World Rugby boss rejects Schmidt's clearout claim
The officials decided not to overturn Hugo Keenan's match-winning try after reviewing a clearout in the build-up from flanker Jac Morgan as the Lions edged a compelling contest at the MCG.
As the Lions attacked near the Australia line, Morgan cleaned out Wallaby flanker Carlo Tizzano, who lurched backwards intimating he had been struck on the head as he tried to steal possession.
The ball was then worked out to the left for Keenan to score, with referee Andrea Piardi sticking by his initial decision to award the try after consultation with the television match official (TMO).
After the game, which the Lions won to take an unassailable 2-0 series lead, Wallabies coach Schmidt said it was a call that "didn't live up to" World Rugby's focus on player welfare.
"I don't agree with that," World Rugby chief executive Alan Gilpin told the Rugby Union Weekly podcast in Sydney.
"I understand emotions are running high and I understand Joe's looking at specific laws and playing that into the sort of officiating and welfare debate.
"But Joe knows well, and so do all the international coaches, that we are investing heavily [in player welfare], whether it's instrumented mouthguards across the professional game, whether it's all the investment we make in the science and research.
"We're trying to find that really tricky but massively important balance between a sport that is a brilliant physical contest and as safe as it can be in for the players. It's a very tough balance.
"One of the great wonders of rugby is the complexity of our laws and the interpretation of that. We know that creates controversy and sometimes frustration but it also gets everyone talking about rugby, and talking positively about rugby and what an amazing game it was."
Morgan produced 'perfect' clearout - Owens
Ringrose ruled out of third Lions Test
'Glorious Lions needed this battle to reveal another side of themselves'
Gilpin wouldn't be drawn about whether figures at Rugby Australia had lodged a formal complaint, but said the referees' body had been going through their customary review of the game over the past few days and that the officials "stand by their decision".
"We've got to back our referees and our match officials. And we do. They're making 800-plus decisions under incredible pressure in front of a global audience in a single game," he added.
"And they don't get every decision right. But as long as they've gone through the right process and as long as they've got a decision that they can stand behind, then we'll support them."
Meanwhile, Australia fly-half Tom Lynagh has asked whether any review findings into the decision should be made available to the public.
"I think it's a grey area," Lynagh said on Tuesday. "I think it would be good for the public to know the final result.
"But unfortunately it doesn't change the result of the fixture, the decision is final."
Former Wallabies captain Michael Hooper has been among those vocal in the Australian media, saying it should have been a penalty against Morgan and the Lions for a dangerous ruck entry.
But he adds that now is the time for the hosts to move on and focus on the third and final Test in Sydney this weekend.
"It's the game, right," he told Rugby Union Weekly. "But these things happen and if being a player teaches you anything, it's that you have to move on.
"I hope the Wallabies have had a couple of days just to grieve, get it over with, and to get mentally prepared to bring it this week."
'Lions need whitewash to be lauded for decades' - Dawson column
'Finish on a high' - Russell seeks 3-0 Lions clean sweep
Get the latest updates from the Lions tour
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Stokes: I'm looking forward to getting to Australia
For months, England captain Ben Stokes has avoided talking about the Ashes in Australia as much as possible. But after a Test match - and series - for the ages against India, even he is prepared to mention it and firmly believes his side are battle hardened after the draining series that finished in a chaotic defeat at The Oval on Monday. More than 7000 runs were scored in the five Tests, but just when England were in need of fewer than 50 runs for the final five wickets, they lost. The last time that happened to them in a fourth innings while chasing victory was in 1902, against Australia at Old Trafford Stokes was England's most effective bowler in the series but exhausted himself into a shoulder injury that forced him to miss The Oval. Stokes praised his seam attack - deprived of himself, Jofra Archer and Chris Woakes, who came out to bat with a dislocated shoulder but did not have to face - for running India so close in the six-run defeat that squared a superb series. "When one of your bowlers goes down so early in the game, the role of the other seamers changes," Stokes said. A stunning end to the five-Test series as India clinch the thriller at The Oval 👏#WTC27 #ENGvIND 📝: — ICC (@ICC) August 4, 2025 "Even in the second innings, the heart and desire they showed was amazing. There were many what-ifs in the last five days, makes the game great, but all (coach) Brendon (McCullum) and I asked was to give it everything. (Josh) Tongue, (Gus) Atkinson and (Jamie) Overton showed it. "The way in which we've been able to perform throughout the series, I'm looking forward to getting to Australia and doing what we want to go out there and do." England and India both wasted earlier chances to win the fifth Test but after India took the final four wickets in a hectic 57 minutes of play on the final morning, Stokes accepted the conclusion was deserved. "The series as a whole has been pretty much toe-to-toe for 25 days. From a cricket fan's point of view, 2-2 is probably fair," he said. "Two very good teams who have thrown everything at each other and left everything out there. We obviously would have loved to get a series win but it wasn't meant to be. "We're bitterly disappointed we couldn't get over the line but it was another hard-fought game and both teams put so much energy and effort into the series, it's been an amazing one to be part of. "There's a little bit of frustration there as well but as a massive advocate of this format and for Test cricket as a whole, this has certainly been one of those series that could hopefully keep off the narrative around 'Test cricket is dying'." Stokes said he was looking forward to being well rested for the first Ashes test against Australia, in Perth, on November 21, but if he is fit, there are serious questions over who will join him in England's attack. Fast bowlers Jofra Archer and Mark Wood have both missed more Tests than they have played in recent years and the chances of Woakes being fit to bowl in less than four months must be remote. England have not won a Test in Australia since 2011, something David Warner will doubtless be reminding them of during his stint playing for London Spirit in The Hundred over the next few weeks. With agencies
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
British and Irish Lions end-of-tour awards
The British and Irish Lions defeated Australia 2-1 to win their first Test series since 2013. It may not have been one of the all-time classic Lions tours but it did deliver controversy, big moments and a second Test for the ages. The Lions played nine tour games, won eight and lost the final match to deny Andy Farrell's side a first series whitewash by the tourists since 1927. Our team in Australia - Chris Jones, Tom English, Lauren Jenkins and Nigel Ringland - dissect the tour on the latest Rugby Union Weekly episode and give out their end-of-tour awards. Player of the tour NR: "Dan Sheehan. He is possibly the best hooker in the world and has only enhanced that reputation. "He set the tone in his first game and captained the side. If he continues on an upward curve with Leinster and Ireland then he could be a potential captain in 2029. At hooker he was way ahead of his competition." TE: "Tadhg Beirne. Played 80, 80, 80 in the Test-match series. Hugely influential right from 16 seconds in. Tom Curry makes a tackle on James Slipper and he is in for the turnover. "I love to see players doubted and then coming through. That is the epitome of greatness. He hit greatness on this tour." CJ: "Tadhg Beirne for me." LJ: "Maro Itoje is up there. His durability and aura as a captain. The third Test was the first time he didn't finish a Test since 2022 against Australia. "You wouldn't put it past him doing it again in four years time. Nine Lions Tests under his belt." Lions player ratings - the incredible, the unlucky & the poor Listen: The big Lions debrief in Sydney 'A strange kind of glory' as legacy-defining win eludes Lions Best moment of the 2025 Lions tour? TE: "For sure, 90,000 people at the MCG, dramatic, the comeback, the controversy of the clearout. We will be talking about that the next time we are in Australia, but there were moments on this trip. "The Owen Farrell call-up too came at the stage when the tour was meandering along and the Lions were beating everyone. A bit of a yawn fest. "He then appears and it is amazing. When he gets out of bed in the morning people are not happy." LJ: "The two tries in four minutes before half-time in Melbourne changed the game. From 23-5 to 23-17, when reflecting on the tour you might not think about it but it was huge." CJ: "When Tom Curry cut James Slipper in half that was a big 'I am' moment. After lots of chat about whether he should play the first Test." NR: "It was the last play of the game in Melbourne. All the controversy and announcing no foul play in the build-up. "It was so well-worked, and so much composure as to where the players needed to be in that moment on the pitch." Performance of the series LJ: "The First Nations and Pasifika XV. That was the performance of the series and the game that it felt like everyone was waiting for. They could have snatched it at the end. I left that stadium with a spring in my step." CJ: "The Wallabies in the third Test after people talking about where Australian rugby is. All the greats of Wallaby rugby saying they can't lose 3-0. They went out and did a job on the Lions." TE: "The first half of Test one." NR: "I am going to cheat a little and go the first half of the first Test and the second half of the second Test. Put those two together. "Those last few minutes in Melbourne is what we will take away." Farrell in 'really good place' to lead Lions again Lions star Aki's baby born in car before first Test Individual performance TE: "It is hard to look past Tom Curry in the first Test or Tadhg Beirne in the first and third Tests." LJ: "Waratahs flanker Charlie Gamble was brilliant. Man of the match in that loss for First Nations Pasifika XV and he was brilliant for the Waratahs." CJ: "Rob Valetini's 40 minutes in Melbourne and Taniela Tupou in the third Test. My player of the tour from an Aussie point of view is Will Skelton, as when he was on the pitch Australia won the series by 14 points. I know that doesn't matter but it shows how amazing he was." Try of the tour CJ: "Tom Wright's try in Melbourne. Joseph Suaalii sees the space and you go 'there is the two million buck man' - that's why they paid the big dosh to get him out of the NRL. "It lifted the stadium and you felt in a special sporting occasion." TE: "It [Wright's try] electrified the stadium, in that moment you felt 'there is the guy [Suaalii]'." LJ: "Finn Russell's miracle pass to Sione Tuipulotu in the first Test. First Scot to score a Test try since Alan Tait in 1997." And a word on the Welshman... LJ: "Jac Morgan comes away with his reputation enhanced. You expect good players to go on Lions tours and perform but that doesn't always happen. As the sole Welshman you knew he was good but he has now done it at the top level. "He hasn't had a Welsh coach fighting his corner or the familiarity of the Leinster or Ireland players around him. It'll be interesting to see where he goes from here, as he will return a better player. "I had him down as a homeboy but this tour would have opened his eyes. Maybe he will think he can go and thrive in different environments." TE: "He is class. You possibly have to go back to Brian O'Driscoll in 2001, the whole waltzing O'Driscoll stuff, when he broke on to the international scene, to find a Lions cult figure like Jac Morgan. "Everyone adopted Morgan. It didn't matter where you were from from, you were willing him on. "He was a huge tourist and brilliant in the way he played." Combined starting XV Four Australia players have made the chosen combined starting XV. It includes Rob Valetini, who played only 40 minutes of rugby across the Test series, and lock Will Skelton, who missed the first Test. Dylan Pietsch was not selected for the first two Tests but impressed in Sydney to earn a spot on the wing. Combined starting XV: Keenan; Jorgensen, Jones, Tuipulotu, Pietsch; Russell, Gibson-Park; Genge, Sheehan, Furlong, Itoje, Skelton, Curry, Beirne, Valetini. Australia players in bold Get the latest updates from the Lions tour Wales stars must 'want a piece of Lions action'
Yahoo
4 hours ago
- Yahoo
India's Siraj 'woke up believing' ahead of Test heroics
Mohammed Siraj said he never lost faith in his own ability to deliver a sensational victory for India in the fifth and deciding Test at the Oval on Monday. England, set 374 to win, lost a nail-biting encounter by just six runs, with Siraj returning innings figures of 5-104 as India ended a rollercoaster campaign level at 2-2. The hosts resumed on Monday's final day on 339-6, needing just 35 more runs for a win that would have given them a 3-1 series success. But they had no answer to the enduring skill of fast bowler Siraj, who featured in all five games. He undid England on Monday with a brilliant burst of 3-9 in 25 balls, ending the match in style when he knocked over Gus Atkinson's off-stump. "From the first day until the fifth game, fifth day, we have fought an unbelievable fight," said Siraj, who bowled a marathon 185.3 overs during the series. "God must have written something good for me, that's why I won this match and took the last wicket. "When I woke up today, I thought I could do it. I downloaded a picture from Google saying 'believe'." The 31-year-old was named player of the match after an overall return of 9-190. Siraj redeemed himself in spectacular fashion after stepping over the boundary rope on Sunday in the act of catching Harry Brook, thereby conceding a six. Brook (111) and Joe Root (105) took the game by the scruff of the neck with a fourth-wicket stand of 195, putting England on course for victory. "I thought the Brook drop was a game-changing moment," said Siraj the leading bowler on either side in the series with 23 wickets at 32.43. "If it had been taken, we might not have come out today." India captain Shubman Gill, alongside Siraj at a post-match press conference, jokingly added: "If he had taken the catch, the game would have been too easy for us." England were in command at 301-3 and on course to break the record run chase in the fourth innings of an Oval Test of 263-9 that has stood since 1902. - England collapse - But India fought back superbly, taking England's last seven wickets for just 66 runs. "What we did this morning kind of summarised what this team is all about," said Gill. "The way Brook and Root were going, not many teams in the world would have given themselves a chance, but this team believes that whenever we have some kind of an opening, we can get through." Gill's first series as India captain was a personal triumph as he scored a mammoth 754 runs, including four centuries. "Each hundred that I scored had a very different significance," said the 25-year-old. "The one in Leeds was my first match (as captain), I was under a bit of pressure. "Then the double hundred and the hundred in Birmingham (where India won the second Test), to be able to seal that match was also special and the one in Manchester (in the drawn fourth Test), to be able to save that game from there, each of them has a story and each of them means a lot to me." jdg/jw/nf
