TD says €12 dole rise in Budget 'not feasible' as social welfare row deepens
It comes as the coalition is on yet another collision course over whether to increase pension rates and the social welfare rates to the same extent during Budget 2026.
John Paul O'Shea, a Fine Gael TD and Chairman of the powerful Oireachtas Social Protection Committee, stated a €12 dole rise 'will not be feasible' in October's budget as he said there is 'no reason' why people should be on the payment for more than 12 months.
Last week, Tánaiste Simon Harris suggested that he was 'not convinced that you need to see as significant a rise in the dole as you do on the pension, for example, at the time when our country's in full employment and there's lots of supports out there for people getting into work'.
However, speaking in Japan, Taoiseach Micheál Martin warned against creating distinctions and said that Fine Gael had never proposed the idea of differing increases.
This is despite senior Fine Gael sources confirming to the Irish Mirror that it was put forward by then Social Protection Minister Heather Humphreys as an option.
New figures provided to the Irish Mirror by the Department of Social Protection confirmed that 46,940 people had been on Jobseeker's Allowance for more than one year.
Some 9,809 people have been receiving the payment for between two and three years, while 5,066 people have been on Jobseekers for three to four years. Another 2,784 people have been receiving the weekly payment for four to five years.
In total, 13,391 people have been on Jobseekers for more than five years. Of these, 8,487 people have been in receipt of it for more than five years, while 4,904 have been classified as unemployed for a decade or more.
Deputy O'Shea, Fine Gael TD for Cork North-West and chair of the Oireachtas Social Protection Committee, told the Irish Mirror that 'there is no reason why people should be on Jobseekers for longer than 12 months'.
When asked if he agreed with the Tánaiste's suggestion that social protection rates and pensions did not need to be increased at the same rate as part of Budget 2026, he said, 'Absolutely'.
He continued: 'We obviously went and gave everyone on social welfare benefits €12 of [an] increase last year. I don't think that is feasible this year, given the conversations we've had only last week in terms of trying to fund the [third level] student contribution fee as part of Government next year.
'A €1 increase [to social welfare payments] would actually pay for the whole of the entire student contribution fee that's required.
'I don't [know] why we should be prioritising job seekers who are on Jobseekers for over 12 months, and not to mention five years or 10 years, on the basis of the other requirements we have to fund within budget.'
At a press conference on Monday following the Government's Competitiveness Summit, Public Expenditure Minister Jack Chambers declined to wade into the potential budget clash between Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael.
He said: '[Social Protection] Minister [Dara] Calleary will obviously examine the different supports that exist in the social protection system and how best to prioritise that in the context of Budget 2026.
'One component is obviously Jobseekers. There's Disability Allowance, Carers and obviously pension supports as well.
'It's within that context that he'll have to assess what the relative increases will be as part of next year's budget.
'But it will be in a different fiscal context than we've seen in previous years, and that means every minister will have to prioritise the increased supports they want to see for different areas that they're responsible for.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
12 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
ieExplains: Why does every infrastructure project in Ireland take so long?
Ahead of the 2024 general election, then-Taoiseach Simon Harris was adamant Ireland needed a new Government department, one solely dedicated to the delivery of infrastructure. While Fianna Fáil was cooler on the idea, there was general agreement across the political spectrum: Ireland does not build things quickly enough. On Tuesday, there was confirmation of this in a new report that confirmed what everybody already knew. While the department of infrastructure did not get established, public expenditure Minister Jack Chambers was given the explicit title of infrastructure when he assumed the role in January. In May, he announced a new Accelerating Infrastructure Taskforce. The taskforce, chaired by the minister, was established to "oversee the department's programme of reform to unblock barriers and accelerate infrastructure delivery". Why is it needed? The need for a taskforce is down to a simple fact: building in Ireland takes too long. Mr Chambers said on Tuesday "every element of the project life cycle has delayed things". "What's been set out here is that for infrastructure projects, the timeline has doubled in 20 years," Mr Chambers said. What does the report say? Tuesday's report uses examples from the likes of Uisce Éireann, which says the lead-in time for a small wastewater treatment project in Ireland is seven-10 years, and ESB Networks, which said the development cycle for an electricity substation has reached seven years. Major road projects can now have a development cycle of up to 15 years, it says, and these timelines have more than doubled compared to the development cycles typical just 20 years ago. This matters, because longer project lifecycles are costing more, and impeding the ability to provide adequate housing. It also delays the achievement of climate and environmental goals. The report also raises questions about the ability of the Irish construction sector to meet the challenges of infrastructure. It says the construction sector employed 236,800 people in 2007. At the beginning of this year, an estimated 178,000 people were directly employed in the sector, considerably fewer than 2007. The report says given limited labour availability, the capacity of the construction industry to expand to meet all of the investment needs in the economy must be carefully considered. The report says the key issues with Ireland's slow delivery are: a lack of public information which magnifies opposition, regulatory burden, risk aversion, insufficient co-ordination on approvals, slow processes, and procurement challenges. Do legal challenges play a part? According to the stakeholders, yes. The words "judicial review" appear in the review a total of 50 teams, with Mr Chambers saying he was concerned these were "too often being used as a mechanism and a tactic to obstruct and delay, and this distorts the intended purpose of judicial review from a remedy of last resort to a tactical tool to delay infrastructure development and clog up our courts". But put to him this view paints those who take legal cases as "bogeymen" in the face of a Government inability to deliver infrastructure, Mr Chambers said everything needed to change internally within how the State regulates and oversees projects. Read More Excessive regulation delaying key infrastructure projects, Cabinet to hear
Irish Daily Mirror
21 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
New Garda Commissioner set to lead force played key role in Kinahan crackdown
The cabinet has confirmed Justin Kelly as the next Garda Commissioner. Mr Kelly, who is currently Deputy Commissioner for Security, Strategy and Governance, was recommended to the cabinet by Justice Minister Jim O'Callaghan at its meeting today. He will replace Commissioner Drew Harris, who has held the position since late 2018. Mr Kelly, who is a native of Dublin, is expected to lead the 14,100-strong Garda force for the next five years. He was appointed after a recruitment competition was carried out by the Public Appointments Service - but Minister O'Callaghan and the rest of the cabinet had to rubberstamp the decision, which they did today. The Irish Mirror's Crime Writers Michael O'Toole and Paul Healy are writing a new weekly newsletter called Crime Ireland. Click here to sign up and get it delivered to your inbox every week Mr Kelly, who is from Clondalkin, joined the Garda in the early 1990s and was regarded as the front runner for the €314,000 a year job. He was appointed Deputy Commissioner last year. He was previously Assistant Commissioner in charge of combating organised crime and played a key role in the crackdown on the Kinahan cartel at home and abroad. As part of that crackdown, he visited Dubai in the United Arab Emirates - where Daniel Kinahan, 47, and other cartel leaders are based - to liaise with local police and government officials. Justin Kelly played a key role in the Garda operation to target Daniel Kinahan and his allies. (Image: Irish Mirror) Before being appointed assistant commissioner, he was the Detective Chief Superintendent in charge of the Special Detective Unit, the Garda's anti-terrorism unit. He also previously worked in the Garda National Protective Services Bureau, as well as Drugs and Organised Crime Bureau. He was also a uniformed Inspector in the Blanchardstown and Clondalkin areas of Dublin - but most of his career has been spent as a detective, Mr Kelly will replace Drew Harris. (Image: Sam Boal/Collins Photos) In 2001 he was seconded to work for the United Nations in Bosnia Herzegovina, where monitored and built the capacity of local policing. He holds a Bachelor in Civil Law from University College Dublin and a Master of Criminal Justice from John Jay College in New York. He also holds an MBA from Dublin City University and has a masters in Serious Crime Investigation from the University of Limerick. And in 2023 he qualified from the Strategic Command Course from the United Kingdom's College of Policing. Sign up to the Irish Mirror's Courts and Crime newsletter here and get breaking crime updates and news from the courts direct to your inbox.
Irish Independent
a day ago
- Irish Independent
Over €1.2 million awarded to water programme in Wexford
The recipient of the funding will be Blackstairs Group Water Scheme, who will use it to address leakage reduction and water conservation, with an estimated 1,114 households to benefit from the investment. Fine Gael Senator Cathal Byrne said funding of €73.9m has been allocated for 291 projects across the county, under the Multi-annual Rural Water Programme 2024–2026 'Today's announcement is great news for communities across the country but particularly those in County Wexford serviced by the Blackstairs Group Water Scheme. It's so important that we protect our water sources and ensure the highest standards in water treatment. We must ensure that communities across Wexford have the benefit of high quality infrastructure and water services,' he said. 'The allocation of €73.9m for 291 projects across the country will directly benefit 63,000 rural households and will address a wide range of needs such as water quality and infrastructure upgrades. Projects will range from minor works right up to major capital investments of over €2m for complex or bundled schemes,' he added. Minister James Browne also welcomed the news and highlighted the Government's commitment to improving water services around the country. "The Government is working hard to fund improvements to water services across the country, including services to rural areas that do not have access to Uisce Éireann services. This announcement today is very much part of that commitment and will support rural communities to thrive as places to live and work,' he said.
