Cooper Cronk urges NRL to make rule change as fans blast 'unfair' Tigers scenario
Although the game was embroiled in controversy when Bulldogs captain Crichton collected a falling May with his shoulder on the way down. Alex Seyfarth was currently in the sin bin for the Tigers after making high-contact with little effort to stop the shoulder to the head.
Unfortunately, May was deemed a category one HIA and the centre is now facing 11 days out from the game. Plenty of Tigers fans, including coach Benji Marshall, expected Crichton to also get 10 in the bin for the ugly tackle that left May dazed.
Although the Bunker deemed there were mitigating circumstances in Crichton's contact to the head with May slipping in the wet. And Crichton was put on report for the incident and the Tigers were handed a penalty.
But commentator and NRL great Cronk felt the rule needs to be re-worked. Crichton remains on the field and gets to play the final 15 minutes of the game, while May is ruled out and the Tigers at a disadvantage. Commentator Warren Smith said the ruling is one of the 'anomalies' of the game.
While Storm and Queensland great Cronk suggested in commentary something needs to be done about the rule. "I agree with that. The game needs to sort that out. Taylan May gone from the field, but Stephen Crichton stays on," Cronk said.
And fans agreed. While many felt there are inconsistencies over when mitigating circumstances come into the equation, others felt the rule doesn't favour the team being penalised. There were suggestions if the player is off for a category one, than the offending player should also be off the field.
The Tigers have the bye next week, which is fortunate because he won't miss a round of action. Although it didn't help them in the moment with only a penalty rewarded to them, while they had Seyfarth in the bin.
How the hell does Seyfarth get 10 in the bin and Crichton doesn't??? 😤🤯🤯
— Keith Galloway (@kgalloway85) August 3, 2025
May gone, Crichton should have gone. Farcical. #NRLTigersBulldogs
— Smokey Johansson (@smokeyjoh) August 3, 2025
So how isn't Crichton binned for that hit? I know it's wet and he's slipped but it's direct and forceful to the head, has to be a binning surely#NRLTigersBulldogs
— Harry Eaton (@HgEaton) August 3, 2025
Critta shoulder charge to the head on May. May cat 1. Critta not binned. Seems unfair. Several Dogs knock ons and offsides missed too. Rub of the green definitely going to Dogs #NRLTigersBulldogs
— The Alaskan (@cockroachBLUE) August 3, 2025
I'm sorry, Crichton should not get to stay on the field if that's a Cat 1. Mitigation or not, direct shoulder force into the head with his feet planted and shoulder cocked. NRL needs to fix this. #nrl #nrltigersbulldogs
— Brad A (@bradlz2912) August 3, 2025
Benji Marshall questions Stephen Crichton ruling
Wests Tigers coach Benji Marshall also questioned the decision to allow Crichton to remain on the field. Marshall tried to remain calm when talking about the situation, but sideline reports suggested he was animated when Crichton made the tackle. And he couldn't fathom how Seyfarth was sent to the bin and Crichton was not.
'I really don't want to get in trouble to be honest,' Marshall said. 'I just can't understand why one is one thing and why another one's another thing and now we lose Taylan for 11 days. Lucky we have got the bye. 'We can't use our 18th man unless he gets sin-binned.'
RELATED:
Classy Jayden Campbell act missed in Panthers trainer furore
Fans fume over Reece Walsh act as Bennett rocked over 18th man drama
Marshall was questioned over whether there are inconsistencies in how some of the rules are enforced. 'You're saying the issue is sometimes you see players sin-binned for one thing and then not for another?' the reporter said in the press conference.
"I'll use your words,' Marshall replied. The game was also billed as the reunion between Jarome Luai and Lachlan Galvin. The Tigers playmaker was seen standing over Galvin after a tackle and celebrating when he won a penalty.
And while Luai got the win over his former teammate the two ended all claims there is tension between the pair having embraced each other after the game. "That's footy bro, I'm a competitor," Luai said. "It doesn't really matter who's on the other side. It's brothers and opposition, that's how I see it."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Stokes: I'm looking forward to getting to Australia
For months, England captain Ben Stokes has avoided talking about the Ashes in Australia as much as possible. But after a Test match - and series - for the ages against India, even he is prepared to mention it and firmly believes his side are battle hardened after the draining series that finished in a chaotic defeat at The Oval on Monday. More than 7000 runs were scored in the five Tests, but just when England were in need of fewer than 50 runs for the final five wickets, they lost. The last time that happened to them in a fourth innings while chasing victory was in 1902, against Australia at Old Trafford Stokes was England's most effective bowler in the series but exhausted himself into a shoulder injury that forced him to miss The Oval. Stokes praised his seam attack - deprived of himself, Jofra Archer and Chris Woakes, who came out to bat with a dislocated shoulder but did not have to face - for running India so close in the six-run defeat that squared a superb series. "When one of your bowlers goes down so early in the game, the role of the other seamers changes," Stokes said. A stunning end to the five-Test series as India clinch the thriller at The Oval 👏#WTC27 #ENGvIND 📝: — ICC (@ICC) August 4, 2025 "Even in the second innings, the heart and desire they showed was amazing. There were many what-ifs in the last five days, makes the game great, but all (coach) Brendon (McCullum) and I asked was to give it everything. (Josh) Tongue, (Gus) Atkinson and (Jamie) Overton showed it. "The way in which we've been able to perform throughout the series, I'm looking forward to getting to Australia and doing what we want to go out there and do." England and India both wasted earlier chances to win the fifth Test but after India took the final four wickets in a hectic 57 minutes of play on the final morning, Stokes accepted the conclusion was deserved. "The series as a whole has been pretty much toe-to-toe for 25 days. From a cricket fan's point of view, 2-2 is probably fair," he said. "Two very good teams who have thrown everything at each other and left everything out there. We obviously would have loved to get a series win but it wasn't meant to be. "We're bitterly disappointed we couldn't get over the line but it was another hard-fought game and both teams put so much energy and effort into the series, it's been an amazing one to be part of. "There's a little bit of frustration there as well but as a massive advocate of this format and for Test cricket as a whole, this has certainly been one of those series that could hopefully keep off the narrative around 'Test cricket is dying'." Stokes said he was looking forward to being well rested for the first Ashes test against Australia, in Perth, on November 21, but if he is fit, there are serious questions over who will join him in England's attack. Fast bowlers Jofra Archer and Mark Wood have both missed more Tests than they have played in recent years and the chances of Woakes being fit to bowl in less than four months must be remote. England have not won a Test in Australia since 2011, something David Warner will doubtless be reminding them of during his stint playing for London Spirit in The Hundred over the next few weeks. With agencies
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
British and Irish Lions end-of-tour awards
The British and Irish Lions defeated Australia 2-1 to win their first Test series since 2013. It may not have been one of the all-time classic Lions tours but it did deliver controversy, big moments and a second Test for the ages. The Lions played nine tour games, won eight and lost the final match to deny Andy Farrell's side a first series whitewash by the tourists since 1927. Our team in Australia - Chris Jones, Tom English, Lauren Jenkins and Nigel Ringland - dissect the tour on the latest Rugby Union Weekly episode and give out their end-of-tour awards. Player of the tour NR: "Dan Sheehan. He is possibly the best hooker in the world and has only enhanced that reputation. "He set the tone in his first game and captained the side. If he continues on an upward curve with Leinster and Ireland then he could be a potential captain in 2029. At hooker he was way ahead of his competition." TE: "Tadhg Beirne. Played 80, 80, 80 in the Test-match series. Hugely influential right from 16 seconds in. Tom Curry makes a tackle on James Slipper and he is in for the turnover. "I love to see players doubted and then coming through. That is the epitome of greatness. He hit greatness on this tour." CJ: "Tadhg Beirne for me." LJ: "Maro Itoje is up there. His durability and aura as a captain. The third Test was the first time he didn't finish a Test since 2022 against Australia. "You wouldn't put it past him doing it again in four years time. Nine Lions Tests under his belt." Lions player ratings - the incredible, the unlucky & the poor Listen: The big Lions debrief in Sydney 'A strange kind of glory' as legacy-defining win eludes Lions Best moment of the 2025 Lions tour? TE: "For sure, 90,000 people at the MCG, dramatic, the comeback, the controversy of the clearout. We will be talking about that the next time we are in Australia, but there were moments on this trip. "The Owen Farrell call-up too came at the stage when the tour was meandering along and the Lions were beating everyone. A bit of a yawn fest. "He then appears and it is amazing. When he gets out of bed in the morning people are not happy." LJ: "The two tries in four minutes before half-time in Melbourne changed the game. From 23-5 to 23-17, when reflecting on the tour you might not think about it but it was huge." CJ: "When Tom Curry cut James Slipper in half that was a big 'I am' moment. After lots of chat about whether he should play the first Test." NR: "It was the last play of the game in Melbourne. All the controversy and announcing no foul play in the build-up. "It was so well-worked, and so much composure as to where the players needed to be in that moment on the pitch." Performance of the series LJ: "The First Nations and Pasifika XV. That was the performance of the series and the game that it felt like everyone was waiting for. They could have snatched it at the end. I left that stadium with a spring in my step." CJ: "The Wallabies in the third Test after people talking about where Australian rugby is. All the greats of Wallaby rugby saying they can't lose 3-0. They went out and did a job on the Lions." TE: "The first half of Test one." NR: "I am going to cheat a little and go the first half of the first Test and the second half of the second Test. Put those two together. "Those last few minutes in Melbourne is what we will take away." Farrell in 'really good place' to lead Lions again Lions star Aki's baby born in car before first Test Individual performance TE: "It is hard to look past Tom Curry in the first Test or Tadhg Beirne in the first and third Tests." LJ: "Waratahs flanker Charlie Gamble was brilliant. Man of the match in that loss for First Nations Pasifika XV and he was brilliant for the Waratahs." CJ: "Rob Valetini's 40 minutes in Melbourne and Taniela Tupou in the third Test. My player of the tour from an Aussie point of view is Will Skelton, as when he was on the pitch Australia won the series by 14 points. I know that doesn't matter but it shows how amazing he was." Try of the tour CJ: "Tom Wright's try in Melbourne. Joseph Suaalii sees the space and you go 'there is the two million buck man' - that's why they paid the big dosh to get him out of the NRL. "It lifted the stadium and you felt in a special sporting occasion." TE: "It [Wright's try] electrified the stadium, in that moment you felt 'there is the guy [Suaalii]'." LJ: "Finn Russell's miracle pass to Sione Tuipulotu in the first Test. First Scot to score a Test try since Alan Tait in 1997." And a word on the Welshman... LJ: "Jac Morgan comes away with his reputation enhanced. You expect good players to go on Lions tours and perform but that doesn't always happen. As the sole Welshman you knew he was good but he has now done it at the top level. "He hasn't had a Welsh coach fighting his corner or the familiarity of the Leinster or Ireland players around him. It'll be interesting to see where he goes from here, as he will return a better player. "I had him down as a homeboy but this tour would have opened his eyes. Maybe he will think he can go and thrive in different environments." TE: "He is class. You possibly have to go back to Brian O'Driscoll in 2001, the whole waltzing O'Driscoll stuff, when he broke on to the international scene, to find a Lions cult figure like Jac Morgan. "Everyone adopted Morgan. It didn't matter where you were from from, you were willing him on. "He was a huge tourist and brilliant in the way he played." Combined starting XV Four Australia players have made the chosen combined starting XV. It includes Rob Valetini, who played only 40 minutes of rugby across the Test series, and lock Will Skelton, who missed the first Test. Dylan Pietsch was not selected for the first two Tests but impressed in Sydney to earn a spot on the wing. Combined starting XV: Keenan; Jorgensen, Jones, Tuipulotu, Pietsch; Russell, Gibson-Park; Genge, Sheehan, Furlong, Itoje, Skelton, Curry, Beirne, Valetini. Australia players in bold Get the latest updates from the Lions tour Wales stars must 'want a piece of Lions action'
Yahoo
4 hours ago
- Yahoo
Lions hooker Dan Sheehan suspended for four matches after reckless ruck clearout
SYDNEY (AP) — British and Irish Lions hooker Dan Sheehan was suspended for four matches on Monday for his illegal ruck clearout of Australia's Tom Lynagh at the weekend. Sheehan was cited for charging into a ruck and hitting Lynagh's head on Saturday in the third test won by the Wallabies 22-12 in Sydney. At his disciplinary hearing, Sheehan disagreed that foul play occurred. But the panel found it was reckless with a high degree of danger. The panel suspended him from four Leinster club matches in September and October, but allowed him to be available for the fourth match if he completed World Rugby's tackle school. ___ AP rugby:
