Hospital security bill soars to R2.5bn amid patient care crisis
The DA noted that PSIRA's annual rate increase stands at only 7.38%, far below the near six-fold rise in overall security spending.
The Democratic Alliance (DA) has voiced concern over soaring security costs at Gauteng public hospitals, which have skyrocketed from R655 million in 2022 to R2.54 billion in 2025 — nearly quadrupling in just three years.
According to DA Gauteng Shadow Health MEC Jack Bloom, the rising security expenditure is diverting much-needed funds from critical healthcare services.
'This squeezes out money needed to improve patient care,' said Bloom in a statement on Monday.
Multi-million rand contracts under scrutiny
Gauteng Health MEC Nomantu Nkomo-Ralehoko revealed in a written reply to the provincial legislature that the increase is due to 'additional points of service provision' and higher rates regulated by the Private Security Industry Regulatory Authority (PSIRA).
However, Bloom questioned the justification, noting that PSIRA's annual rate increase stands at only 7.38%, far below the near six-fold rise in overall security spending.
'As a percentage of the total Gauteng health budget, security costs have gone up from 1.1% in 2022 to 3.8% of this year's allocation of R66 billion,' he pointed out.
Security bills for major hospitals are among the highest. Chris Hani Baragwanath, Charlotte Maxeke Johannesburg, and Bertha Gxowa hospitals are paying R77 million, R72 million, and R26 million respectively to private security firms each year.
In response to Bloom's inquiry, the department stated: 'The security assessment report conducted justifies the additional increase in the number of guards, and it is in line with the PSIRA rates.'
ALSO READ: Mpumalanga primary school pupils treated for food poisoning after eating oranges
Guards unpaid despite soaring costs
Despite these massive outlays, some security workers are not being paid on time. At Tembisa Hospital, guards have gone on a go-slow, protesting after not being paid for three months.
At George Mukhari Hospital, Mafoko Security Patrollers recently lost a court case over failing to pay provident fund contributions.
Similar allegations have surfaced at Bertha Gxowa Hospital, where workers claim deductions are not reaching the required funds.
Although the department insists it uses 'a monthly performance monitoring tool to ensure that security workers are paid on time and according to legislation,' Bloom said, 'this does not appear to be effective.'
ALSO READ: Hospital horror: Cops in frantic search for two premature babies snatched from incubators
Calls for accountability
Bloom suspects widespread corruption.
'Many security companies seem to be grossly over-charging while underpaying their workers,' he said.
The DA has vowed to continue pushing the provincial health department to review the escalating costs.
'Hospital patients suffer because of a lack of budget to fix staff shortages, long queues, and broken equipment,' Bloom warned.
The Citizen has contacted the Gauteng Department of Health for further comment but had not received a response at the time of publication.
NOW READ: Suspect allegedly confesses to Tembisa Hospital fire
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
10 hours ago
- IOL News
SA's largest beef producer Karan Beef confirms a case of foot-and-mouth disease in Heidelberg
Karan Beef confirms a case of Foot-and-Mouth Disease at its feedlot Image: Ayanda Ndamane Independent Newspapers One of the major feedlot groups in South Africa, Karan Beef, has confirmed a case of Foot-and-Mouth Disease (FMD) at its feedlot in Heidelberg, Gauteng. Karan Beef has imposed a temporary pause on purchases after detecting the disease at its feedlot. The Marketing Manager at Karan Beef, Anso Bracken, revealed that the facility was placed under pre-emptive quarantine on May 30 following the identification of a suspected infection. 'This unfortunate development highlights the ongoing risks faced by the livestock industry, even under rigorous control systems, and Karan Beef is working closely with State Veterinary Services to ensure swift containment and to minimise any further risk to the broader industry,' said Bracken. Karan Beef has not disclosed further details on the implications of the situation for its beef delivery operations across South Africa. However, the company stated that additional updates will be provided as more information becomes available. Bracken said Karan Beef will remain committed to transparency, compliance, and maintaining the highest standards of animal health and welfare. Further updates will be provided as more information becomes available. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad Loading South Africa is grappling with significant challenges in its fight against foot-and-mouth disease (FMD), which has persisted for several months. This ongoing crisis has led key trading partners, including Zimbabwe, Namibia, Botswana, and China, to suspend imports of meat and related animal products from the country. In response, Minister of Agriculture John Steenhuisen has announced an urgent order for R72 million worth of FMD vaccines to combat the outbreak effectively. "Funds for the procurement of the vaccine have been transferred to Onderstepoort Biological Products (OBP). The procurement process has started, and the next batch of vaccines is estimated to be delivered by mid-June,' said Steenhuisen. The Freedom Front Plus (FF Plus) has also raised concerns about the disease. The party has called on the Department of Agriculture to intervene and approach this crisis with the necessary urgency. 'This development is creating a crisis for the entire red meat industry in South Africa, even the whole of southern Africa,' said the party. The FF Plus has highlighted that a crisis in northern KwaZulu-Natal and the Eastern Cape has escalated into a national emergency. If a major buyer like Karan Beef halts its livestock purchases, it could disrupt the entire industry. This situation is likely to drive meat prices down, forcing farmers to retain cattle on their farms at a time when grazing conditions deteriorate during the winter months. IOL NEWS
Mail & Guardian
15 hours ago
- Mail & Guardian
Reform of parole policy in South Africa — fact or fiction?
The balance balance between integration and stigma could bring down South Africa's high rate of re-offending. The debate on the possibilities and challenges of parole and rehabilitation in South Africa immediately brings to mind the words of British Journal of Criminology , Nonetheless, the To his credit, the The DA has also weighed in on the issue. Writing on behalf of his party, MP Similarly, These initiatives are not unimportant but are a poor show if it's meant to move the needle on rehabilitation and desistance from crime. It is the unexamined assumptions built into the DA's argument and that of the department that I wish to interrogate in this piece. The recent furore over the promise and possibility of parole reform in South Africa should be contextualised as it seems to have lost direction in a forest of uproar and excitement. To understand the enormity of the problem and the task ahead, it is necessary to first grasp the fundamental distinction between stigmatising shaming (found in South Africa and the US) and integrative shaming cultures (found in China, Japan and many African societies). It is a worthwhile exercise exploring the features and differences between these two cultures as it is important to understand what impact they have on parole policy within that context. I explained the differences in a 'All societies manage deviance through shame that results in either integration or stigma. Stigmatising condemns the offender, rather than the transgression committed, and this results in 'criminogenic labelling', which is 'counterproductive' (to use the well-known Australian criminologist John Braithwaite's words) to any project that wishes to promote rehabilitation and desistance. Integrative shaming, however, encourages reintegration by only condemning the criminal act and not the individual.' In essence, the difference between these two cultures is that whereas stigma drives ex-offenders away from mainstream society, and thus boosts reoffending as a measure of survival, an integrative shaming culture does everything possible to resettle them sustainably by providing employment, accommodation and even encouraging marriage. As a criminologist who devoted For one, I concluded my doctorate on a compelling theme in comparative criminology with the thought that the greatest obstacle to sustainable reintegration of former offenders is the stigma which faces former offenders upon their release from prison. Stigma forecloses employment opportunities for former offenders and leads to social ostracism. South Africa, for its part, exhibits a harsh stigmatising shaming culture and, considering the criminogenic effect of such an environment, it should not surprise us to learn that this country has one of the highest rates of reoffending in the world. On the one hand, Finland is a liberal democracy which, curiously, exhibits features of both integration and stigma and is a model South Africa could I am always amazed to be reminded that South Africa is a country where at least 70% of its inhabitants profess to be Christian and yet there is such an enormous intolerance of former offenders who have served their time and are eager for reintegration. Taking my cue from This is the thought that strikes me as I read the If the rehabilitation paradigm is redundant in this country, as I The deeply unequal income and ownership disparities in post-apartheid South African society adds to the conundrum of stigma. In the words of British Journal of Criminology , 'P The dynamics of a stigmatising shaming culture is described by 'The disturbing phenomenon of people cycling in and out of prison, trapped by their second-class status, has been described by Loic Wacquant as a 'closed circuit of perpetual marginality'. Hundreds of thousands of people are released from prison every year, only to find themselves locked out of the mainstream society and economy. Most ultimately return to prison, sometimes for the rest of their lives. Others are released again, only to find themselves in precisely the same circumstances they occupied before, unable to cope with the stigma of the prison label and their permanent pariah status.' Efforts at resettlement are significantly hindered by the existing stigma threaded through our culture. Regardless of the parole policy in place, stigma continues to seriously impede rehabilitation efforts. Sadly, the debilitating effects of stigma do not begin when the offender is released but are already in place during incarceration, damaging offenders in complicated and significant ways. In a paper published more than 20 years ago, the American researchers 'The bitterness underlying these comments shows the flip side of the power of community reintegration: when stigma and rejection are the dominant experience [as is certainly the case in South Africa], the potentially restorative benefits of civic participation are lost.' Even though the One way of doing so is to follow The excitement around the promise and possibility of parole reform in South Africa is indeed fiction as the route to success stories in rehabilitation and, by implication, positive outcomes for parole, does not, conversely, lie with the institution of parole but with the quality of offenders' reception during their incarceration and, especially, once released from custody. Dr Casper Lötter is a conflict criminologist affiliated with North-West University's School of Philosophy.
The Citizen
15 hours ago
- The Citizen
‘I could die before surgery': Cancer patient lost in Gauteng hospitals backlog
Over 34 000 patients are waiting to undergo surgery in various Gauteng public hospitals. A man from Gauteng, who is suffering from skin cancer and living in pain, has been told he may have to wait up to eight months for surgery at the Charlotte Maxeke Johannesburg Academic Hospital. But he doesn't have eight months. He could be dead before then. There are probably many more like him who are low down on the waiting list for surgery at Gauteng's government hospitals and who may die before they are admitted to theatre. Thousands trapped in growing surgical backlog There are more than 34 000 patients waiting, said Gauteng health MEC Nomantu Nkomo-Ralehoko in a written reply to questions by the DA's shadow health MEC Jack Bloom in the Gauteng Legislature. The man has developed a lump on his cheek, making it difficult for him to eat and speak. Early this year, he was diagnosed with skin cancer known as squamous cell carcinoma which has the potential to spread all over the body if left untreated. He is one of the 3 315 patients who has been on the surgery waiting list at Charlotte Maxeke Johannesburg Academic Hospital. Patient faces starvation and suffocation risk 'The cancer has begun to spread to other body parts causing considerable pain and swelling,' said the patient in a statement. He was scheduled to have a feeding tube and stent inserted yesterday, but the appointment has been moved again to the following week. 'The hospital cannot perform the primary procedure due to a backlog of patients. The growth must be removed, along with reconstructive surgery on my jawline,' said the patient. 'We were told I might have to wait for another six to eight months.' Hospital resources stretched beyond limits Cancer Alliance director Salomé Meyer said the man was turned away from hospital yesterday morning. She said the patient requires a feeding tube and a stent to allow him to breathe and to eat. ALSO READ: Health minister defends nearly R10 million legal spend on NHI court battles 'If that is not emergency surgery then what is? He was told to come back next week as the surgeon is now attending another hospital. 'The hospital has only one operating theatre and one intensive care unit. Patients with trauma from car accidents or gunshot wounds take precedence. 'We are now actively seeking to raise funds to facilitate the removal of the growth before it spreads further and completely blocks his airways.' Meyer said the man first required emergency surgery but his surgery was cancelled. 'If he does not get this surgery as soon as possible, he will starve to death and possibly suffocate,' she said. Budget shortfalls and misused funds deepen crisis Meyer said in 2023-24, a portion of the R784 million that was made available for backlogs was also to be allocated to surgery, but 'we did not get any feedback from the department of health. What we know is that they did not use R250 million of the ringfenced cancer money and now are spending the remaining money on the cancer backlog for radiation,' she said. 'So where is the money for surgical backlogs? The problem is all of the affected hospitals have had staff cuts.' Meyer said it would not be surprising cancer patients were the majority requiring surgery as many of them can 'wait' as their operations are not regarded as emergency or life-saving. She added the budget cuts were affecting all the hospitals. 'Gauteng is particularly affected because of the backlogs. We need to realise that health in SA is in the emergency room – and we do not have blood, or even staff to attend to this crisis,' she said. Patients could wait years Nkomo-Ralehoko said the largest waiting list is 6 764 patients at the Steve Biko Hospital in Pretoria, followed by the Chris Hani Baragwanath Hospital in Soweto (6 232), Dr George Mukhari Hospital in GaRankuwa (5 354), and 3315 patients at the Charlotte Maxeke Hospital. ALSO READ: Gauteng hospital security bill soars to R2.54bn amid patient care crisis Bloom said: 'Furthermore, figures are only given for 17 out of 37 hospitals in Gauteng. 'Waiting times differ for certain types of surgery; for instance, it is only one to two months for a cataract removal at Leratong Hospital, but two years at the Mamelodi and Yusuf Dadoo hospitals. 'While patients at Kalafong Hospital in Atteridgeville wait five years for hip surgery. They will only wait three to six months at Dr George Mukhari Hospital.' He added: 'The MEC blames the long waiting times on the high turnover of patients to Gauteng and the burden of trauma that takes preference over elective cases. She also admits that load shedding and water shortages lead to cancellations and postponements of surgeries. 'In May last year, the MEC claimed that the surgical waiting lists had been reduced from 38 000 to 24 000, so this progress has been reversed. I estimate the real waiting list for all 37 hospitals is probably about 40 000 as the budget cuts and staffing shortages have worsened the situation.' Bloom said while surgical blitzes can temporarily bring the number down, the DA is pushing for effective use of the R66 billion budget to permanently reduce the waiting lists. Health department denies backlog as crisis escalates Gauteng department of health spokesperson Motalatale Modiba conceded there were 34 528 patients recorded on surgical waiting lists at public hospitals in the province, but denied there is a backlog. 'The waiting lists includes patients across key specialties such as cataract, general surgery, paediatrics and others. However, it is important to differentiate between surgical backlogs and waiting lists. 'The waiting list is a dynamic figure as it fluctuates as and when new patients are registered on the waiting list and when surgeries are performed – it is therefore a moving target.' ALSO READ: Mother accuses Mpumalanga hospital of sabotage in medical negligence case Other hospitals with long waiting lists
