Grandmother of boys abducted by her son appeals court ruling in attempt to keep boys in Egypt
The grandmother of two children from Ireland abducted by her son has appealed a ruling in the Egyptian courts in a bid to prevent her grandchildren being returned to their Irish mother.
In March 2022, Mandy Kelly's two children Zayn, who will be seven this month, and Kareem, aged four, from Dundalk, Co Louth, visited their grandmother in Cairo on a family holiday which turned into a "living hell".
During the trip, their father, Ramy Gamal Maamoun Mohamed, locked Ms Kelly in an apartment and abducted his two sons.
Ms Kelly has not seen her children since. She fled back to Ireland where she has campaigned tirelessly for three years to have her children returned to her care.
Both judiciaries in Ireland and Egypt have ruled the children should be returned to their mother. However, Ms Kelly's estranged husband cannot be located by police in Cairo to execute the court order.
The children's paternal grandmother, who is supporting her son in rearing the boys, appealed to the courts to keep the children at a hearing in Cairo last month.
Ms Kelly told the Irish Examiner she hopes for a final conclusion on the case by the summer.
'The judge insisted the school reports be made available to the courts for both children' she explained.
'My ex-mother-in-law did not attend the hearing, and she was represented by her Egyptian lawyers.
'I would also be interested in seeing my children's school reports' she added. "But what is more shocking is that she can appeal a case without attending".
Ms Kelly added she was 'hopeful' the appeal would not be successful and the children would be safely returned home.
'It's three years now since they were taken and I have not seen them and I will never be able to explain what this has done to me let alone what it has done to my sons' she said.
'I have also been informed that prior to my travels to Egypt that the Tánaiste Simon Harris wrote again to his Egyptian counterparts for this case to be concluded — that is something I am very grateful for.
'I am expecting a letter from him in the upcoming days, and I can't thank the Department of Foreign Affairs and those Government ministers and politicians who have lobbied to help get my boy's home," Ms Kelly said.
'It is a long time to be away from your children and despite two court rulings in my favour and following the Egyptian legal process, I am still waiting for Zayn and Kareem to come home.'
Read More
Interpol posts yellow missing persons alert over Irish woman's children being held in Egypt
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Daily Mirror
3 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Ireland faces 'day of reckoning' over Ukraine support, Russian ambassador warns
Ireland will face 'a day of reckoning' for supporting Ukraine the Russian Ambassador warned. Yury Filatov also accused the government of complicity in Ukraine's 'barbaric terrorist acts'. His remarks posted on X are likely to renew calls for him to be kicked out of the country. He stated: 'Those in the West who support [the] Zelensky regime are de-facto accomplices in these terrorist crimes and should be called out as such. 'The European governments, including Ireland, who had been applauding Zelensky and Co., supplying them with money and weapons and spreading Kiev's propaganda, share responsibility for the regime's actions. 'They should be aware the day of reckoning will come.' As recently as last February Filatov told The Star Ireland has nothing to fear from Russia. But it now appears that has all changed. Despite Russia invading its neighbour, the diplomat claimed Ukraine started the war. Filatov added: 'It became clear long ago the Kiev authorities have never shunned violence and terrorist methods. 'First in their war against the people of Donetsk and Lugansk in 2014-2022 and then against the entire population of Russia, including targeted bombings and political assassinations. 'It has become a trademark of the cabal which usurped power in Ukraine in 2014. 'Yet, in recent days they outdid even themselves by staging direct attacks on the ordinary people in the Bryansk and Kursk regions of Russia. 'On May 31, Ukrainian saboteurs had blown up a bridge on the A240 highway, directly above the civilian train that went from the city of Klimov to Moscow, instantly killing 7 civilians and severely injuring more than 118. 'Among the victims of this terrorist attack were eight children, with 2 deceased, and a pregnant doctor who worked in a hospice in Bryanks, who died there. 'Same night at 3:00 there has been another bridge explosion, this time in Kursk region, which resulted in a freight train derailment and injuries of the train driver and his assistants. 'Reaction from the West? None – no condemnations, no sympathy.' In response, a spokesperson for the Department of Foreign Affairs said: 'Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine was an act of unprovoked and unjustified aggression and has resulted in countless deaths and untold suffering. 'Ireland and its EU partners have been unequivocal and steadfast in our support for Ukraine, as it exercises its legitimate right to self-defence in line with the UN Charter. 'We strongly condemn Russia's bombardment of Ukrainian cities and civilian infrastructure, and join Ukraine, the EU and partners in calling for a full, immediate and unconditional ceasefire. 'It is for Russia to demonstrate a genuine commitment towards peace by halting its brutal attacks and implementing the proposed ceasefire, without conditions. It can do so at any time.'
Irish Examiner
6 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Children are being re-traumatised as abusers weaponise the courts system
Groundbreaking research published last week into the Irish family law system undertaken by Trinity College Dublin and University College Cork, and commissioned by Women's Aid, makes for stark and sobering reading. The findings of this 360-degree examination of the experiences of adult and child victim-survivors of domestic violence and abuse in guardianship, custody and access proceedings show court processes are re-traumatising those who have already suffered. However daunting as the findings are, this research offers us a clear strategic opportunity to do better. The voices of victim-survivors of domestic violence and abuse — women, men, and children — are strongly telling us what needs to change. This research comes at a key time for family justice in Ireland, with progress on many of the key deliverables of the national Family Justice Strategy already under way. We can transform a system that is not currently domestic violence and abuse informed or responsive, into one that understands how domestic abuse is impacting many court users, is trauma-informed, victim-survivor-centred, and truly hears the voices and wishes of children. Sarah Benson: 'The children and young people who contributed to this research had engaged with a variety of professionals, including court assessors, social workers, judges and members of An Garda Síochána, but said they felt their experiences were discounted and disbelieved, and their wishes ignored.' This research is unique in Ireland, but its findings strongly echo what is already known from similar international research. It draws from court observations, hundreds of survey responses, wide ranging interviews and focus groups with children, aged-out minors, adults, domestic violence practitioners, health, social care and legal professionals and judges, and the final report provides an in-depth perspective of the barriers facing victim-survivors of abuse in our family law system. It captures hundreds of reports of physical, emotional, economic and sexual abuse of women, men and children. It tells us that sadly it is not enough for some key individuals among legal, judicial and courts personnel to be domestic abuse (including coercive control) informed, which victim-survivors reported as being "transformational" for them in terms of feeling believed, supported and empowered to manage their safety and that of their children. Pockets of individual good practice are revealed as completely inadequate when the system itself is not attuned and responsive to the tactics and impacts of domestic abuse post-separation. Participants in the research spoke of having to adhere to court-ordered access to avoid being charged with violating a court order, requiring them to regularly engage with their abuser. This frequently provided court-sanctioned opportunities for further abuse to occur. Children in Ireland have the constitutional right to have their views heard and considered, particularly in legal proceedings involving their safety, welfare, or wellbeing. However, this research tells us very clearly this is not happening in the Irish family law system. There remains an issue whereby living in a home where there is domestic abuse is still not sufficiently recognised as abuse of children themselves, despite this being a clear position of the WHO and Tusla policy. In court proceedings that impact children's lives, the risks of post-separation abuse, including coercive control, are therefore not considered adequately. The children and young people who contributed to this research had engaged with a variety of professionals, including court assessors, social workers, judges and members of An Garda Síochána, but said they felt their experiences were discounted and disbelieved, and their wishes ignored. Examples given include children disclosing experiences of assault by their abusive parent, and that information being ignored or disputed in court. While the children told the researchers they could not have been clearer that they did not want to spend any time with an abusive parent and gave a good rationale and evidence for that assertion, they described not feeling heard or taken seriously by professionals when contact was continued or extended. Always having contact with both parents as in a child's best interest should not be the starting point in considering matters of custody and access where there are allegations of abuse. It may be, but it also may not, so a neutral starting point as to this question is appropriate. There is also a clear pattern reported, particularly where there are court reports being produced to give "voice" to the child, that in the absence of meaningful consideration of domestic violence and abuse, the highly contested concept of "parental alienation" is being presented as the only possible reason mothers and children are resistant to contact and access. At the launch of research into the Irish family law system were: Ruth Elliffe, TCD; Stephanie Holt, TCD; Davina James-Hanman, Violence Against Women consultant; Sarah Benson, Women's Aid chief executive; Soma Gregory, TCD; Aisling Parkes, UCC; and Ailbhe Smyth, chair of Women's Aid. Picture: Paul Sharp/Sharpix In telling us how the system failed them, the victims-survivors that took part in this research have also shown us exactly what change should and can look like. The family law system is neither simple nor straightforward. It is a complex and evolving network, composed of laws, courts, judges, legal professionals, services, and, crucially, the lived experiences of families. These components do not function in isolation but interact in ways that are often unpredictable and dynamic. The outcomes for individuals seeking support are shaped by the whole system, rather than by any single decision, law, or individual actor. To truly improve the family law system, we must move beyond focusing on its individual parts and instead examine how all these elements are interconnected and influence each other. Women's Aid urges the Government to fundamentally reform the family law system as part of the new Family Justice Strategy in a consciously domestic violence- and abuse-informed manner. We need compulsory domestic abuse training for all professionals, including judges. We need comprehensive screening and risk assessment protocols and practices across all proceedings, radical reform of the 'expert reports' system, and improved access to legal representation. We need the development of clear mechanisms to improve coordination, communication, and cooperation across all civil family law proceedings and with the criminal courts. And we also need the supporting systems and specialist stakeholders that families access to be resourced and facilitated to minimise trauma and risk. This underpinning domestic violence- and abuse-informed approach needs to be an explicit and shared project by all stakeholders to improve the system for the most vulnerable. Everyone involved must understand how perpetrators can weaponise the court system and be an ally and advocate on this. We need to reduce, and eradicate, tolerance for abuse of the system itself, which goes on to retraumatise those we should be protecting. With the voices of adult and child victim-survivors now clearly amplified in this research, we have the evidence, the insight, and the moral imperative to build a system that protects, listens, and heals. Now we need to accelerate action to ensure these voices are heard and rights vindicated. Sarah Benson is chief executive of Women's Aid
Sunday World
6 hours ago
- Sunday World
Murder of Scottish gangsters in Spain could drag Kinahan Cartel into new mob war
Fears that double killing could signal Irish gangsters' involvement in new mob war The pair, who were shot dead in an attack at Monaghan's pub in Fuengirola on the Costa del Sol eight days ago, were key figures in the Glasgow-based Lyons crime gang. The Lyons mob formed a close alliance with the Kinahan Cartel through Eddie Jnr's brother, Stephen, who previously lived in Spain and now resides in Dubai, and were suspected of helping the Kinahans coordinate the shipment of €157million of cocaine on board the MV Matthews. Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party MSP and former crime journalist Russell Findlay yesterday told the Sunday World a major concern for StephenLyons at this moment is whether the Kinahans may have, in fact, sanctioned the hit. The scene at Monaghan's pub in Fuengirola on the Costa del Sol where Eddie Lyons Jnr and Ross Monaghan were gunned down 'We already know the Kinahans' involvement in the Scottish drug trade is significant,' he said. 'Their connections with the Lyons have fuelled gangland violence in Scotland and escalated it over the years. 'In the paranoid world of organised crime, there is a lot of smoke and mirrors, a lot of speculation, but what I suppose this boils down to, is either the Kinahans have had a hand in these murders due to some unknown internal fallout or they have seen two of their allies gunned down in cold blood. 'If it is the latter, then the expectation would be there will be some kind of retribution. 'If I was in Stephen Lyons' shoes, living my luxury air-conditioned lifestyle in Dubai, I would be seeking a meeting with the Kinahans at the earliest possible opportunity to work out who has been responsible for this. . 'But the real fear now is this will only fuel gangland violence, not just in Spain, but also in the streets of Scotland.' In the immediate aftermath of the double assassination at Monaghan's bar, speculation immediately connected the killings to a feud between the Lyons and the rival Daniel gang in Scotland. An escalation in that feud has resulted in assaults, shootings and fire-bombings across Glasgow and Edinburgh in recent months. However, a Lyons family member subsequently discounted this theory, while a statement by Police Scotland said there is 'nothing to suggest that the shooting in Fuengirola was planned from within Scotland'. Ross Monaghan Spanish police are instead understood to be focussed on the likelihood the murders are linked to wider gangland tensions – and are making inquiries to determine what if any stance the Kinahans had taken on the killings. Lyons (46), and Monaghan (43) died when a gunman opened fire on them in the Fuengirola bar – where the pair had watched the Champions League final, at about 11pm on the night of the killings.# The gunman then fled the scene in a car. Sources say the Daniel gang had shied away from making any moves against the Lyons in Spain due to their connections with the Kinahan mob and believe it unlikely their attitude would have changed sufficiently for involvement in the double killing likely. Outlining the background to the Kinahan's alliance with the Lyons and the effect this had on their feud with the Daniel gang, our source referred to a triple shooting in Scotland that occurred at an MOT station in the Lambhill area of the city in 2006. Gangsters Eddie Lyons Jnr In that shooting, Stephen Lyons was badly wounded, as was his associate Robert Pickett, while Stephen's cousin Michael Lyons was shot dead. A source said: 'Going way back, there was a triple shooting in Glasgow at an MOT station, Stephen was shot, his cousin Michael was murdered, and a third man Pickett was shot. backlash 'That resulted in Stephen fleeing to Spain. And it was that, fleeing to Spain, that was either the catalyst for the Kinahan connection being made or that made it bigger than it had already been. 'At that point, some Daniel gang-related associate was in the Costa del Sol and ascertained the Lyons were close to the Kinahans and took the view that they could not make a move on them in Spain. 'They could not make a move against Stephen in Spain. Russell Findlay 'So, if the Daniel gang took the view that was too big a move or that the backlash would be too big back then, it would be consistent with them not having the wherewithal to do it now.' The source said Stephen Lyons is the only member remaining out of the youth gang from which he, Michael and Eddie Jnr emerged. 'The rest are either dead or in prison,' he said. Asked if Stephen Lyons has anything to fear from his long-term allies, the Kinahans, the source responded: 'These people have absolutely no qualms about putting a knife between the shoulder blades of their best friends if it suits them. 'There's no loyalty and there's a paranoia that envelopes everything they do. So, it would be premature to assume the Kinahans are on a war footing over this to avenge the Lyons murders when for all we know they could have been responsible for it.' In their statement released on Tuesday, Police Scotland said they were not directly investigating the double murder. Instead they said: 'The investigation into the fatal shootings in Fuengirola is being carried out by Spanish police,' it said. 'Police Scotland is supporting Spanish police where requested; however at this time we have no officers deployed within Spain. 'There is currently no intelligence to suggest the deaths of these two men in Spain are linked to the recent criminal attacks in Scotland being investigated as part of Operation Portaledge. 'Any misinformation or speculation linking the events in Spain are not helpful to the ongoing investigations in either country.'
