United Nations experts call for Starmer's Chagos deal to be suspended
Keir Starmer is facing humiliation on the international stage after experts at the United Nations (UN) called for his controversial deal with Mauritius on the Chagos Islands to be suspended.
UN special rapporteurs Nicolas Levrat, KP Ashwini, Bernard Duhaime, and Bina D'Costa have slammed the agreement, which hands back sovereignty of the archipelago to Mauritius and leases back the UK-US military base on Diego Garcia for £101m per year for 99 years, for failing to protect the rights of Chagossians.
It follows Sir Keir's government moving rapidly last month to prevent a High Court appeal against the treaty by representatives of the Chagossian community, who had opposed the deal.
Now, the prime minister is under pressure from critics on all sides to suspend the deal just weeks after he signed it with Mauritius.
The attack from the UN comes as the Tories have tabled legislation in parliament to block the deal from coming into law.
In a statement on Tuesday the UN experts said: 'By maintaining a foreign military presence of the United Kingdom and the United States on Diego Garcia and preventing the Chagossian people from returning to Diego Garcia, the agreement appears to be at variance with the Chagossians' right to return, which also hinders their ability to exercise their cultural rights in accessing their ancestral lands from which they were expelled.'
They added: 'In light of these significant concerns, we call for the ratification of the agreement to be suspended and for a new agreement to be negotiated that fully guarantees the rights of the Chagossian people to return to all islands of the Chagos Archipelago, including Diego Garcia. This includes their right to adequate and effective remedy and reparations, including restitution, satisfaction, and guarantees of non-repetition, as well as their cultural rights.'
The deal is also being criticised in the UK for potentially undermining the UK/US base on Diego Garcia, which is seen as crucial to western defence.
While the government claimed that the overall cost would be £3bn for the taxpayer, critics have estimated that over the 99-year lease period, it will cost £30bn potentially eating up the extra spending on the defence budget.
Sir Keir and Foreign Secretary David Lammy have maintained that they had to do the deal because a ruling by the International Court of Justice (ICJ) that the islands should be handed back to Mauritius threatened the existence of the crucial military airbase.
They warned that the UK would face a number of legal challenges which could make the operation of the base of Diego Garcia impossible.
The deal was signed after Donald Trump gave it his blessing, despite lobbying from Nigel Farage.
But the UN experts were highly critical of the government's refusal to properly engage with Chagossians who have been made homeless by their removal from Diego Garcia and the impact of the deal.
They said: 'We are gravely concerned about the lack of meaningful participation of Chagossians in processes that have led to the agreement.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
36 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Boris Johnson: ‘Feeble' defence budget will leave us at Russia's mercy
Boris Johnson has said Labour's 'feeble' spending on defence leaves Britain at the mercy of Russia. The former prime minister told The Telegraph that Rachel Reeves's claims that defence spending would rise to 2.6 per cent of GDP by 2027 had left him 'very puzzled' and that the Chancellor's reluctance to pump more money into the sector suggested she did not view it as a priority. On Wednesday, Ms Reeves said defence spending would rise to 2.6 per cent by April 2027, but did not confirm whether it would climb higher, as demanded by Nato. 'This is feeble,' Mr Johnson said. 'They [Labour] have wasted a big opportunity. 'My view is that this Government is completely failing to show the leadership that is needed to defend Britain and defend Europe. 'Labour are congenitally hostile to defence spending. Their grass roots are still basically Corbynistas who think Russia is a great thing. Those views are still highly influential in Labour.' At the start of this year, Sir Keir Starmer pledged to send British troops into Ukraine in the event that a ceasefire between the two warring nations was negotiated by Donald Trump. A ' coalition of the willing ' was also established between European nations, with the UK said to be leading the group that would establish a road to peace in Ukraine. However, talk on both of these subjects appears to have gone quiet. Mr Johnson, who was prime minister when Russia launched its full-scale invasion of Ukraine in Feb 2022, and has remained close with Volodymyr Zelensky, the Ukrainian president, since leaving government, said: 'What's happened to the boots on the ground initiative? 'As with Ukraine, the way to peace is through strength. If you talk to people in Ukraine or the US, they will say leadership on protecting Ukraine is now being offered by Germany and France.' Mr Johnson also said the Chancellor's increase in the welfare budget was 'out of control' and that such sums should be invested in defence instead. At a summit in the Hague later this month, which Mr Trump will attend, all Nato members will be expected to agree to committing 5 per cent of GDP on defence. Mark Rutte, the Nato secretary-general, has called for all alliance members to get to 3.5 per cent by 2032 and 5 per cent by an unspecified date. Earlier this week, Mr Rutte told The Telegraph that if Nato nations failed to achieve this percentage, then they needed ' to start learning to speak Russian '. Ms Reeves told the Commons: 'A new era in the threats we face demands a new era for defence and security. That's why we took the decision to prioritise our defence spending by reducing overseas development aid so that defence spending will now rise to 2.6 per cent of GDP by April 2027, including the contribution of our intelligence agencies. 'That uplift provides funding for the Defence Secretary, with a £11 billion increase in defence spending and a £600 milllion uplift for our security and intelligence agencies.' However, Tory sources claimed that by adding the single intelligence agencies budget in with the defence budget, it was eating into what money was left for the Armed Forces and did not account for 2.5 per cent of GDP on defence. 'Labour have taken money from a different department and pretended it was going to the Armed Forces,' one said. However, a Labour source accused the Tories of 'getting their numbers wrong' and insisted Wednesday's announcement was 'not a cut to defence' based on the Nato qualifying spend.
BBC News
36 minutes ago
- BBC News
Bedford Mayor wants council staff in the office three days a week
Council staff will be expected to work at least three days a week from the office as part of a new policy, a mayor said. Conservative Tom Wootton confirmed it would apply to "office-based crews" only at Bedford Council, after some workers felt "very lonely". He told BBC Three Counties Radio presenter Jonathan Vernon-Smith that "asking them to come in to work as part of a team was really important".He added that the change was part of a Stability Plan that had originally been discussed at a meeting of its executive in April. In 2020, the Covid-19 pandemic saw many people working from home, and figures from the Office for National Statistics suggested more than a quarter of working adults in Great Britain were still hybrid working in autumn posted on social media that he was reversing what he called the previous administration's "lax approach to remote working".He said "collaboration, visibility and a strong workplace culture matter" and claimed that "you do not build that on Teams calls from the sofa"."This is part of my Stability Plan, a broader mission to drive up productivity, professionalism, and pride in public service," he wrote. "The future of this council rests on a high-performance culture where openness and innovation are not just buzzwords, they are daily practice. Residents expect more. We are raising the bar."Wootton told the JVS show "that asking the authorities 1,740 full-time staff to come in three days a week was a nice compromise" as "everybody used to come in" and "never thought anything of it".He added he "loved Teams calls" for speaking to people outside the borough, but that there was a "time and a place for them", and "getting together and talking with people you are working with" was also important. Follow Beds, Herts and Bucks news on BBC Sounds, Facebook, Instagram and X.
BBC News
37 minutes ago
- BBC News
Peterborough sports quarter and pool backed by government
Plans for a swimming pool in a city that has been left without one for almost two years have been backed by the autoclaved aerated concrete (Raac) was first discovered at Peterborough's Regional Pool in September 2023 and it was forced to her Spending Review on Wednesday, Chancellor Rachel Reeves said she would establish funding to help the City Council develop plans for a sports quarter, including a Pakes, the Labour MP for the city, said it was the "only one of the top 10 fastest growing cities in the country without a public pool". In her speech to Parliament, Reeves said the government would establish a Growth Mission Fund worth £240m "to expedite local projects that are important for growth".She said a sports quarter would form part of the Anglia Ruskin University (ARU) campus in the city and it would "drive activity and community cohesion".Following the speech, Pakes said: "Today's backing from the government for the principle of a new pool and sports quarter, bringing together ARU Peterborough, the council and others means we can now bid for the funding, put the business case in and get a new pool in the city centre."Reeves boosts NHS and housing budgets but Tories say it's 'spend now, tax later'Seven ways the Spending Review will affect youSpending Review: Where key money is being spent... in 99 seconds A decision was made to permanently close the Regional Pool in March 2024 due to high repair costs, with demolition work expected to take place until July. It was hoped that a replacement pool, which would be built at an estimated cost of £30m, would be open by said it could be about 18 months before work on the sports quarter would begin. Funding is expected to be confirmed in the summer. City of Peterborough Swimming Club has been left without a home since the regional pool Stevenson from the club said it was "thrilled" by the announcement both for the club and the wider of the council, Dennis Jones, described the announcement as "fantastic" and said the council would work "at pace" on the business case before it was submitted to the government. Follow Peterborough news on BBC Sounds, Facebook, Instagram and X.
