Plans to slash mental health beds horrify
Plans to slash the number of mental health beds for older people at the new Dunedin hospital even further than first feared have horrified aged-care advocates.
The original business case for the new Dunedin hospital included 24 mental health beds for older people, but the Otago Daily Times understands Health New Zealand Te Whatu Ora (HNZ) has now settled on eight beds upon opening.
HNZ was unable to provide comment before deadline.
If this plan goes ahead, it will mean the dementia and psychogeriatric bed capacity at the new Dunedin hospital will be half that of the existing hospital.
Correspondence seen by the ODT suggests HNZ wants to develop a "new model of care" for psychogeriatric and dementia issues nationwide, but has not yet completed it.
The plan to cut the number of beds has angered aged-care advocates.
Associate professor of psychiatry and consultant psychogeriatrician Dr Yoram Barak said he had been told of the plans to cut the number of beds to eight "several weeks ago".
"I think it is a very, very unwise decision that will impact our ability to help the older adult community in Otago and Southland for many, many years going forward.
"On a scale of 1, not too bad, to 10, catastrophic, I would give it an 8+.
"I'm really stunned by who makes these decisions and do not know what they are based on."
Dr Barak said with the population ageing, and people living longer, mental health issues among older people would only increase.
One nurse, who spoke on condition of anonymity, said "people could die" as a result of the cutbacks.
Care for older people was a "very complex" and growing part of healthcare, she said.
"I think we are all disappointed, but we also feel despondent and deflated and defeated.
"In the time that this hospital is meant to be built, there will already be a greater need for our services, but with less ability to meet that need, which puts more pressure on the community."
She said under the plans for the new Dunedin hospital, there would be fewer beds than the existing hospital.
"This is also probably a way of saving money in the future in terms of not funding staff.
"The public need to be aware of this and need to have a bigger voice and fight for services for now and in the future."
The ODT understands the plans have also frustrated the clinical transformation group, which has provided advice to HNZ throughout the various stages of the new Dunedin hospital project.
Grey Power Otago president Jo Millar said she was disappointed but not surprised by the revelation.
"The very first chop you make is where the older people are involved, because for some reason they're seen as not mattering any more."
She said resourcing the new Dunedin hospital for older people was absolutely vital, particularly when it came to mental health issues.
"The biggest problem is that when you get older people, and when we're talking mental health, they put them in the categories of dementia and Alzheimer's and things like that.
"These conditions affect older people in various different ways, depending on what part of their brain is affected.
"So we end up in a situation where many older people do need to have specialist hospital care."
The present situation of care was a "lottery" for older people, and the new Dunedin hospital needed to be better resourced, she said.
It is the second report of significant cost-cutting in the past week, after the Otago Daily Times revealed this week the government was planning to cut the number of ICU beds on opening from 30 to 20.
Health Minister Simeon Brown has since said the new hospital has the potential to expand the number of ICU beds to 40 over time.
In January, Mr Brown announced the government would proceed with a scaled-back version of the new Dunedin hospital at the former Cadbury's site at a cost of about $1.88billion.
Mr Brown announced the new hospital would open with 351 inpatient beds — 59 fewer than originally proposed, but with capacity to expand to 404 beds over time.
Cutbacks to the ICU beds and mental health for older people beds were not flagged by the minister at the time of the announcement.
matthew.littlewood@odt.co.nz
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
8 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Call for action on creating more health roles for Māori
Calls for the government to create more roles for Māori in health in the Southern region will mean nothing if they are not followed by action, the leader of a major Māori health organisation says. Ōtākou Health Ltd (OHL) chairwoman Donna Matahaere-Atariki was responding to concern from Health New Zealand Te Whatu Ora (HNZ) Southern leader Dr Hywel Lloyd, who at a recent Southern community meeting said he was "disappointed that Māori leadership has been confirmed to not be coming back to the districts". Ms Matahaere-Atariki shared the disappointment, but said if it was up to HNZ, there would never be the support those roles would need. "If Māori are going to wait on government to make room for us in leadership roles, we're never going to get there. "So my position has always been that I know I have enough information to be a leader in health here and I will take those roles if they're there." OHL created Te Kaika, an integrated health service, in 2018. It now has more than 12,000 people on its books across the region, and through its low-cost approach, is able to offer initiatives such as free dental care for under-18s. "What I've found in my experience is these roles and these Māori roles that [government] created, they have leadership roles, but they never have a budget, they have no staff and so you might get the high salary, but you're actually not able to do anything. "So I think it's better that I've always said, 'no, we'll create our leaders on the outside and we'll wait for them to lean into us'. "So rather than chasing that up, because we can't be held hostage to whatever government is in town and whoever thinks what is right." Previous health board roles dedicated to Māori were "practically useless", she said. "The problem is when you produce Māori leadership roles in your organisation, sometimes you think you don't actually have to go out there and talk to community. "Māori leaders are not public servants — we serve our communities." She said Te Kāika, which is based in Dunedin, Oamaru and Queenstown, was a "one-stop health shop" which improved health and wellbeing outcomes for all whānau and community by making essential health, social, education and employment services affordable and accessible across the wider Otago region. "When we set up Te Kaika and we had to pay for all that ourselves, you know, we got a big bank loan and that to build that — our attitude was 'we set up the infrastructure, they will come knocking'. "We know that we've got ourselves into a position where we have the only health infrastructure that doesn't belong to government in town. "We had to use our own money to get into the sector, set up the infrastructure and then be noticed by them. But we did that really well." The Dunedin base in Caversham was a site designated for high-density residential living. "We could have just gone and built apartments there, but we didn't want to do that. "The most outstanding lesson I've learned is we can't rely on government to look after us. We've had so many reviews that say they don't look after Māori — I'm sort of tired of these reviews and reports." Te Kaika's success reminded her of the need to grasp opportunities. "Over the years, I've realised that there are particular moments that were a perfect storm, that allowed us to put it right at that time: we got that money from the Whanau Ora Commission, the Ministry of Health, and the Education Ministry gave us that building until it was sold — then, of course, when it was sold, we bought it. "So, there was a perfect storm at that gate." She said she wanted to thank Dr Lloyd for his "well-intentioned" comments. "From his perspective, there doesn't seem to be any Māori voice there [in HNZ Southern]. "I think that's important. However, that Māori voice needs to know what they're saying or else I don't want to hear it." HNZ has been approached for comment.
Otago Daily Times
10 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Call for action on creating more health roles for Maori
Calls for the government to create more roles for Maori in health in the Southern region will mean nothing if they are not followed by action, the leader of a major Maori health organisation says. Ōtākou Health Ltd (OHL) chairwoman Donna Matahaere-Atariki was responding to concern from Health New Zealand Te Whatu Ora (HNZ) Southern leader Dr Hywel Lloyd, who at a recent Southern community meeting said he was "disappointed that Māori leadership has been confirmed to not be coming back to the districts". Ms Matahaere-Atariki shared the disappointment, but said if it was up to HNZ, there would never be the support those roles would need. "If Māori are going to wait on government to make room for us in leadership roles, we're never going to get there. "So my position has always been that I know I have enough information to be a leader in health here and I will take those roles if they're there." OHL created Te Kaika, an integrated health service, in 2018. It now has more than 12,000 people on its books across the region, and through its low-cost approach, is able to offer initiatives such as free dental care for under-18s. "What I've found in my experience is these roles and these Māori roles that [government] created, they have leadership roles, but they never have a budget, they have no staff and so you might get the high salary, but you're actually not able to do anything. "So I think it's better that I've always said, 'no, we'll create our leaders on the outside and we'll wait for them to lean into us'. "So rather than chasing that up, because we can't be held hostage to whatever government is in town and whoever thinks what is right." Previous health board roles dedicated to Maori were "practically useless", she said. "The problem is when you produce Māori leadership roles in your organisation, sometimes you think you don't actually have to go out there and talk to community. "Maori leaders are not public servants — we serve our communities." She said Te Kāika, which is based in Dunedin, Oamaru and Queenstown, was a "one-stop health shop" which improved health and wellbeing outcomes for all whānau and community by making essential health, social, education and employment services affordable and accessible across the wider Otago region. "When we set up Te Kaika and we had to pay for all that ourselves, you know, we got a big bank loan and that to build that — our attitude was 'we set up the infrastructure, they will come knocking'. "We know that we've got ourselves into a position where we have the only health infrastructure that doesn't belong to government in town. "We had to use our own money to get into the sector, set up the infrastructure and then be noticed by them. But we did that really well." The Dunedin base in Caversham was a site designated for high-density residential living. "We could have just gone and built apartments there, but we didn't want to do that. "The most outstanding lesson I've learned is we can't rely on government to look after us. We've had so many reviews that say they don't look after Maori — I'm sort of tired of these reviews and reports." Te Kaika's success reminded her of the need to grasp opportunities. "Over the years, I've realised that there are particular moments that were a perfect storm, that allowed us to put it right at that time: we got that money from the Whanau Ora Commission, the Ministry of Health, and the Education Ministry gave us that building until it was sold — then, of course, when it was sold, we bought it. "So, there was a perfect storm at that gate." She said she wanted to thank Dr Lloyd for his "well-intentioned" comments. "From his perspective, there doesn't seem to be any Maori voice there [in HNZ Southern]. "I think that's important. However, that Maori voice needs to know what they're saying or else I don't want to hear it." HNZ has been approached for comment.
1News
4 days ago
- 1News
Billy Joel has excess fluid in his brain – symptoms, treatment explained
When Billy Joel cancelled his upcoming concerts in the US and the UK last month, it was the first time many had heard of normal pressure hydrocephalus, the brain disorder that was affecting his hearing, vision and balance. But the condition has a broad range of symptoms and can mimic the symptoms of other neurodegenerative diseases, such as Alzheimer's or Parkinson's disease. Neurology expert Danielle Wilhour explains. Cerebrospinal fluid, or CSF, is a clear, colorless liquid that plays a crucial role in maintaining the health and function of your central nervous system. It cushions the brain and spinal cord, provides nutrients and removes waste products. Despite its importance, problems related to CSF often go unnoticed until something goes wrong. Recently, cerebrospinal fluid disorders drew public attention with the announcement that musician Billy Joel had been diagnosed with normal pressure hydrocephalus. In this condition, excess CSF accumulates in the brain's cavities, enlarging them and putting pressure on surrounding brain tissue even though diagnostic readings appear normal. Because normal pressure hydrocephalus typically develops gradually and can mimic symptoms of other neurodegenerative diseases, such as Alzheimer's or Parkinson's disease, it is often misdiagnosed. Hilary flew to the Hamptons for a sit-down interview with Billy Joel ahead of his New Zealand concert. (Source: Seven Sharp) ADVERTISEMENT I am a neurologist and headache specialist. In my work treating patients with CSF pressure disorders, I have seen these conditions present in many different ways. Here's what happens when your cerebrospinal fluid stops working. What is cerebrospinal fluid? CSF is made of water, proteins, sugars, ions and neurotransmitters. It is primarily produced by a network of cells called the choroid plexus, which is located in the brain's ventricles, or cavities. The choroid plexus produces approximately 500 milliliters (17 ounces) of CSF daily, but only about 150 milliliters (5 ounces) are present within the central nervous system at any given time due to constant absorption and replenishment in the brain. This fluid circulates through the ventricles of the brain, the central canal of the spinal cord and the subarachnoid space surrounding the brain and spinal cord. CSF has several critical functions. It protects the brain and spinal cord from injury by absorbing shocks. Suspending the brain in this fluid reduces its effective weight and prevents it from being crushed under its own mass. Additionally, CSF helps maintain a stable chemical environment in the central nervous system, facilitating the removal of metabolic waste and the distribution of nutrients and hormones. If the production, circulation or absorption of cerebrospinal fluid is disrupted, it can lead to significant health issues. Two notable conditions are CSF leaks and idiopathic intracranial hypertension. ADVERTISEMENT Cerebrospinal fluid leak A CSF leak occurs when the fluid escapes through a tear or hole in the dura mater – the tough, outermost layer of the meninges that surrounds the brain and spinal cord. The dura can be damaged from head injuries or punctured during surgical procedures involving the sinuses, brain or spine, such as lumbar puncture, epidurals, spinal anesthesia or myelogram. Spontaneous CSF leaks can also occur without any identifiable cause. CSF leaks were originally thought to be relatively rare, with an estimated annual incidence of 5 per 100,000 people. However, with increased awareness and advances in imaging, health care providers are discovering more and more leaks. They tend to occur more frequently in middle-aged adults and are more common in women than men. Risk factors for the condition include connective tissue disorders such as Ehlers-Danlos syndrome as well as postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome. Broad symptoms can be confusing ADVERTISEMENT Unfortunately, it's common for health care providers to misdiagnose a CSF leak as another condition, like migraine, sinus infections or allergies. What can make diagnosing a CSF leak challenging is its broad symptoms. Most people with a CSF leak have a positional headache that improves when lying down and worsens when standing. Pain is usually felt in the back of the head and may involve the neck and between the shoulder blades. In addition to headaches, patients may experience ringing in the ears, vision disturbances, memory problems, brain fog, dizziness and nausea. Imaging may help guide diagnosis, including an MRI of your brain or entire spine, or a myelogram of the space surrounding your spinal cord. Features of a CSF leak that are visible in a scan include your brain sagging down in the base of your skull as well as a fluid collection outside of your dura. However, an estimated 19% of people with a CSF leak can have normal scans, so not seeing signs of a leak on imaging does not entirely rule it out. Conservative treatment for a CSF leak involves rest, lying flat and increasing your fluid intake to give your spine time to heal the puncture. Increasing your caffeine consumption to an equivalent of three to four cups of coffee per day can also help by increasing CSF production through stimulating the choroid plexus. Caffeine also relieves pain by interacting with adenosine receptors, which are key players in the body's pain perception mechanisms. If a conservative approach is not successful, an epidural blood patch may be necessary. In this procedure, blood is drawn from your arm and injected into your spine. The injected blood can help form a covering over the hole and promote the healing process. Headache improvement can be fast, but if the patch does not work or the results are short-lived, additional testing may be needed to better locate the site of the leak. In rare cases, surgery may be recommended. Most patients with a CSF leak respond to some form of these treatments. Idiopathic intracranial hypertension Idiopathic intracranial hypertension is a disorder involving an excess of CSF that elevates pressure inside the skull and compresses the brain. The term 'idiopathic' indicates that the cause of the raised pressure is unknown. Most patients with idiopathic intracranial hypertension have a history of obesity or recent weight gain. Other risk factors include taking certain medications such as tetracycline, excessive vitamin A, tretinoin, steroids and growth hormone. Middle-aged obese women are 20 times more likely to be diagnosed with idiopathic intracranial hypertension than other patient groups. As obesity becomes more prevalent, so too does the incidence of this condition. ADVERTISEMENT Patients with idiopathic intracranial hypertension typically experience headaches and vision changes, tinnitus or eye pain. Papilledema, or swelling of the optic disc, is the hallmark finding on a fundoscopic examination of the back of the eye. Clinicians may also observe paralysis of the patient's eye muscles. Normal pressure hydrocephalus, Joel's diagnosis, is a form of this condition that commonly results in difficulty walking, loss of bladder control and cognitive impairment, sometimes referred to as the 'wet, wobbly and wacky' triad. Joel's diagnosis has brought awareness to this underrecognized but potentially treatable disorder, which is often managed through surgically placing a shunt to divert excess fluid and relieve symptoms. Brain imaging of patients suspected of having idiopathic intracranial hypertension is crucial to excluding other causes of elevated CSF pressure, such as brain tumors or blood clots in the brain. A lumbar puncture or spinal tap to measure the pressure and composition of CSF is also central to diagnosis. Since high intracranial pressure can damage the optic nerve and lead to permanent vision loss, the primary goal of treatment is to decrease pressure and preserve the optic nerve. Treatment options include weight loss, dietary changes and medications to reduce CSF production. Surgical procedures can also reduce intracranial pressure. Future directions and unknowns Cerebrospinal fluid is indispensable for brain health. Despite advances in understanding diseases related to CSF, several aspects remain unclear. ADVERTISEMENT The exact mechanisms that lead to conditions like CSF leaks and idiopathic intracranial hypertension are not fully understood, though there are many theories. Further research is vital to enhance diagnostic accuracy and effective treatments for CSF disorders. This is an updated version of an article originally published on Aug. 14, 2024. Danielle Wilhour is assistant professor of neurology at the University of Colorado, Anschutz Medical Campus. This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons licence.
