof Police Station from early Friday morning, demanding the immediate release of their detained colleagues. We will not be intimidated by our own government. Let's meet in Diepkloof Police Station at 8:00 for a proper shutdown of Diepkloof Police Station. — Operation Dudula (@0perationDudula) August 8, 2025 The group maintains its members were conducting legitimate operations to identify illegal foreigners allegedly accessing South African healthcare services. According to Operation Dudula member Thami, the three women entered the clinic to establish facts about foreign nationals in the facility. 'These three members had gotten inside to go and establish the facts and find out who is an illegal foreigner in the country,' Thami explained to eNCA. 'They had not even gotten to ask those questions. But they were in the maternity ward to try and find out.' Thami emphasised that the organisation follows specific protocols during their operations. 'When we conduct this operation, we engage with the staff first before we engage with whoever is not supposed to be there,' he said. ALSO READ: Why mass deportation is failing SA's immigration system Operation Dudula arrests and allegations The detained members claim they were arrested without proper procedure. In a viral video seen by The Citizen, one of the arrested women described the incident: 'We are in a van, we were arrested, foreigners have filled up Koos Clinic and its maternity ward. We don't know which account we have been arrested on.' She alleged that someone named Zodwa called the police on them. 'Zodwa always harasses us at clinics when we do our programmes. Today, she called the police on us, and more than 20 police officers came to us, the three women commanders,' the woman said. The arrested member claimed procedural violations during the arrest. 'We are travelling right now, and we don't even know which police station they're taking us to. They just told us that we are getting arrested; they didn't even read us our rights. We were just put inside the van.' According to video footage taken by Operation Dodula members, the three arrested women are identified as Cindy, Xoli, and Mamsi. It remains unclear which of the three was speaking in the viral arrest video. ALSO READ: Operation Dudula wanting to know why organisations prioritise foreign nationals Threats of Diepkloof Police Station shutdown Operation Dodula leader Zandile Dabula issued strong warnings following the arrests. 'Today, our commanders were arrested in Diepkloof. The charges are that they are impersonating immigration officers, police and labour inspectors,' Dabula said. She threatened broader action if the women are not released. 'We are going to make a call that everyone… If this country has to be closed, it's going to be a shutdown. Let's do that because we are not going to be intimidated by the police,' Dabula declared. Organisation's position on healthcare access Thami defended the group's actions as the enforcement of constitutional rights. He argued that foreign nationals were 'stealing our medication, abusing our system, our health care systems' and 'should not be given those rights because constitutionally they are not supposed to get those rights.' The Operation Dudula member described their detained colleagues as 'patriots' and 'South African citizens that have taken a stand' against what they perceive as illegal immigration. Police response Police spokesperson Brenda Muridili confirmed the women are in custody. 'They have not yet been charged, but they are still in custody,' Muridili told The Citizen. 'The charges that they are facing now are trespassing.' This response rebuts Dabula's claim that the charges are more serious, including impersonating immigration officers, police, and labour inspectors. Muridili said she would confirm when and where the three women will appear in court. READ NEXT: Saps probes officers after video shows police offloading beer bottles at liquor store
The Citizen
4 hours ago
- The Citizen
Morero given ultimatum over MMC's joy ride to KZN
A recent court ruling removed VIP protection from certain Johannesburg mayoral committee members. The DA in Johannesburg has given mayor Dada Morero 48 hours to fire one of his mayoral committee members for abusing the municipality's resources. This comes after the MMC, known to The Citizen, took a luxury car belonging to the city and a number of JMPD officials to a political party event in KwaZulu-Natal. Alleged abuse of the bank card The DA also alleges that during this trip, the city's bank card was used to refuel the car twice. The Citizen has seen a letter that the party sent to Morero giving him until the end of the week to dismiss the MMC in question. This development follows a court ruling against Johannesburg MMCs who were receiving VIP protection and luxury cars without a threat risk assessment. 'Your failure to act within 48 hours leaves us no choice but to use all legal means, including law enforcement, to assist you in complying with the rule of law, because, as you are aware, contravention of a court order is a criminal matter.' The DA also wants Morero to reveal the contents of an investigation into the matter, which The Citizen first reported on in June. According to the letter, the investigation has been carried out by the Group Forensic Investigation Services (GFIS). ALSO READ: Joburg's cure: Place the city under administration Why should Morero act against the MMC? Speaking to The Citizen on Friday, DA caucus leader Belinda Kayser-Echeozonjoku described the MMC's actions as 'criminal'. 'We condemn this criminal contempt of the High Court order in the strongest terms,' she said. Kayser-Echeozonjoku said Morero is compelled by his oath of office to act against the MMC. 'The myor is to blame because he is the head of the mayoral committee and all MMCs serve at his pleasure as per section 60 of the Municipal Structures Act,' she said. The Citizen has approached Johannesburg and the MMC in question for comment. They had not responded by the time of publicatiion and their responses will be included once received. NOW READ: Motorists could become targets of aggressive revenue collection operations by JMPD, says DA
The Citizen
8 hours ago
- The Citizen
Denza B8 SUV could arrive in SA alongside B5 next year
BYD-owned Denza has released specification details of the export market B8 destined for the Middle East and African markets. What is it? According to The Citizen, the rebadged version of the Chinese domestic market Fangchengbao Bao 8, the B8 rides on the same Dual Mode Offroad body-on-frame platform as the BYD Shark bakkie, with dimensions of 5 195mm in overall length, a wheelbase of 2 920mm, width of 1 994mm and height of 1 875mm. Currently only the second Fangchengbao model to be badged as a Denza – the other being the Bao 5 that will be called the Denza B5 – the Bao 8 provides seating for four, five, six or seven in China, though the B8 is likely to offer only the latter two configurations. Similar to the B5, the B8 comes equipped with BYD's Disus-P hydraulic adaptive air suspension that increases ground clearance from 220mm to 310mm. In the latter position, the B8 has an approach angle of 34 degrees and a departure angle of 35 degrees. No details on its breakover angle were divulged. Packed spec and more Available in four trim levels in its home market, notable specification comprises the same three-screen layout as the Bao 5/B5 – a 17.3-inch infotainment display and two 12.3-inch screens for the passenger side and instrument cluster. Also included is BYD's latest LiDAR system, an augmented reality head-up display projected onto the windscreen, a night vision camera, no fewer than 14 airbags, a fragrance dispenser, automatic parking and an 18-speaker sound system. As an option, the Chinese-market Bao 8 offers an unofficially titled drone package as part of a joint development with manufacturer DJI. Besides the actual drone itself, which can travel at up to 54 km/h, a docking station has been placed on the Bao 8's roof, complete with a charging system that requires a waiting time of 30 minutes from 30–80%. Supercar power For the Bao 8 itself, motivation comes from a plug-in powertrain, but not modelled around the 1.5-litre turbocharged petrol engine as in the Bao 5/B5 and Shark. Instead, the setup uses BYD's 2.0-litre turbo-petrol working in conjunction with a 36.8kWh Blade battery pack powering two electric motors. As in the Bao, the B8 will use this configuration when it goes on sale outside China, meaning the same combined output of 550kW and 0–100 km/h in 4.8s. The claimed all-electric range is 100km and the combined range, with the combustion engine included, is 1 200km. As well as low range and three locking differentials, the B8 also comes equipped with five off-road modes: Wading, Snow, Sand, Rock, Mud and Mountain. Coming? Priced from 379 800 to 407 800 yuan (R936 713 to R1 005 771) in China – with drone-equipped variants ranging from 395 800 to 423 800 yuan (R976 175 to R1 045 232) – the B8 has reportedly been confirmed for South Africa as a step-up from the B5. This, according to which claims the export roll-out will start from the third quarter of the year in the mentioned African and Middle East markets. According to a related post from CAR Magazine, local Denza operations will start early next year, headed by the B5, with the B8 likely to either follow later or arrive at the same time. As it stands, clarity will only emerge in 2026.
