"Criticising Israel is not always antisemitism" says Dr Shmuel Lederman, an Israeli genocide scholar
Initially hesitant to apply the genocide label, his assessment changed dramatically: "Until mid-2024 it was somewhat possible not to say that what Israel is doing is genocide, but over time, Gaza was simply being destroyed." By year's end, "the continued destruction—of hospitals, schools, and cultural sites—was genocide."Challenging Legal DefinitionsLederman argues that the legal definition of genocide has become an obstacle to prevention. "Genocide scholars for a long time have been engaged in a discourse that is critical of the legal definition because it's very narrow and originated partly in the political interests of the states that formulated it."The 1948 Genocide Convention requires proof of specific intent to destroy a group. Lederman contends: "Once you have this kind of destruction of a group, it should be called genocide—regardless of intent." More troubling, he suggests: "The legal definition of genocide actually serves to block us from preventing genocide when it actually takes place—like in the case of Israel and Gaza."advertisementConfronting Antisemitism AccusationsAs an Israeli Jew criticising his own country, Lederman faces unique challenges. "We need to distinguish very sharply between criticism—however harsh—of Israel, and anti-Semitism," he emphasises. "Anti-Semitism is about certain prejudices, stereotypes, generalisation, demonisation of Jews—not criticism of a sovereign state."He notes his identity provides some protection: "Me being an Israeli Jew, it's harder to criticise me as anti-Semitic... there's a certain privilege." However, he warns: "Very often, calling people anti-Semitic is simply a way of silencing them because they criticise Israel."Societal ComplicityLederman's critique extends beyond government policy to Israeli society itself. "Much of Israeli society either participated in it actively or gave it legitimacy," he observes. Even among government critics, "the majority of Israeli politicians criticising Netanyahu are not doing so on moral grounds—they're talking about hostages or tactical failures."Most concerning is the impact on Israeli youth: "The dehumanisation and demonisation of Palestinians has been ongoing for a long time in Israel—especially when it comes to Gaza." He warns: "For many young people, mocking the suffering in Gaza is almost a form of entertainment, revenge."International InactionLederman doesn't limit criticism to Israel. "Without American support, Israel could not have done what it did," he states bluntly. Regarding international justice mechanisms, he's pessimistic: "It's very likely that the ICJ would conclude there's no proof that Israel intended to destroy the group—because of the very high legal bar."As a genocide scholar breaking ranks with more cautious colleagues, Lederman represents a growing voice calling for fundamental changes in how mass atrocities are recognised and addressed.Must Watch
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NDTV
13 minutes ago
- NDTV
Why Alaska, Once Russian Territory, Was Chosen For Trump-Putin Meeting
Washington: US President Donald Trump and Russian counterpart, Vladimir Putin, will meet face-to-face for the first time in seven years on Friday for talks aimed at ending the war in Ukraine. The Russian President will fly to Anchorage, the largest city in Alaska, for the much-anticipated US-Russia summit, scheduled to take place at Joint Base Elmendorf-Richardson. The choice to host the meet in Alaska is not an accident. The westernmost US state's complex history and strategic location have close geographic and cultural links to Russia. Its strategic and symbolic position in the US and Russia's past stretches back centuries. Alaska's History A Russian colony since the 18th century, Alaska was sold to the United States for $7.2 million in 1867 by Tsar Alexander II. It is now a symbol of the entwined history of the countries, whose relations have been severely damaged since Russia launched its offensive in Ukraine in 2022. The remote territory was economically very difficult for the Russians to exploit, and at the time, its sale was welcomed by the Imperial Court as the country was struggling economically. In recent years, the price at which Alaska was sold, considered by some to be ridiculously low, and the legal validity of the transaction have become regularly recurring debates in Russia. The transaction has come to be seen as a regrettable bargain after what formerly was a fur trading hub turned out to house crucial natural resources: gold and oil. In July 2022, in the midst of patriotic fervour in Russia and as tensions soared between Moscow and Washington following the offensive against Ukraine, the Alaska issue resurfaced. The speaker of the Duma, the lower house of the Russian Parliament, Vyacheslav Volodin, spoke of "lands to be returned", describing Alaska as a "disputed territory". But, Russia's authorities are apparently not interested in reclaiming it. In 2014, Vladimir Putin, asked by a pensioner about the possibility, replied: "My dear, why do you need Alaska?" adding the territory was "too cold". Why Alaska Was Chosen As Meeting Venue Legal Shield To Putin: The Russian President was indicted for war crimes in 2023 by the International Criminal Court (ICC), and so is subject to arrest in as many as 125 countries. Given the ICC warrant, Putin can't travel to most nations across the globe. But the United States does not recognise ICC jurisdiction, which means hosting the summit in Alaska avoids potential legal complications for the Russian leader. Earlier, the US also hosted Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netyenyahu, who is also subject to an ICC warrant over war crimes in Gaza. Strategic Symbolism and Geography: A four-kilometre-long Bering Strait separates Alaska from Russian territory. Its close proximity to Russia serves as a powerful symbol of their intertwined history and the potential for renewed diplomacy. Once Russian territory, Alaska embodies both geopolitical intrigue and shared legacy. Security and Seclusion: The summit is being hosted at Joint Base Elmendorf-Richardson-- Alaska's largest military base-- that combines the Air Force's Elmendorf base with the US Army's Fort Richardson. The remote military installation plays host to some of America's most fearsome fighter jets and provides exceptional security and privacy. The base has Cold War roots and remains critical to US Northern defence infrastructure.
News18
38 minutes ago
- News18
Gaza Cartoon Programme With Mickey Mouse Lookalike Taught Children To 'Kill Israelis': Report
Last Updated: Tomorrow's Pioneers was aired on Hamas-owned Al-Aqsa TV every Friday from April 2007 to October 2009, which encouraged anti-Jewish violence and martyrdom. Children in Gaza reportedly grew up watching a cartoon programme, featuring a Mickey Mouse lookalike, which encourages kids to 'kill" Israelis, hate Jews and embrace martyrdom. The show called Tomorrow's Pioneers was aired on Hamas-owned Al-Aqsa TV every Friday from April 2007 to October 2009. It includes Farfour, a costumed Mickey Mouse lookalike, and celebrates anti-Jewish violence and martyrdom, according to a report by the New York Post. Farfour promises the children of Gaza that they will oversee Islamic world domination and liberate Jerusalem from the 'murderers", while mimicking grenade-throwing and shooting an AK-47. Farfour was later shown beaten to death by Israeli soldiers and replaced with other characters. Farfour was replaced by a bumblebee with a squeaky voice named Nahoul, who preaches, 'We will liberate Al-Aqsa from the filth of the criminal Jews" and swears 'revenge upon the enemies of God". He is later shown getting sick and being denied a travel permit to seek treatment in Egypt before dying. Moreover, in one episode, children were invited into the studio to tell the hosts of their wish to die as martyrs, and then sing a song about it. 'It's a constant stream of horrific propaganda that is almost impossible for a child to break out of. And so the kids grow up thinking that every Israeli should be killed because every Israeli is bad and evil," said Mia Bloom, professor of communication and Middle East studies at Georgia State University. 'Directing Trauma In Children' Bloom said Hamas knew the children were already traumatised by the decades-long Palestinian conflict and sought to traumatise them further with Tomorrow's Pioneers to 'control the narrative" and 'direct the trauma" against Israel. 'This kind of layered trauma that you're deliberately exposing young Palestinian children to was not just a form of child abuse, but a long-term manipulation," she told the New York Post. 'It relates to October 7th. To have those resources and instead of making things better, you've just made things so much worse." The show's co-host, Gaza child star Saraa Barhoum, was around 10 years old when the show first aired, and the daughter of a university professor mother and a Hamas spokesman father. She revealed in a 2007 interview that she wanted to be either a doctor or a martyr when she grew up. Barhoum also launched a singing career, recording pop songs with lyrics like, 'raise your sail for the sailors, and let your lighthouse illuminate the sea of blood." The NYP report implied that the show demonising Jews played a role in the October 7, 2023, attacks, as many of the Hamas fighters who attacked Israel were aged between 16 and 35 years. view comments Location : Jerusalem, Israel First Published: August 14, 2025, 15:01 IST News world Gaza Cartoon Programme With Mickey Mouse Lookalike Taught Children To 'Kill Israelis': Report Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Tehran true story: John Abraham's film inspired by 2012 attacks on Israeli diplomats; explosions and their impact explained
Tehran true story: John Abraham's upcoming film Tehran is based on the 2012 attacks on Israeli diplomats in New Delhi. These coordinated blasts, which stunned the nation and drew international attention, from the intense backdrop of the movie. Blending real events with high-octane drama, the film promises a gripping take on one of India's most shocking incidents in recent history. Tehran true story - What were the 2012 attacks on Israeli diplomats? The 2012 attacks on Israeli diplomats involved a series of coordinated bombings targeting Israeli diplomatic staff in New Delhi, India; Tbilisi, Georgia; and Bangkok, Thailand, on February 13 and 14, 2012. In New Delhi, a magnetic bomb attached to the car of an Israeli diplomat's wife exploded, injuring her, the driver, and two bystanders. In Tbilisi, a similar device was discovered and safely defused, while in Bangkok, a failed bombing attempt left several people injured. Bombings and their impact Israel accused Iran's Revolutionary Guard Corps of orchestrating the attacks as part of a broader retaliation for the 2008 assassination of Hezbollah commander Imad Mughniyeh. The bombings were seen as an extension of the Iran–Israel proxy conflict, with Iran allegedly seeking to avenge the killing of its ally. The attacks heightened tensions between Israel and Iran, with both countries accusing each other of state-sponsored terrorism. Increased security measures were implemented at Israeli diplomatic missions worldwide. The incidents intensified international scrutiny of Iran's activities. Who all star in Tehran? Alongside John Abraham, Tehran features Manushi Chhillar in action-packed roles. The cast also includes Neeru Bajwa, Hadi Khanjanpour, Madhurima Tuli, Adam Karst, Allon Sylvain, and Ido Samuel. Where to watch Tehran on OTT? Tehran is now streaming on Zee5.
