
NDTV Decodes: Engines Shut, Fuel Cut Off - Inside Doomed Air India Flight
On June 12, Air India Flight 171, a Boeing 787-8 Dreamliner, departed Ahmedabad's Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel International Airport at 1:39 pm, bound for London Gatwick. Within 32 seconds of takeoff, the aircraft crashed into a medical hostel near the airport, killing 241 of the 242 passengers and crew on board and 19 people on the ground.
The sole survivor was a British-Indian man seated in row 11A. This was the first fatal crash of a Boeing 787 since its commercial debut in 2011.
A probe report by the Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB) was released last night. The report points to a series of possibilities and also raises multiple questions on what transpired inside the doomed flight.
Add image caption here
The Takeoff and Aftermath
According to data extracted from the aircraft's Enhanced Airborne Flight Recorder (EAFR), commonly referred to as the black box, Flight 171 carried out a routine takeoff. The Dreamliner accelerated to a takeoff speed of 153 knots or roughly 283 kmph. It then reached a maximum airspeed of 180 knots or roughly 333 kmph, climbing steadily as expected. The flap setting was recorded at five degrees, and the landing gear lever remained in the 'DOWN' position, both standard takeoff procedures.
Weather conditions posed no threat, skies were clear, visibility was good, and winds were light. Yet, within seconds, the fuel control switches for Engine 1 and Engine 2 moved from the "RUN" to "CUTOFF" position, one after the other, within a one-second interval.
These switches govern the flow of fuel to the engines, and their transition to "CUTOFF" halted the supply, causing both engines to lose thrust. The black box data shows that thrust levels began to decrease from their takeoff values almost immediately, triggering a rapid de-throttling process.
The Cockpit Exchange
The cockpit voice recorder (CVR), one of two black box components, captured a brief exchange between the pilots. Captain Sumeet Sabharwal, the commander and pilot monitoring (PM), and First Officer Clive Kunder, the pilot flying (PF), were both experienced and medically fit, with no reported issues that could have compromised their flying. As the engines faltered, one pilot -- identity unconfirmed -- asked, "Why did you cut off?" The other responded, "I didn't."
This dialogue is now at the centre of the investigation.
Was it a misunderstanding, an unacknowledged action, or an external factor beyond the pilots' control? The fuel control switches on a Boeing 787 are not simple toggles.
Each switch features a guard rail. To move a switch from "RUN" (forward) to "CUTOFF" (aft), a pilot must lift and shift it downward. This design minimises the risk of accidental movement, such as a hand brushing against it during flight.
The switches for Engine 1 and Engine 2 are spaced approximately two to three inches apart, making it improbable for both to be moved simultaneously without intent. Yet, the data confirms that both transitioned to "CUTOFF" within a single second.
The Pilots' Response
As thrust diminished, the aircraft's altitude began to drop. The black box indicates that the pilots acted swiftly, moving both fuel control switches back to the "RUN" position. This action, executed approximately 10 seconds after the initial cutoff, aimed to restore fuel flow and restart the engines.
Engine 1 responded and its core speed deceleration halted, reversed, and began to recover, with thrust levels rising. Engine 2 also relit, but its core speed continued to decelerate despite repeated attempts to reintroduce fuel and accelerate recovery. The thrust levers, found near idle in the wreckage, had remained forward until impact, per the flight data recorder (FDR).
Simultaneously, the Ram Air Turbine (RAT), a small propeller deployed automatically in the event of dual engine failure, extended from the fuselage during takeoff. CCTV footage from the airport captured this deployment.
The RAT provides emergency power to sustain critical systems, but it cannot generate thrust. With the aircraft barely a few hundred feet above ground, the partial recovery of Engine 1 proved insufficient.
At 1:39:32 pm, Flight 171 struck the hostel, sparking a fireball that devastated the site.
The Key Focus
The AAIB's preliminary report, spanning dozens of pages, drew on data extracted from the heavily damaged black box units, one located in the forward section, the other in the rear.
These devices, designed to withstand extreme temperatures and impact, house memory chips that record flight data. The National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) of the United States provided specialised equipment to retrieve this data.
The investigation now centres on the fuel control switches. Three primary theories are under scrutiny:
Human Action: Did one pilot deliberately or inadvertently move the switches? The cockpit exchange suggests neither accepted responsibility.
"No pilot in their right mind would do this. The switches require intentional effort-lifting and moving them past a guard rail. It's not a light switch you flick by mistake," Captain Saurabh Bhatnagar, a former senior commander at Air India Express, told NDTV.
Mechanical Failure: Could a defect have caused the switches to move independently?
External Factors: Could fuel flow have ceased despite the switches remaining in "RUN"? The report finds no evidence of this.
The AAIB has ruled out other variables. No significant bird activity was detected, negating a bird strike theory.
The Auxiliary Power Unit (APU), a rear-mounted mini jet engine, was operational and attempted an autostart to assist engine relight, but its role was secondary to the switches' position. Crucially, the report states there is "no immediate evidence of sabotage."
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


India.com
an hour ago
- India.com
Boeing 737 plane of American Airlines aborts takeoff, catches fire after landing gear failure, 173 passengers rescued; chilling video goes viral
(Image: X/@krithi_sharma) New Delhi: A major accident was averted on Saturday, July 27, at Denver International Airport in America. The takeoff of American Airlines' Boeing 737 Max 8 plane had to be aborted due to failure of landing gear. During this, a fire broke out in the rear part of the plane. This flight was going to Miami. When did the mishap occur? The incident happened at 2:45 pm US time (2.15 am Indian time). There were a total of 173 passengers and 6 crew members on board the plane. All were evacuated through emergency slide. 6 people suffered minor injuries in the accident, one of whom has been admitted to the hospital. FAA (Federal Aviation Administration) and airlines have started investigating the matter. What did American Airlines say? American Airlines confirmed that there was a technical fault in the plane's tyre, due to which it has been removed from service. It is being investigated. At the same time, the fire department said that the fire in the plane was extinguished. A new aircraft has been prepared to take the passengers to Miami. The ground stop was in effect at the airport from 2 pm to 3 pm, due to which 87 flights were affected. Now normal operations have started at the airport. Similar incident occurred in March Earlier in March, an American Airlines aircraft had to make an emergency landing at Denver International Airport due to engine related problems. Just 24 hours before this incident, 'Southwest Flight 1496' had to make a sudden 'nose drop' (dive downwards) to avoid a mid-air collision while flying from Burbank, California to Las Vegas, due to which the passengers jumped from their seats and hit the ceiling.

The Hindu
an hour ago
- The Hindu
The tale of the tigers
Where it all began… Did you know that a rough conservative estimate of India's tiger population at the start of the 20the Century was around 40,000? The top end of the estimates even placed the number of tigers in the Indian subcontinent in 1900 at around 1,00,000! That number, however, nosedived to a mere 1,827 in 1972, the estimated population figure the result of a nation-wide tiger census conducted that year. This meant that in just 70 years, only about one in every 25 tigers (or 4 out of every 100) remained, even if we were to start with the conservative estimate. The dismally low number was an urgent call for action. The Government of India set up the Project Tiger in 1973 with the primary objective of protecting the Bengal Tiger, and its natural habitats, while ensuring a viable tiger population for ecological balance. Secondary objectives included controlling poaching and illegal trades, raising awareness about tiger conservation among the public, and developing and incorporating better methods to monitor tiger populations. How was it implemented? A multi-pronged approach has been employed to implement Project Tiger through the last half a century or so. Central to it has been the establishment of tiger reserves, which are managed with a core-buffer strategy. While the core areas enjoy legal protection as national parks or sanctuaries, buffer zones around the core areas allow for sustainable human activities, balancing conservation efforts with local needs. The tiger reserves are designed such that they serve as secure habitats for the tigers, and minimise human-wildlife conflict. The National Tiger Conservation Authority (NTCA) was established under the Wild Life (Protection) Act of 1972 and serves as the wildlife conservation agency that provides regulatory oversight and also manages the funding of Project Tiger. Even though the project is an initiative by the Indian government, a number of collaborators from other countries and organisations have also lent their support to aid the efforts of tiger conservation. Data that highlights the project's success 50+ When the project was started, there were nine tiger reserves, including the iconic Jim Corbett National Park – India's first national park, established in 1936. In a little over 50 years, the number of tiger reserves have ballooned to more than 50, meaning that the country has been adding almost one tiger reserve every year. As big as Jharkhand When Project Tiger was launched in 1973, an area of 9,115 sq. km was encompassed by the nine reserves. As of 2025, the area under the 50+ reserves across 18 states in the country has gone past the 75,000 sq. km mark. If all those areas were to be placed together to form a single parcel of land, it would be comparable with the state of Jharkhand, which has an area of 79,714 sq. km. Over 2% of the country India has an overall area of 3.287 million sq. km. If the area demarcated as tiger reserves were compared with the total area of the country, it is a little over one-fiftieth of the total area. This means that over 2% (2.2%, if you wish to be more precise) of India's landmass is now devoted to this project. More than 3,000 tigers The most recent estimate of tiger population in the country ranges from a minimum of 3,167 to a maximum of 3,925, with an average of 3,682 – generally given out as the number of tigers in India. While a jump from 1,827 in 1973 to 3,682 in 2022 represents a commendable annual growth rate of 6.1%, the growth in reality was far from linear. This means that the rate of growth didn't steadily keep on increasing, and there were, in fact, even some dips before the numbers bounced back. The estimate in 2006, for instance, was 1,411 – even lower than the 1972 mark! This decrease from previous estimates actually led to a major overhaul in the way in which things were done, and they have borne fruit as the tiger numbers have more than doubled in the last two decades. Roughly 75% India's tiger population has, in fact, doubled in a decade according to a study whose results were published earlier this year. As a result, India is now home to roughly 75% of the global tiger population. Yes, you read that right. Three out of every four tigers in the world are now in India! A tigress's tale Programmes like Project Tiger do better off with a face. Machhli was the poster child of this conservation effort as she saw the numbers of her species both decline and grow during her lifetime. Meet Machhli Name: Machhli, also spelt Machli or Machali Tiger code: T-16 Gender: Female Species: Bengal tiger First seen: 1997 Died: August 18, 2016 Habitat: Ranthambore National Park Nicknames: Queen Mother of Tigers, Tigress Queen of Ranthambore, The Lady of the Lakes, Crocodile Killer Claims to fame: India's most famous tigress; labelled most photographed tigress in the world. Machhli inherited her name – Hindi word for 'fish' – from her mother and also because of the fish-shaped mark on her left ear. A dominant cub, she started hunting at the age of two and her ferocity was well documented throughout her lifetime. The most famous incident showcasing this is her fight with a 14-foot mugger crocodile, which she killed while losing a couple of canine teeth. She gave birth to five litters and raised 11 cubs, contributing significantly to the park's tiger count. Some of her cubs were even relocated as a couple of female cubs were transferred to Sariska Tiger Reserve to boost the big cats population there as well. She soon became a favourite subject for wildlife photographers and filmmakers, and her photogenic nature even earned her the title of being the most photographed tigress in the world. This had a strong impact on both tourism and conservation, as it brought more footfalls to Ranthambore and more eyeballs to the conservations efforts. As is to be expected, Machhli did split opinion as well. By the time she died in 2016 as a 19-year-old, she had far outlived most 'wild' tigers, who generally live to the age of 10-15. Her fame and the money that she brought in meant that she was tended for as she aged, raising questions of whether she was still 'wild' at all. If that weren't enough, some commentators even stated that the establishment was going out of the way to keep its star alive, even though she was no longer performing any ecological function. This drain in resources, they believed, could have been better employed in actual conservation efforts. Machhli was, doubtless, an icon. And when it comes to capturing the public's imagination and grabbing their attention, an icon always works. The Tiger Man of India If Machhli is seen as the face of Project Tiger, then Kailash Sankhala is the brains behind it. Nicknamed the 'Tiger Man of India,' Sankhala is an Indian biologist and conservationist who served as the first director of the project. Here's more about the man who lived for a cause that he cared about… An early start Born in Jodhpur in 1925, Kailash Sankhala obtained his master's degree in Botany from Jaswant College, Jodhpur in 1950. He went on to earn a postgraduate diploma in forestry from the Indian Forest College in Dehradun in 1953, and joined the Indian Forest Service (IFS) in 1957. Less than a decade after independence, when much of India was still coming to its feet, Sankhala began raising awareness about the plight of the tigers. As early as 1956, Sankhala had begun spreading the word about the alarming decline in their numbers, establishing himself as an early advocate for tiger conservation. Bear in mind that this was a time when tiger hunting was still a common practice, and there were countless problems plaguing the country as it was taking baby steps towards governing itself. Research and management As an IFS officer, Sankhala had a distinguished career. He managed a number of wildlife sanctuaries, including the ones at Sariska, Bharatpur, Van Vihar, and Ranthambore. By 1965, Sankhala had accepted the position of Director at the Delhi Zoological Park, a position he held for five years. His methods and innovative approach to zoo management earned him recognition as he completely changed how zoos in the country function. The practice of having animals perform for onlookers was stopped, and animals were provided enclosures that were akin to their natural habitats. By 1970, Sankhala had extensively studied tigers. His research on tiger population, their behaviour and population dynamics, paved the way for Project Tiger. He was also the first civil servant to receive the Jawaharlal Nehru Fellowship in 1969-70 to study tigers. The first director Sankhala realised that the onus was on him to employ his knowledge to educate the public and persuade the government for conservation efforts. His efforts brought the attention of both national and international media to the issue of tiger conservation. Indira Gandhi, who was India's Prime Minister at the time, took notice of Sankhala's work. The hunting of wild animals was first banned, and then efforts were taken to protect tigers. When she set up a task force for the protection of tigers, Sankhala was part of it. Once the Wild Life (Protection) Act of 1972 was passed, it was a matter of time before Project Tiger kicked-off. Gandhi had no doubts in appointing Sankhala as the project's first director. Under Sankhala's leadership, the project established nine tiger reserves, putting in place a nationwide network of protected areas. Along with his team, he came up with conservation strategies and implemented them, protecting the tiger and its habitat. Tiger Trust Sankhala literally lived for the cause that he had taken up, spending much of his lifetime to protect tigers, even after his tenure as the director of Project Tiger. In 1989, he set up Tiger Trust, a non-governmental organisation focussed on tiger conservation. Through this NGO, he tried to further the involvement of the community in the conservation efforts, while also bringing about initiatives and measures to preserve habitats and prevent poaching. He authored several influential books on wildlife and conservation, including 'Tiger! The Story of the Indian Tiger.' He received the Padma Shri award in 1992, a couple of years before his death in 1994, aged 69.


The Hindu
3 hours ago
- The Hindu
Nominations open for ‘Best Teacher' award
Leaders of Andhra Pradesh Primary Teachers' Association (APPTA) has invited nominations for the national-level 'Best Teacher Award' instituted in memory of late Rampal Singh, former president of the All-India Primary Teachers Federation (AIPTF). In a statement on Sunday, the APPTA president A.G.S. Ganapathi Rao and general secretary K. Prakash Rao announced that interested and eligible candidates can submit their applications with supporting documents through the link: The last date for submission of nomination is August 30, 2025. They said that Rampal Singh had rendered exceptional service to the teaching community during his tenure as the national president and general secretary of AIPTF, secretary general of the SAARC Teachers' Federation and as a Board Member of the Education International. He played a key role in resolving numerous educational challenges and worked tirelessly to raise the status of Indian teachers to international levels.