
Experts say eating MORE of an ultra-processed food is actually good for you
But not all ultra-processed foods are created equal.
Health experts are urging Americans to give faux meat a chance, citing lower risks of heart disease and a better carbon footprint.
Plant-forward diets, including the doctor-endorsed Mediterranean diet, are lauded for their inclusion of clean protein like nuts and legumes, mineral-rich leafy greens, and fibrous whole grains.
But doctors have been hesitant to recommend meat-alternative brands like Beyond Meat and Impossible Burgers because of the processing used to create them.
Meat substitutes may undergo various temperature treatments or 3D printing to mimic the texture of real meat, and may contain binders, emulsifiers, dyes, flavorings, stabilizers, and preservatives.
Despite this, doctors and nutritionists encourage their patients to make the switch to plant-based alternatives, which contain the same amount of protein, less saturated fat, fiber, and other beneficial vitamins.
Plant-based meat companies have a vested interest in appealing to carnivores who are concerned about the additives in everyday foods, including followers of the Make America Healthy Again movement.
Companies have overhauled some of their recipes amid flagging sales, lowering saturated fat and sodium, to bring them in.
A 2024 analysis published in the Canadian Journal of Cardiology of dozens of studies found that compared with meat, plant-based alternatives, while considered ultraprocessed, are generally healthier than meat.
They contain less saturated fat and cholesterol and have more fiber, showing in clinical trials to confer lower bad cholesterol and reduced body weight.
'Doctors and dietitians are reluctant to consider alternative proteins when advising patients on nutrition because they view these foods as ultra-processed,' nutrition scientist Roberta Alessandrini, director of the Dietary Guidelines Initiative at PAN International, told CNN.
'Yet if carefully chosen, these foods can be a valid and helpful way to shift toward more plant-forward diets, which are good for people and the planet.'
Plant-based burgers generally have their basis in soy , pea, or rice proteins, coconut oil, potato protein, yeast to impart a meaty taste.
They also contain compounds to bind the 'meat' together, such as methylcellulose, which gives the burgers fiber and, in some cases beet juice extract to simulate blood.
Despite being nutrient dense and overall beneficial, meat-free alternatives come from highly synthesized ingredients like soy protein concentrate, processed fats like coconut oil, binders and texturizers to better resemble meat, and the addition of non-whole food-based nutrients like B12 and zinc.
An ultraprocessed plant-based burger is a far cry from an ultraprocessed Twinkie or hot dog, though.
Ultraprocessed junk foods have strong links to obesity, heart disease, and diabetes, all while packing little to no nutritional benefits. No such links have been established with meat-free alternatives.
An 85 percent lean ground beef burger contains around 6.5 grams of saturated fat, compared to six grams in an Impossible Burger and two grams in a Beyond Burger.
They all contain similar amounts of protein, ranging from 19 to 21 grams per serving.
The high sodium content of meat alternatives is a significant downside. A 2019 CNN analysis found that Beyond, Impossible, and more traditional grain-based burgers each contained 370 to 390 milligrams of sodium.
Store-bought turkey burgers, however, contained 95 to 115 milligrams of sodium, while beef patties had only 65 to 75 milligrams.
They caution that this might be a misleading comparison, given that many people salt and season their meat as they cook it.
Processed and red meats are fine to eat sparingly, but eating them every day or even several times a week has been linked to colorectal and breast cancers, heart disease, and diabetes, though evidence is limited.
Concerns over health and nutrition are the primary drivers of the shift toward plant-based meat, although many people opt for non-meat alternatives due to concerns related to climate change.
Global meat production is a significant contributor to climate change, and demand is projected to increase by at least 50 percent by 2050.
Still, most people begin to incorporate meatless alternatives into their diet due to concerns about their weight, cholesterol, blood pressure or other health-related red flags.
'The fat composition of beef is so undesirable for health that it's very easy to be better than that,' Dr Walter Willett, professor of epidemiology and nutrition at Harvard, said.
'Animal products not only have too much saturated fat but lack polyunsaturated fat, fiber, and many of the minerals and vitamins available in plants.'
Those minerals and vitamins, such as B12, can be added to meatless alternatives in a similar way to how producers add vitamins D and A to milk.
Ultra-processed junk foods have strong links to obesity, heart disease, and diabetes, all while packing little to no nutritional benefits.
Plant-based meats are nutrient-dense, though, more so resembling a can of beans.
'So I think we really need to look at each one of these novel products on its own merits,' Dr Willett said.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Independent
24 minutes ago
- The Independent
RFK Jr. looks to boot panel that decided which HIV and cancer screenings would be free: report
Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. is reportedly planning to remove all the members of an influential health task force that helps determine what preventative care services insurers must cover for free, after removing all members of a vaccine advisory board last month. Kennedy wants to clean house at U.S. Preventative Services Task Force next because he believes its 16 members have become too 'woke,' The Wall Street Journal reports. Under 2010's Affordable Care Act, the task force makes evidence-based, public recommendations on a variety of treatments, ranging HIV prevention to prenatal care to mental health, that insurers must cover at no cost to patients. Health and Human Services has said the secretary hasn't made a final decision regarding the task force. The Independent has contacted the agency for comment. Kennedy's reported dissatisfaction with the group comes after the American Conservative magazine accused the task force of being a 'festering corner of woke bureaucracy' in an article earlier this month. 'The task force is packed with Biden administration appointees devoted to the ideological capture of medicine,' the author argued, pointing to 'sinister' recent task force actions committing to removing racial inequities in health care and using more inclusive language around gender. Earlier this month, a July meeting of the task force was postponed. At the time, a letter from over 100 health organizations warned about the politicization of the task force's work. 'The loss of trustworthiness in the rigorous and nonpartisan work of the Task Force would devastate patients, hospital systems, and payers as misinformation creates barriers to accessing lifesaving and cost effective care,' the letter reads. 'When something works well and helps inform doctors about how to take care of their patients, to postpone the task force's work just doesn't make any sense,' Dr. Bobby Mukkamala, president of the American Medical Association, told The New York Times after the meeting was postponed. 'This flies in the face of what is good for the country's health.' In June, the Supreme Court upheld the task force's ability to recommend free coverage for preventative services, in the face of a challenge from individuals and businesses objecting to the body's recommendation regarding HIV prevention medication. Concern over the fate of the task force comes after Kennedy removed all the members of a vaccine advisory board, replacing them with some members who share the secretary's vaccine skepticism.


Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Ben Askren reveals devastating impact of double lung transplant in heartbreaking new health update
Ben Askren has revealed the incredible toll his health episode has taken on him in a new social media post on Saturday. UFC cult hero Askren, regarded as one of the world's top lightweight fighters during the peak of his career, has been the subject of widespread concern among the MMA community after being hospitalised with pneumonia. Askren, 41, required a double lung transplant to save his life and returned home from hospital this week. He has been told by doctors that he s fully capable of living a lengthy, healthy life. But for now, the American former wrestler has a long journey to a full recovery, revealing on Instagram that he struggles to lift a five-pound dumbbell, such is his lack of strength post health crisis. 'I've been home for four days now,' he began. 'It's awesome. I get to sleep in my own bed, eat my own food, hang out with my family, it's great. 'That being said, I've still got so many physical challenges to deal with. I'm still down abot 35 pounds from where I should be. I can't walk. This five-pound weight, it's actually hard for me to curl. 'Right before I had to go to the hospital I was feeling strong, I was able to curl 45 pounds. I was out doing hill sprints.' However, Askren, who struggled to speak at certain points of video and had to catch his breath, is determined to improve his condition. 'I am where I am now,' he said. 'But I know I'll be somewhere different in a month.' Askren previously revealed that he had died four times before his life-saving transplant. 'So, I only died four times. The ticker stopped for about 20 seconds,' he said. 'But, I got the double lung transplant and made it out to the other side of it. I was actually 147lbs. I haven't been 147lbs since 15-years-old. 'The thing that was most impactful to me was the love I felt from everybody. It was almost like I got to have my own funeral. 'The outpouring of love from the wrestling community was just amazing. It felt so good. So I'm more motivated than ever to get back and do what I can to help out. 'I love you guys and I appreciate you guys. This has been tough. Not only on me but on my whole family and community. 'I hope you guys appreciate the update and sometime down the road maybe Amy and I can detail everything a little more'. More to follow. View this post on Instagram A post shared by Ben Askren (@benaskren)


Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Woman left BLIND after performing 13 cartwheels in a row
A fun day at the beach turned into a months-long medical ordeal for a Seattle teenager who went temporarily blind after doing cartwheels with friends. Deborah Cobb, now 42, was just 19 when she decided to see how many cartwheels she could perform in a row while having fun with her friends on a summer day in 2002. But after completing 13 consecutive cartwheels, the young woman fell over feeling 'super dizzy' and quickly realized something was terribly wrong with her eyesight. 'I decided to see how many cartwheels I could do in a row just for fun,' Cobb told Newsweek in a recent interview. 'So I started doing them and got to 13 and fell over super dizzy. My eyes were kind of spinning so it took a moment to realize that my eyes weren't focusing.' At first, she thought she was just dizzy but panic quickly ensued when she realized she could no longer see anything clearly. 'Looking at her [friend's] face, it was a giant orange blur. My eyes wouldn't fully focus,' she said. 'There was no pain, and my peripheral vision was fine, but everything I looked directly at was blocked by an orange blur.' Cobb first tried to play it cool and didn't immediately tell her friends how scared she was. 'I was panicking inside, but not outwardly so my friends didn't think anything of it,' she said. But her vision has not improved by morning. That's when she went to the hospital. 'My central vision was completely gone... I couldn't drive, I couldn't read, I couldn't see myself in the mirror... which meant I couldn't put on makeup... I couldn't even watch TV,' she said. At the hospital, doctors initially thought she had simply 'sunburned' her retinas. But when she saw a retinal specialist, she got a far more serious and rare diagnosis. 'I had hemorrhaged in both of my maculas and it was going to take three to six months to fully heal,' she said. Experts say the condition is extremely unusual in someone so young. 'In healthy individuals, especially young people, this occurrence is quite rare,' Dr. Rajesh C. Rao, an ophthalmologist who specializes in surgery of the retina, told the outlet. 'The head being upside down abruptly or repeatedly can also increase pressure in veins in the retina, and some at-risk individuals can be prone to macular hemorrhage.' Cobb said it took a while for reality to truly hit her. 'I started sobbing,' she told the outlet. It was the first time it fully hit me how limited I was and how dependent I was on other people for simple things like reading—which I had completely taken for granted.' While her vision did return after about three months, the bizarre injury still causes issues. Even decades later, Cobb still suffers flashes of light and dark floaters caused by retinal jelly detachment. 'The only option is surgery,' she said, 'but surgery almost always causes cataracts, which would only mean another surgery. So I'm okay to just live with it.' Despite the traumatic ordeal, Cobb remains grateful for all the joys in her life. 'We so often focus on what's going wrong in our lives, that we miss all of the things that are going right. 'There are so many simple gifts that could be bringing us joy every day, if we just learned to appreciate them. That's what this experience taught me: never stop being grateful.'