Power bill demand of Rs 1.91 crore ‘wholly unnatural and arbitrary', Allahabad High Court gives relief to Sambhal MP, directs that electricity supply be restored
The Allahabad High Court has directed the Uttar Pradesh Power Corporation Ltd (UPPCL) to restore power supply at the house of Sambhal Member of Parliament, Zia Ur Rehman Barq.
In a significant relief to the Samajwadi Party MP, the Allahabad High Court also stayed the operation of an electricity bill demand of Rs 1.91 crore raised by the UPPCL, terming it 'wholly unnatural and arbitrary', in its June 4 order.
The matter was heard by a division bench comprising Justices Saumitra Dayal Singh and Sandeep Jain. The court was hearing a writ petition filed by the Sambhal MP challenging the assessment order dated May 15, 2025. The court also directed the restoration of the electricity connection, subject to a deposit of Rs 6 lakh and timely payment of future bills.
'Subject to the petitioner depositing Rs.6 lakhs within a period of two weeks from Wednesday, the effect and operation of order dated 15.05.2025, shall remain stayed and the electricity connection of the petitioner, that may have been temporarily disconnected, may be restored forthwith and be maintained subject to timely payment of future bills,' read the court order.
Barq was represented by advocates Bidhan Chandra Rai and Stuti Rai, who argued that the UPPCL lacked jurisdiction to assess electricity usage for 'a period of 12 years', asserting that the maximum permissible assessment period under the law is one year.
'Submission is that even if the inspection report and adverse facts allegedly found therein are accepted, no jurisdiction arose with the respondent authorities to make assessment for a period of 12 years,' the court order read.
The order further said that the maximum period for which assessment may have been made could not exceed one year. 'By breaching the statutory period of assessment, wholly unnatural and arbitrary demand of Rs.1 crore 91 lacs has been raised. The petitioner cannot be made to deposit 50% of such illegal demand to maintain an appeal,' said the order passed on June 4.
The court granted three weeks to the UPPCL to respond and fixed the date of next hearing as July 2, 2025.
The fine was imposed on the MP after allegations of power theft at his residence, on December 19. On the same day, he was charged with large scale electricity theft and the power supply to his residence was disconnected.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
19 minutes ago
- Indian Express
Today in Politics: Will Sachin Pilot and Ashok Gehlot bury the hatchet in Dausa?
All eyes will be on Dausa on Wednesday, where a tribute ceremony to mark the 25th death anniversary for former Union Minister Rajesh Pilot will be held. The meeting assumes significance as it comes days after Congress national general secretary Sachin Pilot met former Rajasthan Chief Minister Ashok Gehlot and invited him to the programme. This was the first such meeting in recent years and is being seen as a sign of thaw between them. The two leaders are often seen as power centres within the state Congress. Gehlot shared the video of their meeting on X and recalled his long association with Rajesh Pilot. 'AICC general secretary Sachin Pilot invited me to the program organised on the 25th death anniversary of former Union minister Rajesh Pilot at his residence,' Gehlot said on X. He said, 'Rajesh Pilot and I reached the Lok Sabha together for the first time in 1980 and were MPs together for about 18 years. We are still saddened by his sudden demise. The party also suffered a deep shock due to his departure.' Sachin Pilot also shared the photo of the meeting and wrote on 'X', 'Met former chief minister Ashok Gehlot today. Requested him to attend the tribute ceremony organised in Dausa on June 11 on the 25th death anniversary of my father Rajesh Pilot.' Ties between Pilot and Gehlot were strained after the political crisis that hit the Ashok Gehlot-led government in 2020. Jharkhand Congress to meet over SC welfare Senior Congress leader Radha Krishna Kishore on Monday said that the Jharkhand unit of the party would convene a state-level meeting on June 11 to formulate a roadmap for the socio-economic development of the Scheduled Caste (SC) community. Kishore, also the Jharkhand finance minister, said that the alliance government in the state is committed to establishing an advisory council and a commission for the SC community soon. 'The Jharkhand Congress has convened a meeting with senior leaders and activists from the SC community to develop a strategy for the socio-economic development of the community in the state,' Kishore said while addressing reporters. He said that Jharkhand Congress in-charge K Raju, co-in-charge Dr Bela Prasad, AICC's SC department chairman Rajendra Pal Gautam and state president Keshav Mahto Kamlesh, among others, would participate in the meeting. 'The SC population in the state is approximately 50 lakh but their socio-economic conditions remain poor. Officially, the per capita income in Jharkhand is stated to be Rs 1.05 lakh annually. However, based on my observations, the per capita income of the poor and SC community is likely to be not more than Rs 60,000 annually,' he said. KCR may appear before Kaleshwaram probe panel Bharat Rashtra Samithi (BRS) president and former Telangana CM K Chandrashekar Rao is likely to appear before the judicial commission probing the alleged irregularities in Kaleshwaram project Wednesday, party sources said on Tuesday. KCR, sought to appear before the panel on June 11 instead of June 5, the day he was earlier summoned, they said. The commission had last month issued notice to KCR for appearance as part of its ongoing inquiry. The damage to the barrages of Kaleshwaram project was a major issue during the 2023 assembly elections in the state. Telangana Irrigation Minister N Uttam Kumar Reddy recently announced that the National Dam Safety Authority (NDSA) has labelled the Kaleshwaram project, built at a cost of over Rs one lakh crore, to be 'probably the biggest man-made disaster in the country'. – With PTI inputs
Hans India
25 minutes ago
- Hans India
FAPCCI presents 11 awards in across sectors
Visakhapatnam: Industries Minister TG Bharath announced that the TDP-led NDA government under the leadership of Chief Minister N Chandrababu Naidu has successfully regained the trust of national and global investors. Speaking at the Federation of Andhra Pradesh Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FAPCCI) Excellence Awards 2025 presentation ceremony held here on Tuesday, the Minister stated that in just one year, the government has secured investment proposals worth over Rs 9 lakh crore, marking a significant shift in investors' confidence. He emphasised that major corporate houses have reposed faith in Andhra Pradesh's leadership and vision. He also highlighted that tenders worth Rs 60,000 crore have been called for in Amaravati, signaling the government's clear intent to fast-track capital development. 'We are taking decisions at a brisk pace to foster ease and speed of doing business,' he informed. Visakhapatnam MP M. Sribharat called on industry leaders to partner with the state's economic development by not only pointing out bottlenecks but also suggesting solutions to address them. The MP announced that 15 key roads in Visakhapatnam are being upgraded at a cost of Rs 500 crore, improving the city's infrastructure backbone. On the much-anticipated Visakhapatnam Metro Project, he informed that the DPR is ready, and a double-decker metro has been proposed for the Rs 15,000 crore-project. Highlighting Andhra Pradesh's push towards digital governance, Sribharat said that over 300 government services are now being offered via WhatsApp, reducing the need for people to interface directly with the officials concerned. He also stressed the importance of collaboration between academia, industry, and government to collectively address challenges faced in the business ecosystem. FAPCCI president Kankatala Mallikharjuna Rao, former president Karunendra Jasti, CV Atchut Rao, among others, addressed the gathering. Recognising excellence in business and entrepreneurship, 11 awards were presented to leaders from across different sectors. It was the first-ever excellence awards hosted by the FAPCCI.
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
35 minutes ago
- Business Standard
Best of BS Opinion: India is faced with a strategic turning point
There's a moment in every fight, every conflict, every country's economic strategy, where the shield cracks. The noise outside gets louder, the sand underfoot more uncertain. It's not just a question of survival anymore. It's what you do next. You lunge, adapt, recalibrate or you're trampled. The same test of resolve applies now across India's economic, strategic and scientific frontiers, where shields once considered strong are showing signs of stress. Like gladiators, the dent in the armour is visible and now we must choose when and where to strike. Let's dive in. China has just driven a spike into India's rare earth supply shield. With new export controls on vital metals and magnets, India's green and defence ambitions are exposed. Japan faced this once and countered swiftly with strategic deals and stockpiles. India, though, is only starting to build its moat, through ventures like KABIL and domestic processing, notes our first editorial. But these are still early moves. Without stronger regional alliances and a clear long-term plan, Indian manufacturing could be caught off guard. In space, however, India's aim is high and its resolve stronger. Group Captain Shubhanshu Shukla is poised to soar aboard SpaceX's Falcon rocket under the Axiom-4 mission. Supported by Isro, this journey to the International Space Station will test the limits of India's readiness for manned missions, highlights our second editorial. It's a proving ground for Gaganyaan, and perhaps even future space habitats. What Shukla brings back, in terms of data, insight, and instinct, could patch the cracks before the next big lift-off. Back on Earth, the fiscal shield is looking thin again. A K Bhattacharya writes that revenue overestimation is back after a four-year break. Personal income-tax collections have missed by Rs 74,000 crore. Spending has been reined in. And while capital expenditure was protected, the crack in the armour, 6.5 per cent GDP growth, down from 9.2 per cent, can't be missed. Deep Kapuria flags another chink: the QCO regime meant to upgrade product quality is under strain. With only 769 out of 23,000 BIS standards enforced, and trade partners grumbling, India's quality crusade is caught between ambition and implementation. The solution? Less brute force, more finesse: decentralised certification, smarter MRAs, and a phased, strategic charge, not a wild swing. And when it comes to the marketing colosseum, Siddhesh Joglekar reviews Marketing Mixology: Four Essential Ingredients for Marketing Success by Ambi Parameswaran — a swift, jargon-free training manual for modern brand warriors. Less textbook, more battle guide. Whether you're a fresh grad or a founder, the book is a well-timed reminder that even when the battlefield shifts, the fundamentals of storytelling, empathy, and timing stay firm.
