2025 MLB Draft top 50 prospects rankings: Ethan Holliday, Liam Doyle leading the way
We're now past the midpoint of the college baseball regular season, when just about every high school prospect of note has begun his spring season as well, making it a good time to update the rankings of the best players in this year's draft class. As I said in the first ranking in March, this is a deep class, but it's weaker than ever at the very top, rivaling the 2016 draft for the worst top echelon of any draft I've ever covered. That's going to mean we see a lot of well-under-slot deals this year, maybe right at the very first pick, to make up for the fact that none of these players would have gone first or second in a typical year, probably not even in the top five picks in the loaded 2023 class.
Advertisement
There is real depth in this draft, though: There's a huge group of high school shortstops, many of whom project to stay there for the long term, along with a strong set of college left-handed starters and at least an average group of hard-hitting college outfielders. The college catching crop isn't bad, either, although the high school group is almost nonexistent; the two best ones are probably going to end up in the outfield. It's a good year to pick later in the first round, and still a good year to have an extra pick or two.
The SEC and ACC remain the powerhouses of talent they've always been. The California high school group is the best it's been in several years. The Pacific Northwest has four high schoolers on this top 50 plus two college hitters; the Chicago area has two guys on this list, and could see two more on the top 100 that we'll release next month. The Mid-Atlantic and Northeast are down, and Georgia is weak for the second year in a row.
I'll do a full top 100 Big Board at some point in early May; it'll be easier to do that than it has been to figure out who goes in the top 10 here and in what order. As a reminder, this is a ranking, not a prediction of who'll be drafted where (I'll start doing that in May as well). I've seen 31 of the players on this list myself this spring, and I add my own scouting notes on those players to what I've learned from talking to scouts and directors, reviewing video and looking at data on these players where available. This ranking is my best attempt to say in what order I'd draft these players if I were a scouting director for an MLB team, based on the best information I have right now.
(Notes: Scouting grades are on a traditional 20-80 scale; 'the shadow' refers to space just past the strike zone, usually measured by the size of one baseball.)
(Top photo illustration by Will Tullos / The Athletic; photos left to right of Liam Doyle, Ethan Holliday, Jamie Arnold — Isaiah Vazquez, Aaron M. Sprecher, Dustin Bradford / Getty Images)
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Newsweek
9 minutes ago
- Newsweek
Yankees Trade Idea Brings In $5.9 Million, 2-Time All-Star Closer to End Bullpen Woes
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. Even after losing two of three to their arch-rivals, the Boston Red Sox, over the weekend, the New York Yankees entered Tuesday's action with the second-best record in MLB, behind only the Detroit Tigers. But the Yankees have a problem at the back of their bullpen. First, offseason acquisition Devin Williams, at a price of $8.6 million for one year, was such a bust in April and most of May that he lost his closer's job. NEW YORK, NY - APRIL 12: Luke Weaver #30 of the New York Yankees looks on during the game against the San Francisco Giants at Yankee Stadium on April 12, 2025 in New York, New... NEW YORK, NY - APRIL 12: Luke Weaver #30 of the New York Yankees looks on during the game against the San Francisco Giants at Yankee Stadium on April 12, 2025 in New York, New York. More NewManager Aaron Boone then gave the assignment to Luke Weaver, a 10-year veteran pitching for his sixth different team. But Weaver also had the closer's job down the stretch last season, seeming to find his place in the role. With four saves in September, Weaver played a crucial role in the Yankees' run to the postseason. Taking over for Williams, he picked up where he left off, saving eight games in nine opportunities. But in a June 1 game against the Dodgers in Los Angeles, Weaver pulled a hamstring warming up and was given a trip to the injured list. What now? According to baseball insider Mark Feinsand, a two-time All-Star closer will likely be available on the trade market. Would the Yankees target him, as insurance against any further collapses by Williams or injury flare-up for Weaver? More MLB: Red Sox Outfielder Reveals Timeline To (Finally) Return From Injury That closer is 30-year-old righty David Bednar of the Pittsburgh Pirates, who saved a National League-leading 39 games in 2023, despite pitching for a team that finished the season 10 games under .500. "Bednar struggled so much to start the season that the Pirates demoted him to Triple-A on April 1, but the reliever has been formidable since returning to the Majors on April 19," Feinsand wrote. "Pittsburgh faces a double-digit deficit in both the NL Central and Wild Card races, and with Bednar earning $5.9 million this season with one more year of arbitration eligibility remaining, the time is right for the Pirates to trade him," the insider continued. The Pirates' closer has recorded eight saves this season, with a solid 3.74 ERA. Bednar's remaining full season of team control might make Pittsburgh's asking price somewhat higher than if he were simply a rental. On the other hand, his age and recent struggles mean he probably won't be worth a top prospect. The Yankees' No. 15 prospect, catcher and first baseman Rafael Flores, could headline a package to obtain Bednar. "Flores generates plus raw power and some of the best exit velocities among Yankees farmhands," according to an MLB Pipeline scouting report. "A right-handed hitter, he employs a pull-heavy approach designed to crush balls to left field, and he could tap into even more pop if he could make more consistent contact and lift more balls in the air." MLB Pipeline estimates Flores, now playing for the Yankees' Double-A affiliate, the Somerset Patriots, will be ready for the big leagues next season. More MLB: Dodgers' Shohei Ohtani Could Pitch Sooner Than Expected, Per Latest Update
Yahoo
31 minutes ago
- Yahoo
With the World Cup exactly one year away, the USMNT is spiraling
Yahoo Sports AM is our daily newsletter that keeps you up to date on all things sports. Sign up here to get it every weekday morning. ⚽️ The USMNT is spiraling () The USMNT has lost four straight games for the first time since 2007, and with the Gold Cup starting this weekend and the World Cup exactly 365 days away, the team is spiraling. Advertisement From Yahoo Sports' Henry Bushnell: The 2026 World Cup has been billed as the opportunity of a lifetime, as a chance for the USMNT to "change soccer in America forever." It will be a monthlong moment to captivate a country and lift an entire sport; a moment that everyone, for years, assumed a rising USMNT would seize with pride. And yet, with the World Cup a year away, the USMNT is directionless. It clunked to a new low on Tuesday night in Nashville, falling 4-0 to Switzerland. It failed to record a single shot on target, and it trailed by four goals inside 40 minutes at home for the first time ever. Advertisement It made head coach Mauricio Pochettino sigh, repeatedly, perhaps in disbelief, perhaps with alarm. And it made a half-empty stadium boo their brains out. That, astonishingly, is the state of the USMNT with a year to go. Two years after former head coach Gregg Berhalter said "the sky's the limit" for what many believed was a "golden generation" of players, they are insipid and astray, uninspired and uninspiring. Many of those prominent players were absent for Tuesday's loss to Switzerland and Saturday's to Türkiye, so there are caveats. But they and their dubious effort were responsible for the first two losses, in March to Panama and Canada. Bottom line: Instead of rising to meet this unmissable moment, the USMNT plateaued in 2024; and now, it is regressing. Advertisement Read the full story. ⚾️ Paul Skenes and the case against pitcher wins () There have been 63 occurrences in MLB history where a pitcher had a sub-2.00 ERA and 90+ strikeouts through 14 starts. The only one without a winning record? Paul Skenes this season. By the numbers: The NL Cy Young favorite ranks second in the league in ERA (1.88) and first in WHIP (0.84), but he's just 4-6 on the year due to a historic lack of run support. The last-place Pirates score the second-fewest runs in the majors (3.24 per game), and their bats always seem to be quietest when their ace is on the bump. Consider this: Skenes has allowed 0 or 1 earned run in nine of his 14 starts, yet he has fewer wins than 50 other MLB pitchers. A useless statistic: Win-loss record is a common gauge of a pitcher's performance, but as Skenes proves, it's not a very meaningful one. To further highlight the point: Arizona's Brandon Pfaadt (8-4) has twice as many wins as Skenes despite an ERA three times worse (5.50), simply because his teammates score a lot of runs (MLB-best 5.09 per game). Advertisement Looking ahead: If Skenes keeps shoving — and the Pirates keep losing — the former No. 1 overall pick could become just the second-ever Cy Young winner to have a losing record.* *Who was the first? Dodgers closer Eric Gagné won the 2003 NL Cy Young with a 2-3 record to go along with his 1.20 ERA, 55 saves (fourth-most ever) and perfect save percentage (55-for-55). 🌟 16-year-old phenoms make history (Peter H. Bick) A couple of 16-year-old phenoms were in the news this past week for historic performances in the pool and on the track. 🏊 In the pool: Luka Mijatovic (Pleasanton, California) broke the American records for the 15-16 age group in the 200m (1:45.92) and 400m freestyle (3:45.89) at U.S. Nationals. Advertisement Here's the kicker: Both times also broke the records for the 17-18 age group, one of which had belonged to Michael Phelps. In other words: Mijatovic is faster at 16 than Phelps was at 18 (in the 200m freestyle, at least). (Northwest High School) 👟 On the track: Cooper Lutkenhaus (Forth Worth, Texas) set the national high school record in the 800 meters (1:46.26), eclipsing a mark that was set 12 years before he was born (1996). This comes four months after the sophomore sensation set the national high school indoor record (1:46.86). By the numbers: Lutkhenhaus beat the field with a rare negative split, meaning his second lap (52.67) was faster than his first (53.59). Advertisement What's next: Mijatovic earned a spot at this summer's World Championships, where he'll be the youngest U.S. male to compete since Phelps in 2001. Lutkenhaus will be at the USATF U20 Outdoor Championships and Nike Outdoor Nationals this month before potentially lining up against senior competition at the USATF Outdoor Championships later this summer. 🏀 The Alex Caruso story (James Pawelczyk/Yahoo Sports) From Yahoo Sports' Yaron Weitzman: The pinky finger on Alex Caruso's right hand doesn't look like a typical pinky. Around the middle knuckle, it bulges as if a small marble was implanted under the skin. Advertisement It will come as no surprise to anyone who's watched Caruso play basketball that this slight disfiguration is the result of him throwing his body around the court. "Somebody stepped on it while I was on the ground during a game," Caruso said during a phone interview. What might be surprising, though, is how old he was when the injury occurred. "I think it was in, like, the first or second grade," he said. So, yes, the player we've seen throughout the playoffs, and in his first season with the Thunder, and really over the past five seasons, is who Caruso has always been. The running, the diving, the swiping, that blur of activity that looks like a tornado with arms — it all comes naturally to him. On the court, it's his version of breathing. Advertisement That capacity for wreaking havoc is what propelled Caruso, now 31, from an undrafted guard in 2016, one close to accepting a contract to play overseas, into the NBA. But what's transformed him into into one of the great role players of this decade, someone who is three wins away from a second ring, has been his ability to both build on those skills and refine them. These days, Caruso is more than just a basketball version of the Tasmanian Devil. In fact, ask him about his propensity for creating chaos, and he'll balk at that description. "I think when you use the word 'chaos,' it's for the other team," he said. "Creating chaos for them and making them have to think and second-guess things. Advertisement "For us, I'm trying to be settling and create a rhythm and flow." More than that, he's trying to "have an understanding of what we're gonna do and then putting guys in positions where they can just play and don't have to think." Keep reading. 📺 Watchlist: Wednesday, June 11 () 🏀 NBA Finals, Game 3 | 8:30pm ET, ABC Shai Gilgeous-Alexander scored 72 points across Games 1 and 2, the most ever through a player's first two career NBA Finals games. Can the Pacers put the clamps down on the league MVP as the series shifts to Indy? ⚾️ Yankees at Royals | 7:40pm, Prime Lefty Kris Bubic toes the rubber for KC as he looks to continue his breakout campaign. He leads all AL pitchers in ERA (1.43) and WAR (3.5) in his first full season since undergoing Tommy John surgery in 2023. 👟 NCAA Track & Field Championships | 7pm, ESPN The coed four-day event begins today at Oregon's iconic Hayward Field, where the Florida men seek their fourth straight title and the Arkansas women look to defend theirs. Advertisement Today's full slate → 🏒 NHL trivia Maurice on the bench during Game 3. () With Monday's Game 3 victory, Florida's Paul Maurice became just the third head coach in NHL history with 1,000 career wins. Question: Who are the other two? Hint: One is still active. Answer at the bottom. 🏀 Finally! (Ben Solomon/NCAA Photos via Getty Images) Coach's challenges are coming to men's college basketball this fall, and the NCAA is also removing automatic out-of-bounds reviews in the last two minutes. Net result: The end of games shouldn't take forever now, which is a win for everybody. Trivia answer: Scotty Bowman (1,467 wins) and Joel Quenneville (1,090) We hope you enjoyed this edition of Yahoo Sports AM, our daily newsletter that keeps you up to date on all things sports. Sign up here to get it delivered to your inbox every weekday morning.
USA Today
43 minutes ago
- USA Today
Texas A&M fans celebrate Jace LaViolette's historic college career
Texas A&M fans celebrate Jace LaViolette's historic college career It's unofficially official that Texas A&M junior outfielder Jace LaViolette's playing days in the Maroon & White have ended. With him projected as a top-15 pick, MLB is calling his name, and he hears it loud and clear, posting his farewell message to Aggieland on social media. We all knew this day was coming. Even with hope that NIL deals could persuade him to stay, the writing was on the wall after his breakout freshman year, his draft entry was inevitable. So, it's best to wish him well and cherish the memorable moments he gave fans over three years. The All-American leaves A&M as the career leader in home runs (68), walks (169), and ranks third in RBIs (202). Even after a challenging season, he finished the year on his terms. After suffering a broken hand from a pitch in the SEC tournament, he could've easily shut it down without second thoughts. However, he fought through the pain, returned the next day, and collected a few hits against a strong LSU pitching staff. For the extremely optimistic Aggie fans, there's a .01% chance LaViolette has a change of heart, declines his MLB contract, and returns to A&M. Anything can happen, but for now, we wish Jace a successful and healthy pro career. Below are some of the reactions to Jace LaViolette's farewell post to Texas A&M fans. Jace will be missed One of the best to ever do it Thanks for the good times Jace It's going to take a lot to make Jace miss a game The talent was undeniable from the beginning Aggie legend Lord Tubbington set the standard for the new generation of Aggies MLB Bound Proud Jace decided to join the Aggie family No. 17 rewrote the record books There is not a dry eye on X Jace won't be forgotten anytime soon Contact/Follow us @AggiesWire on X and like our page on Facebook to follow ongoing coverage of Texas A&M news, notes and opinions. Follow Jarrett Johnson on X: @whosnextsports1.
